Dexter Retrospective: Every Season Reviewed & Analysed
Dexter has been on my mind a lot lately, and I've been trying to figure out why that is. I guess the show holds a special place in my heart after all, with the exception of Doctor Who (which, due to perpetual reinvention, is pretty much a different show than when I started) it's the series I have followed the longest. Every year, like psychopathic clockwork, came more Dexter. Yet bit by bit, this ceased to be a good thing. Fans of the show know all about the sharp decline in quality that plagued Dex, but I feel like there's a little more to discuss here, primary in the strange fluctuating of the series that has been part of it since day one. The series appealed to me from the moment I first glimpsed it at a friend's house. A show entirely based around a serial killer hunting only bad people while working for the police? Perfect. The black humor and compelling plots helped a lot as well, in the early days at least. But somewhere along the line, things went very, very bad. So, now that she series has come to an end, it's time to take a trip back through all eight seasons, celebrate the things that worked and lament the point where one of the best shows on television went wrong.
Season One
I remember when the first season of Dexter started, and newspapers everywhere were reacting in shock. 'A TV series about a serial killer? The audacity!' Most people thought it would just be a quirky oddity that lasted a couple of seasons before becoming another cult curiosity cancelled before its time. But it worked; through good writing, pitch perfect performances and edge-of-your-seat plotting, this strange show became appointment viewing for many people. There a still a lot of Dexter fans who will argue that the Ice Truck Killer is a better villain than Trinity (they are wrong), and it's not uncommon to hear people claim that the first season was the best. It is a fine chunk of TV. It's action packed and exciting with a strong cast and a plot that keeps you guessing. It's also, apart from a very unique protagonist, not terribly different to any other drama on TV. Yes, it was engaging, but compared to the shock twists that would populate the next three years? For a show about a serial killer, season one seems almost tame in retrospect, and while I know Brian Moser has his fans, he's not much more than a stereotypical Hannibal Lecter pantomime knock off. I ploughed through the DVD box set in a weekend and could not wait to get into season two. Sure, it was nothing revelatory, but it was great entertainment. Then it all changed.
Season Two
I still blame season two of Dexter for the love affair with TV that has plagued my brief adult life so far. It was the first time I'd ever realized just what the medium was capable of; a gripping, multi-layered plot racing through twists entirely predicated on well-developed characters, building to a satisfying climax. It was a raging success of a season of TV, a sophomore year that managed to avoid the flaws of its first while building on the strengths. I guess the genius was that it held nothing back in blowing wide open the kinds of subplots that other shows will leave boiling for years. In the first season I asked myself questions like 'will Doakes be able to figure Dexter out?' and 'what will happen if someone discovers where Dexter is dumping the bodies?' The season tackled these issues head on and the results were utterly satisfying. It was just so hard to stop watching this season. The attention of the law was not the only threat hanging over Dexter's head; he had to contend with Lila, with Deb's PTSD, with his own sense of loss after killing his brother, with more domestic demands from Rita and with Doakes' unending, single minded pursuit of him. Even years later it's hard to think of a series that would start a season with a plot point as bold as having those bodies discovered, but season two of Dexter did it without hesitation, and it paid off brilliantly. It seems so funny now to remember a time when the writers of Dexter were smart, brave and completely comfortable to take risks. I still believe that, for all the brilliance of season four, this was still the last time when Dexter ever genuinely felt like he was in danger. Season two of Dexter is what a television series looks like at its peak. Fresh, confident and utterly unpredictable. To this day it is a benchmark rarely topped by any other show. Breaking Bad notwithstanding.
Season Three
I finished watching season two just as the third season started, and I could not be more excited. The first episode was a bit slow, but that could be expected. When this sluggish pace populated the rest of the season, it became an issue. Still, I remained hopeful. The show had made everything count so far; surely the saga of Miguel Prado and his dysfunctional family would soon be as compelling a story of that of Doakes, Lila or the Ice Truck Killer? Maybe, having paid off most of its ongoing subplots in season two, the show was merely carefully setting up new ones. It made sense and it would surely build to something brilliant. And for a moment, it kind of did. The last handful of episodes in season three were great TV, but they came at the end of a dull slog of a season. There was nothing especially wrong with what was happening, it just wasn't all that interesting. The problem with season three is that I always just felt like I was waiting for the moment when I would start caring about the Skinner, or Miguel, or Anton Briggs, or Ellen Wolf or any of what was happening. And yeah, they managed to recapture some compelling tension at the end there, but did we really have to wait until the third last episode for something genuinely exciting to happen? Jimmy Smits was really very good as Miguel Prado, but the material was beneath him, and it's hard not to feel sorry for him considering he will now always be remembered as one of the Dexter adversaries who just wasn't really as good as Trinity. To me, season three represents a television show that had played all its trump cards already and was trying to find a new way forward. It was passable, but not hugely successful, and this left me with a slight sense of concern for the future of the series. This concern was warranted, but as time would tell, it came a year too early. Season three finished with me still loving the show, but less enthused about what was to come next. When season four started, I didn't bother watching it all straight away. I would get to it when I got to it. That was my mistake.
