Doctor Who Title Sequences Rated
The Doctor Who Title Sequence is a strange beast, it has changed almost as much as its titular character over the last 50 years. Since 2005 alone we have had 3 variations. Like the Doctor himself everyone has their favourite. The signature image that symbolises the adventures that are about to unfold. We have had variations on time tunnels, star fields and psychedelic swirls, each testing the ingenuity of their creators and anchoring the eras in the time in which they were produced. Similarly the theme, created by Delia Derbyshire during many nights in the Radiophonic Workshop and written by Ron Grainer on a torn off piece of paper of all things. The theme has essentially remained the same at its core but has had many different reworkings. Speaking of which, honourary mention must go to the group Orbital for turning a cult theme into an epic modern tune which wouldn't be out of place played to drunken ravers in the early hours of the morning on a Saturday night. The logo too is a key part of this as well, which again has changed so much over the years. In an era when marketing is the big thing, the branding has never been so crucial. I will be taking a look through the title sequence archive and ranking each based on three factors, the logo, the style and the theme. Lets get started.
The First Doctor
The Style: Though technically the least sophisticated, there is something eerily iconic about the opening titles of the William Hartnell era. That opening spike, piercing through the blackness before swelling into these waves of light, sweeping across our screens in kaleidoscopic patterns. The sequence in actual fact is quite spooky. It's not trying to be bombastic or overwhelming, it is very hypnotically matter of fact, you are entering the weird and mysterious worlds of Doctor Who. You better be ready, because here we go. It's quite representative of the time, when the character of the Doctor played by William Hartnell was much darker and mercurial, you can't be sure whether he is good or if he is harbouring a bad side. This would change as the character developed. How far in advance the approach was known it is difficult to tell, but whether by design or accident it set the trend for what was to come later. Score: 7 The Logo: Eeh... this is where the whole thing kind of flounders. The Logo at the time might as well have been typed out on a typewriter or stenciled in with different sized rows of letters. The box shape with 'Doctor' on top of the 'Who' is the only respectable style decision made. It's only now that we can jazz it up for whatever purposes in black or white or with a drop shadow to lift it. It just kind of feels like little effort was made to make it look like a logo. It's just the title. I am probably being unfairly harsh as resources were limited, but given the sequence itself it lets the whole thing down. The only good thing about it comes from its entrance into the title sequence. When it materialises finally is an underwhelming moment. Score: 4 The Theme: It would be sacrilege to say a bad word about the original theme. It is dated to an extent but that is not a bad thing. It and the titles are a perfect blend of mystery and wonder so in that respect it is a superb combination. On its own however, whilst being an immense technical achievement that would set the basis for the next 50 years, doesn't quite have the same impact as later versions. But credit where it's due, it paved the way for many years to come. Score: 7.5
Overall Score: 18.5
The Second Doctor
The Style: The Second Doctor's title sequence despite using the same techniques manages to refine those techniques and look completely different. It doesn't look as experimental, but also it doesn't look as exciting either. It was due for a change as even at the time it was looking dated, having an experiment run for 4 years. Plus it's difficult to imagine the Hartnell sequence playing before a Troughton story despite it being the case up to 'The Faceless Ones'. It was a change made out of necessity, because they had to rather than because they had a great idea. Of course the major change was the addition of the face! This would become a trademark for the rest of the classic run and was a great way of establishing the new identity of the character. Troughton's expression in the image used oozes character and it makes the sequence a warmer introduction to the show and offer some safety and security. The Doctor was now your friendly traveling companion. Score: 3 The Logo: The logo suffers the same issue as its predecessor. Having changed to a serif font it now looks more gothic which is appropriate for some of Troughton's stories such as 'Tomb of the Cybermen', 'The Abominable Snowmen' and 'The Web of Fear'. If anything though it is even less stylized. At least the previous logo had some subtle design influences. On its own it's a very bland looking design. Score: 2 The Theme: When you listen to this theme it feels a lot more complete compared to the original. The updates are subtle but make it more dramatic and reinvigorate the original and it would remain this way for much of the next decade. The spangles and glittery sounds don't make it tacky, if anything they finish the theme off nicely and the original is still at the heart of it. What is unusual though is how the original theme was still used as the closing music for most of the episodes... When watching stories on DVD as one episode ends and another begins the difference is extremely noticeable. Score: 8
