Doctor Who: 11 Greatest Matt Smith Stories

Matt Smith The Doctor may be regenerating this Christmas but there's enough time to celebrate Matt Smith's number 11 before he goes on his way. With bow ties and floppy hair, childish glee and the sorrow of an old man Matt Smith's Doctor has provided us with a unique era defined by many unforgettable companions and mind-boggling timey-wimey plot arcs. It is not, however, the plot-arcs that this article is celebrating but the stand-alone stories that make up the larger whole. From 'The Eleventh Hour' to 'The Day of the Doctor,' this article will go through the most memorable and the most emotionally hard-hitting episodes of Matt Smith's tenure.

11. Journey To The Centre Of The TARDIS

doctor-who-journey-to-the-centre-of-the-tardis-review-whatculture-whatculture_trrrj_0

Coming part-way through a fairly drab run of episodes, 'Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS' proved to be an impressive second attempt at a Doctor Who script from Steve Thompson. The episode does what Doctor Who fans had been dreaming of for years €“ it showed the hidden depths of the TARDIS. It's a satisfyingly logical look at what the ship would have under her shell from the massive, Gallifreyan library to the surreal 'heart of the TARDIS' trapped in a paused moment of time. The guest cast are given defined personalities and each go through arcs that are as interesting as can be expected for a story told in the space of 42 minutes. Also, the idea of a human coming to terms with the idea that he is not a cyborg is a neat little twist on the stereotypical self-aware machine. The best thing about the story however is the discoveries that Clara makes about her current predicament. We see her learn about the Doctor's past and come a little closer to him as a result. Also great is the revelation that she is about to become one of the hideous monsters that has been stalking them throughout the episode. It is well set up yet still unexpected, the sign of a well written twist in an an exciting, twisting episode of television that ties together nicely.

10. The Angels Take Manhattan

Angels Take Manhattan

'The Angels Take Manhattan' succeeds where many of its contemporary episodes fail in that it is a very exciting piece of drama. It's a claustrophobic work that puts each of its characters in immense danger and maintains throughout its running time a lingering sense of impending doom. It may not be the most fun episode of Doctor Who to watch - it is very dark - but there can't be many people out there who deny that it is a very well made piece of television. Even considering just the exceptional cinematography, you're blown away by the episode's cinematic ambition. The way New York is shot somehow feels fresh despite the innumerable number of times the city has appeared on film in past, and what's more, the episode has a story epic enough to match the look of the thing - this is the finale, the danger so great it will tear The Doctor and Amy apart forever. Arthur Darvill's Rory remains my favorite companion to this day and he gives a fantastic performance here dealing with the hideous implications of his inevitable death. He adds layer upon layer of hopelessness and misery to his performance that really drive home just how horrendous the Weeping Angels' plan is. The final scenes of the episode live up to the whole Amy Pond era. Amy's letter is poignantly worded and its impact is only made stronger by Matt Smith's distraught face. The final surprise €“ when we see young Amy again one last time €“ brings the Amy Pond story round full circle in a harrowing yet hopeful way.

9. The Eleventh Hour

Eleventh Hour

From the very end to the very beginning, 'The Eleventh Hour' is a classic piece of entertainment. Not only is it one of the best series openers it is one of the most effective first episodes for a Doctor. Matt Smith has his portrayal down from the very beginning and so many things are set up. His lasting friendship with Amy, his enduring ability to relate to children and treat them like equals, The Pandorica, The Silence and Rory's journey to becoming an intergalactic hero.

The dialogue is witty, memorable moments like fish custard offer levity to an episode that is telling a very serious story, the story of a poor, lonely girl who is abandoned by all of her guardians. The Doctor's innate authority is put into question, he's shown to have ruined a poor girl's life €“ accidentally but still irresponsibly €“ it's an interesting dilemma.

Moffat taps into an unsettling idea of mouths speaking with voices that are not their own, adding Prisoner Zero to his roster of freaky baddies. It is clever how Moffat utilities everyday technology to defeat the villain as it makes the resolution to the story that much more satisfying since we understand how it was done. Despite having no TARDIS and no sonic screwdriver the Doctor saves the day in style, leaving the audience satisfied with the new guy at the helm.


8. Amy's Choice

Dream Lord

This episode never fails to satisfy. Appearing half way through Series 5, it gave the fans a well needed exploration of where Amy's loyalties lay when it came to the choice between her boyfriend and her best friend. Simon Nye takes full advantage of the science-fiction set up for the story and literally forces Amy to choose between a home on the TARDIS (representing the Doctor) and a home in Leadworth (representing Rory). It's a simple story-telling device but one that when combined with the surreal promise of dream-worlds is highly effective. The highlight of this episode is unquestionably The Dream Lord. I have high hopes that he is going to return in one of the last two Matt Smith episodes because the confrontation between the two characters is intense and just so memorable. There is enough gravitas surrounding the conversations between them to make this episode feel as though it could be a series finale. The episode blends humour with the drama beautifully. Not only are the Dream Lord's many quips darkly hysterical but the back-and-forth between the leads is very entertaining too. This is an episode with its tongue firmly planted in its cheek and it deserves to be remembered for a long time to come.

