Doctor Who: 50 Unanswered Questions
The Eighth Doctor
13. Why Was The Master Being Tried By The Daleks?
In the 8th Doctors only televised appearance, we learn that not only do the Daleks have a robust judiciary system but unsurprisingly, they also have no aversion to using the death penalty. Yet the last time we saw The Master and the Daleks together, they were allies. What changed? More to the point, why have a trial and execute him when they could have easily killed him on the spot whenever they captured him? It could be argued that they were in on his scheme to kill The Doctor. Consider this the last time the 7th Doctor encountered the Daleks he used The Hand of Omega to destroy their home world. Yet in a remarkably uncharacteristic display of grace, they stood aside and allowed The Doctor to collect The Master's remains from (the oddly resurrected) Skaro. The only possible reason for this unusual behavior was that this was all an unnecessarily elaborate scheme that would have failed miserably if the Doctor hadn't been accidentally gunned down by street thugs.
12. Is The Doctor Half Human?
If only The Doctor could be counted on to tell the truth! The revelation by the 8th Doctor that he is half human came after decades of Doctor Who being on the air and totally out of the blue. It has never been raised again and largely ignored within the TV series. Did the 8th Doctor regenerate as half-human perhaps as a survival mechanism to address the fact that his last incarnation died as a direct result of not being human? He still has two hearts, but were there other, unseen changes? Did he perhaps pick up human DNA from all his regenerations near and around humans? Was this something he has never mentioned before or since out of a sense of shame? The Doctor being half human would provide another explanation as to his affinity for Earth and humanity and might also explain why he was "so lonely" (The Girl in the Fireplace) as a child.
11. Why Would The Eye Of Harmony In The Tardis Need A Human Eye To Be Accessed?
To access The Doctor's Tardis, The Master needed a human retinal pattern. Considering that the Eye of Harmony was the power source for a machine intended to be piloted by Time Lords, this seems to be an exceedingly odd security feature. Is this a measure installed by The Doctor to prevent exactly what The Master attempted? This makes sense from the standpoint that The Doctor pretty much always has a spare human laying around that he could use if needed and he does have an aversion to the Time Lords being able to tamper with his Tardis going back to his 3rd Doctor days. But what about when he's traveling alone? Does The Doctor somehow ensure that his eyes are always human even though the rest of his body changes when he regenerates? Or is the simplest answer is that for once The Doctor told the truth and he is half human?
The Ninth Doctor
10. What Caused The Time War?
It has been argued that the 4th Doctor's attempt to either prevent their creation, reduce their aggressiveness or find an exploitable weakness against the Daleks at the instruction of the Time Lords (Genesis of the Daleks) was the first shot in the Time War. From there, the Daleks retaliated with an assassination attempt against the High Council of the Time Lords (Resurrection of the Daleks). Russell T. Davies has referred to the destruction of Skaro by the 7th Doctor in Remembrance of the Daleks is the first official act of the Time War but there are no indications during the remainder of the 7th Doctor's tenure that the Time War had broken out. So what forced hostilities to escalate into open conflict?
9. Which Doctor Used The Moment, Destroying Dalek And Time Lord Alike And Time-Locking The Time War?
Prior to the revelation of the John Hurt Doctor at the conclusion of the Name of The Doctor, fans had argued that either the 8th or 9th Doctor had been the one to pull the trigger that ended the war. Some felt that the 8th Doctor had met his demise prior to the Time War or had regenerated in the early days of the conflict leaving the 9th Doctor to use the Moment and end the war. Now with the SPOILER ALERT unveiling of "The Night of The Doctor," we know that the 8th Doctor was not The Doctor who fought in the Time War. On the BBC sanctioned whoisdoctorwho site mentioned in Rose, a sighting of the 9th Doctor "...wearing some old Edwardian outfit, not a leather jacket," is listed. The witness thought that The Doctor was "a loon" or "drunk" but recalls hearing him say, "They're all gone, I'm the only one left." This gives the impression that 8 became 9, but as we now know, even that were still possible, the 8th Doctor had stopped wearing the Edwardian outfit before taking his final breath. Evidence is mounting that the Hurt Doctor is the one face of the Doctor unworthy to carry the name, but did he act alone and will he somehow be redeemed by the conclusion of "The Day of The Doctor?" We may have an answer on November 23rd!
8. At The Time Of The Events Documented In Rose, How Long Has It Been Since The 9th Doctor Regenerated?
The only indication that the Doctor is newly regenerated is based on his remarks made after catching a glimpse of himself in the mirror. Its hard to believe that he has been in this body for too long if he hasn't had the chance to see what he looks like. Arguably, he simply might not have had time in all the excitement to have even changed his clothes from his previous regeneration. If you look at the 8th Doctor's recently updated look, the case could be made that the 8th fell in battle, the 9th rose and never looked back. Nine doesn't seem the type to be preoccupied by his looks or his wardrobe, so maybe he just simply couldn't be bothered to have checked his new body out. Or perhaps his guilt over his actions in the Time War was so great that he couldn't stand the thought of looking at his own face. But surely, he must have had to brush his teeth or shave at some point? There are various pictures displayed in this episode showing the Doctor throughout history but traveling without Rose Tyler. Were these adventures that occurred when he disappeared in the Tardis for what seemed like seconds near the end of the episode or were these adventures he had prior to meeting Rose?