Season Four
As any Dexter fan knows, season four was and remains the peak, crowning glory of the series. It was nothing short of phenomenal television; shocking, exciting, terrifying and entirely, utterly brilliant. How many standout moments came from those twelve episodes? Lundy's shocking death, the chilling thanksgiving scene and that ending. That insane, perfect, heart stopping twist that nobody saw coming. It was a moment that has simply never been topped for me no matter how much good TV I watch on a daily basis. It left me silent and unable to process what I had just seen. It was exactly the kind of thing I had expected from the series after season two, the kind of audacious twist that managed to not only shock me to my core but make every brilliant moment that had come before even better. But the greatest achievement of that twist is how it managed to overshadow the excellent twelve episodes that preceded it. I watched season four in a day. One day, hunched in front of a computer, heart in my mouth, knowing I should go to bed but unable to move, to even think about sleeping without knowing what the hell happened next. The cat and mouse game between Dexter and Arthur Mitchell was genius on so many levels; their animosity belied the fact that they were very, very similar, and that Dexter's attempts to kill Mitchell were always undercut by his terror that this was what he could one day become. The specter of the police finding out about Dexter may have lessened considerably since season two, but this was a far more interesting threat. The war with Trinity felt personal, and when it ended in the most horrifying way imaginable, any sense of shock was tempered with satisfaction; the writers had not disappointed us. They were willing to make risky, shocking choices, to shake up the status quo and leave us desperate to know what would happen next. Season five could not come fast enough, but now, in retrospect, I wish I'd given up here.
Season Five
Now let's step back for a moment and look at just what season five could have been. Season four left us with Dexter shattered by the murder of his wife, with a sister who was beginning to learn harsh truths about him and a new animosity with the otherwise useless Quinn. Arthur Mitchell's family also knew exactly what Dexter looked like and could identify him in a heartbeat if they wanted to. And the very first trailer for season five made all of this central. We saw Quinn looking into Rita's death and approaching Mitchell's son with a photo of Dexter. We saw what looked like a thrilling cat and mouse game beginning between Dex and this apparent new adversary. We saw the leftover subplots from season four becoming huge new threats to Dex. It looked like everything I could have wanted from a new season of Dexter. But here's the thing. All those brilliant moments in the trailer? They comprised the first three episodes. Then Quinn, for no convincing reason, dropped his suspicions, the FBI backed off and Arthur Mitchell's family faded into obscurity. Instead of the natural progression of plot we had hoped for, we got a new season-long adventure with Dexter trying to help the bland and unlikeable Lumen Pierce. Now, I appreciate a lot of people really enjoyed her role, but I never did. I found Julia Stiles to be annoying and unconvincing, and their relationship totally lacked chemistry. I had to watch in irritation as the plots I cared about were dropped in favor of a pointless revenge story that was tied up so neatly at the end that it need never have happened at all. The bad guys died, Lumen left and Dexter went back to exactly as he was before. Quinn seemed to forget completely that he had good reason to suspect Dexter and our hero was left with a clean slate. While the season had some good moments, these were overshadowed completely by the sheer waste of time that it all turned out to be. The tragedy of season five, ultimately, is what could have been. Imagine, for a second, a world where Dexter had the integrity of Breaking Bad; a world where the powers that be simply said 'we've told all the story we could, lets end it at season five.' Imagine a scenario where the writers were forced to resolve every lingering loose end and subplot. Because really, the plot hinted at by the trailers could have been the conclusion to the series. It quite easily could have fed into an excellent and memorable finale, leaving Dexter remembered today as a great series that went out at the top of its game. Season five is and remains Dexter's most disappointing moment simply because it not only failed to live up to its promise, but refused to. The expectations had never been higher, and the resultant season did everything in its power not to reward them.
Season Six
Which brings us, painfully and inevitably, to season six. Oh, season six. To this day one of the worst, most abysmal pieces of crap I have ever sat through. My expectations had been set so low and yet this season still managed to disappoint. If season four was a collection of some of the greatest moments the show has ever yielded, season six is its antithesis. From the stupid religious killers to the painfully obvious 'twist' regarding Travis' split personality to the downright insulting 'Deb is in love with Dex' subplot; it was as if the writers recognized everything that made the show great and decided to just do the opposite. Moments of sheer idiocy abounded; when the villain paints a gigantic incriminating picture of Dexter at a crime scene, the police conveniently wait for our hero to arrive before going inside because they 'need the blood guy'. This has literally never happened before. In every crime scene the show has ever done the investigation is already underway when Dex arrives. This painful contrivance exists so we can get a 'tense' scene of Dex destroying the picture before the other police see it. Then, the revelation about Deb's feeling for her brother. It was a slap in the face for long-time fans of the show. After all, the relationship between the two adopted siblings was one of the strongest elements of the series. They cared about and supported each other through everything, and to make it romantic simply destroyed all of that. Add to this the poor scripts, the overabundance of unnecessary voiceovers (characters discuss the Bay Harbor Butcher, Dexter's voiceover announces 'I am the Bay Harbor Butcher' as if we'd forgotten) and it starts to seem like the show had completely lost it. I was quite prepared to just give up on the show by this point, until that final moment. The writers must have realized the level of audience goodwill they had spent the season destroying, and this was all they could do to ensure viewers stuck around another season. I can tell you now; it's the only reason I did.
Season Seven
The first half of season seven was not so much an improvement as a miraculous reinvigoration of the ailing series. The first episode dove straight in with Deb confronting Dexter over what she witnessed and for the first time since season two the pace began to rocket along again. One by one Deb put all the pieces together and suddenly the show was compelling again. It did not shy away from delving right into this supremely messed up sibling relationship and even managed to tie in Deb's apparent romantic feelings in a way that didn't make me cringe. Add to this the addition of the best guest character since the Trinity Killer, the dangerous, suave, gay Ukrainian mob boss Isaac Sirko, played by the awesome Ray Stevenson. His relentless pursuit of revenge against Dex for killing his lover gave the show a sense of stakes that it had lacked for the last two seasons. Within three episodes Sirko figured out Dexter's identity and began the hunt. Dexter was once again compelling in a way it had not been in years. Between Deb's confrontations and Sirko's attacks, the noose had never felt tighter around Dexter's neck. But then it all went wrong. First, the show killed off Sirko in the most anticlimactic way possible. So, it turned out that Sirko had no real purpose toward the overall story and left with no lasting impact on anyone. The season then switched all its attention toward the relationship between Dexter and Hannah MacKay (or Lumen 2.0). This may have worked, if the whole 'Dex finds a soulmate' concept hadn't already been done in season five. Sure, you could argue that Hannah, as a cold blooded killer, was a different kind of partner for him, but the effect was the same. Dex learns to love someone who he relates to, blah, blah, blah. Suddenly it felt like we were back in season five or six. The momentum was gone, Deb had accepted the truth about her brother and the only thing close to tension was generated by the very much in the background investigations of LaGuerta into the Bay Harbor Butcher. Then, in the final two episodes, things got interesting. Dexter's dogged pursuit of the man who killed his mother, who, it turned out, was released by LaGuerta as a trap for Dex, created a last minute sense of danger and tension and for the final two episodes Dexter was back to doing what it did best; dangerous cat and mouse games between Dex and a worthy opponent. In this case, that enemy was LaGuerta, a supporting character from the start now turned into a genuine threat. And the ending, where Deb kills her in order to save Dexter was truly shocking and disturbing, the kind of thing one would expect from Breaking Bad or Sons of Anarchy. It left the series in a place it had never been before and made the impending eighth season look pretty promising.
Season Eight
By the time season eight rolled around, I was cautiously optimistic. If they could retain the strength of the first half of season seven, then we might just be in for a decent finale. The first episode was good, but not especially mind blowing. Not a problem, it would doubtless pick up. Then the second episode was more of the same. And the third, and the fourth and then, distracted by Breaking Bad's far superior final run, I just sort of gave up. Well, maybe gave up is too strong a term. I planned on catching up; I just didn't feel particularly compelled to. Nor did I feel compelled to avoid spoilers at all costs, like with Breaking Bad, so when I started hearing about what had been happening in each episode, and how dull everything was even as the series reached its denouement, I realized that I had very simply run out of patience. It wasn't the tantrum throwing 'this has to improve or else' attitude I had toward season six. Nor was it the blind fury I felt at the ending of Skins' final season earlier this year. It was something a lot sadder; I simply no longer had any passion for the show. A series that had once left me breathless, on the edge of my seat, gagging for the next episode and desperate to find out what would happen now was simply another show I used to watch, continuing in the background of my far too TV obsessed life. I was told that I should just watch the finale and forget the rest of the season. Just to be caught up and be able to discuss it with everyone. But I didn't want to. I heard about what happened, and aside from the inherent hilarity of Dexter ending up as a lumberjack, it didn't make me angry or anything. It was a bad ending, for sure, laughable even, but it kind of suited what the series had become. While I haven't seen it, it doesn't sound jarring compared to the rest of season eight. Dexter deserved an explosive, shocking and satisfying conclusion at the end of season four or five. I still recommend Dexter to friends, but with the caveat that they should just pretend Rita's death is the end. I don't really know how to feel about Dexter anymore. At the end of the day it was an excellent series that descended into poor writing, stupidity, and awful plotting. And aside from anything else, it committed probably the worst crime any series can. It got to a point when even a fan as loyal, devoted and obsessed as me just stopped caring. And that requires some extreme effort. As to what went wrong, I suppose it was a matter of changing writers and the desire of the studio to keep milking a lucrative cash cow, even long after it had exhausted any originality or genuine creativity. Who really knows? The end result remains the same, and the final fate of Dexter is just sad. Did you love Dexter? Share your own reactions to the show below in the comments thread.