7. A Town Called Mercy

Town Called Mercy

A personal favorite of mine, 'A Town Called Mercy' manages to sum up the character of The Doctor in just 42 minutes. I find it so clever how writer Toby Whithouse took what could have been such a limiting premise €“ it's set in the wild west (horrifying flashback to 'it's set on a pirate ship'...) but still, he makes so much of it. There are scares and sorrows abound in this mini-masterpiece that pits the Doctor against a big, mean cyborg and human nature itself. In 'Amy's Choice' the Doctor faces himself in a fairly literal sense, yet in this episode he is forced to confront his own sins in the form of another. Kahler-Jex embodies The Doctor in more subtle ways than The Master or The Dream Lord do but he no less resembles a side of the old man that he would far rather not face. Jex is a survivor of a war in which he lost his integrity and his honor for the greater good, just like the Doctor. He sets himself up in Mercy in order to atone for his sins just as the Doctor travels, righting wrongs in order to make up for his. The episode concludes with the gunslinger setting himself up as a guardian of Mercy to do the same and so we see in these three characters distorted mirror reflections of each other. It's a character study of a depth that one has no reason to expect from a family, Saturday-evening TV show. Ultimately this episode is about self-reflection and morality. How far will one go to the dark side before they cannot forgive them self and how can one forgive something in them self when they cannot forgive in another? So treat yourself, go and watch it again because this episode offers so much more than the average episode of Doctor Who.

6. Asylum Of The Daleks

Asylum Of The Daleks

This is how you open a series! Packed full of epic, other-worldly locations and nail-biting tension this episode has it all. The idea that the Daleks need the help of the Doctor is a little far-fetched, but the writing of the episode makes you conveniently forget that as it entertains you with its sharpness. The inclusion of Oswin, an offspring of Clara, is a smart and intriguing one. It allows audiences to get attached to the actress as her banter and brilliance do indeed make her the highlight of the episode. Her flirtations with Rory and the Doctor are very amusing yet cleverly Moffat makes sure that Oswin is an equal to the Doctor, not his superior. She doesn't put him down in any way and it helps the audience get behind her. The great twist of the episode is also very neatly built up, from the terrifying scene where Rory accidentally wakes up a room full of clinically insane killers ('EGGS EGGS EXTERMINATE!) to the slow transformation that Amy starts going through to become one. The fact that Oswin, the new companion, is a Dalek doesn't come out of nowhere but it still makes a huge surprise for the audience, ensuring they'll come back next week and the week after that.

5. The Girl Who Waited

Girl Who Waited

A mini-masterpiece, many episodes of Doctor Who attempt to convince the audience of Amy and Rory's devotion to each other, but this one definitively proves it. There's a lot going on between the two characters here all set off by the fascinating premise of the two Amys. I view this episode as being Rory's story €“ much like Amy's Choice where Amy is forced to choose between her two men. this is Rory's choice, where he's forced to choose between his two wives. It marks the climax of Rory's character arc €“ from nurse to becoming very much like the Doctor himself €“ when he is forced to make one of those terrible moral decisions that the Doctor is faced with every day. Beyond epic betrayal and unforgettable drama however there is a lot of subtlety in the performances of our two leads. Darvill doesn't get enough credit for the things he can do with a script €“ in this one without dialogue or cue he makes it clear how torn up Rory is over seeing Amy grown old. He isn't sad that she's older; he loves his wife no matter what. If anything, he's just sad he didn't get to grow old with her. It is a very human piece of drama that is a testament to what science fiction and the Doctor Who show can do.

4. A Christmas Carol

Doctor Who A Christmas Carol

This is possibly the first and definitely the last great Doctor Who Christmas Special. On Moffat's first go he managed to combine an epic tale with lovable, memorable characters and a truckload of Christmas spirit. On the basest, most immature level I love this episode because it is an entire era of Doctor Who in an hour, namely it's the Kazran and Abigail era. We see the Doctor meeting them, their first few adventures, dissent growing between The Doctor and his friends and finally the day when they must leave him. On the level of a pretentious literature student I see this as being a very rich script filled with easter eggs for the discerning fan willing to sit down with a notepad. There are themes of inspiration and finding understanding in the darkest of places, and it is the ultimate update of the Christmas Carol, replete with flying sharks. On the level of a hopelessly over-emotional, Christmas-loving fool it's just a mosh-pit of shmultz. I find the romance between Kazran and Abigail to be very compelling, and the tragic omnipresence of death makes theirs a bittersweet relationship. Yet the way Moffat simply mentions that, turning something as tragic as death into just another part of living just brings the whole script to a satisfying, poignant close.

