Doctor Who: All Doctors Ranked From Worst To Best

12. The Fifth Doctor - Peter Davison

Best Episode: The Caves Of Andronzani - the greatest regeneration story of all time. Worst Episode: Warriors From The Deep - Silurians and Seas Devils? How did it end up so bad? Enter the Myrka... After the huge impact of Tom Baker's Doctor on the show, his successor was always going to have a tough time meeting audience expectations. Producer John Nathan-Turner went for a character far removed from the imposing, larger than life persona of Baker; the result was Peter Davison's boyish Doctor - the youngest actor to play the role until Matt Smith came along. But it wasn't just the look, it was the character that was radically different and it wasn't fully successful. The Fifth Doctor had some great stories - The Caves Of Andronzani is still the greatest regeneration story of all time - but he himself didn't make much of an impact. Overpowered by loud companions and reactive rather than proactive in nature, this Doctor often came across as a bit of a wet fish and certainly not in control of the situation. He was simply too nice at times to be imposing. He wasn't a bad Doctor, just not a dynamic one and sadly he comes across as forgettable on more than one occasion.
In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter