Doctor Who: The 10 Most Pathetic Plans Put Forward By Villains

The Doctor's gone up against many villains in his time, but only a select few have shot themselves in the foot so spectacularly.

Disturbances in the Whoniverse come down to a handful of basic conflicts involving survival, greed, and lust for domination. Each of these must be foiled by some combination of the Doctor, his friends, and very often the bravery of someone we didn't know at the top of the hour. Sometimes the solution comes down to our heroes being just a little bit cleverer. Other times, it is a last minute defection of a trusted minion. Still on other days, the only option left is a Deus Ex Machina-style universe restart. But in nearly all cases, the Doctor's victory requires a misstep of the Doctor's opponent. Often, this miscalculation is forgiveable, but with more than two hundred documented schemes to win wars, breed, gather fuel, claim untold riches, or seize great power throughout the known Whoniverse, some are bound to be duds. While one can assume the enemy of the week never sets out to fail, some plans are so poorly thought through, or contain so many mistakes along the way, that you nearly feel sorry that that poor sap ended up where they did. So be prepared with your best facepalm and groan as I not-so-proudly present the Ten Most Pathetic Plans Put Forward By Villains.

10. Dalek + Human = Disaster

Attempts at some version of human-Dalek hybrids have occurred in various forms since the First Doctor ran across the Robomen workforce in the mid 22nd Century. They fulfilled the dual needs of bolstering numbers as well as instilling fear. The most recent attempts focus on allowing the new hybrids to retain greater degrees of humanness, as was demonstrated by the events of the Asylum, and the character of Tasha Lem. These creatures, known as Dalek puppets, can be clever traps. The most famous hybrids are those that resulted from Dalek's Sec plan in 1930s Manhattan. Sec, wanted to not only bolster numbers, but to truly ensure Dalek survival by adding human emotions back into the new Dalek population, and to remove the instinctual desire to fight tirelessly for universal supremacy. What Makes This Pathetic? Each of the attempts at a Dalek-human interbreed has such gaping difficulties that what is truly pathetic is that they keep trying this strategy. In the case of the Robomen, it is clear that they were phased out for simply being far too wasteful. While their noticeable human elements probably helped during such a full scale invasion, their short lifespans would make them largely ineffective otherwise. Dalek Puppets, like Tasha Lem, the Oswin fragment of Clara, and the others the Eleventh Doctor met in the Dalek Asylum, are problematic because the strong-willed can still tap into their original humanness to ruin the Daleks' plans. Finding someone strong enough to retain enough humanity to fool the Doctor but not aid him is really balancing the razor's edge, and so far it has backfired horribly. Between the Daleks and the Cybermen, you would think one of them would have found a more successful in-between state by this point. Dalek Sec's plan is actually a good one in theory. From this standpoint, he has identified the major cause of Dalek mass death, and found a way to combat it, while increasing the current population substantially. However, as the supposedly most brilliant of a race of superintelligent beings, he should have been able to foresee the significant backlash that would result from such a course of action. A wiser path would have been to undergo traditional Dalek reproduction to create a faction of "pure" Daleks who also saw the wisdom in such a strategy and then branched off as a new race to then attempt to convince other Daleks of the benefits, or wage war for control, or merely co-exist peacefully elsewhere. All that said, the Daleks do at least seem to be benefiting off their mistakes in each case and each of these plans had clear benefits in its time, even if they remain unsuccessful altogether. So with that in mind, the history of human Daleks makes for only the first spot in this Hall of Shame.

9. The Valeyard's Plans to Steal His Own Lives

The Valeyard is a dark version of the Doctor from near the end of the Doctor's lifetime, who, desperate for more lives, plots to steal them from his younger self. In order to make this happen, he sets up an elaborate trial against the Doctor. He aims to prove that the Doctor is a chronic interferer incapable of rehabilitation, who should therefore be put to death. Apparently along the way the Valeyard would somehow be able to capture his younger self's future regenerations for his own use and would achieve the added bonus of separating himself from the influence of the Doctor's conscience. What Makes This Pathetic? It is quite pitiable if we consider what this means for the Doctor's character, as most creation stories for the Valeyard give the Doctor some hand in his creation. It is deeply saddening to picture a version of the Doctor willing to abandon his moral principles in exchange for more time. The man who has been so aware throughout his lives that "everything has its time and everything dies" would hopefully always accept his own, no matter what. Additionally, the Valeyard's methodology in this first trial seems rather flawed. Even at this point in the Doctor's personal history there was enough evidence of interference that there should have been no need for manipulation of information. Some people suggest this misstep is a result of self-sabotage, the Doctor within the Valeyard fighting to foil his plot. But most in excusable of all, the Valeyard should know better than anyone else that the Doctor's friends are particularly good at showing up to ruin even the best laid plan, and that tangling with his younger selves was a losing proposition for so many. Still, the Valeyard hasn't been the only one with some trouble letting go and his plan seemed to have the potential for success, unlike the next desperate soul on this list.

