Doctor Who: 25 Actors Who'd Make Great Companions

Series 8 is expected by some to be Jenna Coleman's last. With that in mind, here's 25 candidates for who could be the next Doctor Who companion.

A few weeks back, we speculated on which actors we'd love to see take on the role of Doctor for future incarnations, but what about companions? A companion is just as vital to Doctor Who as the Doctor is; they provide the warm, human normalness that balances out his eccentricity, and they're what leads viewers into the show. Christopher Eccleston once claimed that Russell T Davies never wanted to be the Doctor, he wanted to be a companion, and he's not alone; millions of us have wondered at one time or another what it would be like if the Doctor fell out of the sky and took us on a journey through time and space. Series 8 is expected by some to be Jenna Coleman's last, but which actresses (and a few actors) would make an excellent addition to the TARDIS crew? Here, in no particular order, are twenty-five we'd like to see; add your suggestions below!

25. Louise Brealey

Immensely popular playing Molly Hooper in Sherlock, Louise Brealey certainly be a popular choice for those fans that watch both of Moffat's big shows. Of course, Martin Freeman's an obvious choice too, but Brealey's pretty much already playing a companion role too; she started off mesmerised by Sherlock, grew to stand up to him, and she's there whenever he needs her. She's also brilliantly funny and really sweet; could you imagine what the chemistry would be like with the probably grumpy Capaldi? Steven Moffat likes to cast actors he knows well, from Amanda Abbington (Freeman's wife) to his own son, both in Sherlock. Maybe Brealey's one of the more likely names on the list...

24. Rose Byrne

Doctor Who was criticised in the 80s for casting American and Australian companions, as some critics felt that it was too obvious an assault on overseas markets. Rose Byrne however is an Australian actress capable of a brilliant English accent, as demonstrated in I Give It A Year. At 34, she's older than most companions, which could provide an interesting dynamic in the TARDIS, especially if she's not all that impressed with a man, just because he has a time machine. She's also fantastic at comedy, she has great timing, and she's an excellent character actress; it's a shame she's probably staying in Hollywood.

23. Gemma Chan

Having already had a small role in 'The Waters of Mars', Gemma Chan is slowly becoming more and more well-known. The girlfriend of Jack Whitehall, Chan has played shy, vulnerable characters (Dates), and bitchy, brash ones (Fresh Meat); she's also used to playing characters younger than her age (31), and is waiting for a huge role in television. Everything points to becoming a companion one day, and she's definitely got the likeability to succeed as one. She's another actress who's also appeared in Sherlock, as well as Secret Diary of a Call Girl, alongside a certain Billie Piper.

22. James Corden

Another actor who's already appeared in the show is James Corden, as the ever-popular Craig. Whether Alfie would travel with him or not is unsure - maybe the Doctor could take Craig along when Alfie's a bit older - but Corden's a fantastic actor who would be brilliant as a full-time companion. Whether he's funny or not seems to divide people, but there's no denying he has an everyman quality about him that contrasts well against a Time Lord, and if he got as enthusiastic about adventure as his character Phil does, in The Wrong Mans, he'd be incredibly popular with fans. It might also be nice to see him write an episode; Gavin and Stacey was brilliant, after all.

21. Emilia Clarke

A face that's already known both sides of the Atlantic, Emilia Clarke is a young actress tipped for huge things. Already a regular in Game of Thrones, She's young, mercurial and mysterious. She's definitely in the mould of a traditional companion, as she can play feisty and fearless, and she would definitely draw Game of Thrones into watching Doctor Who. As well as stagework she's done in America, she's signed up for the new Terminator film, out next year; it looks like a Hollywood career beckons.

20. Lenora Crichlow

Another actress used to fantasy-drama, Lenora Crichlow is an up-and-coming actress that many have touted for a role as a companion. One of the leads in the first few Being Human series, Crichlow's Annie Sawyer was unsure of herself to begin with, but as she eased into the series, she became more confident, having to prove herself and save and the world. She's a very funny actress, extremely enigmatic, and who knows, if Toby Whithouse becomes showrunner, she could be given a role on the show. In Series 3 of Doctor Who, she appeared as one of the passengers in 'Gridlock'.

