Doctor Who: 10 Greatest David Tennant Stories

David

David Tennant's tenth Doctor charmed his way into the hearts of the nation with his youthful energetic portrayal of the ancient Time Lord. What with his imminent return to our screens €“ both large and small €“ we here at WhatCulture! feel that it's time to celebrate his tenure by listing ten of his best stories before a brand new one is released.

David Tennant's era was populated with grand, overblown finales, strange overarching plot threads and smaller episodes that gave the cast real chances to display their brilliant acting skills. Most of all however, it pushed the boundaries of what the word 'epic' could mean in the realms of a television show and introduced millions of viewers to the weird and wonderful world of Doctor Who.

So this hopefully extensive list looks to provide you with an overview of David Tennant at his best and get you as hyped as we are for the 50th Anniversary. Obviously, SPOILERS abound here, so unless you want to be spoiled for Doctor Who episodes released 4 years ago, at which point I'd suggest you drop what you're doing and go and watch it, because seriously man, you're missing out. Even if you don't like the show, you'll come away with a new appreciation for natty suits and Converse shoes.

Anyway, without further ado, Allons-y!


10. Utopia/ The Sound Of Drums/ Last Of The Timelords

Utopia

Written by Russell T. Davies Series 3 Episodes 11, 12 & 13 I think it would be a gross oversight to not include this story on the list. The memories I have of being a 13-year-old enraptured by the possibility of a three-part Doctor Who story are so vivid and exciting that there is no way I wouldn't acknowledge the brilliant achievement that is Utopia/ The Sound of Drums/ Last of the Time-Lords. So many iconic things from the David Tennant era come from this episode €“ The Master as played by John Simm is a true fan-favorite and it also introduced us to the relationship between a new Doctor and Captain Jack that would change Jack's character for years to come. Utopia, upon first viewing, is a truly exciting 42 minutes of television. Derek Jackobi gives an astounding performance as Professor Yana €“ the highlight of it being the moment where he turns around and using only his eyes shows that he's gone all evil and Master-ly on us displays such acting talent that it's almost a shame that he has to regenerate in the following scene. The shock reveal of the Master in Utopia is one of the greatest twists of the new series, and is not let down by the episode that follows it. For starters it gives us a similar audience-gazumping twist €“ namely that Mr Saxon €“ a character hinted at briefly throughout the third series €“ in The Master, in Prime Ministerial form. But aside from that, there's an overwhelming sense of grim, almost Orwellian hopelessness as we see The Doctor and his chums lose one hiding place and ally after another in their battle against Mr Saxon. It's clear to see why John Simm is so popular €“ the guy is loving every second of playing his bonkers, black-hearted bad-guy. Scenes like his take-over of the Toclafane-conference or his brutal, thumbs-up-waving murder of the cabinet show him to be the perfect dark-reflection of David Tennant's Doctor. He is boisterous and funny one minute and deadly serious the next, his very facial expressions imply the weight that such a long life has put on his shoulders. These two episodes are so good that I don't think the haphazard, thrown-together finale can undermine their brilliance. Even in this sub-satisfactory episode there are great moments like Martha's final triumph over both Time-Lords €“ not onyl does she help Deus Ex Machina the Master and his paradox, she chooses to leave the TARDIS of her own accord, prioritisng personal growth over gallivanting around the stars with a man who will never truly love her.

9. Gridlock

Ridlock

Written by Russell T. Davies Series 3 Episode 3 I've heard very mixed things about this episode, so much so that I'm not even sure if it's particularly popular. Yet to me, Gridlock is the highlight of the first half of Doctor Who's Third Series (which is coincidentally my favourite). Returning to New Earth for the first time since Rose was torn from him, The Doctor is shocked to find the lower streets of New New York have been abandoned. He discovers that all of the lower class New New Yorkers are trapped in an endless traffic-jam progressing mere feet every day. Why have they been abandoned by their upper-class counterparts? And why is a cat-nun chasing The Doctor with a big gun? This episode feels a lot like one of those ones that are born of a list of strange dreams or flights of fantasy that I'm sure Russell T. Davies regularly goes on. 'Cats With Guns, Head in Jar, Old Lesbian Couples, Feline aviators who make nose-picking jokes' are among the ridiculous check-list this time around and yet despite all of the absurdity it still portrays some pretty heavy themes beautifully. It explores the idea of faith and how it can save people from terrible situations as well as talking about drugs and how they can prove to be extremely dangerous because they provide artificial relief from life's problems. It all ties into how the Doctor is hiding the fact of his planet's destruction from Martha to make himself feel better, even for a short time. I find the closing scene where the Doctor reminisces about Gallifrey to the chorus of Abide With Me under a setting sun to be one of the defining moments of the Tenth Doctor. It's just beautiful.