The Tenth Doctor
7. Who Was The Woman In White?
The End of Time featured a mysterious woman in white. Originally said to be The Doctor's mother, the writers and then showrunner have since left the answer vague. My first impression was that the woman in white was intended to be The Doctor's granddaughter Susan. The references to having been lost, the ability to break the time lock and connect in a seeming psychic way with Wilf (Susan exhibited various mental powers while traveling with her grandfather) meant that to me, it all added up. Were it not for the initial semi-official line about the woman in white actually being his mother, I would be totally convinced of her identity. Others have argued that it was former companion Romana with a new face and body. Unfortunately we may never get an answer to this question.
6. What Happened To The Master?
Sucked into the Time War with the Time Lords? Body burned up through the draining of his Sith Lord style fingertip lightning blasts? Destroyed by Rasillon? Slipped away in the confusion? The subtle incorporation of The Master's theme music into the 50th Anniversary could be seen as a hint that an answer may be on the horizon.
The Eleventh Doctor
5. What Happened To The Cybus Cybermen?
The Cybermen of "Pete's World" replaced the original series Cybermen without missing a beat, and for the Russell T. Davis era "Cybus Cybermen" were the only Cybermen. For the uninitiated, these Cybermen stomping about bellowing "DELETE" at the top of whatever Cybermen have for lungs were no different from the Cybermen faced by the first 9 Doctors. But then Steven Moffat took over and in interview about "The Pandorica Opens," he confirmed that the metal monsters in that adventure were the original Cybermen from Mondas. They didn't have enough in the budget to remove the Cybus logo, but since then it no longer appears on the Cybermen. Plus, it appears that the originals are not only back, but have totally phased out the newer models. So where are the Cybus Cybermen? One possible answer is that the Mondas Cybermen simply assimilated the Cybus ones and went about their business. Another answer is that they managed to find their way back to the alternate universe from which they originated and are wreaking havoc with only Rose Tyler and the meta-crisis Doctor to stand in their way.
4. Why Does The Tardis Always Take The Doctor "Where He Needs To Go?"
The Tardis has been shown to be a sentient being with no problem expressing itself in the limited means it has at its disposal. From trying to avoid Captain Jack to "not liking" Clara, to disrupting the attempts of a salvage team to steal her parts, the Tardis is by all indications as alive as you or I. In The Doctor's Wife, the matrix of the Tardis is removed and placed in the form of a woman named Idris. When chastised for being unreliable at getting him where he wants to go The Doctor learns that the Tardis always takes him where he is needed. Why would the Tardis constantly be dropping someone it claims to love in circumstances that not only could, but have led to his death? What could possibly be its motivation? A possible answer may be found in Idris's claim that the Tardis "stole a Time Lord" to see the universe. With a shared sense of adventure, the Tardis could be taking The Doctor where not only is he most needed, but where he would definitely not be bored! 3. Why Was It Impossible For The Doctor To Retrieve The Ponds?
Even though the New York to which the Ponds were banished is inaccessible by time travel, what would stop The Doctor from traveling to New Jersey in the same year, taking a train to New York, collecting them and heading back to the Tardis and adventuring with the Ponds? Even if they needed to place a fake headstone in the graveyard and have Amy write her novel and have it published in the 1930s wouldn't it at least be worth a try? The simple answer is that the showrunners were done with the Pond's story and as with the death of Adric, no amount of timey-wimey jiggery-pokery could overcome that.
2. Who Gave Clara The Number To The Tardis?
The Doctor first meets the version of Clara Oswald that would become his companion, when she called the number to his Tardis. She said that the number was given to her by a "a woman in the shop," who told her, "it's the best helpline out there. In the universe." So who was the woman in the shop? Let's narrow down the suspects. Sally Sparrow. She owns a shop and while she never traveled with The Doctor, after her adventure with the Weeping Angels, it is conceivable that he returned and gave her his number if any other problems arose. A former companion. Remember, Clara said the woman was, "in the shop," she never said the woman worked there. Possible suspects include Martha Jones and Sarah Jane Smith. River Song could be ruled out as Clara met River later and failed to recognize her. The Woman in White. Out of left field, but she has a history of being able to break the time lock and interact with at least one person important to The Doctor. Why not a second? The Tardis. The Doctor's time and space machine has a history of putting The Doctor where he "needs" to be. Could it have intercepted the call? The most intriguing possibility is that the number was given to Clara by a time splintered version of herself! Regardless of who gave Clara the number, perhaps an equally big mystery is why The Doctor didn't seem concerned about a mysterious woman giving out his number to strangers.