Doctor Who: 10 Great Ideas That Went Absolutely Nowhere
The Fugitive Doctor? More Captain Jack? These are some of Doctor Who's biggest wasted ideas.
For a show that covers literally everything that has happened (and ever will happen), Doctor Who is stuffed to the gills with untapped potential.
The Time Lord time-traveller can go wherever they want, whenever they want, meet whoever they want, and be home again before you can say "wibbly-wobbly".
With so much to do and see, things on the show do get forgotten about every now and then. This isn't usually a big problem, but sometimes viewers are left thinking "Hey, where did that really interesting storyline end up?" or "Whatever happened to that character I really liked?"
Over multiple decades, hundreds of episodes, lots of showrunners, and more TARDIS designs than you can shake a round thing at, Doctor Who's back catalogue is full of ideas that had all the promise in the world, but were not given the time and attention they deserved.
Any great TV show has its "What If?" moments, and Doctor Who is no exception - and it would be thrilling if any of these ten ideas made a comeback.
Don't put money on it, though.
10. Gwen’s Ancestry
Gwen Cooper is a no-nonsense, ass-kicking member of the Torchwood team in the popular Doctor Who spinoff. Originally a police officer, Gwen stumbles across Captain Jack Harkness and his gang, eventually joining them to fight those alien threats the Doctor doesn't get to.
However, this was not the first time Whovians had seen her face.
In the third episode of NuWho, the Ninth Doctor and Rose Tyler travel to Cardiff in 1869, where they encounter ghost-like aliens called the Gelth. Along the way they meet famed author Charles Dickens, and also bump into Gwyneth, a clairvoyant servant played by Eve Myles, who also plays Gwen Cooper in Torchwood.
This was actually addressed when the Tenth Doctor meets Gwen in Series 4. He deduces that she is from an old Cardiff family and, through something called "spatial genetic multiplicity", she has the same face as her ancestor.
While the showrunners could've done something with this, Gwen's connection to her psychic forebear is never mentioned again. What could've been an interesting storyline exploring the connection between Gwen and Gwyneth was instead a quick line to get around a case of double casting.
9. The Minister Of War
Who'd have thought that a throwaway line would've caused so much trouble.
In the two-part story Under the Lake/Before the Flood, the Doctor encounters a number of underwater miners who he must protect from an army of ghosts. One of the miners is a woman named O'Donnell, and she is a big fan of the Doctor.
She reels off all of his greatest hits, recounting the times he has saved the Earth from danger. She tells him about Harold Saxon, the moon being an egg, and The Minister of War.
The Doctor is just as confused by this as we are, and asks O'Donnell who that is. However, he stops himself, realising that this is an adventure he is yet to have.
Under the Lake/Before the Flood came out in 2015, and fans are still waiting to find out who The Minister of War is. Some have theorised it could be the Master, Omega, or the War Lords, but those are just guesses for now.
At this point, it feels unlikely that we'll ever get a follow-up to this. Or maybe there were never any plans for one and we all need to get a life.
8. Ryan’s Dyspraxia
Dyspraxia is a disorder that can affect a person's motor skills and coordination. It's a severely under-represented condition in the media, which is what made the announcement of Ryan Sinclair so exciting.
Played by Tosin Cole, Ryan accompanied the Thirteenth Doctor between 2018 and 2021. He lost his mother at a young age, has a frosty relationship with his father, and has dyspraxia.
Showrunner Chris Chibnall did everything right when creating the character, even consulting charity the Dyspraxia Foundation on how Ryan should be portrayed. The initial buzz surrounding the character achieved its goal of drawing attention to the condition, but as time went on, mentions of it in the show got less and less common.
Basically, Ryan only had dyspraxia when the plot called for it. The rest of the time, he acted as if it didn't affect him at all.
This is a real shame, as the show had the opportunity to shed some light on this relatively obscure condition. Sure, they drummed up some initial interest in the subject when Ryan's character was first revealed, but they failed to do anything meaningful with it in the actual show.
7. Jackie Tyler In Survival
Now, this is something that's completely fan-driven, and hasn't actually been explored, set up, or even hinted at by the show itself - at least, not intentionally. Still, it's a brilliant idea, so we thought it deserved a bit of shine!
It revolves around actress Michelle Martin, who holds a very special distinction in Doctor Who history. Not counting the two leads (Sylvester McCoy as the Seventh Doctor and Sophie Aldred as Ace), her character was the last person to speak in 1989's Survival, the final serial in classic Who before it was taken off the air.
What's extra notable about this is that her nameless neighbour bears a striking resemblance - both her appearance and personality - to Jackie Tyler, a character who was introduced in the next regular episode of Doctor Who in 2005.
It's insane to think that someone with such Jackie Tyler energy was the very last guest character seen in classic Who, and though the opportunity was there for the show to confirm that they're the same person, that opportunity has never been taken.
Obviously, this isn't a huge glaring flaw or anything like that, but it would've been a brilliant way to further strengthen the bridge between the classic and modern eras.
Plus, it even makes sense in-universe. Jackie was born in 1967, putting her in her early twenties during the events of Survival. The neighbour also lives in Perivale, London, not a million miles away from Jackie's Powell Estate home in the 2005 revival.
Alas, this is pure head canon for now.
6. Thirteen's Fob Watch
The finale of Flux saw the Thirteenth Doctor hide a fob watch containing her lost memories deep within the TARDIS.
This was a strange decision considering that her mission in this series was to uncover the truth about her past, but ok, fair enough. Showrunner Chris Chibnall was just saving the watch for a future story, right?
