Doctor Who: Top 8 Unmade Stories

Sometimes it's painful to think about what could have been.

Doctor Who Unmade Over the course of the last fifty-one years, there have been many, many proposals for Doctor Who episodes that just€never made it. Wikipedia has a whole article devoted to this concept. Some of these stories never made it past the €œcocktail napkin€ stage, but others were actually bought, paid for, and ready to shoot before various things (usually cancelation), stopped them from being made. In some cases, this was a very bad thing. In other cases, such as the ideas for the American 8th Doctor TV series, this was nothing but a very, very good thing. Seriously, go read about €œThe Leaky Bible€, and just try to deny the point. This is just a short list of what€™s out there as far as unmade episodes, and it€™s devoted only to Doctor Who episodes. There were several planned for The Sarah Jane Adventures, as well as ideas for various anniversary episodes, an animated series, and a couple different movies, but we€™ll ignore those for now. It is true that all the various ideas vary in quality, but they all have this in common: they will never grace our TV screens. Whether that is good or bad is up to you to judge, but here are the ones we think had the most potential.

8. The Daleks In London

The concept: Much like €œThe Dalek Invasion of Earth€, this story would have featured the Daleks invading Earth, with the Third Doctor, Jo and UNIT fighting them off. This time, though, it would have been in modern times. It would have been their first appearance in five years, and was to be the cap to the ninth season. How far along: The story was commissioned in 1971, we know that. It was to be a six-parter and was written by Robert Sloman, who did write a few other Third Doctor stories. And€that€™s all we know about that, really. Why it was never made: As is said two paragraphs up, €œMuch like €˜The Dalek Invasion of Earth€™€€ There€™s your problem right there. It was way too similar for producer Barry Letts to be comfortable with it. In the end they decided to shelve the story and bring the Daleks back later in the season with a different story. One can also imagine budget considerations, since we can assume at least one large battle scene. Why it€™s on the list: Are you seriously asking? The Daleks in €œmodern€ London, with UNIT fighting them? Explosions and excitement and explosions? Remember how much fun it was watching Ace destroy a Dalek with an RPG? Imagine several of those. And just picture the Brigadier leading Benton and Yates into a fight against the Dalek hordes and then try to say that doesn€™t send a little tingle up your spine. The eventual fate: Not much. This story was never adapted for any medium, which is both a shame and a surprise. Even Big Finish, who did an entire series of adaptations of unfilmed stories, didn€™t do anything with it, and the scripts were never released. Still, it€™s fun to think of what might have been.

7. The Nightmare Fair

The concept: Planned for the 1986 season, this story would have featured the Sixth Doctor and Peri visiting Blackpool. There they would have encountered the sinister figure known only as the Celestial Toymaker who, just possibly, would have been played by Michael Gough (best known to many for playing Alfred in the 1980s and 1990s Batman movies), who originated the role in the First Doctor€™s time. How far along: Far enough along that the writer, Graham Williams, was able to turn it into a novel. The scrip was apparently completed, but with the 1986 season being transformed into the €œTrial of a Time Lord€ arc, it wasn€™t needed. Why it was never made: As mentioned, the planned season was instead turned into the €œTrial of a Time Lord€ arc, which ran for fourteen episodes. Now it could have been possible to use it during that arc, but the producers instead went another direction, which probably enabled them to better set up the Ravalox and Valeyard concepts. Why it€™s on the list: A meeting between the Doctor and the Toymaker is something old series fans wanted to see again for a long time; or for most of us, see at all. The character€™s only old series appearance is missing, and it would have been great to see him on screen in full color, especially if Michael Gough had returned to the role. The eventual fate: The script was turned into a novel, and the novel was turned into not one, but two, audio plays. The first was a charity thing back in 2003, and then later into a full-cast audio with Colin Baker and Nicola Bryant as the Sixth Doctor and Peri. It was the inaugural title for the Lost Stories line, and wound up setting a very high bar.