Overall Score: 13
The Third Doctor
The Style: Doctor Who was now in colour and boy did we know it. Every colour of the rainbow is used in the Pertwee title sequence, from the sumptuous red we are treated to varying, blues, greens, then swirls of pinks, yellows and purples after the face that erupts in a veritable orgasm of colour. It could be a bit much, but it isn't. It's weighted by the deep black surround from which the diamond pattern emerges. The technique used is the same howlaround/smokey effect used in the previous sequences only it is refined a lot better this time around and looks like some design and structure is behind it. It is a very good piece of work and I like it. It is flamboyant and colourful but also sophisticated like the new Doctor himself. The only thing about it that doesn't come together as well is Pertwee's headshot. For one thing he looks the happier than his stern and serious Doctor ever was and although the Doctor's hair famously became more bouffant over the years he played the part it looks deceptively flat in this shot like he has just been wearing a motorbike helmet (which may well have been the case). Also the edge of the Doctor's shirt collar is visible but this for some reason makes it look like the Third Doctor was disguised as a vicar. Score: 8 The Logo: They nailed it with this one clearly as it is being used as the 50th Anniversary Logo on all the merchandise this year and the same 10 years ago. It's a very clever design, which could have just been block text but has enough flair to set it apart from that. The indentation on the D of 'Doctor', the interlocking slant on the C and T of 'Doctor' and the curved bridge on the H of 'Who'. Credit where it's due to the designers and production team behind it, this was a classic in the making. It is bold, individual and iconic. Score: 10 The Theme: Mostly the same as before, which is a wise choice because it didn't need to change. An attempt was made for season 10 but that was pitiful, sounding like it was made with a single banjo string. Credit for resisting that urge. Sometimes part of good design is knowing what NOT to change. The theme was one of them. The only adjustments were the removal of a bar of 'diddly dums' to get to the 'oo ee oos' sooner and the recurring howl leading into the episode. It structures the piece that little bit better rather than just fading it out gradually. Similarly on the closing, the final note of the theme that has been used ever since. By far the most significant contribution though is the sting at the end of each episode. That sting should be used on all television dramas. Score: 9
Overall Score: 27
The Fourth Doctor
Style: This title sequence was used for a full 6 years. 7 if you include the version used for Jon Pertwee's final year. For most of that time it remained unaltered bar a couple of colouring experiments in the early days, a side effect of which turned Tom Baker's image green and the change from block text to a gothic serif font for the credits from Tom's third year onwards. This was a significant departure from the howlaround effect, instead using a technique known as slit scan, which means nothing to me. Dependant on how you look at it, it is an inventive portrayal of travel through the time vortex. The more critical of you may call it an illuminating journey through a vacuum cleaner tube, being reunited with the Tom Baker Weetabix cut out. Speaking of which, while Tom looks every inch the Doctor, he looks bloody miserable, like most British folk, peering out of the window on a wet summers day. Regardless, its success at the time has made it an iconic classic of a title sequence from an iconic era. It is also the first to feature the TARDIS in the opening. It is the quintessential Doctor Who title sequence and I actually think the effect is pretty good. Score: 10 The Logo: The diamond logo is a radical departure from anything that has gone before or since. The design is actually surprisingly intricate, more so with the official colours. It is a dramatic rebrand and it's hard to tell what prompted this as Pertwee was still the Doctor when it was introduced. As good as it is, there is something childlike about it and 70's, which does date it. But again it is the quintessential Doctor Who logo that was the identification point for a lot of kids of the time. At present it can be seen as brilliantly retro. Score: 8 The Theme: There isn't really a lot I can say, it is the same as before but points for keeping it when everything else changed... again. Score: 8
Overall Score: 27
The Fifth Doctor