8. Borusa's Plan for Eternal Rule

Then President of Gallifrey, Borusa, captures multiple versions of the Doctor and a handful of companions out of their respective places in time and space, thereby forcibly recruiting them to work through a series of traps and puzzles in an area known as the Death Zone as part of the Game of Rassilon. The prize for a winner of the Game, legend states, is immortality. Borusa hopes to use the Doctors and company to clear the way and then sweep in at the end to collect the prize. What Makes This Pathetic? Even judging by results makes this one pathetic. The scene of Borusa's capture proves that more than one Time Lord was already immortalised by Rassilon as a stone relief, it seems odd no-one in Time Lord society discovered what happened to other victors, even if Borusa had not personally been alive for an attempt at the Game of Rassilon. But even being doomed from the start is not really good enough evidence. Rassilon certainly had the power to keep his activities hidden, so I'm willing to give Borusa some benefit of the doubt. However, the means to his end seem equally flawed as well. While one could argue that the Doctors and his crew were able to complete Borusa's goal and thus were the right ones to choose, the renegade population appears to be fairly sizeable and leads me to wonder if perhaps there was a more suitable Time Lord for the task. Lastly, it seems fair to find this one pathetic as there is no real need for Borusa's stated objective. While power madness is, in part, an end unto itself, it seems especially silly to desire to be Eternal President of Gallifrey. But enough of plans already doomed for failure at the moment, what about ones that might work too well?

7. Destroy Everything...Well, Except Us

A lot of smaller-scale genocide happens in the Whoniverse. In fact, it seems all species are either destined to make war, or be warred upon. Considering the high propensity of even the human species to destroy itself as well anything in its way, it is not altogether surprising that some species are willing to take things even further. For the Daleks especially, universal ethnic cleansing is their stated objective and Davros took this goal even a step further declaring he would destroy everything, just for the momentary satisfaction of being the one to do so. The Time Lords too, were not above complete annihilation. They had created the Ultimate Sanction, a device that when activated would bring about the end of time itself, thereby destroying all of reality where they alone would ascend as beings of pure consciousness, as Rassilon once informed the Doctor. What Makes This Pathetic? Unlike in the last case, this one is not pathetic by design. If the Daleks are to remain a truly powerful enemy, we have to operate under the assumption that they can achieve complete domination, but simply have not chosen to yet. Similarly, despite not having done so in End of Time, I have to believe the Time Lords could have activated the Sanction with relative ease. My argument then is one that wonders about their plan had they come to fruition. The Daleks' self-declared 'Emperor' has been driven mad by his time alone in the dark. While the Daleks have always maintained that their supremacy would lead to a period of universal peace, one has to wonder what would the Daleks do? How would they stave off madness, while floating in the voids of space€”or if some chunk of the universe is left standing€”driving about on these barren lumps of rock? Do they simply cease to function, hibernate in their own eternal suspended animation? Seems a terrible plan. But then I am not a Dalek. Granted, I am not a Time Lord either. But Time Lords have human-like emotions. They suffer from similar vices, have comparable desires, and they get bored. They get very bored. From renegades, to those out in Gallifrey's wilderness, to the most devout of the High Council, no one in the Gallifreyan population gives the impression that they could give up bodily life so easily and merely think. There is a multitude of potential logistic problems, even from a group that is presently on board with that plan. But perhaps most importantly, could the Daleks really appreciate victory if there is nothing around to witness it? Are the Time Lords really exacting punishment€”on anyone other than themselves€”if there is no one else around to bear it? Both the Daleks and the Time Lords are supposed to be super-intelligent races. I would hope such great minds could see the foolishness in such of a course of action. And speaking of great minds...