8. Silence in the Library/ Forest of the Dead

Silence

Written by Steven Moffat Series 4 Episodes 8 & 9 Silence in the Library and The Forest of the Dead are perhaps two of the most interesting episodes of modern Doctor Who. They're written by Steven Moffat at the time when he knew he was going to take over the job of showrunner. They feature River Song for the first and last time, so essentially play like a two-part Matt Smith story but featuring David Tennant as The Doctor. If anything, however, this just goes to show that David Tennant is incredibly versatile. He could always lead any episode with the utmost confidence and proved time and time again that he was the right person for his job. Moffat is usually celebrated for a few things €“ his episodes are dark, scary and Gothic, and while there is a big element of this in Silence in the Library I always find that the Donna story-line in Forest of the Dead is some of the most powerful storytelling to come out of Doctor Who's fourth series. The idea of watching Donna's life pass by like a dream is so sinister yet brilliant. The simplest ideas are the hardest to come up with, and the idea of a character on television living their life like a character on television through cuts and editing is just as unnerving as the piranha-shadows. The climax of the two episodes is immensely emotional too €“ from Donna losing her husband to The Doctor 'saving' his wife all punctuated with the monologue from River about the Doctor's existence. It's audio-visual poetry and a testament to love and loss, which isn't bad for a cheesy Saturday night Sci-Fi-Soap-Box drama.

7. The Fires Of Pompeii

Pompei

Written by James Moran Series 4 Episode 2 Taking our travelling Time-Lord to major moments in Earth's history is a grand tradition in our favorite show, so it was only logical for this ambitious, high-tech incarnation of Doctor Who to tackle one of the grandest, most tragic moments in history €“ the destruction of Pompeii. The reason that this episode is on the list is because (weird lava-centurion-men notwithstanding) it lives up to all of the tragedy and terror of the real event. Catherine Tate as Donna Noble is popularly considered one of, if not the best, companions in all of Doctor Who and this is really the first story where she gets to show off her great acting skills. She is entirely convincing in portraying Donna's completely hopeless distress at the end of the episode. 'Just save someone' she begs The Doctor in a scene whose dramatic potential will prove to be so important later in the Tenth Doctor's reign. Yet that thread had to begin somewhere, and Donna is definitely the right person to start it off. Another fun aspect to this episode is the presence of a second Doctor and a second companion. Karen Gillan isn't given much of an opportunity to shine but Peter Capaldi, who plays Pompeian father, Caecilius is charming and memorable in his part. This is a landmark episode for Who because of the cast, the characters and an amazingly epic tale.

6. Army of Ghosts/ Doomsday

Doomsday

Written by Russell T. Davies Series 2 Episodes 12 & 13 For many people I think this is the best of the Doctor Who finales. The pure, raw emotion of Doomsday is incredibly moving, while managing not to be quite so morbid and unpleasant as 'The Angels Take Manhattan'. For New Who fans, Rose was our first love and the most important woman in the Doctor's life, so something massive was required to tear her apart from our hero. One of the best ways to experience the tear-jerking tragedy (except by watching the episode of course) is listening to the exquisite track 'Doomsday' from the Series 1 and 2 soundtrack, which really surmises the incredible work that Murray Gold put into reflecting the overwhelming tragedy of the episode €“ it's utterly fantastic, and adds many more dimensions to the episode just by itself. Even if you take away the incredible conclusion to the Rose/Doctor story-line you still have the brilliantly wacky confrontation between the Daleks and the Cybermen. It must be the dream of any child whose life and imagination has been shaped by Doctor Who to see these two behemoths of the monster world fighting each other. There must have been bets taken and fan-fictions written about who would win in this epic battle and we finally get to see that the Daleks would sweep the Cybermen aside like crumbs from a table (well at least we know now.) There's a pure, ephemeral joy to a Russell T. Davies finale that always makes the series you've just watched feel like the most important story that you've ever seen, and the multi-universe massacre that is Doomsday set a high standard for the following David Tennant finales to live up to.