Style: John Nathan Turner wanted to bring the programme kicking and screaming in the 80's. He certainly did that with lens flared stars and the trailing effect on the face. This sequence was first used for Tom Baker's final season but it's pointless reviewing that separately because it is the same as this one but oddly with fewer stars, so for the most part we have black empty space. This could have been much worse as at least the stars are moving and layered so it actually feels like traveling. It's really quite bland and must have looked dated at the time. It doesn't seem to go anywhere. It's just stars and black, trying to cash in on the Star Wars effect. The headshot of Peter Davison just looks boring as well. It is a shot of Peter Davison, not the Doctor. Score: 4 The Logo: Neon tube logo. Why not go all the way and make it light up bright green. It really is awful and out of all the logos the series has had was used second longest. Used for 6 years and over 3 variations of the title sequence and I can't fathom why. Plus it is just plain white, nothing all that visually interesting. I honestly don't like it and it has not survived the test of time. Score: 2 The Theme: About the only thing that I can positively give thumbs up to is the reimagining of the theme music. It manages to be trendy and alien as well reimagining not the tune, but the theme, the atmosphere behind it that made it great. That is what makes this version successful. It is an updated version of a theme and it came at the right time. Coming up to two decades it was bound to happen sooner or later and at least it was done well. Score: 8
Overall Score: 15
The Sixth Doctor
The Style: The sequence is on the surface, basically the same as the previous apart from some spangly rainbow effects. This might seem garish, but after 3 years of Davison it must have been a godsend. It also says a lot more about the character of the Doctor. Brash and colourful. But also they got a bit more technically interesting by having the Doctor's expression change when his face appears, which is a nice touch. It is a small touch that shows, actually, this Doctor can have a bit of fun. These changes made the titles exciting again. Score: 6 The Logo: Again mostly the same as last year apart from a minor change in shape and a purple glow. But you know what... it actually works. Even the way it appears is an improvement turning towards camera in quite a cool move. It doesn't look as tacky anymore and it doesn't look as cheap. Score: 4 The Theme: Now here's a point of contention. After Colin Baker's first year, the great Peter Howell theme was removed and a hastily cut theme by Dominic Glynn was added for no conceivable reason. Supposedly the plan was a new title sequence as well, but the budget wouldn't go that far. So we literally get a half baked attempt at an update, which makes it worse. It's not as awful as people say but it is a step back and just doesn't seem right. It just doesn't work. Score: 4
Overall Score: 14
The Seventh Doctor
Style: Again this was a radical departure from anything that had gone previously and is actually fairly impressive for the time. It's just too bad that nothing that ever followed the title sequence ever matched that quality. It's quite a cool sequence, a bit dated admittedly but it is a funky set of graphics. The only ropey part is the asteroids that pass the camera that look like screwed up balls of paper and a just awful. Take that out and I think this sequence would be a lot more solid overall but it's like someone stuck a flag in it saying 'cheap'. Also another criticism I have is that as a sequence it is far too long. It goes on for around a minute due to the changes to the theme music. The TARDIS makes a welcome return to the title sequence and puts in the energy, dynamism and visual interest the previous sequence lacked. Score: 7 The Logo: What were they thinking. When I saw this for the first time I didn't think it was real, I thought it was some knock off or fan design but nope it's real. It looks like a cheesy, 90's, American, childrens', sci fi show. This is the kind of look that at the time would have been going out on Childrens' BBC. Then again that's where the standard of the show seemed to be heading. Someone in the design department either hadn't seen the programme but heard about it or just didn't care or both. The signature 'Doctor' is abysmal and is the epitome of tacky. Score: 1 The Theme: Keff McCulloch has a lot to answer for. Apart from 3 years of awful stabbing keyboard music that sounds like being beaten to death with synth pop, thinking he was so cool probably, he gives us this awful trashy variation of the theme. He completely misses the point of the theme. He cuts the diddly dums from the beginning, he puts the middle eight in the opening and the sting is replaced with a pop. As a result of this, the opening theme is more like the closing theme and messes up the timings. This is why the opening is so long, with this tasteless variation of the theme. The only small merit is that they didn't create a new theme altogether. Score: 1
Overall Score: 9
The Eighth Doctor