19. Alice Eve

The daughter of Waking the Dead's Trevor Eve, an actor who auditioned for the Eighth Doctor, Alice Eve has already made her name in sci-fi, starring in Star Trek Into Darkness and Men In Black 3. An actress more used to film than television, Eve is especially glamorous and exciting but she can also come across as vulnerable, adventurous and hugely intelligent. She probably wouldn't be as bubbly and witty as Clara or Amy, but play more of a cool, aloof match for a Doctor. She caused controversy by appearing in her underwear in Star Trek, but probably wouldn't be allowed to do the same should she land a role in Doctor Who, despite Matt Smith appearing naked at Christmas.

18. Martin Freeman

A hugely obvious choice, Martin Freeman plays the companion role in Moffat's other big hit, Sherlock. Freeman is a wonderfully gifted actor who in Moffat's words, "finds poetry in the every-man". He's capable of the hilariously funny, extremely moving, and often, amusingly grumpy, which would certainly work well with Peter Capaldi. Even if he doesn't become a full-time traveller though, why not draft him in for an episode or two, as a Craig-like friend for the Doctor? He recently claimed that he's a fan of the show, but hasn't actually been offered a part. Maybe after the Ponds, the Doctor could make friends with another couple, in Freeman and partner Amanda Abbington?

17. Michelle Keegan

A favourite with men across the country, Michelle Keegan is another immensely popular northern soapstar, much like Jenna Coleman. Although she's only ever appeared in Coronation Street, Keegan is a fans favourite; ballsy, exciting and sweet. Whether she could cut it in the BBC's biggest drama when she's more known by the tabloids than the Baftas is debatable, but everyone has to start somewhere: who knew that popstar Billie Piper would make an amazing companion? The Mancunian actress is leaving Corrie this year, so will no doubt start acting in other roles.

16. Tommy Knight

Already a companion in the Sarah Jane Adventures, Tommy Knight's Luke is a familiar face in the Whoniverse. But what about giving him a chance on the flagship show? It would be a nice chance to say goodbye to Sarah Jane, rewarding fans of the spin-off who know about Knight's character Luke Smith, and introducing a new set of fans to the show. He's a child genius, a character that would probably enjoy some amusing clashes with the Doctor, and there would be nostalgic references to be made that fans would love. Russell T Davies planned a future for the character; he had intended for Luke to come out as gay, before the show was cancelled with Sarah Jane apparently going to remark that as long as he didn't date a Slitheen, she didn't mind.

15. Jennifer Lawrence

We can dream, can't we? When asked what he'd love to see most in the fiftieth anniversary of Doctor Who, Matt Smith replied "Jennifer Lawrence". A lot of the fandom would probably love to see her in the show too; she's funny, vulnerable and gutsy, and she'd probably have a fantastic relationship with the Doctor; that's without mentioning the attention she'd draw to the show. It seems though that she'll be too busy and far too famous to ever appear in Doctor Who; she's the most in-demand actress in Hollywood, and starring in the next two Hunger Games films will probably be much more attractive an offer than nine months a year shooting in Cardiff.

14. Carey Mulligan

One of the best one-off characters that Doctor Who has ever produced, Carey Mulligan is another Hollywood star, and another actress that Whovians would love to welcome back to the show. Her performance as the no-nonsense, loveable Sally Sparrow captured fans hearts, and started a campaign to give her a full-time companion spot. If Sally were to travel with the Doctor, she'd no doubt show a curious, inquisitive side again, coupled with an excitement for adventure, and she wouldn't be patronised, that's for sure. Unfortunately though, she's another actress far too big for the show these days. Maybe a cameo one day?