5. The Waters of Mars

Waters

Written by Phil Ford and Russell T. Davies The Specials: 3 It was a hard year for Who fans... We had been treated to four excellent years of thirteen part series, each accompanied by an hour-long Christmas Special and suddenly we had to make do with one 'kind-of-OK' episode at Easter and another one at 'date-to-be-confirmed' before Tennant left at Christmas. This might explain why 'The Waters of Mars' is so well-regarded but there are other reasons too. The Waters of Mars gave to us one of the most horrifying Doctor Who monsters to date in The Flood. The humans these water-bound baddies kill and take over are the stuff of nightmares €“ the broken veins combine with the empty eyes to give an original portrayal of pure evil. Guest star Lindsay Duncan is a world-class star and she puts all of her effort into portraying Adelaide Brook with as much authenticity and subtlety as she can. The interplay between Adelaide and the Doctor is probably the best thing about the episode. Their relationship turns from un-trusting on one side and awe-inspired on the other, to trusted but doomed-to-be-parted friends who inspire each other before finally being flipped back on its head and leading to a suicide. The relationship is so central to the episode that it comes at the expense of fully characterising the other inhabitants of 'Bowie-Base One,' though this hardly matters when it is all leading to the heart-breaking yet thrilling end to the episode that displayed so much about Tennant's Tenth Doctor's character while promising so much about what was to come.

4. The Girl in the Fireplace

Fireplace

Written by Steven Moffat Series 2 Episode 4 Series 2 was Tennant's first and he really had to hit the ground running. In only his fourth episode he had to perform the emotionally-charged 'The Girl in the Fireplace,' a task which would've surely tasked any actor. When the Doctor meets French aristocrat Reinette Poisson (or, oddly enough Madame de Pompadour) he quickly falls in love with her (despite the fact that she was a child a few minutes before, which is a bit creepy). Sophia Myles portrays the vivacious lady with all of the charm and sparkle that must be expected from an important woman in the Doctor's life. Emotions are central to the episode. Until this point the most important things that we had seen the Doctor do had been portrayed by Christopher Eccleston. He showed us a Doctor damaged by the Time War and overcome with grief, but Tennant now had to show us who the healed Doctor would react to love and loss in light of this character development. Tennant's performance tugs on the heart strings artfully €“ if the score by Murray Gold doesn't get you then Tennant reading Reinette's final message to him before folding it up and tucking it into his chest-pocket certainly will. Though the love story will no doubt thrill the girls in the audience, there is also a great amount here for the boys too. Horses on spaceships, crashing through windows and beautifully designed clockwork robots are abound building up a story as mad as anything that came from the tobacco-fueled mind of Russell T. Davies. It's an episode that everyone must watch whether they like Doctor Who or not.

3. Midnight

MidnightWritten by Russell T. Davies Series 4 Episode 10 I think that there can be no list celebrating David Tennant without this episode featuring very highly on it. This is one of the scariest episodes ever written yet it still manages to achieve this without much action or a marketable monster. All of the power here comes from the writing and David Tennant's performance. By this point in Doctor Who Davies and Tennant had come to fully understand what the other one wanted and what their limitations and capabilities were and I think that this episode is the ultimate example of what their partnership could achieve. They each were the two halves of what made this episode the masterpiece of television that it really is. Russell T.Davies excels when writing groups of characters. He can come up with a dozen people, give them each histories, likes and dislikes and most impressively of all he can convey to the audience who they are in a nominal number of words. From the Professor to Sky Silvestry, each of the characters represent different walks of life and different types of people €“ from the common holidaymakers with their embarrassed son, the faux-intellectual Professor and the keen, sharp-as-a-tack assistant. Even though the episode does feature a wonderful supporting cast, its success still hinges on David Tennant's performance. The story focuses on an invisible creature that takes over the Doctor's body so Tennant has to portray through his eyes and face alone the terror he feels because of his attackers, and his disgust and disappointment in humanity. The closing scene shows Donna mimicking The Doctor's voice in the manner of the mysterious creature and the Doctor €“ for the first time not playing along €“ tells her to stop. It shows that the Doctor has been through something unlike anything he ever has before, and highlights this as a very important episode.

