Doctor Who: 10 Ways They Could Screw Up The Peter Capaldi Era

Things to avoid so the Doctor can go on to bigger and better things.

Peter Capaldi Doctor Who Fanart Doctor Who is Britain's greatest export and a favorite science-fiction series for fans of the genre, but that doesn't mean the people in charge are immune to making bad decisions. Certain events in the history of The Doctor have left viewers scratching their heads asking "Why did they just do that?" Sometimes it's retconning something important in The Doctor's history, sometimes it's ignoring something completely and sometimes it's doing something unexpected for the sake of a shock. The most recent example is how The Doctor was able to live past what was supposed to be his final regeneration. It was just a little too convenient that he was granted another set of regenerations by the Timelords to keep him going. We would have all been sad to see him go, but having a poor excuse to keep him around is almost as bad. The way it happened almost felt like lazy writing, but the writers probably explored several options before settling on an easy fix. Still, there had to have been a better option than "Oh look, I have more lives thanks to my old friends on Gallifrey." Peter Capaldi is set to take over the role this fall when Doctor Who returns to television. This slideshow will examine some of the ways they could monumentally screw it up.

10. Get Rid Of Clara

The companions of The Doctor are almost as iconic as The Doctor himself. We have seen many come and go throughout the years, but Clara Oswald was given a larger role in The Doctor's history than any previous companion. Clara was transposed into the life of every incarnation of The Doctor, making her a guiding light for him throughout his journeys. One of the biggest letdowns the writers could give us at this point is ending her story after such a short time. Clara had a slow introduction, first popping up in The Asylum of the Daleks and then again as a Victorian governess who perished at the hands of a woman made of ice. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N34g5z4t168 She appeared throughout the last half of the last season of the show and was right there when Matt Smith morphed into Peter Capaldi. New Doctors usually get new companions, with the exception of Rose who was with The Doctor during his regeneration from Chris Eccelston to David Tennant. The writers should do the same thing here and keep Clara around for at least another full year. She has too much left in her character to ditch her at this point.

9. Rely On The Daleks Too Much

The most recognizable villain in the Doctor Who universe is the Dalek. Their history with The Doctor dates back decades and they are a go-to bad guy for any good Doctor Who adventure, but sometimes it feels like the writers rely too much on the rolling trash can with a strange voice and a plunger for an arm. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CUsj3U9WtmA Matt Smith's tenure may have featured more stories involving the Daleks than anyone since the first Doctor, but that is a trend that should not continue into Capaldi's run. One of the great pleasures of watching this show is seeing which old villains will pop back up and what kind of new monsters the writing team will churn out. They should not be taken away completely, but Steven Moffat should give them a rest and rely on some other mainstays like the Cybermen or The Silence.

8. Too Many New Monsters

In contrast to the previous point, not only should Doctor Who not rely too heavily on old monsters, they also shouldn't make an effort to come up with too many new ones. There needs to be an even mix of classic Doctor villains and new creatures spread out through the season to keep things fresh while still paying respect to its own past. Some of the greatest monsters in the history of the series have come from the new generation, but there are just as many we wish never existed. Killer Santas come to mind.

7. Never Bring Back Any Old Companions

Matt Smith's run as The Doctor was amazing for so many reasons, but one very frustrating thing about his years on the show was a lack of any previous companions. Steven Moffat almost seemed to go out of his way to exclude Captain Jack, Rose and Martha from the show. Why? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RAszjUxMZkE There is a rich history of compelling companions that should be revisited, even for just a short time. Fan-favorites Donna Noble or Mickey Smith could be brought in for an episode to hang around with Clara and The Doctor, or he could even run into his daughter, who was played once by Georgia Moffett and then never seen or heard from again. Forging a new path is important for every actor who plays The Doctor, but forgetting the people who helped him get to where he is today doesn't help anyone.

6. Change The TARDIS

The TARDIS is quite possibly more iconic in pop culture than The Doctor himself. The blue police box is so ingrained into his history that changing it in almost any way would confuse and upset fans around the world. The console room has changed many times over the course of the show, but it always keeps a few key elements and a similar layout to make it familiar. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OHHTw-chJ64 While it may seem impossible to consider that the writers would change the one constant from the show's history, I would not put it past Steven Moffat. He has already changed some key parts of The Doctor's history during his time as show-runner. We now know that The Doctor is not limited to 13 lives due to being granted a new series of regenerations by the Time Lords, and he even added a Doctor to the history of the character that had never been referenced before. Sure, we all loved seeing John Hurt interact with Matt Smith and David Tennant, but that is where the story altering changes need to stop. Leave the TARDIS alone, Steven, or you will have a mutiny on your hands.

