Doctor Who: 10 Historical Figures We Need On the Show

Houdini Smith Alright, so the pure historical may be a lost relic, never again to return to Doctor Who. Although undeniably interesting (and occasionally educational), the powers that be think that there needs to be some science fiction or fantasy element to the story for it to be proper Doctor Who, and a lot of viewers agree with them. But I don't think that the psuedo-historicals are going away anytime soon, and while they're still around, we have the opportunity to meet any number of historical figures. It's fascinating to think of how the Doctor could get mixed up in the lives of people who have dramatically impacted history. When dealing with biographies that have been closely studied, we can pick out the points at which the Doctor could have gotten involved. In the case of Agatha Christie, it was the explanation for her mysterious disappearance. With Vincent van Gogh, it was the opportunity to see the impact he would have on society. But there's so many more historical figures out there, some of them seemingly tailor made for Doctor Who. So instead of setting yet another story in present day London, I humbly suggest the following to appear on the show.

10. Rasputin

Rasputin

I have no doubt in my mind that Rasputin was, in fact, an evil alien hellbent on chaos and destruction. Let's look at the evidence, shall we? He cozied up to the Romanovs, gaining unheard of influence to the point that he had an almost hypnotic effect on the Tsarina. His presence at court directly coincided with the Romanovs increasing unpopularity with the Russian populace and the February Revolution of 1917, which saw the family imprisoned and eventually assassinated. Although reports of his murder are embellished, he allegedly died only after being stabbed, poisoned, strangled, shot once through the chest and once in the forehead, clubbed, and finally thrown in an icy river with weights tied to him. Plus, there's those eyes. Those are not human eyes. So if Rasputin is an alien on Earth, obviously the Doctor's going to end up meeting with him sooner or later. Maybe he's a Timelord (now that the Timelords are being brought back), and the Doctor has to convince him to leave the planet before he causes any more trouble. Maybe this is how we finally bring back the Meddling Monk! He was known for getting all embroiled in major historical events, and the Doctor did leave him stranded in 11th Century England. Maybe this is just him a few regenerations down the line, after being driven mad by boredom.

9. Roanoke Colony

Britain Roanokecolony01 Full

What I'm proposing here is not so much a historical figure, as it is a group of historical figures in one of the world's greatest mysteries. Back in the 1600s, England sent a group of settlers to what would become Virginia in the hopes of creating a new colony. They set up shop on Roanoke Island, but things weren't going what you might call swimmingly, so one of the leaders went back to England for more supplies. When he returned a number of years later, the settlement was gone. There were no traces of human life, and the entire village had been torn down. All that was left was the word, "Croatoan" carved into the bark of a tree. So where did the settlers go? If that doesn't sound like the set-up for a good Doctor Who episode, I don't know what does. The Doctor and his companion could arrive at the colony shortly before it disappears, and of course the Doctor's natural curiosity would make him want to stick around to finally figure out the mystery of Roanoke Colony. Maybe there could be a return of the Judoon, where there was secretly an alien hiding out amongst the humans, and they destroyed the colony for harboring fugitives. I don't know, there's limitless possibilities here!

8. Edgar Allan Poe

Edgar Allan Poe

On October 3, 1849, Edgar Allan Poe showed up on the streets of Baltimore, delirious and in need of medical attention. He died four days later, and never regained coherency to explain his situation. And you know what that means: the Doctor was involved. He got mixed up in some crazy adventure with the Doctor, and he didn't make it. What's more, there's that story about the Poe Toaster -- every year for more than seven decades, a mysterious individual would visit Poe's grave on the anniversary of his death, raise a toast to his memory, and leave three roses in a distinct pattern on his grave. To me, the only conceivable explanation is that the Doctor was wracked with guilt over not being able to save Poe, and returns there every year to honor him. I like the idea of having another dark, morbid artist featured on the show...out of all of the 19th century authors I can think of, Poe would be the one to immediately believe in monsters and aliens. I think seeing something along the lines of what happened in The Unquiet Dead would make him feel really validated in his stylistic choices, and I'd love to see it play out.

7. Roald Amundsen

Tumblr Llvjqgwyqa1qcpvfr

This is definitely one of the more obscure figures on the list, but he's totally worth it. Roald Amundsen was a Norwegian explorer who led an expedition in 1911 to reach the South Pole. Are you all thinking what I'm thinking? Well, if you're thinking that this would be the perfect opportunity to feature the Ice Warriors, then yes. You are. So the TARDIS lands in the middle of a frozen tundra, and the Doctor and company see some evidence of civilization. Weird, Martian-y buildings. The Doctor assumes that they're on Mars, although something doesn't feel right about this to him -- but he doesn't have much time to think about it, because they're captured by Ice Warrors. The Amundsen crew is also being held prisoner by the Ice Warriors, who had planned on establishing a colony on the South Pole. They manage to escape and foil the Ice Warriors plans to set up shop on Earth, so they have no choice but to fly back to Mars. Amundsen and his crew are grateful, and promise not to tell anyone of what they found on the South Pole. Not that anyone would believe them, of course. And that's why Roald Amundsen came back to Norway with very little surveying reports, and only two photographs. Once back to civilization, the Doctor alerts a very early version of UNIT, so that they're prepared for the buildings that are down there.

