Doctor Who: 7 Key Themes That Defined The Matt Smith Era

7 things that made Matt Smith's turn as the Doctor one of the best ever.

It's been about a month since Matt Smith bid farewell to "Doctor Who," and now that the corpse has cooled and the bow-tie given a proper burial on the fields of Trenzalore, it's time to take a closer look at the Eleventh Doctor's era. As other writers have pointed out, "Doctor Who" is a show that thrives on renewal, and €“ like the Doctor himself €“ the series has long embodied an eagerness to change and adapt to the shifting landscape of entertainment. Every chapter of the show is unique in and of itself: the William Hartnell years were largely designed as an after-school program for children; the Pertwee era was a kind of science-fiction spy thriller; and David Tennant's tenure was basically the story of a post-war survivor trying to find his place in the world while also dealing with the aftermath of a cataclysmic intergalactic war. By this logic, the Matt Smith era is a dark, bombastic fairy tale about the dichotomy between fiction and reality. And like all incarnations of the show, the Eleventh Doctor's tenure - largely the brainchild of current showrunner Steven Moffatt - essentially acts as yet another chapter of "Doctor Who" while simultaneously operating as its own independent artistic statement. Thankfully, "Doctor Who" isn't a show that's overly concerned with its own subtext, nor is it seeking to shatter the audience's worldview with a pretentious harpoon of truth soaked in philosophy and cynicism. It's a piece of popular entertainment, and its foremost goal is to entertain. But still, that doesn't mean you can't have some fun reading between the lines. And while it's tempting to deconstruct the narrative issues Moffat has run into, the aim here is to examine the subtext rather than the text itself. We'll leave it to slightly more intellectual commentators to give rundowns of plot mechanics and story structure. And yes, this article is full of SPOILERS that cover everything up to "The Time of the Doctor", so read at your own risk.

7. Fairy Tales

All throughout Eleven's almost four-year run, this is the motif that Moffat most consistently returns to. Series Five plays out like a classic fairy tale: it's the story of a young woman who goes on a whirlwind adventure with her imaginary friend, rekindles her sense of wonder, saves the world with the power of faith, and still finds enough time to wrap things up with a big, fat, fairy tale wedding. Fresh of his regeneration and stranded in the village of Leadworth, one of the first things the new Doctor observes is that Amelia Pond has "a name from a fairy tale." When he reunites with her years later, she has abandoned the fairy tale name in place of a simpler, more adult "Amy," ostensibly because she's become a bit disenchanted after years of therapy and abandonment issues.
The Doctor: So, coming? Amy Pond: No. The Doctor: You wanted to come fourteen years ago. Amy Pond: I grew up. The Doctor: Don't worry, I'll soon fix that.
This brief exchange pretty much defines Smith and Moffat's mission statement: to make Amy Pond (and by extension, the audience) believe in fairy tales again, even if it's only for forty-five minute increments. But it doesn't stop there. Story elements from the Eleventh Doctor's tenure might as well have been pulled right from the pages of Brother's Grimm or even Mother Goose. A mysterious man who crashes a magic box into a tiny village in England? An immortal centurion who guards the love of his life for two-thousand years? Two lovers, lost in time, never meeting in the right order? Check, check, and double check. When his stint as showrunner began, Moffat described "Doctor Who" as the "modern equivalent" of classical fairy tales, stating, "It's the way we teach our children that there are things in the world that might want to eat them." A common (and probably valid) criticism leveled at Moffat is that his plots don't abide by a logical framework and are prone to resorting to mystical mumbo-jumbo as opposed to the pseudo-science employed by previous writers. But maybe Eleven's tenure is more aptly defined as pure-blooded fantasy as opposed to the "sci-fi lite" pastiche that previous incarnations enjoyed and, in that context, the mumbo-jumbo kind of works. It's a fairy tale, after all.