Well, no. Eve of the Daleks and Legend of the Sea Devils came and went without so much as a mention of it, and with the Thirteenth Doctor now having regenerated, it's unlikely that this plot thread will ever be revisited.
And that's highly frustrating, as well as being a shame. Think of the craziness that would ensue were the Doctor to dive into that watch's secrets - we could learn more about Gallifrey, the Division, and the Doctor's own history.
The watch could've even served as a way to revisit previous Doctors. Chibnall invented a mechanic (the Guardians of the Edge) to bring back classic Doctors in The Power of the Doctor, even though he already had a mechanic sitting right there.
At the very least, the watch could give us more memories of the Doctor's missions with Karvanista, and more screen time with that good doggo wouldn't go amiss.
5. The Paternoster Gang
Appearing out of nowhere in the Series 6 episode A Good Man Goes to War, The Paternoster Gang aided the Eleventh and Twelfth Doctors in various quests.
Madame Vastra the Silurian, her human wife Jenny, and their Sontaran butler Strax appeared five times on television, including a Christmas special, the 100th episode of NuWho, and the Twelfth Doctor's first adventure. Not a bad spread.
Despite putting minimal effort into explaining where they came from and how they met the Doctor, the show gave the Gang a decent treatment once they were established. Plans were tentatively discussed for a spinoff starring the trio, but Steven Moffat vetoed the idea in fear of overexposing audiences to Doctor Who content.
They have lived on in the form of audio stories, novellas, and magazines, but a lot of potential was left on the table by not giving them their own show. The group was tailor-made for a kid-friendly series in the vein of The Sarah Jane Adventures, but it just wasn't meant to be.
4. The War Doctor
First things first: John Hurt as the War Doctor looks absolutely incredible.
Rugged and worn down by the weight of combat, dressed in raggedy clothes and wearing a grizzled expression on his face, this version of the Time Lord gives off major John Wayne vibes - an old gunslinger, back in town for his final shootout.
The Elephant Man actor played the role as part of the show's 50th anniversary special The Day of the Doctor, where it's explained that he committed atrocities during the Time War, and that his future incarnations have shunned his memory out of shame.
A star like John Hurt was always going to be hard to tie down, but it would've been fantastic to see the War Doctor in more than one story. They managed to get him to commit to Merlin!
He was used brilliantly in The Day of the Doctor so this is more a case of untapped potential rather than a flat-out wasted idea, but just think how awesome it would be to explore his days in the Time War in greater detail.
Despite Hurt's passing in 2017, the role could be recast for a spinoff or standalone episode, like David Bradley as the First Doctor. Get it done Russell!
3. Captain Jack’s Missing Years
John Barrowman might be persona non grata following accusations of inappropriate on-set behaviour, but Captain Jack Harkness remains one of the most beloved creations from the NuWho era.
An immortal conman from many centuries in the future, a Jack appearance alongside the Ninth or Tenth Doctors was always a treat. He even resurfaced during the Thirteenth Doctor's tenure, busting her out of space prison.
As explored in the Torchwood series, Jack is a multi-faceted character who has done (and seen) a lot across his never-ending life. But he's actually missing two entire years of his memory, as explained in the episode The Doctor Dances.
The years were wiped from his mind by the Time Agency, Jack's former employers. Despite this posing some very intriguing questions about the future Face of Boe, the character has never seemed too interested in finding out more about them.
Jack doesn't even pursue these memories in the Big Finish audio series, which usually mops-up loose ends like some sort of plot janitor.
And with Barrowman likely out of the picture when it comes to Doctor Who, those two years might just remain a mystery for the rest of Jack's life - so basically, forever.
2. The Fugitive Doctor
Jo Martin first appeared as Ruth Clayton in the episode Fugitive of the Judoon. A seemingly normal woman, Ruth's world is turned upside-down when the rhino-headed aliens invade her hometown in search of her.
She eventually discovers that she isn't Ruth Clayton at all. She's actually a version of the Doctor from some unknown point in their timeline.
It is believed that this "Fugitive" version of the character is from their very distant past, before their time as the First Doctor. However, as of right now, we still don't really know an awful lot about this incarnation of the Doctor.
The Fugitive Doctor has mainly appeared in projections and holograms since her first appearance, which has been thoroughly unhelpful when it comes to learning more about her.
Jo Martin is brilliant in the role and it would be great to see more of her, but considering that things like this don't tend to pass from showrunner to showrunner, it's unlikely that RTD will choose to explore the Fugitive Doctor further.
We also want to know where she got that coat from, because that thing is snazzy.
1. The Cartmel Masterplan
Andrew Cartmel was a script editor on Doctor Who between 1987 and 1989, during the Seventh Doctor era of the show.
Alongside other writers like Marc Platt, Cartmel devised several plots to help bring some mystique back to the show and turn around its falling ratings. These ideas have been dubbed "The Cartmel Masterplan" by fans.
Regrettably, the Masterplan never saw the light of day, as Doctor Who was cancelled before the new storylines were put in place. This is hugely disappointing, as these plans sounded awesome.
Cartmel planned to make the Doctor a demi-god, one of Gallifrey's founding fathers alongside Rassilon and Omega. He also planned to introduce an alter-ego called The Other, a shadowy figure deeply connected to the planet's past.
Fragments of these ideas made it into episodes of the TV show pre-cancellation, as well as other media, like books. This all came too late to save the show though, which was confined to the television waste bin until 2005.
Would The Cartmel Masterplan have rescued Doctor Who? It's impossible to say, but the potential that it had makes it one of the most intriguing "What Ifs?" in the show's storied history.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You Know Classic Doctor Who?