6. The Rani, Her Brain, and Strange Matter

The Rani gathers a number of great minds€”including a handful of Earth's noted historical geniuses and the Doctor€”to create a rather large brain. She needs the help of this mass mind to deal with an asteroid composed of strange matter, as part of a larger plot to develop a time manipulating device out of an entire planet via a chronon shell process so that she may rewrite evolution as she sees fit. What Makes This Pathetic? The entire idea of recruiting a group of geniuses as minions also means the risk that they may devote their resources to delaying or sabotaging one's plans. Though perhaps the use of Earthlings and the Doctor, a relatively dim Time Lord, indicate some level of planning for this aspect. Perhaps the Rani gathered minds just smart enough to solve her obstacle, but potentially unable to stop her larger plan. However, such an argument is weakened when one considers that she was ultimately defeated by a local's sacrifice and the Doctor. It is mainly the Rani seemed so entirely unprepared for anything to go wrong that makes this such a weak outing. But then the Rani never seems particularly phased with the outcome of any plan, so perhaps it is an unfair standard. Let us move from one case of poor planning to another.

5. Drashig Rebellion

The vast majority of the adventure known as Carnival of Monsters is reactionary behavior. Very little of what occurs can be considered much of a plan. It is not until Kalik and Orum€”the powder blue fellows€”decide to let the Drashigs out to start a bloody revolution in the belief that war is the cure to the boredom facing them on their planet that the first true plan commences. However, it is clear from the start it is poorly thought out. What Makes This Pathetic? Using anything as a tool of chaos is just a bad idea. While the resulting instability may be mildly entertaining, there is no guarantee that any rebellion will result in a better outcome than the status quo. It is also difficult to see how the chaos and danger presented by the Drashigs would result in purpose or meaning for the inhabitants, even if elections were necessary. It is difficult to see how large carnivorous sea serpents running amok can lead to fun for all. Ultimately, all Kalik and Orum achieve is to get themselves eaten before the Drashigs are stopped, thereby proving even from a results perspective that the plan was a miserable failure. But, we can at least concede that Kalik and Orum's rather desperate plan had some possibility to work, unlike the man who made the fourth spot in this countdown. He does have something in common with Kilik and Orum, they all managed to get themselves eaten.

4. Solomon's Greed

Solomon, the 24th century pirate from that time the Doctor ran across dinosaurs on a spaceship, is a shining example of greed robbing one of intellect. While it's almost an insult to those with an agenda to call what Solomon did planning, his original idea seems to have been gone like this: take over the Silurian ship; dump the Silurians; then pilot the ship somewhere to sell off the dinosaurs for top credits, or equally desirable currency; then scrap, sell, or trade the Silurian ship and take off with his new found wealth to more piracy. What Makes This Pathetic? Even before the Doctor shows up, Solomon is deep in dino doodoo. He neglected to realise he had no ability to pilot the Suilarian vessel before dumping its original inhabitants, and was headed for collision with a missile from planet Earth. In addition, he was half-eaten and crushed, leaving him immobile and defenceless should another dinosaur have decided he looked like a tasty snack and broken through the limited barriers. Even if somehow he survived the missile, re-entry into the atmosphere, landing on Earth and the dinosaurs, his injuries would have killed him. At least a half dozen other scenarios seem like they might have greater success if he hadn't chosen to kill the Silurians. Sadly, his decision-making skills haven't improved by the time he meets the Doctor. While Solomon's ship was too small to take the lot of dinosaurs, he could have easily held one given the size of his rather large robot friends. He would have had far better success trying to make off with one then he did in his bid for Queen Nefertiti. Even his final moments demonstrate an utter lack of forethought. The Doctor claims the missile is locked onto the bit of machinery he tosses at Solomon, but rather than attempt to dump it out an airlock, Solomon spends his final moments begging for mercy. It's stupid, but then again, Solomon is not the only man to be undone by greed.

3. The Inferno Project

The Inferno Project is a mining expedition to the Earth's core to retrieve a supposedly sustainable traditional fossil fuel alternative, Stahlman's gas. The greedy men running the project, especially the man for whom the gas is named (pictured above), ignore and cover up repeated safety concerns in the quest for their goal. What Makes This Pathetic? Even before the "point of no return" as the Doctor called it, there were enough early effects to suggest turning back: the inadvertent creation of a gaggle of violent creatures known as Primords, and exposing many to a high risk of mutation€”both causing deaths to the crew. The narrative benefit of the parallel universe allows us to know with absolute certainty that the end result of the Inferno Project was a mass explosion, capable of destroying the Earth. But perhaps most pathetic of all was that although the Doctor played a role in making certain the project was halted in his home universe, he was not particularly necessary. If Professor Stahlman and his devotees had listened to anyone, they could have realised it was a foolish endeavour long before things got as bad. On a somewhat snarkier note, I wish Stahlman would've left some notes for the people in charge of the Blessing, the split straight through the Earth in Torchwood: Miracle Day, before it got sealed up. If he had, we might've collected the gas from there danger-free.