13. Kimberley Nixon

It seems odd that the revived Doctor Who hasn't had a Welsh companion; granted, the Doctor seems to spend a lot of his time in London, but wouldn't it be nice if we saw another companion who lived somewhere else? Kimberly Nixon is a Welsh actress perhaps best known for her roles in Fresh Meat and Cranford. She's extremely funny and feisty, and she's capable of good English and Irish accents, as well as her natural Welsh. She's someone who's progressing to bigger and better roles, and something in Doctor Who seems inevitable one day. Nixon has even admitted herself that it would be "convenient" to be in Doctor Who, as they film in her hometown.

12. Ingrid Oliver

Another character who appeared in Doctor Who, Osgood, has been mentioned as a possible companion in the future. From a story point of view, Osgood could be a mystery to the Doctor, over where she acquired his scarf, and how she knows him. As an actress though, Ingrid Oliver almost played the part of an ordinary fan in 'The Day of the Doctor'; she was awestruck by him, shy and timid. If she was to appear again in the show, it would interesting for her to develop as a character, and show the braveness that she did when fighting Zygons. Or maybe, the Doctor could find her before the events of 'The Day of the Doctor', and that's how she acquired the scarf?

11. Ellen Page

One of only a few North Americans on this list - a lot of core British Who fans massively dislike the idea of an American companion - Canadian Ellen Page would be a frontrunner, should the Doctor travel with someone from overseas. Massively down-to-earth and dryly funny, Page would be perfect in that sort of role, even if it was a Canton-like guest appearance during a trip across the pond. And as her roles in Juno and Inception are anything to go by, she'd have an intriguing and unpredictable relationship with a Time Lord. Another actress more likely to stay in Hollywood though, it doesn't seem like Page will be in Who any time soon.

10. Katherine Parkinson

A name touted for the first female Doctor, Katherine Parkinson would be just as great as a companion. In her mid-thirties, she's older than a lot of companions, but it would be interesting to see a friendship with the Doctor similar to the one he had with Donna; The IT Crowd definitely shows Parkinson in that kind of role, becoming friends with a couple of nerds despite their differences. She's got a lot of presence and a lot of experience on television, ranging from Sherlock to Doc Martin, and would thrive in such a big TV role. And how brilliant would it be if Richard Ayoade joined her and the Doctor in the TARDIS?

9. Simon Pegg

Simon Pegg actually played the villainous Editor in the first series of NewWho, but has since claimed that he doesn't actually watch the show anymore. A film star these days, Pegg is often cast as the witty, daft, human everyman, from Scotty in Star Trek, to Shaun in Shaun of the Dead. Reportedly a massive sci-fi nerd too, it would be fantastic to see a companion genuinely excited by aliens and distant planets, especially if he's read up on them, like Rory did before entering the TARDIS. It's perhaps too obvious to suggest Nick Frost as well, but either of them would no doubt have a fantastically funny and tempestuous relationship with Capaldi's Doctor.

8. Freida Pinto

Doctor Who doesn't tend to cast many non-white actors, especially in the role of companion, but Indian Freida Pinto would excel as the Doctor's best friend. Originally only a model, Pinto got into acting on the back of Slumdog Millionaire, and received multiple award nominations for her role as Latika. Director Danny Boyle claimed that he knew she was right for the part just from her audition tape; she has an effortlessness in front of camera, and can play both shy and commanding characters. If she were to appear in Doctor Who though, it would certainly make for an interesting relationship with the Doctor.

7. Lara Pulver

Another star that Steven Moffat has worked with on Sherlock, Lara Pulver is an actress who was rumoured to have been cast as the Twelfth Doctor. Again, she'd provide a different dynamic to Doctor Who though, as she's much more a River-type character than say Amy or Rose. Though she's excels at playing love interests with rivalries - and not just as Irene Adler, but in Skins: Fire too - it would be interesting to see her acting opposite Capaldi, showing more of the humour she's capable of. It would be surprising if she actually was cast as a companion, but surely she's going to appear in Doctor Who at some point or another?