The Style: Where's the face! Words! Lots of words! This is a bizarre creation which is more like a closing sequence again. Given as the closing sequence is actually just scrolling credits against black it's pretty much all we have to go off. The sequence actually starts off pretty well with the logo bursting out of a cosmic explosion and zooming into the screen. After a pause it gets a bit awkward and just kind of turns around and shuffles off into the time vortex. I don't know what this is meant to represent as it just looks awkward. The only thing it is indicative of is Sylvester McCoy's participation in the film. He's back, ok now we have to get rid of him as soon as possible. After the logo has showed itself, the sequence doesn't really have anywhere to go. So we have this extended time tunnel sequence with all the cast and crew in it that just gets really boring really quickly but we do get to see a cool representation of the TARDIS time travelling, but by that time we are technically in part of the story. Not a fan of this one. Score: 3 Logo: Another weird one because it is basically the old Pertwee logo but blue. At least they chose one of the best versions, it looks like it is being taken seriously, Doctor Who as a brand. I can't really say much more than that. Score: 7 The Theme: Again, really weird. For some reason performed on piano and opens with the middle eight. It's like a tasteful version of the McCollough theme but again it misses the mark. It doesn't have the otherworldly quality and it doesn't fit the ethos of the programme or notion of the character. It's almost just noise, melodic noise admittedly, but it doesn't say anything about the programme, it just appeases the fans but is linked stylistically with our classical Eighth Doctor . Score: 3
Overall Score: 13
The Ninth/Tenth Doctor:
The Style: The Ninth and Tenth Doctor's title sequence is a tough one to fault as it was done so well. It takes its structure almost from the Tom Baker sequence, the most recognisable sequence arguably and really gives it everything as if to point out, this is what Doctor Who can be, with money, modern tech and effects and it doesn't disappoint as it was deliberately aiming to compete not just with cinematic sci fi but also high quality drama. The sequence is dramatic and befittingly so, fitting in with the programme's remit to grab audiences on a Saturday night. It is loaded with energy, the fast moving vortex and the TARDIS rocketing through the Vortex. The best part by far is the midpoint where the TARDIS pauses, lamp flashing before darting off back through time. What more do you need to see to know the TARDIS is a machine of wonders. The only niggle really is the absence of the Doctor's face. Admittedly I can't think of a way it could be put into that title sequence without making it look naff, but equally the appearance of the names, especially in Christopher Eccleston's case look a bit convoluted and doesn't have that same sense of identity. Easter egg for classic fans was the Time Crash titles with Peter Davison's name in the titles, which is a great moment. Score: 9 The Logo: The lozenge or taxi sign logo is the first to have 'Doctor Who' on one line to make use of the widescreen format. I don't like it. The structure has gone and it just doesn't look as strong. The letters are thin and spindly and it just doesn't grab me. For series 3 the lozenge itself was updated to have a fiery background to tie in with all the other branding and to be fair that is probably the best part of the logo, but not the shape, it's to minimal. Thumbs down on this one. But given its success, I feel obliged to give it some complimentary marks. Score: 6 The Theme: The theme is a tricky one to tackle as it changed from 'Voyage of the Damned' onwards for no conceivable reason and given as that was the only major change for this sequence over the RTD Years I can't really approach the sequences as a whole separately so I will discuss the merits of each theme separately and come to an average score as a reflection on the production team. The Ninth Doctor: I can't really find a bad thing to say about the theme. You can hear the original elements in it and as with the oft used Derbyshire version adds the varying bells and whistles to really bring it up to standard. The only thing that is missing is the diddly dum baseline throughout the majority of the theme but the classic oo ee oo is there for all to hear and it is glorious and packs a punch after all this time. It complements the visuals appropriately and is a tasteful modernisation. What followed, did not. Score: 8 The Tenth Doctor: Why! Why fix what isn't broken. We have some electric guitar thing that tries to mimic the Peter Howell theme. Why go from 1963 1981 after just 3 years. It's a completely unnecessary change that cheapens the whole thing. As a piece on its own it's not bad, but it just doesn't have cause to be there and it makes me pine for the previous version which had depth and gravity. Also despite the changes, this version isn't half as powerful and gone is the original Derbyshire base. Sorry Murray Gold, you let the side down. Score: 5 Theme Score: 6.5
Overall Score: 21.5
The Eleventh Doctor