2. The Abzorbaloff's Meal

The Abzorbaloff creature first finds a group of humans €“ known collectively as London Investigative 'N' Detective Agency or LINDA €“ who are tracking the Doctor. He then uses their knowledge to find Jackie in an attempt to hopefully find Rose. All so that he may eventually hunt down and absorb the Doctor, for "the ultimate meal" and thus enjoy the wealth of the Doctors' lives and experiences for himself. What Makes This Pathetic? Despite the intricacy of the explanation above, this alien could have done a much better job planning. LINDA is ridiculously inefficient, so there had to be better choices: Sarah Jane, Luke, and Mr. Smith, for example, or raiding UNIT or Torchwood. Hell, even Wilf's Silver Shroud team even did a more efficient job. Not that Wilfred Mott knew the Doctor yet, but you get the point. Even setting a trap for the Doctor would have been more effective. But the poor skills of LINDA are nothing compared to the ease with which the alien is ultimately dispatched. Because the creature's cane is central to his continued survival, it would have been wise to first keep that information from those he has ingested until they were more fully incorporated, or at the very least, made some attempt to secure the cane against damage. A member of LINDA or any other human exposed to the Abzorbaloff could have killed him through sheer accident. What could possibly top the sheer buffoonery of the alien who didn't even need the Doctor to meet his end?

1. General Carrington's Xenophobia Campaign

His use of a suitcase bomb, which failed to kill the Doctor because it exploded under a table, was enough to earn this General a glib mention in the silly planning department. Really, what kind of explosive is that? But that turns out to be nothing compared to the depths of pathetic in his overall plan. Apparently, this ex-astronaut had a terrible experience with aliens in this past, and decides when aliens arrive that he must prove their evil intent by murdering humans involved and manipulating everything so it seems the aliens themselves are to blame. Carrington is so terrible at covering his tracks, he draws the attention of UNIT, rather than simply the TARDIS. But still, the real clincher is the discovery that Carrington himself invited the aliens in a plot to spread global xenophobia against aliens generally, so that Earth reacts with violence to all future alien visitors. Why Is This Pathetic? Well for one, General Carrington caused himself a lot of extra work. Aliens, especially hostile ones, seem to invade Earth regularly enough that he could've just waited for and publicised the danger of the next invasion, or researched and made public evidence of past invasions. Of course, all of these strategies, including Carrington's original plan, assume that humanity A) pays careful attention to news of alien invasion and B) then acts on that knowledge, which they clearly do not. Moreover, I fail to see what mobilising public opinion could really do. Humanity might choose to elect politicians with a hard-line stance against aliens, who are willing to pull a Harriet Jones on the situation? Set up mini-Torchwood-style militias? Give greater funding to UNIT? But regardless of General Carrington's nebulous goals, and setting aside the debate of our ability to act against alien forces, perhaps the single dumbest part of this plot is that arguably it was not even necessary to begin with. As human history dictates, xenophobic attitudes are a default setting. No matter how positive an initial encounter with aliens was, many would remain sceptical of our new visitors even without murders or threats. Carrington is a terribly tragic figure because his heart is bizarrely in the right place. He believes we need to be protected from the alien menace. He tops the list of truly pitiable ideas because of not only the futility of his enterpris,e but because we can truly sympathise with his perspective. Nothing is more sad to see than a misguided courageous person fighting for the wrong cause. The breadth of this list is surprising to me. While all ten of the entrants into the Doctor Who Hall of Shame are united by the sheer depths of their failure, these Ten Most Pathetic Plans are diverse in aim, flaws, and relative success. I would say better luck next time, but no one wants any of these baddies succeeding any time soon. What say you readers? Any one else who would be better off sticking to conquering Tivoli and mining on ancient Telos? Let me know below.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A person who thought a lot, then decided thinking with other people is more fun. If you fancy a chat, feel free to email NicoleatWhatCulture@excite.com