Doctor Who: 10 Best First Doctor Stories

He told you he would come back...

Doctor Who William Hartnell First Doctor
BBC Studios

The first time The Doctor was introduced to audiences in 1963, he was a grumpy and temperamental old man that held no qualms about kidnapping two school teachers and forcing them to embark on adventures against their will. Whilst this premise sounds much stranger than it actually is, the 50+ years of excellent sci-fi television proves that there is at least some method to the madness, and has ensured that the show has managed to survive the numerous transformations, revisions and variations that it has undergone in the five decades since William Hartnell was in the lead role.

Whilst the classic episodes of Doctor Who are an entirely different kettle of fish to the new series, it's still fascinating to see the incredibly humble beginnings of this iconic show and see the origins of dozens of characters and monsters that have been firmly ingrained within British pop culture. Although this statement has been echoed countless times in countless places, the fact of the matter is that it's unlikely Doctor Who would be the show it currently is if Hartnell hadn't taken the role of the Doctor.

Disclaimer: I've only included episodes that are fully complete in the BBC archives. It's a little difficult to judge stories that only partially exist (or in some cases, not at all) in their original format, but I'd also highly recommend the animations and audio reconstructions that have been created in the intervening years.

Here's the very best of the beginning...

10. The Sensorites

doctor who
BBC

After landing on a spaceship stranded in orbit over the "Sense-Sphere", the Doctor and his companions discover that the remaining crew are being menaced by a species of telepathic aliens known as the Sensorites. After the Sensorites take Susan as a hostage back to the planet, the situation only escalates as the TARDIS crew are called upon to assist the Sensorites in curing a disease that is wiping out the population.

The main highlight of this story is the opening episode: atmospheric, intriguing and genuinely unnerving at times (so long as you can look past the £3.50 budget). The way in which the main characters are slowly exposed to the situation by the frightened and confused crew is superb, and made all the more better by the eeriness of the black and white footage and quality acting from both the main and side cast. Granted, the tension is somewhat spoiled by the admittedly cheesy design and makeup of the Sensorites, but it still serves us a good example of how Doctor Who garnered a reputation as a terrifying show this early on in its run.

The main problem with this episode is that it is quite slow-paced and painfully drawn out over the course of six half-hour episodes. Although the criticism of having the plot spread too thin over multiple episodes could be made towards multiple stories throughout the entire series, this is one of the only stories where it really shows, and ultimately, The Sensorites could have benefited from being condensed into a four-part serial, but this doesn't detract from the more positive aspects of the story overall.

Even though the story pacing and make-up work of The Sensorites might seem sub-par when compared to other examples present in the early run of the series, the story still has its merits, and works as an adequate taster of Doctor Who in its infancy.


9. The Keys Of Marinus

Key Of Marinus Doctor Who
BBC Studios

As the first of many "quest-based" episodes, this serial revolves around The Doctor, Ian, Barbara and Susan as they split up across multiple different planets in order to find components of the "Conscience of Marinus", a computer that controls justice across the entire planet. Whilst being chased by the Voord, the TARDIS crew scramble across various dangerous locales to find the various keys and avoid being killed by the litany of hostile people/aliens/plants/brains-with-eyes-in-jars that they encounter.

This story has the distinction of being only one of two stories written by Terry Nation that does not feature the Daleks, and the writing talents that made the classic adversaries popular is clearly on display here. With such an adventurous premise, the story makes the most of a relatively tight budget, and the ingenuity on display to realise a variety of locations is nothing short of admirable. Even if the special effects of early '60s television wasn't as impressive as today's standards, one thing that Doctor Who had for the most part was the quality of the writing behind it.

Although the serial may lag in its latter episodes with the trial scenes, the whole premise of The Keys of Marinus was quite ambitious for the early days of the show, and it's a shame that the format was never tried much outside of the classic series. For the most part, this kind of serial was abandoned in favour of the much cheaper and easier to produce four-part serials. Nation himself would reuse the basic idea later on for "The Chase" and "The Daleks' Master Plan" (the latter of which sadly only has three out of its twelve episodes currently in existence). From their introduction, it's also painfully clear that the Voord are the first in an incredibly long line of attempts to try and recreate the appeal of the Daleks (which in this instance, did not work).

An interesting slice of Doctor Who, The Keys of Marinus represents the quality of a show in its early days, regardless of any limitations that may have come about.


