Doctor Who: Big Finish Mega-Review - October's Releases
A Jo Grant Companion Chronicle, a Tenth Doctor and Donna story, a Second Doctor Lost Story, a Main Range Sixie and Peri tale and that most wonderful of surprises, an early release to Big Finish's 50th anniversary story, "The Light at the End". We have a lot to cover for Big Finish's October releases! Let's get to it! The Companion Chronicles "Ghost in the Machine"
rating: 5
Mary had a little lamb, its fleece was white as snow And everywhere that Mary went, that lamb was sure to go. The TARDIS is empty. The Doctor has gone. Jo Grant steps outside into the darkness and finds the frozen body of her friend, and the ship's log recorder. On it is attached a simple message - 'Use Me'. As she explores this place, recording her every move, Jo discovers the horror that lies in the shadows. But by then it is too late.Katy Manning has constantly been one of the best things about the audio ranges. Her vocal talents are really quite impressive, which she displays in her one-woman show story, "Not a Well Woman", and shows off regularly playing both Iris Wildthyme and Third Doctor companion, Jo Grant. This story is no exception. She very briefly voices the Doctor and one other person, but mostly she voices Jo and a sentient audio tape recording of Jo's voice. It's extremely sinister and extremely effective. Yes, the story centers around a machine that allows audio tape to record people and, in a certain way, bring them back to life. It's frankly a weird premise, and one that could have failed in lesser hands, but Big Finish does their usual great job of making it work despite itself.
Destiny of the Doctor "Death's Deal"
rating: 3
Responding to multiple maydays, the TARDIS lands on the planet of Death's Deal, but the distress calls are old, the final echoes of terrified lost souls. This is an exotic world of lethal creatures, nicknamed 'The Deadliest Planet in the Galaxy', and only the brave, foolhardy or greedy would ever dare to visit. Finding themselves stranded among a motley bunch of space-tourists, the Doctor and Donna must lead a struggle for survival against the frenzied wildlife, as they slowly realise that other members of the group have very different agendas. And soon the Doctor learns of an even bigger threat hiding on Death's Deal. Somewhere deep below the surface, is something that must never be unearthed. Time is running out, and only an impossible survivor holds the key...I absolutely adore Donna Noble, and I wanted to really love this story. As it is, well...it's not horrible by any means, but it is pretty forgettable. I will say that it does follow the standard formula for a Davies-era story, right down to a planet with a name at least as silly as "Woman Wept". And it really is quite splendid to hear Catherine Tate back as Donna for what is likely, sadly, the last time. Well, barring someone at Nu Who waking up and realizing that they really need to find a way to "fix" her character's fate and bring her back for a last hurrah. But other than her performance, there isn't much to recommend this very paint-by-numbers story.
Main Range "1963: The Space Race"
rating: 4
November 1963, and the Soviet space programme reigns supreme. Having sent the first animals, then the first men beyond Earth's atmosphere, now they're sending a manned capsule into orbit around the Moon. Just as Vostok Seven passes over into the dark side, however, its life support system fails. Only the intervention of the Sixth Doctor and Peri, adopting the identities of scientists from Moscow University, means that contact with the capsule is regained. But something has happened to the cosmonaut on board. She appears to have lost her memory, and developed extreme claustrophobia. Maybe she's not quite as human as she used to be...Gather 'round, ye children, and let ole Uncle Chris tell you about a simpler time. A time called "The Cold War", when the world's fate hung by a thread, and humanity could be wiped out with the simple (and at times, quite likely), press of a button. It was also the time of the space race, when the Soviets and the USA raced to see who could get to the Moon first. The Soviets, as this story pointed out, had the first satellite, the first man in space, the first woman in space, and the first spacewalk. Then it all kind of went tits up for them, America spent billions, and got to the Moon first. Well, at least in real history. In the Whoniverse, that isn't quite the case. There was much to enjoy here, even if the overall story was almost quite literally a bit "base under siege". It was nice to see Nicola Bryant get some time to play Peri without the Doctor being around to overshadow everything. I also rather liked the "hole" figure that was behind all the problems, even if was a bit shades of V'Ger. I also really enjoyed the way the story tied in with the whole 1963 feel, especially when, while on a rocket heading back from the Moon, the Doctor realizes what day it is. This is a major problem when he has to try and call off a nuclear strike, only to learn that President Kennedy is away in Dallas at the time. Aside from a bit of the "secret history" stuff that I had to roll my eyes at (in one case, VERY HARD, given what's located on the Moon), I found much to enjoy here. It's a good, solid, stand-alone story.