5. Turn Another Villain Into A Comedy Character

Doctor Who has built up an impressive roster of villains over the years, but one race of aliens went from being a vicious group of cloned soldiers to comedy characters within the span of an episode. During "A Good Man Goes to War" we saw Strax, a Sontaran clone soldier, portray a bumbling sidekick to The Doctor, effectively killing any kind of intimidation factor the aliens had before. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nZxShriR0Y While there were a lot of laughs to be had at Strax's expense ("Doctor, help! I think I've been run over by a cab."), this is one thing the writers should avoid in the new season. The potato-headed alien could always return to help The Doctor, but turning any other villain into a pal would be a mistake. One of the greatest things about this show is the villains, but they have to maintain a certain level of scariness in order to be effective. The Sontarans were once a great enemy of The Doctor, but now they are little more than an excuse for some humor. After all, we don't want to see a pet Dalek or another Cyberman turned into a talking head.

4. They Don't Find Gallifrey

The last episode of Matt Smith's run saw the return of Gallifrey. The Timelords gave him a new set of regenerations in exchange for saving the universe on countless occasions, and The Doctor made sure to establish that his new goal would be locating his home world to bring it back, wherever or whenever it is. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BuUmnZ1GRLI One of the major changes that was made when the show first returned in 2005 was that The Doctor was the last of the Timelords. He had trapped the Daleks and his own race in a never-ending loop following a brutal time war in order to keep them from destroying the universe. Bringing back Gallifrey and his former compatriots would give us a whole new set of possibilities and adventures. It would be a shame if Steven Moffat decided not to have The Doctor bring his homeland back to the universe, but he has ignored storylines before, so it's not impossible that The Doctor's journey ends without the return of Gallifrey.

3. Make The Doctor Fall In Love

There have been teases of a love interest for The Doctor in the past, but it was never full fleshed out. He came close to telling Rose that he loved her and he even got married to River Song, but the closest he ever came to having a companion that was more than a friend was in the 1996 made-for-TV movie, and many fans of the show would like to forget that ever happened. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NK7srGITFpA Fox Studios had a big hand in making the eighth Doctor appear to fall in love because they thought American audiences wouldn't accept a lead male not falling for his leading lady. but that's probably what happens when us Yanks try to take something British and turn it into our own thing. Apologies about that. Every protagonist on every show seems to fall in love with someone these days, so it's refreshing to have a character who chooses to keep a degree of distance from the idea of love. A girlfriend would certainly limit his ability to make decisions for the good of everyone else at the expense of someone he cares about, which has happened on numerous occasions in the show's history. He just works better as a bachelor.

2. No Sonic Screwdriver

Ever since the show was brought back in 2005, the sonic screwdriver has been a main fixture in Doctor Who. The multi-tool with a million and one functions is almost as recognizable as the TARDIS, but it wasn't always his go to solution for a locked door or medical scan as it is today. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YS7PyULf_FY The device first appeared during the run of the second Doctor, but it was slowly phased out before the series was brought back by Russell T. Davies. New functions have been revealed over the past few years, with River Song even introducing the "Red setting." It was originally taken away due to the fact that writers had a hard time writing stories where problems could not easily be solved with a quick wave of the device. Today's writers are a bit more creative and often find ways to neutralize the tool's effectiveness in order to make a story more compelling. Let's just hope it stays that way.

1. Ignore The Canon

It's no secret that Steven Moffat likes to change things about the history of Doctor Who to serve the storyline of the show, but that should be kept to a minimum. Changing something established in his history works every so often in order to give the character a richer backstory, but it also angers some fans who have spent years learning about The Doctor, only to have something they knew to be true turn out to be unimportant. Science fiction fans are the most devoted fans out there. We study the history of our favorite characters and we discuss, debate and defend out favorite things about them. Remember when it was established that The Doctor was half human? What about his granddaughter, Susan Foreman? And Who could forget that he has broken his own rule about crossing his own timeline on numerous occasions? A show like this is bound to have some things that no longer work when it lasts this long, and therefore it's alright to change a minor detail so long as there is an explanation given, but everyone's favorite Timelord has a tendency to ignore his own warnings and do things he has established he should not be able to do. These are just some of the ways Peter Capaldi's era could be ruined. What are some other things you hope to see unchanged when the show returns this fall? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

I have been a writer for Bleacher Report for several years, and am now happy to also be a writer at What Culture! I do my best to contribute anywhere I can in a positive way, and that includes in my writing. Some people call me The Doctor, but Chris is fine.