6. Memory

Along with his proclivity for fairy tales and all things whimsical, Moffat also holds a fondness for more classic, universal themes than his predecessors. While former showrunners like Russell T. Davies were more keen on exploring themes of morality and ethical dilemma common in science fiction, Moffat and Smith seem to prefer broader, more conventional motifs to define the series' narrative. Make no mistake: Moffat's "Who" is more fantasy than sci-fi, right down to the fairy tale logic that holds the whole thing together. One of the classic staples of fantasy and parables is the power of memories and the way they shape who we are. Eleven's greatest recurring enemy is the Silence, a race of aliens that gain power from tampering with the memory of their victims and basically erasing themselves from history. The Silence (or Silents/Silentses/Silenti, however you want to say it) understand the importance of memory and the influence it holds over humanity. By holding power over humanity's memory, they are essentially castrating the entire human race and robbing us of our agency over our lives. (We apologize if that last sentence conjured up images of alien-managed castration factories.) The fact that the Silence are able use this power to slip in a kind of post-hypnotic suggestion and manipulate human history only illuminates the idea that our memories ultimately make us who we are and help dictate the course of our lives. "The Rings of Akhaten," despite being condemned by a large section of the fanbase as a disaster rivaled only by the Hindenburg crash, cleverly presents memories as a means of currency and, to an extent, actual oh-my-Jeebus power. If you needed any more proof that Moffat prefers fantasy over sci-fi, look no further than the scene where the Doctor literally kills a sun-god with the power of memory and a sentimental leaf. In "The Day of the Doctor," the Moment (which, if you're not a "Doctor Who" fan, is a galaxy-eating nuclear weapon that chooses to represent itself as a former British pop singer) describes the Eleventh Doctor as "the man who forgets," and yeah, the name totally fits him. The Doctor has always been a creature in motion, and the Eleventh Doctor is, in many ways, both the embodiment and the result of this tendency, largely preferring to ignore the ghosts of his past. But mere moments before his regeneration, the Eleventh Doctor finally comes to term with his past and the need to strike a balance between dwelling on the past and forgetting it. As he breathes his last, the man who forgets finally vows to remember.
"Times change and so must I... When you think about it, we're all different people all through our lives, and that's okay, that's good, you gotta keep moving, so long as you remember all people that you used to be. I will not forget one line of this. Not one day. I swear. I will always remember when the Doctor was me."

5. Fostering Your Own Legend

In "Mother Night," Kurt Vonnegut wrote that "we are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be." While a fine line remains between the person we are at heart and the person we present to the world, human beings spend our entire lives building our reputations, sowing little deceits here and there either out of necessity or vanity, and far too often we wake up one morning to find that the lie has become us. We are, inevitably, what we pretend to be. The Doctor has had hundreds upon hundreds of years to forge his own legacy, to change the story where he sees fit, and define the legendary figure that the rest of the universe sees him as. He calls himself The Oncoming Storm, openly boasts about his past victories, and has absolutely no problem eradicating an entire fleet of Cybermen just to make a point. As he enters into his eleventh incarnation, that legend finally starts to catch up with him. The Silence, Eleven's most dangerous and persistent foe, was formed purely with the intention of ending the "endless, bitter war" the Doctor supposedly waged against the whole of creation. And when you consider his track record, it's easy to see their point. It's been a recurring theme in all things Batman for decades: the idea that the hero, in all his heroic splendor, creates and is in some way responsible for the existence of his own enemies and, in some regards, does more damage than he does good. Even the Daleks €“ his greatest adversaries €“ believe that they have done nothing but grow stronger in fear of their eternal foe. It's as much an indictment of the Doctor's growing hubris as it is an observation on the dangers of power: rise high enough, and it's only a matter of time before someone shows up to knock you back down, either out of ambition or faith or simple terror. As a result, Doctor decides to step back into the shadows, erasing himself from the archives of the universe and becoming, once again, a simple traveler.

4. Religion and Faith

"Doctor Who" has always had a tenuous relationship with organized religion, with the Doctor himself largely championing a humanist worldview and perpetuating a habit of dethroning would-be deities on a semi-regular basis. It's an undercurrent that has been downplayed as much as possible, and it's easy to see why. Offering any sort of critical observation on religion or even faith can stir up a mess of trouble, especially on a program aimed largely at children. Nevertheless, that hasn't stopped the writers from slipping in the occasional charge against organized religion or exploring the conception of faith as a dangerous notion. The Church of the Silence is built entirely around the belief that the Doctor will €“ at some point €“ speak a secret so black and unrighteous (i.e. his name) that the very utterance of that secret will undo the very fabric of creation. In their sacred quest to bring down the Doctor, the Silence a) kidnap a child, b) manipulate human history for thousands of years, and c) essentially nuke the Universe by blowing up the Doctor's TARDIS. The Silence become so convinced of the Doctor's malevolence that they fail to see it in themselves, often to universe-shattering results. And yeah, the idea of a militarized space church seems pretty silly, even for "Doctor Who," but then you remember that this exists. On the other hand, faith itself is presented as a double-edged sword. Take little Amelia Pond, sitting in a garden in the vain belief that the mysterious Raggedy Man will hold true to his promise and return to her. By the time he finally does return, she's a grown woman and is, understandably, just a wee bit jaded. The entire fifth series is built around the idea that Amy's adventure with the Doctor is the only thing that can undo the damage he's done, and it's that long-lost faith that saves the Doctor and restores him to the primary universe in "The Big Bang."

