Doctor Who: 3 Things Wrong With The 50th Anniversary

Doctor Who 50th Sonic Screwdrivers Since the end of series seven and even before that, we've been eagerly anticipating Doctor Who's 50th anniversary episode. Finally, it came. I had such high hopes for this episode. Some of them were met €“ David Tennant and Matt Smith played off of each other really well, the banter between the pair was brilliant and John Hurt's more serious Doctor only heightened the humour. Hurt himself was also a really great addition to the show and played the part of an angrier, pained Doctor really well, even if the role could have easily been played by Christopher Eccleston. But then there were some things that, to me, just weren't right. Read on to find out what - but if you haven't seen it yet, watch out for spoilers.

3. The Zygon Story Didn't Have A Resolution

Zygon In true leaving-Hitler-in-the-cupboard style, Moffat strikes again with the Zygon story. It seems like these aliens were only really used as a filler to stretch out the suspense and to keep the episode going a little longer, as they didn't really do an awful lot. It was a pity, as they had a lot of potential €“ how had they come to capture Queen Elizabeth I? What were their plans? And most importantly, how did they resolve their issue? It was a really interesting set up €“ not knowing who was from what species, especially when two of them knew but didn't speak up (or did they?). Well, I guess we'll never know because they didn't finish the story! The Doctor's just swanned off to save Gallifrey and left the argument to resolve itself €“ surely not the best idea when there are killer aliens around in a bunker stocked with all sorts of powerful technology?

2. The Doctor Is Just A Hero

Mp I found the ending to the 50th anniversary really disappointing €“ I was actually hoping for it all to go wrong and for Gallifrey to be stuck in the timelock. I understand that destroying his entire planet and people was very distressing for the Doctor €“ it was a burden that he had to carry for over 400 years, so I do understand why he did it. But at the same time, having a good-guy all of the time is just dull. One of the main reasons why the show was so successful when it was rebooted with Christopher Eccleston as the Doctor was that he was angry and war torn. The Ninth Doctor stormed onto the show with an interesting personality and a grim intensity. He was obviously damaged, and you got to see him develop and recover, sparking off a process which would affect all his successors. Now he's just a boring, standard hero like any other. He's only ever saved people €“ he's never done anything horrific in his life. Although he's had to live with himself thinking that he's destroyed Gallifrey, the Timelords and countless other races, he didn't actually do it, so all of that pain was felt in vain.

1. The War Was Hell... Or Was It?

timeWar In the last Russell T Davies' episode, The End Of Time, the Doctor explained to the Master how, at the end of the Time War, the war had become 'hell'. It seemed that even though destroying Gallifrey and the Timelords distressed him, he knew that it was what he had to do. He even made the decision again in the episode, sending the Timelords and Gallifrey back into the timelocked war under the logic that they had changed and become something other than the great Timelords he remembered. So obviously, it was an informed decision that the Doctor understood to be the right thing to do. Now, however, it's as if all of that has been completely ignored. Instead, we're left with a situation where the Doctor has completely forgotten about what the Timelords had planned, and what he had put a stop to. Some might argue that Moffat was only correcting Davies' mistake of getting rid of Gallifrey and is now opening up a whole host of new storylines, but the war-torn, pained Doctor was one of the main reasons that the reboot of the series was so successful and if Gallifrey was the cost, then surely it should stay that way? Even if just in the name of continuity? So that's what I think. What do you think? Feel free to comment!

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hayley is a twenty year old student, studying Creative Writing and Sociology at the University of Winchester. In her spare time she writes her novel, sings in a musical theatre choir and goes to the gym. For her creative writing blog: http://hayleymay1993.tumblr.com Or follow her on twitter: @miss_hayley_may