Doctor Who: 10 Big Talking Points From The Magician's Apprentice

Surprise returns, shocking deaths and everything inbetween!

clara doctor who
BBC

Doctor Who finally returned to our screens with The Magician's Apprentice and it was certainly worth it. From the return of Missy as delightfully evil as ever, the Twelfth Doctor showing his lighter, more mischievous side and numerous Daleks (1960's, the Special Weapons and the Supreme Dalek to name a few), there was plenty to keep the audience on their toes from beginning to end.

“Why not start with a blockbuster?" Steven Moffat recently touted The Magician's Apprentice and The Witch's Familiar "Why leave it till the last two weeks? So yes, it’s like starting with a finale, and having a big, grand, movie-sized story, as opposed to a 45-minute story.”

And true to form, there were even bigger shocks and surprises in store, proving that the trailers kept more than a few twists hidden from fans eager to uncover every stone in search of what was coming up on their favourite show. The first gasp-worthy moment happened before the credits had even begun to roll and continued all the way up to that dramatic, nail-biting cliffhanger.

Here are ten of the huge moments in The Magician's Apprentice. Turn away now if you haven't seen it. And then go watch it. Because if this opener set the tone from what to expect in series nine, this might be the most thrilling year of Doctor Who yet! 

10. The Boy On The Battlefield Is Davros

Doctor Who young Davros
BBC

One of the best kept secrets of the series opener was the return of Davros, creator of the Daleks. A couple of months ago, Peter Capaldi teased an image from the new series that showed the Doctor making a mistake that had cataclysmic repercussions. Well he certainly wasn't exaggerating.

After another Moffat-chilling creation, the hand mines trapped the boy, the Doctor appeared to save him, throwing across his sonic screwdriver and trying to convince him that he would survive. It was a thrilling opening, only topped the first of many shocks the episode had in store; the boy the Doctor had saved was his arch nemesis Davros. 

Suddenly this episode had nothing to do with Missy or the Daleks - they were just the icing on the cake. The Magician's Apprentice was a Davros story and it was all the better for it.


9. The Return Of The Shadow Proclamation

shadow proclamation
BBC

Another creepy Moffat creation, the hooded servant searching for the Doctor across the galaxy, travelled to many interesting locales. The alien bar that featured 'blink and you'll miss it' returns of old aliens like the Sycorax and the Hath and the planet Karn, featured in the prologue, which saw Clare Higgins back as Ohila.

But perhaps the biggest surprise was the servant's arrival at The Shadow Proclamation, last seen in The Stolen Earth. Not only did we get the return of the Judoon  but Kelly Hunter also reprised her role as the Shadow Architect. Whether this sets up a return for this galactical peacekeeping facility remains to be seen though it is interesting that this marks their first appearance since Davros tried to destroy the galaxy.


8. Missy's Return

doctor who missy return
BBC

We all knew she was coming back, but the manner in which she did it was brilliant, providing plenty of shocks and surprises for Clara and a returning Kate Stewart. With planes frozen mid-air across the globe, UNIT picks up a message. Hey Missy you're so fine, you're so fine you blow my mind. Hey Missy! Hey Missy! It is a fantastic tease before she hacks into the Doctor Channel and demands that Clara bring along eight snipers and meet her in whatever hot country she has found herself in.

Even better, Missy makes no attempt to explain how she survived the blast of the Cyberman Brigadier's gun at the end of the last season. She just did. Now she has the ability to freeze planes with Timelord parlour tricks just to get the attention of the one person she needs to find the Doctor; Clara.

But just to prove she hasn't gone good she executes a couple of UNIT soldiers. The man with the wife and kids didn't stand a chance. As reintroductions go, Missy certainly knows how to make one.


7. Missy Puts Clara In Her Place

Doctor Who The Magician's Apprentice Missy Clara
BBC Studios

Love her or hate her, it was still hilarious to see Missy put Clara firmly in her place. Clara Oswald might think that she is the Doctor's closest friend but Missy had other ideas. "You see that couple over there?" she asks, pointing to the man and woman walking their dog. "You're the puppy."

Clara held her own, but there was no denying that Missy's perspective on the Doctor / companion relationship when it comes to her own long history with her fellow Time Lord. Missy and the Doctor are best mates - they might have tried to kill each other over the last few centuries - but that is just part of their twisted friendship.


6. Missy Gets The Doctor's Last Will And Testament

will doctor who
BBC

Even more interesting was the idea that the Doctor reciprocates Missy's statement. When he faces certain death at the hands of his arch nemesis Davros - Missy certainly seemed put out by that statement - he send his last will and testament not to current companion Clara but Missy, another member of his own race.

Worse still, he doesn't seem surprised by her arrival in 1138AD Essex. Missy might have entrapped humanity in a fiendish plan and been responsible for Danny Pink's death but the Doctor chose not to reveal to Clara that she survived. 