3. Vincent And The Doctor

A mosh pit of schmaltz is a bit of a cruel way to describe this episode but there is a cavalcade of emotions contained in-between it's opening and closing credits. Vincent Van Gogh is a tragic figure, manic depressive and unappreciated in his own time, so writer Richard Curtis makes the most of his stint at the TARDIS controls by indulging his history-fanboy side and letting the painter know how much he would be appreciated in the future. That is why this episode works so well, it is the result of love. Richard (Blackadder) Curtis clearly cares passionately about Van Gogh and history in general. In addition to making this episode a fanboy-squee-fest he still finds time to tackle an important discussion about manic depression. Van Gogh is not portrayed to be mad in his depression, just rather passionate at times and isolated in others. The episode handles the issue sensitively and it is clear that as much research went into Van Gogh's mental condition as went into his surroundings. The episode is a thing of beauty, cheesy at times but it has its heart firmly in the right place. An unforgettable moment which defines the optimism that prevails in the episode (despite the dark themes) is when Amy, the Doctor and Vincent are lying together upon a hill, looking up to the sky and before their eyes the sky changes to how Vincent sees it. Wind and movement and color all exist in everything and Vincent and the Doctor takes it upon itself to remind us all of that.


2. The God Complex

God Complex

The soundtrack, the characters, the nightmarish imagery - The God Complex is a brain-child of Toby Whitehouse and he brings the same levels of comedy and horror to the episode as he does to his own BBC fantasy series, the unmissable Being Human. The episode is based on the idea of a hotel that contains within it one room that stores your greatest fear in the universe. It 's a fun concept with tantalizing overtones of Kubrick's The Shining but the best thing about it isn't the premise €“ we know all too well that a bad writer can take the best idea in the world and crush it into the ground €“ it's how the story is told. It's so easy to sit before an episode of Doctor Who and watch it passing by feeling nothing but the slight sense of disappointment when your prediction for how it would end comes to pass. This one plays it right €“ despite being set in a mysterious, surreal location, the episode is relatable because it's about human emotions. Our guest cast feel real because the nature of the complex is one that exposes their personalities, what makes them tick, what they fear, why they are who they are. Rita in particular is one of those characters who come into a story and prove that they have enough guile and spirit to become a proper companion. This is also a notable episode for being the one to round off Amy and Rory's time in the TARDIS, and I think it manages to pull this off is far more interesting and mature than the departures of previous companions. They don't leave because they're trapped in another world, tragically separated forever! No, through the device of the monster that feeds on faith we see how Amy has been clinging on to her faith in the Doctor. She met him at a young impressionable age when she saw him as the greatest man in the universe and she continues to hold this view of him, which has stopped her from growing up. This is a poignant episode yet it's fun and kind of scary too. A well considered end.


1. The Doctor's Wife

Doctors Wife

Like all the best episodes of Who this one simultaneously plays up the macabre and tugs on the heart strings in a thoroughly unique fashion. The greatest thing about Doctor Who is that it is a show that can do anything and be anything, and this episode takes full advantage of the infinite possibilities. The Doctor's Wife is full of neat ideas €“ the patchwork people are sickening yet brilliant, their absurd personalities proving unnerving while their stitched-up bodies horrify. Amy and Rory's journey through a dark, deceptive TARDIS is actually scary too. We watch them getting tested physically and mentally as they try to survive the psychotic mind that is playing with them but the best idea of all is the one that provides the emotional core of the episode. The most important relationship the Doctor has is with his TARDIS. They're the only two things to appear in every Doctor Who story, so to see him get to talk to her is an exciting opportunity that pulls from Matt Smith one of his best performances as the Eleventh Doctor. The Doctor's love for the TARDIS is shown on screen to be pure and innocent. He is a boy again in her company, eager to impress and quick to invest his entire heart in their relationship. As a result, the sight of his face when at last he must say good bye to her is doubly heartbreaking because of the vulnerability that Smith brings to his performance. The episode contains all you could want from a Doctor Who story and is, in my opinion the greatest of Matt Smith's era. So that's what I think. What do you think? Feel free to comment!

Contributor
Contributor

Whilst not writing articles for WhatCulture! Stephen can usually be found livin' it up in the city or livin' it down on the couch in front of one of many DVDs. You can tell how many of his friends are in Edinburgh at any given time by measuring how prolific he is on this site.