3. Predestination and the Destiny Trap

While "Doctor Who" has always abounded with ontological paradoxes and time-bending shenanigans, Smith's run has been filled to the brim with temporal trickery and head-scratching chicken-or-the-egg moments. Many story arcs are built around the idea of an immovable future catastrophe that the Doctor must - against all laws of time - strive to prevent, but in doing so must contend with changing a fixed point in time, which are the immovable, unalterable points in the fabric of history that cannot be tampered with, lest the whole tapestry of reality come crashing down. Basically, any attempt to change history ultimately accomplishes nothing more than the fulfillment of the destiny trap, which is the idea that attempting to meddle with a previously established timeline will only result in yourself becoming a part of it: imagine if you went back in time and tried to shoot Hitler, only for the bullet to lodge in his brain and fill him with a hatred of all things Kosher. Over and over again the writers present us with the idea that Disaster X is irrevocable, unshakeable, and forever a-fixed in the fabric of history. And every time, the conclusion is that no, it totally wasn't. We're constantly told that you can't change the future any more than you can your own past. And over the course of three series, the Doctor does both. Even Eleven's last stand on the clock-tower of Trenzalore (we refuse to mention the name of the actual town in this article) is one that ends and ultimately revels in a good kick in the groin to the Stupid Grown-Ups with Their Stupid Grown Up Rules. In the end, it's Amy Pond who sums it up most succinctly: "Changing the future. It's called marriage." It doesn't mean that tying the knot will give you destiny-defying abilities or even that your father-in-law is obligated to give a time-travelling DeLorean as a wedding present. It hearkens back to Doctor's own humanist leanings and implies that human beings have agency through choice rather than imprisonment through fate. The future is always in flux.

2. Endings

It's been a recurring theme since the Ponds took their fateful plunge off Winter Quay in "The Angels Take Manhattan." We've already discussed how the Doctor is always in motion, never looking back because he dare not, either out of guilt or because the anguish of doing so would be too much for his heart(s) to bear. Even as a timeless alien far removed from humanity, the Doctor exemplifies an all-too-human characteristic: the fear of change. He's over a thousand years old, and he's never even finished a book, always tearing out the last page so the story never has to end. If anything, this provides a point of closure for Eleven's long, convoluted story arc: he's an old man at heart, with a deep longing for things that once were and can never be again. Of course he's terrified of change. Of course the last page frightens him beyond all measure. Besides the TARDIS, it's the only true constant in his long, storied existence: things will change, people will leave, and the Doctor must carry on as if nothing ever happened. It's what the Tenth Doctor struggled with and was ultimately defeated by: letting go and moving on. This is why Amy's final appearance at the end of "The Time of the Doctor" is so poignant. At the end of the day, it doesn't matter whether this Amy was real, a Nesteen duplicate, a Zygon general gone rogue, or a hallucination brought about by the stress of the Doctor's impending regeneration. What matters is that a withered old man who'd lived his entire life refusing to face the last page could finally look at an end and find peace instead of despair.

1. Dreams And The Power Of Stories

Ultimately, this is the keystone that holds the whole thing together. While it may sound pretentious and a bit self-serving, the story of the Eleventh Doctor is ultimately about itself and the escapism that stories like "Doctor Who" represent. There's a reason this show has survived for fifty years, inspired generation upon generations of fans, and ignited a debate about whether or not the show itself constitutes the basis of a genuine religious experience. It's because "Doctor Who," like all great escapist fiction, offers a reprieve from the everyday world while simultaneously encouraging us to make that world a better place. At the beginning of this article, we made the (kind of pretentious) claim that the Matt Smith era is, at heart, a dark fairy tale about the dichotomy between fiction and reality. The bulk of the Eleventh Doctor's tenure was largely concerned with Amy Pond's efforts to balance her real-life commitments (her relationship with Rory) and the reckless comfort found in the imaginary (her travels with the Doctor). The result is an examination of the way fiction and reality intermingle to give us purpose, direction, and inspiration. It may have come two episodes late, but the revelation that Amy Pond eventually finds work as a children's author only solidifies her arc: she's a girl who outgrows her imaginary friend but never forgets him. It stands to reason that this might well be the thesis of Moffat's entire run on "Who" so far: the Doctor himself is, in essence, a story. It might not even matter what the "truth" of the matter is, but what that story means to you is nothing less than paramount. Depending on who you ask, the Doctor can be a scarf-wearing lunatic with a penchant for jelly babies, a buzz-headed war veteran desperately seeking redemption via an essential human connection, or a childish, prideful old man who legitimately thinks bow-ties are the apotheosis of fashion. The Doctor is all these things and none of them. He's everything that a good story should be. And now that the book is closed (for now), the sad and wonderful tale of the Raggedy Man now stands as another great era of "Who" that exists as an almost-completely independent statement: a testimonial about the power of story, the importance of fairy tales, and the impossible allure of a simple blue box.

Contributor
Contributor

I am not creative enough to make up a fake biography.