The Lost Stories "The Queen of Time"
rating: 3
Somewhere outside our universe, she is waiting. A god-like immortal, living in a realm of clocks. The hours tick slowly by as she plots and plans. She is readying her trap. A trap for a very special man in a very special police box. Hecuba has all the time in the world. But for the Doctor, time is running out.I am very, very confused as to how a story like this could have been even remotely considered for filming back in the day. I have a feeling it would have looked and felt every bit as bizarre as "The Mind Robber", only perhaps even less coherent visually. It also doesn't help that the story is a bit confusing, and felt quite padded. I think this is one of those rare Big Finish stories that could have benefited from being a three-part story. Two would be too little, and four was too much. That aside, I liked Hecuba's relationship to a previous Doctor Who villain, and, of course, even when the story itself leaves a bit to be desired, Frazier Hines' work as the Second Doctor is always something wonderful to hear.
"The Light at the End"
rating: 5
November 23rd 1963 proves to be a significant day in the lives of all eight Doctors... It's the day that Bob Dovie's life is ripped apart... It's also a day that sets in motion a catastrophic chain of events which forces the first eight incarnations of the Doctor to fight for their very existence. As a mysterious, insidious chaos unfolds within the TARDIS, the barriers of time break apart... From suburban England through war-torn alien landscapes and into a deadly, artificial dimension, all these Doctors and their companions must struggle against the power of an unfathomable, alien technology. From the very beginning, it is clear that the Master is somehow involved. By the end, for the Doctors, there may only be darkness.Well, here we are. You've waded through the previous reviews to get to this one. This is the review of Big Finish's 50th anniversary special, and against all expectations, it was released in October, not November. It also crashed the Big Finish website, which wasn't completely unexpected by anyone who remembered what happened with "Dark Eyes". So who all is in this? Tom Baker, Peter Davison, Colin Baker, Sylvester McCoy, Paul McGann, Louise Jameson, Sarah Sutton, Nicola Bryant, Sophie Aldred, India Fisher, Geoffery Beevers, William Russell, Carole Anne Ford, Maureen O'Brien, Peter Purves, Jean Marsh, Anneke Wills, Frazier Hines, Katy Manning, Janet Fielding, Mark Strickson and, surprisingly, others. Yes, this is the multi-Doctor story that fulfills the dreams of many Who fans. You get the Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Seventh and Eighth Doctors all together, along with at least one companion for each, plus you get the Master, and a number of little surprises. I am pleased to say that this is a multi-Doctor story that, unlike so many others, doesn't disappoint. Each Doctor, and all of the major companions, are all given something to do, and they're split up into interesting teams. You get the Fourth and Eighth Doctors together, plus Sixie and Seven working with one another. Five gets his own thing, where he gets to see just how truly evil the Master can be. I am truly staggered by how well Big Finish managed to pull this off, and I'm especially pleased by how good the actors all are together, especially Tom Baker (in his first multi-Doctor story), and Paul McGann, who really play well off one another. To say much more would be to give away way too many spoilers. Suffice to say that if you are any kind of old series fan, you really do owe it to yourself to get this audio. It's not very expensive, and it is very amazing. Next month: The first adventure for the Doctor and Susan when they leave Gallifrey, the conclusion to the Destiny line, the Second Doctor, Jamie and Zoe meet the Ice Warriors, the Seventh Doctor and Ace reunite with the Counter-Measures squad, and the return of Bernice!