It may have been a betrayal but it also shows how deep his relationship with the Master / Missy goes, even with all the bloodshed they have caused.


5. The Doctor Has A Party

doctor who party
BBC

In series eight we have seen the Twelfth Doctor grim, moody and altogether a much harsher self than we were used to in the Tenth and Eleventh incarnations. But that changed in The Magician's Apprentice as Peter Capaldi delivered a much more playful side to his character, having had some fun before confronting Davros.

Wearing sunglasses in 1138AD Essex, playing an electric guitar, riding a tank and introducing the word  'dude' several centuries early, this was a huge but very fun difference in the Doctor and it was great to watch. Oh sure he didn't care about messing with history - this Doctor isn't quite as feely as his immediate predecessors - though he still found time to compliment Clara and give her a hug.

Was this the Twelfth Doctor with nothing to lose, indulging in a one-off party, or a new side to his character? Only time will tell.


4. Return To Skaro

doctor who skaro
BBC

Despite the Seventh Doctor destroying Skaro in Remembrance Of The Daleks (surely a prelude to the Time War itself?), the return of the Dalek's home planet was another huge moment in the episode. Made invisible to the rest of the universe, the floating space station containing Davros and the Supreme Dalek was revealed to an uncloaked part of a larger Dalek city.

A brief cameo of sorts in Asylum Of The Daleks aside, this was the first confirmation that, like Gallifrey, Skaro had emerged out of the Time War stronger than ever. Grumblings over the power ranger Daleks aside, the events established in Victory Of The Daleks led to a huge resurgence of Dalek power in the galaxy, culminating in the return of Davros and Skaro as the centre of its power base.

Is this the beginnings of another Time War?


3. Missy And Clara Are Exterminated...

doctor who exterminated
BBC

The return to two-parters and the weekly cliffhangers of old Classic Who was surely justified by this dramatic end to the Magician's Apprentice that saw not one, but two pivotal characters exterminated before the end credits. Missy's attempt to strike a deal with the Daleks was not surprising - just look to her / his past actions in Frontier In Space, but no one expected this evil Time Lady to meet her maker without a regeneration in sight. 

More shocking still was the death of Clara moments later, while the horrified Doctor looked up from Davros's chamber, his arch nemesis laughing maniacally. The BBC have just announced that Jenna Coleman will be leaving the show - is Clara's end sooner than we expected? And if so, how do you explain her presence in trailers for future episodes?

Of course, knowing Missy's penchant for survival, one or both of them might have made it out. Unless of course, future episodes are set before The Magician's Apprentice - it's a rather timey wimey headache that ensures this huge moment will leave audiences desperate for next week!


2. ...And The TARDIS Is Destroyed

tardis destroyed
BBC

Not content with killing off the Doctor's companion and frenemy, the Daleks go one step further to deliver a truly epic cliffhanger. As Davros cackles with glee, the Doctor is forced to watch as the Supreme Dalek orders the TARDIS to be destroyed. 

It isn't the first time in Doctor Who history that an episode has ended with the TARDIS seemingly destroyed (see Frontios for example) but it certainly built on the shocking exterminations of Missy and Clara to give audiences a proper water-cooler moment; the Doctor will certainly find a way to circumvent it, but that will be half the fun, guessing just how this huge moment will be resolved next week.


1. The Doctor Kills Child-Davros?

doctor who killer
BBC

Could the Doctor commit the genocide of the Daleks? It was an idea that started with Genesis Of The Daleks and was a pivotal part of the Time War. It was certainly an idea that returned in The Magician's Apprentice. But this time, it actually appeared as if the Doctor would see it through for the second time, but not with the destruction of the Daleks but the murder of the young child Davros.

Returning to the battlefield on ancient Skaro, Dalek gun in hand and fuelled with rage over the death of Clara, Missy and the TARDIS, this huge moment provided a shocking cliffhanger to start the new series on. Will he see it through, changing history irrevocably? 

Like those deaths, this remains the big question for next week's episode. 

The Magician's Apprentice certainly set up series nine in style, delivering shocks, twists and plenty of revelations. What are your thoughts on those big moments? Please let us know in the comments below...


Contributor
Contributor

A writer for Whatculture since May 2013, I also write for TheRichest.com and am the TV editor and writer for Thedigitalfix.com . I wrote two plays for the Greater Manchester Horror Fringe in 2013, the first an adaption of Simon Clark's 'Swallowing A Dirty Seed' and my own original sci-fi horror play 'Centurion', which had an 8/10* review from Starburst magazine! (http://www.starburstmagazine.com/reviews/eventsupcoming-genre-events/6960-event-review-centurion) I also wrote an episode for online comedy series Supermarket Matters in 2012. I aim to achieve my goal for writing for television (and get my novels published) but in the meantime I'll continue to write about those TV shows I love! Follow me on Twitter @BazGreenland and like my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/BazGreenlandWriter