8. The War Machines

Doctor Who The War Machines
BBC

The thing that makes The War Machines interesting is it's setting, that of a contemporary 1960's London. Whilst similar settings would be used in abundance during the Third Doctor's tenure, and have even flourished during the latest seasons, the background of the present day was rarely used during the First and Second Doctor's eras. For The War Machines, this works perfectly when combined with the main premise, as it serves to make the danger of murderous A.I. even more real.

In this serial, The Doctor and Dodo find themselves in 1966 London, encountering a professor who has just finished work on his latest project: WOTAN, a supercomputer that will shortly be linked up to other similar systems worldwide; an ambitious project overseen by one Sir Charles Summer. To the surprise of absolutely nobody familiar with the concept of science fiction, WOTAN decides that it doesn't like humans that much, to the point that it strives to end all of humanity and to conquer the world with the aid of murderous robots. With his only companion and several others under the control of the supercomputer, it is up to the Doctor alone to stop the threat of WOTAN.

Even back in 1966, this serial effectively displays the paranoia surrounding artificial intelligence and its integration into society, paranoia that has arguably survived up to the present day. It's aged remarkably well, given the circumstances, and is a brilliant example of how some of the best science fiction is less speculative and more predictive. The War Machines is also worthy of note, as it features the introduction of Ben and Polly, companions that would outlive the First Doctor and serve with the Second Doctor for a while. The only thing that detracts from this serial is how the departure of Dodo is handled. Instead of giving her a proper send-off, she disappears halfway through the serial, and when the Doctor asks where she is, he is told that she has left and won't be returning for no apparent reason, a move that fells cheap, and does no justice to the character.

Despite this, The War Machines is still in impressive highlight of Hartnell's final serials, and delivers a compelling drama that, when viewed today, feels less like science fiction and more like a legitimate threat.


7. The Time Meddler

Doctor Who The Time Meddler
BBC Studios

To a viewer watching in 1965, The Time Meddler must have been an astonishing instalment of Doctor Who. For the first time, a member of the Doctor's species (excluding Susan) was introduced, and the mystery surrounding the Doctor would only become clearer from here onward.

Before landing in England in 1066, not long before the Battle of Hastings, the Doctor and Vicki discover that Steven Taylor, who had been introduced in the previous serial, had stowed away on the TARDIS, and essentially made himself a new companion of the Doctor's. Once the TARDIS lands, the three explore medieval England, noticing a number of anachronistic objects littered all over the place. This is the work of The Monk, a rogue Time Lord that is intent on ruining human history by introducing knowledge and technology hundreds of years before it was initially discovered, mainly for his own amusement.

Years before the names "Time Lord" and "Gallifrey" were established, the Meddling Monk was created to be the perfect foil for the Doctor. Where the Doctor was serious, noble and keen to ensure that time flowed correctly despite his visits, the Monk was flippant, childish and wanted nothing more to throw history off its course for the sake of humour. The character proved so popular, that it would only be a matter of months before he was brought back as a secondary antagonist in "The Daleks' Master Plan", aiding the Daleks in their plans to activate the Time Destructor, once again breaking the Time Lords' no-interference policy (to a much more dire extent than the Doctor ever did)

Although the Time Lords have appeared numerous times since this episode, with their history and lore being more fleshed out with every new appearance, it's important to view this episode as it would have been watched in 1965, where very little knowledge of the Doctor's past existed, and there was absolutely no clear answer to the question, Doctor who?


6. The Aztecs

Doctor Who The Aztecs
BBC Studios

From the opening minutes of The Aztecs, a mysterious and compelling atmosphere is created when the four leads step out of the TARDIS and into an ancient Aztec tomb. The room is a shrine to the god Yetaxa, and the body within is draped an a large amount of riches in jewellery, including a bracelet that Barbara takes and wears herself. When the travellers leave the tomb, the find that the door is constructed so that they cannot return through it, and a wandering Aztec priest summons guards to imprison The Doctor, Susan, Ian and Barbara. When the Aztecs notice that Barbara is wearing the bracelet that the departed "god" was wearing, they mistake her for Yetaxa. From here, Barbara is forced to assume the position of the Aztec god if the travellers are to ever recover the TARDIS, a task that is made all the more difficult by the fact that one of the high priests has doubts about her divinity.

The Aztecs is one the earliest "pure historical" stories in Doctor Who, meaning that besides the main cast and the TARDIS, there are no other science fiction elements. Having the villains simply being tyrannical, bloodthirsty historical figures works extremely well in the case of The Aztecs, especially given that the titular civilisation was infamous for carrying out brutal sacrifices to their gods in order to ensure that basic phenomenon such as the rising of the sun and the coming of the rains actually happened.