6. Mission To Magnus

The concept: The Sixth Doctor and Peri run into Anzor, a Time Lord the Doctor knew from school and did not have fond memories of. They escape from him and wind up on the distant world of Magnus. There they encounter the Ice Warriors, and the sinister, chortling alien known as Sil. How far along: At least a completed script, from what we can tell. This is another story that was also turned into both a novel and an audio play by Big Finish, so clearly there was a fair amount of it that was complete. Why it was never made: This was another casualty of the 1986 woes. In this case, the actual story that wound up being used as part of the €œTrial of a Time Lord€ arc ended up being €œMindwarp€, which was written by the same author and also featured the return of Sil, as well as the departure of Peri. Why it€™s on the list: Look€€œMindwarp€ had a lot going for it. It€™s one of many peoples€™ favorite 6th Doctor stories, and it also features Sil, who is one of many peoples€™ favorite characters. But€well, frankly, this is a better story. The Ice Warriors would have come back, and it would have been great to see them again. Plus the character of Anzor seems massively entertaining. The eventual fate: As mentioned above, both a novel and an audio play, which among other things, featured the return of Nabil Shaban as Sil; something which made many people very happy, since no one else can do that laugh quite like he can. Well, unless they€™re part murloc.

5. Untitled Stephen Fry Story

Stephen FryThe concept: This story was to be written by Stephen Fry. Yes, that Stephen Fry. We know very little about the story, other than it was to be set in the 1920s and written, as mentioned, by Stephen Fry. How far along: A script was written and was read-through at least once by the cast. So quite a bit farther along than most of the unmade stories. Why it was never made: As mentioned, the story was read by the cast. It was well-received, but some rewrites were needed, mostly due to cast changes, so it was sent back to Fry for further work. It was then moved from season 2 to 3, which meant changes due to the new companion, Martha. This put quite a lot of pressure on Fry, who eventually had to write an €œI€™m sorry, I can€™t do this,€ letter to Russell T Davies. Why it€™s on the list: Fry, along with JK Rowling, were two writers who had been bandied about since the start of the new series. It would have been fascinating to see what Fry, widely-known for his appearances in Jeeves and Wooster, could have done with a 1920s sci-fi story, and it€™s a great shame that we shall never know. The eventual fate: None so far. For all we know, it€™s gathering dust in a drawer somewhere. Hopefully at some point, Fry will dust it off, polish it up, and publish it so we can all have a look-see.

4. Untitled Paul Abbott Story

NinthdoctorThe concept: The Ninth Doctor, Rose and Jack, all arrive in Pompeii in the year 79, right around Volcano Day. There, Jack discovers that the Doctor had been manipulating Rose€™s timeline in order to create the ideal companion. Rose as the ideal companion? Perhaps this was proof that even the Doctor can make mistakes when poking about in time. How far along: The episode was at least partly written, and may have been close to completion, but exactly how far long it was, we don€™t know. Why it was never made: Abbott, who was the creator of Shameless, had to drop out due to his commitments to that show. The Russell T Davies story €œBoom Town€ took this episode€™s place. I€™m willing to bet there were probably also money issues, given how much an episode like this would have cost vs one like €œBoom Town€, which was pretty much just filmed, and set, in Cardiff. Why it€™s on the list: Imagine if we had learned that the Doctor had been manipulating time to create Rose! What a twist that would have been. To be honest, it was probably a bit too much of an ask for the series at that early of a stage, but it would have been so interesting to see! The eventual fate: Probably sitting in the same drawer next to Fry€™s script. Maybe someday, the two will team up, and we€™ll get to see both. It€™s not likely, but one can dream.

3. The Prison In Space

seconddoctorThe concept: The Second Doctor, Jamie and Zoe arrive on a strange, alien world, where the gender roles are the opposite of what we€™re used to here on Earth. The planet is ruled over by the sinister Chairman Babs. Why she shouldn€™t be Chairwoman is left up to the imagination. As the story progressed, Zoe would have wound up leading a sexual revolution on the planet, and Jamie would have dressed in drag, though if he chose a plaid skirt, he could have just stayed dressed as he normally was. The whole thing would have ended with the Doctor spanking Zoe to cure her of being brainwashed. How far along: Again, a script, by Derek Sharples, was completed. It was never purchased, and was rewritten extensively. Why it was never made: Did you see the part about the Doctor spanking Zoe? That wasn€™t a typo. While it would have created much slash fiction, it was perhaps a bit sexist, even by 1960s BBC TV standards. To make things even more difficult, the story was written with Jamie in mind, but Frazier Hines was on the fence about continuing, so it was rewritten to introduce a new character named Nik. Then Hines decided to stay, and it was rewritten again. Two scripts were submitted to the production staff, but certain issues remained, and after Sharples declined yet another rewrite, the serial was dropped from the production list. Why it€™s on the list: Ok, it€™s sexist as hell, but come on. It would have been a fairly fun, light-hearted story. Plus it would have been a fairly Zoe-heavy episodes, and those didn€™t happen as often as we might€™ve liked. The eventual fate: As with some other stories on this list, Big Finish adapted this one, and put it into The Second Doctor Boxed Set. The audio featured Hines as Jamie and the Second Doctor (his Second Doctor voice has to be heard to be believed), and Wendy Padbury as Zoe, with Susan Brown as Chairman Babs. It was solidly entertaining, if a bit eye-rolling at times, and one imagines both those things would have been true in the TV version.