6. Spartacus

Spartacus

As we all know, thanks to Kirk Douglas and Tony Curtis, Spartacus was an ultra badass former slave who dared to take on the entire Roman Empire. Just the kind of odds the Doctor likes. Spartacus was a former gladiator who led a slave uprising against one of the most powerful enemies in all of history, and there are no are reliable records of what happened to him after the war. Although some historians have suggested that Spartacus died during one of the last battles of the Third Servile War, reports are dubious and no body was ever found. I can see the Doctor having an interesting, yet tentative, relationship with Spartacus. He would sympathize with the desire to rise up against oppressors, but would be very uncomfortable with the level of violence involved. I think it would be really cool for Spartacus to somehow get pulled out of time, and for the Doctor to have an adventure with the gladiator in some other time period. You would have the fish out of water element, with the Doctor desperately trying to curb his more violent tendencies.

5. Salvador Dali

523449d911cd7

You know what I want? More surreal episodes of Doctor Who, a la The Mind Robber or Amy's Choice. Basically, what I want to see is an episode set in the 1920s with Salvador Dali, where the Dream Lord returns. Mind-screwing chaos ensues. Dali is best known for his clock melting paintings, but he also has a significant background in early film. Ideally, I would love if they were somehow able to pay homage to elements of his famous surrealist film, Un Chien Andalou. Experimental episodes don't work all the time, but if they got the perfect writer to come up with a really brilliant idea, this is definitely something that could work as a one-off. Plus, Salvador Dali was such a quirky, interesting character, it would be a shame not to see him interact with the master of weird and quirky. I get the feeling that those two would just immediately understand how each other's mind works. They would meet and be all goofy, and whoever the Doctor's companion is would have to be like, "Do you two need a room or something." Last but not least: that moustache. How can you possibly not want that moustache to be Doctor Who canon?

4. Amelia Earhart

Amelia Earhart Via Wikimedia Commons

How has there not already been an episode with Amelia Earhart? Amelia Earhart was pretty much one of the most famous pilots in history, being the first woman to fly solo across the Atlantic Ocean. In 1937, she attempted to circumnavigate the globe, but she vanished under mysterious circumstances, never to be seen again. Which, let's face it, just has the Doctor written all over it. Picture this: they meet Amelia, she goes on her legendary flight, but she never actually crashes. If I was writing the story, I would have it go this way: she has an adventure with the Doctor and ends up on another planet or something, where she decides to stay. Or maybe even dies there, which would certainly be a bold move, but might be a bit morbid for the show as it currently stands. There would be the same old conflict about whether or not the Doctor can change established history, until he realizes that he was always meant to take Amelia with him. That's why no one ever found any remains from her body or plane. It's a perfect opportunity to play with a popular historical figure that has enough leeway that you don't feel like you just totally changed their life story.

3. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Arthur Conan Doyle

Come on. It would be PERFECT. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was best known for writing several stories that we now collectively refer to as the Adventures of Sherlock Holmes (less known for his follow-up series about a gentleman named Professor Challenger, but hey, Sherlock Holmes is a tough act to follow). Just imagine a world in which the Doctor is partially the inspiration for Sherlock Holmes rather than the other way around. I tend to have a really soft spot in my heart for the Victorian historical type episodes, so I'd love to see the Doctor tooling around London (or, even better, Edinburgh, just to give the Scottish agenda some serious momentum) with Doyle, especially if they were investigating some sort of murder mystery. Doyle could come up with some really impressive observational detective work, only to have the Doctor tell him, "Nope, I think it's just aliens." I don't think is something that could happen with Moffat behind the wheel, just because his current work on Sherlock would make it all feel a little nudge nudge wink wink, but with a different showrunner? Absolutely!

2. Florence Nightingale

Florence Nightingale

So the Doctor lands in the middle of a war zone: it's the 1850s, and he is faced with the Crimean War. While there, he meets "The Lady with the Lamp" herself, Florence Nightingale. She revolutionized the field of nursing, by being the first person to really say, "Hey, maybe all these people are dying because they're cramming into a dark room lying in their own filth. Maybe we should give them baths and wash their bed linens, and they might not die." Sounds like common sense, but given that this took place twenty years before Louis Pasteur and germ theory, her contributions were incredibly impressive. So tell me: is there any other person in the world that the Doctor would like to meet and have an adventure with? This woman, in an age where most women were just there to have respectable marriages and make babies, combined compassion and intellect to save lives. If done correctly, I could see her being one of those characters that you desperately wish could become a full-time companion.

1. Harry Houdini

Movies Harry Houdini

Harry Houdini is actually an alien. I'm going to repeat that, one more time: Harry Houdini is an alien. Wouldn't that just make so much sense? It could be a small scale episode, and for the record, I'm always on board for more of those. Give me tightly written character pieces about saving a few people over big budget save the entire universe storylines any day of the week. There's two ways you could go with this. Harry Houdini is an evil alien, who is using his powers to hypnotize the audience while he's performing magic, and eventually more of his people will come and be the new overlords of Earth. Or, Harry Houdini is an alien who doesn't know that he's an alien, because he's been raised by humans. He finds out when he meets the Doctor (and of course the Doctor tells him, so tactless), and has a big identity crisis. Then the Doctor could take him to see his homeland, which is a world full of people who can do what looks like magic, but Houdini decides that Earth is his home. I'm just brainstorming here, but you get the idea.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.