It is these brutal ritualistic killings that also form the basis for one of the story's main plot threads, as Barbara tries desperately to prevent the high priests from killing innocents, with both parties failing to understand the ideology of the other. It is in The Aztecs that the Doctor states for the first time the fundamental law of time travel: observe, but do not interfere (even though the Doctor would break this rule a year later in "The Romans", when he suggested that Emperor Nero should burn Rome). Try as you might, you can't rewrite history. Not one line.

Ambitious and thought-provoking, The Aztecs serves as an amazing jumping-on point for anyone exploring this era of Doctor Who for the first time (as it did for this writer).


5. The Space Museum

Doctor Who The Space Museum
BBC

After landing near the titular museum, The Doctor, Vicki, Ian and Barbara decide to explore when they come across themselves and the TARDIS as exhibits. Just as quickly, the exhibits disappear, and the TARDIS crew find themselves in a plot assisting the oppressed Xerons to start a revolution and overthrow the controlling Moroks, all the while hoping that their part in the revolution will prevent them from becoming the exhibits in the Morok's museum.

For a television show that revolves around a time-traveller and his big blue box that can go anywhere in space and time, very few episodes actually feature the concept of time travel outside of the main premise. There are a few notable exceptions to this, including The Space Museum, such as 1983's "Mawdryn Undead", as well as more recently in 2015's "Under The Lake/Before The Flood".

The way in which the four leads try to avert a possible future timeline echoes plot points from Back To The Future, a full 20 years before that film was released. It's this premise, with impressive uses of common sci-fi tropes throughout that make this serial stand out amongst others. With talk of time tracks, potential futures and alternate timelines, The Space Museum has more in common with the complex plots of newer series than it does with most classic series episodes, and still stands as a must-watch serial.

Ultimately, the highlight of this episode is The Doctor amusing himself by hiding in an empty Dalek shell. 55 years later, and it's still iconic.


4. An Unearthly Child

Doctor Who An Unearthly Child
BBC Studios

As the first ever story of Doctor Who, An Unearthly Child does an amazing job of introducing the show to fresh eyes, making one of the most bizarre premises in television history seem down-to-earth and credible. 57 years worth of television has followed on the basis of this pilot, and for any fan of the show, it's required viewing, if only for mild curiosity value, to find out where it all began.

The serial starts with school teachers Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright, who are both concerned with one of their pupils, Susan Foreman. Susan seems to have an amazing intellect and in depth-knowledge of science and history, but also has tremendous gaps in her knowledge. For example, she's able to run rings around her science teacher and point out flaws in history textbooks, but doesn't have the faintest grasp of how English currency works. Further investigation reveals that her "address" is listed as a junkyard in a London alley, a junkyard that contains nothing except trash and police box.

After meeting Susan's grandfather, an old man who insists his name is "The Doctor", they barge their way inside the police box, only to discover a glistening control room that is much bigger than the dimensions of the police box outside. From there, a journey to the Stone Age, and an encounter with a violent tribe of cavemen becomes the ground work for a show that would dominate British television for more than half a century.

Rewatching the opening episode of An Unearthly Child is always a peculiar and intriguing experience. From the first bars of the (then) revolutionary electronic opening theme, to the first shot of the TARDIS, to the introduction of The Doctor and to the first ever "it's bigger on the inside" moment, it's positively littered with milestones and firsts that will leave any fan awe-struck upon viewing.

Whilst the characters and iconography have become commonplace today, it's important to watch this serial (as it is with all classic series stories) from the perspective of a viewer in 1963, who couldn't have foreseen the impact that could have been made by An Unearthly Child.


3. The Chase

Doctor Who The Chase
BBC

The Chase has many elements in common with The Keys of Marinus, which makes sense given that both episodes were penned by Terry Nation. This time round, Nation brings the megalomaniacs from Skaro back for the third time, as they have gained the ability to travel through time, and are using it to try and kill The Doctor once and for all. With an army of Daleks in pursuit, The Doctor, Vicki, Ian and Barbara scramble through time and space in order to survive an onslaught of Daleks.

