Doctor Who: Exploring The Many Doctors That Weren't
Dr. Who - Peter Cushing (1965, 1966)
Back during the 1960s, when Doctor Who popularity was really getting going and Dalekmania was at its height, two theatrical Doctor Who movies were made. They featured a human character named Dr. Who who built a machine called TARDIS that was bigger on the inside than out. With his granddaughters, Susan and Barbara, and Barbara's boyfriend, Ian, they travel off to Skaro and fight the Daleks. Later, they have a second adventure against the Daleks, this time with Susan, Louise, Dr. Who's niece, and a police officer who later went on to be Donna Noble's grandfather. These movies are not good. They aren't horrible, but they certainly, well... suck compared to the rest of the cannon. Put it this way: if you couldn't get enough of the Power Ranger Daleks, then these movies are right up your alley. That said, Peter Cushing's character, Dr. Who, is an interesting fellow. He's part Hartnel, part something else. The movies themselves aren't a part of the official Doctor Who canon, though there are those who say that in the Doctor Who universe, they were created by Ian and Barbara to warn the world of the dangers of the Daleks. We can see how well that worked, since clearly everyone in the new series who has seen a Dalek knows exactly what they are and how dangerous they can be. /sarcasm
The Fatal Death Doctors - Rowan Atkinson, Hugh Grant, Jim Broadbent, Richard E. Grant, Joanna Lumley (1999)
Did you know that there are, kind of, sort of, three different versions of the Ninth Doctor? One of them is Eccleston's version. One is the so-called Shalka Doctor, and we'll get to him in a bit. The other is Rowan Atkinson's Doctor who appeared in a one-off charity special written by Steven Moffat and called "The Curse of Fatal Death". Yes, Blackadder himself plays the Ninth Doctor, and does so in exactly the fashion you'd expect. He eventually gets killed off and regenerates into Hugh Grant's Doctor, who dies off and turns into Jim Broadbent's Doctor, who dies off and turns into Richard E. Grant's Doctor who then dies off and turns into Joanna Lumley's Doctor. It's quite a fascinating set of regenerations for such a small story. It's silly to even vaguely pretend this story is canonical, and no one has really tried (though there is mention in, I believe, one of the books about there being three different Ninth Doctors). If you're a fan of the old series who hasn't seen this, I do very much recommend it. It's really very entertaining and Johnathan Pryce makes for an excellent Master.
The Shalka Doctor - Richard E. Grant (2003)
This is the one and only Doctor on this list who was intended to be canonical. This Doctor appeared only once, in "Scream of the Shalka", a BBC animated webseries written by Paul Cornell. He was voiced by Richard E. Grant, and was supposed to be the "new" Doctor. He was to go on to appear in novels, comics, more webseries and the like. Alas, not long after this story was made, news broke that a new TV series was in development. Russell T. Davies announced that the Eccleston Doctor would be the Ninth Doctor and that was the end of the Shalka Doctor. I've been watching the DVD of "Scream of the Shalka" recently, and to be honest, I find it rather hard going. I've had it for two weeks and I've managed to watch two of the roughly 12 minute episodes. It isn't bad, but it certainly isn't anything special, and I kind of have to agree with Davies, who found Grant's performance rather uninspiring. That said, like with all Doctor Who stuff, if you're a true fan, you should see it at least once. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jV7Vwqy-vb0
The Unbound Doctors - Geoffrey Balydon, David Warner, David Collings, Derek Jacobi, Arabella Weir, Michael Jayston (2003, 2005, 2008)
For the fortieth anniversary, Big Finish did a series of audio stories with the "what if...?" question. Things like "What if the Doctor never left Gallifrey?" or "What if the Doctor's exile to Earth was in the 1990s?" or "What if the Doctor was a drunken supermarket employee?" They cast the roles and went for it, producing something that was nothing if not ambitious. I haven't listened to all of the Unbound audios, but the ones I have heard, I've enjoyed. David Warner, in particular, makes for such an excellent alternate Third Doctor that one wonders why he was never offered the role of the Doctor for TV (or the role of the Master, come to that). Arabella Weir's story is also quite excellent, if you've ever wanted a female, alcoholic Doctor who enjoys watching the X-Files and gets harassed by an elderly Time Lord in disco gear and voiced by David Tennant. Sadly, the series didn't sell well enough for Big Finish to continue on, and that's really a shame. But at least during its brief time they managed to find a way to use one of the more sinister Doctors-who-wasn't; the Valeyard. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZygnwgzJaM
The Dark Doctors Michael Jayston, Toby Jones, John Hurt...? (1986, 2010, 2013)
Twice the Doctor has confronted future versions of himself with all the goodness removed. One of those was the Valeyard, an incarnation somewhere between the 12th and 13th Doctor that had all his darker impulses. He traveled back in time and manipulated the Matrix so as to make the Doctor look guilty of many horrible crimes. In the process he corrupted the path of Time Lord justice and managed to get one of the Doctor's companions killed...or not. It depends on what ending you prefer. Then in 2010, we got the Dream Lord, another distillation of the Doctor's darker desires. We don't know where, if at all, he fits into the Doctor's timeline. But he was an interesting character, and one we will hopefully see again. Lastly we have the Hurt Doctor. We don't yet know who or what he is. The current rumor is that we can view him as the Eighth-and-a-half Doctor; someone between Eight and Nine who does something horrible during the Time War to make him unworthy of being called the Doctor. Is he a dark and evil force? Is he simply a version of the Doctor who did what must be done and can't live with it? Time will tell. It always does.