2. Human Nature/ The Family of Blood

Nature

Written by Paul Cornell Series 3 Episodes 8 & 9 Paul Cornell is one of the most sadly underrated writers to work on Doctor Who. True, among the fans he's a complete legend for his work on the books and audio spin offs, but the brilliance of Human Nature what has really earned him the right to even more respect. One thing that people always say about the Tenth Doctor is that he's very human. Barely any of his stories take place away from Earth €“ he came through his regeneration and landed the TARDIS in a council estate, for god's sake €“so it only seemed natural for the production team to commission an adaptation of Cornell's 'Virgin New Adventures' novel of the same name. The Family are terrifying creations, green balls of light that will carve out the contents of your mind and set up residence inside, and just to add a scary cherry atop a fear sundae, they can bring scarecrows to life in order to shepherd you to your death. Also, they're willing to disintegrate anyone with the poor enough judgment to get in their way. Simultaneously, they are unstoppable tanks like the Daleks and as creepy as the shadow-dwellers that are born from Moffat's pen. The insane 'Son of Mine' is one of the most memorable and distinctive villains from this series and Harry Lloyd makes you believe that he is an inter-dimensional, psychopathic shock of shining light. The scene when he tells you he wants to smash people into dust, turn the dust into glass and smash it all over again is particularly memorable in this regard. The story gives David Tennant the opportunity to explore two distinct characters each with completely defined quirks and personalities, and the script itself is an exploration of The Doctor's relationship with humanity. It's an exploration of what the character (particularly the tenth Doctor) wants from life and also what he is willing to give up to achieve it. Tennant will blow you away with his incredible abilities here. He'll fall in love before your eyes and break your heart along with his.

1. The Impossible Planet/ The Satan Pit

Impossible

Matt Jones Series 2 Episodes 8 & 9 This is without a doubt one of my favorite Doctor Who stories of all time. I love the second of the two-parters to feature in each of the Russell T. Davies series - they all feel as though the writer has been asked to think of the most fascinating, dark ideas that they can and then just go crazy with them. Silence in the Library, Human Nature and The Empty Child are all great stories and yet I still love The Impossible Planet/ The Satan Pit the most. There are many side characters in this story, and each one of them feel real and memorable. In only a few lines the guests are each very clearly defined as people €“ Zachary Cross-Flane is the Captain who shouldn't have ever been, Danny is the naturally clever wastrel and Ida Scott is the kindly matriarch. They are each played expertly by television actors who would never have the chance to play such unusual people in their day jobs, so are making the absolute most of their time among the fantastic environs of Doctor Who. It's worth mentioning the Ood too, for they are probably the first original monsters in modern Who to actually make it into the canon of returning creatures. Like the Daleks before them and the Weeping Angels after The Ood are part of the pantheon of creatures to regularly return to the show over and over again because they can give you narrative magic. They somehow, after 45 years of Doctor Who they find a way to fit into the universe by becoming synonymous with a certain archetype. The Daleks are the Nazi-esque killer, the Cybermen the stomping progress of mechanically-influenced evolution, and the Ood €“ far less dramatically €“ are the lowest, most sh*t-upon creatures in the universe and a series barely goes by without the distinctive tentacle-faced creatures appearing. The world of the Impossible Planet is incredible too. This was the first alien planet for the Russell T. Davies Dynasty to attempt creating and the result is incredible. With only a couple of sets and a few costumes, they're able to put across a truly vivid and believable impression of what living in this culture is like. It's so good that they returned to the same time period for the seventh episode of the following season. Overall, however the details add up to one scary story wrapped in the most incredible atmosphere. It tries the Doctor's beliefs as much as it test David Tennant's acting skills, proving once again that he was possibly the best choice for the timeless role of The Doctor. So that's what I think. What do you think? Feel free to comment!

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Whilst not writing articles for WhatCulture! Stephen can usually be found livin' it up in the city or livin' it down on the couch in front of one of many DVDs. You can tell how many of his friends are in Edinburgh at any given time by measuring how prolific he is on this site.