2. Farewell Great Macdeon

firstdoctorThe concept: This would have been a purely historical, First Doctor, first season, story. It was to feature the TARDIS crew arriving in Babylon, and there encountering Alexander the Great and his generals. But as Barbara knew, the question of the day was whether it was Alexander€™s first visit, with him then continuing on toward India, or his second, where he would die? There was also to be the usual sort of political machinations that one would expect, the Doctor and pals being framed as part of a conspiracy against Alexander, and, as a historical, no sci-fi elements other than the TARIDS and its crew. How far along: We know that a script was written by Morris Farhi, a noted Turkish writer, as it formed the basis for Big Finish€™s adaptation of the story. The script wasn€™t bought by Doctor Who, but it was far enough along that Farhi later pitched it to the BBC as the basis for a TV series about Alexander. Which could have been interesting. Certainly more interesting than Shatner€™s Alexander piece. Why it was never made: At a guess, cost. The long-missing story, €œMarco Polo€, apparently had very lavish sets with beautiful costumes. I€™m sure it set the production back a pretty penny (or€pence? Shilling? Groat? Whatever English people use), and doubtless there wouldn€™t have been enough money to recreate ancient Babylon in a convincing fashion. Why it€™s on the list: Lavish costumes, beautiful sets, a great historical, a wonderful character in Alexander€there€™s so much to like here, and so many reasons to be disappointed that this story wasn€™t made. Historicals have fallen out of favor with fans since, oh, about 1967 or so, but this could have been one of the better ones. The eventual fate: In 2010, Big Finish turned this story into an audio play as part of their €œLost Stories€ line. William Russell played Ian, while Carol Anne Ford returned as Susan. The story did indeed live up to the potential we€™d all hoped for, and in our minds, the costumes and sets looked better than they ever could have on TV.

1. Season 27

Doctor Who AceThe concept: Season 27 would have aired in 1990 (yes, the last episodes of Doctor Who aired at the same time as the first episodes of Red Dwarf and TNG), and would likely have seen the departure of Ace, heading to Gallifrey to become a Time Lord (yes, really), and the introduction of a new companion, Raine Creevy. The season possibly would have ended with the departure of Sylvester McCoy and the introduction of the 8th Doctor, played, at least in theory, by Richard Griffiths, best known for his role as Victor Dursley in the Harry Potter movies. We may have also seen the finale of the Cartmel Masterplan, which was an ongoing effort to restore a sense of mystery, and occasional menace, to the Doctor and the Time Lords. How far along: It varied. There may have not been scripts, but there were at least story ideas and titles, such as €œLungbarrow€, €œEarth Aid€, €œThin Ice€ and €œCrime of the Century€. Why it was never made: Well, generally once a show has been cancelled, very few further scripts are put into production. The cancelation occurred after the final episode had been shot, and before it was broadcast, so really, after the last episode had been shown, all production stopped. Why it€™s on the list: Because seeing a resolution to the Cartmel Masterplan would have been nice. It was apparently resolved in book form in the now out-of-print, insanely-expensive novel version of Lungbarrow, but never on TV. Plus it would have been nice to have Ace get her own send-off, and to see the new companion. It really would have been interesting to see Richard Griffiths play the Doctor, as well. The eventual fate: €œEarth Aid€, €œThin Ice€ and €œCrime of the Century€, along with another story, €œAnimal€, were all released in audio form by Big Finish, with Sylvester McCoy as the Doctor, Sophie Aldred as Ace, Beth Chalmers as Raine and Angela Bruce as Brigadier Bambera. And they were good. Ace commanding a starship and doing her best Picard impression is a beauty to behold.

Contributor

Chris Swanson is a freelance writer and blogger based in Phoenix, Arizona, where winter happens to other people. His blog is at wilybadger.wordpress.com