6. Jessica Raine

Another actress to appear in Doctor Who, Jessica Raine is an actress that Whovians know from two big parts, as she also starred in the docudrama, An Adventure in Space and Time as Verity Lambert. In both performances, Raine was subtle, quiet and extremely charming, and though she wouldn't have to reprise her role as Emma from 'Hide' to become a companion, it would be fascinating to see more of that character. Likewise, the appearance playing Lambert showed what she could do if she was given a bigger role in Who; let's face it, she pretty much was a companion to David Bradley's William Hartnell. She's already a favourite on the BBC, as she stars in Call The Midwife, but would Moffat have her back for another part in Doctor Who?

5. Andrea Riseborough

Another film star, and an actress who appeared in the Being Human pilot before being replaced by Lenora Crichlow, Andrea Riseborough is an actress who would make a great companion. Having played roles as diverse as a young Margaret Thatcher, to Tom Cruise's wife in a sci-fi epic, Riseborough would be perfect as a mature counterpart to the often ridiculous Doctor. She is more used to playing intense roles in darkly serious films, which would suit many Doctor Who episodes to the ground, but it would be interesting to see her lighten up a bit for the fantasy side of the show. Doctor Who might've missed the chance to cast her - she's a rising star in Hollywood now - but it's certainly interesting imagining what she'd be like opposite Peter Capaldi.

4. Rafe Spall

Rafe Spall is another up-and-coming British actor with a few blockbusters under his belt, often mentioned in relation to the role of the Doctor. As anyone who's ever seen Pete Vs Life will tell you though, Spall would be just as good as a companion. He's not only hilariously funny and extremely believable as an unlucky nobody, he's a great character actor with exceptional timing; he's definitely an actor that would make the most of the funnier Moffat scripts, and his relationship with a Doctor might be similar to Jack Harkness's, or Rory's. Not only is Rafe Spall brilliant at comedy though, he's capable of the serious too, as roles in Anonymous and Prometheus prove; he's also the son of Peter Pettigrew himself, Timothy Spall.

3. Antonia Thomas

Another rising star of British television, Antonia Thomas is an actress who seems like a perfect fit for Doctor Who. One of the stars of comedy-drama Misfits, Thomas's character Alisha saw one of the biggest arcs of the series, eventually becoming a kind and compassionate character. Creators of the show claimed that it was Thomas that made Alisha so vulnerable, and thus, she became a more complex character within the show based on Thomas's own talents. It's a similar arc to Amy growing up or Martha leaving the Doctor, and it's definitely a role that Thomas could take on.

2. Victoria Wood

The oldest name on this list, 60-year-old Victoria Wood is comedy royalty, and would make an excellent best friend to Peter Capaldi's Doctor. She's easily one of the finest comedy talents that Britain has ever produced, but Wood is a brilliant character actor who would excel in Doctor Who as a human antithesis to the Doctor's otherworldly weirdness. She's often quite maternal, dry and commanding on-screen, and she'd no doubt put the Doctor in his place; having an older face in the TARDIS could bring out either the child in the Doctor or the ancient being, and either would work well to Wood's contrast. Doctor Who really doesn't feel like Victoria Wood's kind of thing, but it would incredible if she'd make an appearance, like long-term collaborator Celia Imrie did in 'The Bells of Saint John'. Or even better, why not write an episode?

1. Emma Watson

And finally, perhaps the most obvious choice for a Doctor Who companion. When David Yates announced that he was to direct a Doctor Who film (which never saw the light of day, after all), Emma Watson was the first name mentioned for a role. It's easy to see why; in the Harry Potter series, she plays a similar kind of character, providing wisdom and warmth to the passionate lead. Though she's probably more likely to stay in film, rather than return to the UK for TV roles, she's still a dream companion for many Doctor Who fans. Who would you like to see though? Comment below!

Contributor
Contributor

Mark White hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.