Style: Oh, dear. I remember being bitterly disappointed when this opening sequence kicked in at the beginning of the Eleventh Hour. The vortex has been redecorated with cotton wool and the TARDIS seems need the batteries changing as it just lollops about the Vortex before being overtaken by the camera, in which case the cameraman is travelling faster than a super duper time machine. It's pretty disappointing, like the comedown after drinking a whole bottle of cola. It doesn't put a patch on its predecessor. This is because it tries to recreate that title sequence and took away everything that made it great rather than creating a new title sequence. It's a thin veil of disguise that is very unimpressive. Also the drop into the orange vortex feels like being flushed down a toilet filled with lucozade. You may well have noticed that in Series 7 someone got to play with some buttons and Instagram filters leading to the title sequence being different colours for each story, which was catastrophically awful. What were they thinking! Score: 4 The Logo: When the new logo was originally revealed I got really excited because it was previewed in the old 'Doctor' atop the 'Who' and actually looked really good. I wasn't too fond of the 'DW' TARDIS as it was too gimmicky but I could overlook that as it wouldn't be part of the actual title sequence. Wrong on both accounts. 'Doctor Who' was on the one line then of all the things, the DW was slap bang in the middle. I thought briefly, 'They wont be as obvious as to, oh wait, yep it's going to turn into the TARDIS'. A lot of effort must have been put into that little design element. Whilst the logo does have a lot more impact than the previous, they have shown how it could be so much better and bad decision making has spoiled it. Score: 4 The Theme: Like everything else in this sequence the theme is just as lacklustre. When this was released on the Series 5 album it states (best enjoyed at full volume). You can't make a theme that can only be enjoyed at a certain level, that wasn't necessary before, why is it necessary now! It's a poor rendition, which while incorporating some more ethereal sounds, just doesn't compete. The original Derbyshire arrangement is now a long forgotten memory, which could have successfully underpinned this. Also why do we now have the diddly dums replaced by rising notes, which make my eyebrows want to rise further and further up my head whenever it is heard. Score: 4
Overall Score: 12
50th Anniversary Title Sequence
Style: I have addressed this variation as such due to the fact that it will most likely be rolled over into the Twelfth Doctor's reign due to the fact so far the sequence has only been used for half a series. I first saw this sequence on the big screen at a preview showing of 'The Snowmen' and I was blown away. They finally decided to do something other than the time tunnel and explore the different worlds and phenomena. Some might call it 'space porn' and that's almost what it is. Almost only the actual rendering of it on repeat viewing is pretty stilted and poor. People have produced their own improved versions online which do put the official sequence to shame. Still, I'll take it for what it is, which is a dramatic and bold improvement. Also points for adding Matt Smith's face and not making it look awful, but points lost for the horrendously tacky, TARDIS doors opening to camera but at least the ship has its mojo back. Score: 7 Logo: It's mostly the same but thank God they have abolished the DW logo. That is all. It still looks very generic though. Score: 6 The Theme: It isn't dissimilar to the previous version but has had a similar update as the original did in the 60's with the various sounds and jingles added, which does make a difference. Plus the diddly dum base line is back. This theme manages to sound both dark and modern whilst still conjuring up that energy at its heart. A vast improvement. Score: 6
Overall Score: 19
Bonus Title Sequence
So now I am left with a difficult situation. Both the Third Doctor title sequence and Fourth Doctor title sequence have 27 points. But which one can we officially say is better? If only there were some way to combine the two... oh wait there is. In 1974, a new title sequence was given to the Third Doctor in his final year that used the same slit scan effects as the Fourth Doctor Title Sequence. Though there are many notable differences between the two. Firstly the opening is completely different. Instead of the TARDIS approaching we have the time tunnel forming, almost 'Space Odyssey' style and then Jon Pertwee materialises into view, pulls back to a full body shot in the only title sequencer to do so and then evaporates into a brilliant white light allowing the logo to pull through as per the Fourth Doctor titles. I personally prefer this version to the Fourth Doctor's title sequence. It combines the iconic status of the Fourth Doctor's title sequence with some of the psychedelic marvelousness of the Third Doctor's sequence. So there you have it. The rating of best Doctor Who title sequences, themes and logos. Do you agree or disagree? Do you have a favourite title sequence? Let us know in the comments.