Like The Keys of Marinus before it, this serial has The Doctor and his companions "location-hopping" from one place to another, encountering a plethora of interesting side-characters (and Daleks) wherever they land. The Chase, however, has the leads show up in more outlandish and unexpected places. From the deck of the Mary Celeste (inadvertently causing it's abandonment) to a haunted house populated by animatronics of classic horror movie villains, The Chase is notably more offbeat when compared to other stories of a similar vein (and for a show like Doctor Who, that's saying something). On the bright side, it never gets to a point where it distracts from the main tension of the plot, which when put simply, is quite a remarkable one.

To the First Doctor's era as a whole, The Chase is significant for a number of reasons. Firstly, it marks the departure of Ian and Barbara, meaning that the only remaining member of the original TARDIS crew was now The Doctor himself. Steven Taylor was introduced for the first time, as an astronaut who crash-landed on Mechanus and had been the prisoner of the Mechanoids for two years. After the events of The Chase, Steven would go on to become a fully-fledged companion in the next serial, The Time Meddler. Lastly, This story is also the first time that the Daleks adopt their iconic cry of "Exterminate", having used variations of the phrase until this point.

Exciting and adventurous, The Chase is still an absolute classic. If you haven't already watched it, do it. Now.


2. The Daleks

Doctor Who The Daleks
BBC Studios

Having originally being broadcast in December of 1963, World War Two was still well within living memory. Everyone except the youngest of children would have had some memory of being evacuated, participating or actively fighting in some way. That's an important detail to remember when viewing The Daleks, as it is what made the metal monsters so terrifying in the first place. Uniformed steel creatures that scream sentiments of racial purity and total destruction of anything unlike in enraged cries: it's a clear allegory for the Nazis. An allegory that would surely awaken a sense of unease and paranoia within an audience of the time.

In the second ever story of the show, The Doctor, Ian, Barbara and Susan land on a planet that has been ravished by a nuclear war. From there, the travellers discover a metal city populated with the Daleks, and a petrified forest that has become the camp of the Thals, the survivors of Skaro's other species which the Daleks consider "horribly mutated" compared to themselves. It's only a matter of time before the Daleks attempt to wipe out the Thals in order to achieve complete Dalek purity, and it's up to the Doctor and co. to prevent a race war that would only result in the destruction of the entire planet itself.

In their first appearance, the Daleks are notably different from their more modern iterations. Firstly, they are unable to travel outside of their city as they require the static electricity in order to move around (meaning that the only thing needed to defeat them is a particularly thick blanket). As mentioned previously, there's also no cries of "Exterminate!", as that would come later as well. Even without these elements, it's still fascinating to see the debut of the Daleks. From their earliest appearance, the seeds are sown for them to become The Doctor's arch-enemies as he struggles to best them to the point where it would have made a first time viewer completely despondent. With their cries of death and genocide, the Daleks would quickly become one of the most formidable foes the Doctor has ever had to face.


1. The Dalek Invasion Of Earth

Doctor Who The Dalek Invasion of Earth
BBC Studios

The Dalek Invasion Of Earth is quintessential early Doctor Who. The return of the Daleks, this time landing on home territory. A memorable and engrossing premise. Infinitely quotable lines. The first companion departure, coupled with an iconic speech to go with it. For a first time viewer, it's all here.

In the far off future, the Daleks have launched a successful invasion of the planet Earth. No longer confined to their metal city, they were able to wipe out the majority of the human population and convert the survivors into Robomen, zombie-like slaves that carry out the Daleks bidding. The Doctor and his companions meet up with a resistance force that aim to repel the Daleks before they are able to complete their final plan: planting a bomb inside the Earth's core, thus rendering the planet unstable. The crew of the TARDIS split up as they aid different members of the resistance in fighting the Daleks, whose control of the entire planet brings with it a natural advantage, leaving the humans in dire straits.

In this story alone, there is a vast amount to discuss. After the praise and popularity that the Daleks earned following their first appearance, their reappearance less than a year later would have a been a massive deal back in 1964. By taking the Daleks from their home planet of Skaro and placing them next to iconic London landmarks, the fear that they manifested was quite literally brought much closer to home. The Dalek Invasion Of Earth also marks the first companion exit, as The Doctor leaves Susan behind with a resistance fighter once the Daleks have been defeated. The final speech that he gives to his granddaughter has gone down as one of the most memorable in the program's history, and has been re-quoted and reworked many times after the fact. Don't just find a clip of it on the internet, watch it in the context of the whole serial in order to get the full emotional impact of the Doctor's goodbyes.

Engaging, enjoyable and a tad tearful, this is Hartnell's era at its best.


Contributor

Cameron Morris hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.