Doctor Who: 10 Worst Twelfth Doctor Moments
Sometimes even the best Doctors are guilty of malpractice.
Peter Capaldi’s 12th Doctor is about to ride off into the sunset, making room for the upcoming 13th Doctor and new showrunner, Chris Chibnall. Unfortunately for most incarnations of The Doctor, “riding off into the sunset” involves a painful death.
But until that moment, Capaldi and crew are enjoying the little time they have left. Now it’s all about creating moments to give the 12th Doctor a proper sendoff. And while Capaldi has already given fans a myriad of memorable moments, there’s a particular expectation of epic-ness for a Doctor's final episodes. Here’s hoping Capaldi doesn’t disappoint.
That’s not saying Capaldi’s run was flawless. Whether it had to do with writing, directing, or simply misfires in execution, the past three series had their share of moments that didn't quite live up to what is typically expected from the good Doctor. And even some of the moments that truly resonated were later ruined, or had their impact lessened, by another uneven moment in direct contrast to what made the initial one so powerful.
These hiccups by no means detracted from the big picture moments that made the 12th Doctor's tenure so powerful. However, they did reinforce the notion that no matter how many billions of years The Doctor has lived, he still has much to learn.
10. Robin Hood And Robots
Robot of Sherwood began with The Doctor allowing Clara to choose to go anywhere she pleased. And of course the logically-minded schoolmarm chose late-medieval England so she could meet Robin Hood, who, for lack of a better word, is fictional.
Granted, the legend may have been loosely based on various anti-crown vigilantes named either Robert or Robin who existed between the 10th and 17th century. But sword/spoon fighting with a pseudo-fictional dandy wasn’t even this episode’s biggest sin. The true crime was not doing this historical episode justice.
In the past, episodes where The Doctor went back in time to rub elbows with the likes of Van Gogh, Charles Dickens, and Queen Victoria, were some of the show’s finest. Because whenever a historical figure showed up, The Doctor and his companion would dig deep not only into the person but also into his/her time period, resulting in a truly poignant and meaningful reason for disrupting the space time continuum.
Meeting Robin Hood, however, amounted to little more than low-stakes adventure story. And Robin himself behaved eerily like the 11th Doctor acting as a sort of placeholder giving Clara more time to get used to her new, more crotchety Doctor.
9. Those Blasted Sonic Sunglasses
Starting in series nine, The Doctor replaced his iconic sonic screwdriver with what he referred to as “wearable technology” in the form of a pair of regular looking black sunglasses. These sonic sunglasses worked similarly to the screwdriver, with a few added bells and whistles to justify this downgrade.
One of the most noticeable problems with the glasses was that, unlike the screwdriver, their effects weren’t visible. Doctor Who is ordinarily a visual program that has always drawn attention to its colorful sci-fi/fantasy moments. Also, unlike the screwdriver they weren’t exclusive used by The Doctor, making them far less special. Clara, Ashildr and Osgood all donned the specs during the limited number of episodes in which they appeared.
In series 10, the glasses committed their greatest sin. After the events in Oxygen rendered The Doctor blind, instead of having him deal with the extent of losing one’s vision, he popped on his magic glasses, thus cheapening the experience. While they didn’t restore his vision, the tech provided him with enough guidance to dramatically lessen the full extent of his blindness. Sadly, if the writers had allowed The Doctor to go 100% blind, the sheer vulnerability of such a powerful character could've made the Monk Trilogy a much stronger arc.
8. Found Footage Sandman
Writer Mark Gatiss hasn't really been knocking them out of the park when it came to standalone episodes. Responsible for the aforementioned Robot of Sherwood and series 10’s Empress of Mars, Gatiss’ episodes amount to an underwhelming three-act structure that doesn’t quite live up to the wonder of Doctor Who.
However, while Sherwood and Mars had their moments, series nine’s Sleep No More was nothing short of a colossal mess. Set up like a found footage horror movie, this episode was about as entertaining as a found footage horror movie - and not one of the passable ones.
Gatiss’ main shortcoming is that he’s far too focused on plot when Doctor Who has always been a program focused on its characters. Sleep No More didn’t work as a spooky story because the audience didn’t care about the characters being picked off. Typically when somebody dies on the show, it’s not about him/her, but rather how The Doctor or his companion feels about his/her death.
Besides, the found footage format doesn’t work when there are survivors.
7. Superhero Christmas Extravaganza
The Return of Doctor Mysterio was the weakest Christmas special in recent history. It involved The Doctor helping the guy from Shameless (U.S.) save the world for some reason after inadvertently giving him superpowers in his youth. Nardole, who appeared in the previous year’s Christmas episode, acted as The Doctor’s pseudo-companion, and the episode as a whole didn’t quite come together.
The relationship between The Doctor and the episode’s protagonist, Grant, came across as completely phoned in. Unlike other times when The Doctor had been without a companion, the writers tried to force a backstory between them without doing the work of having their relationship grow throughout the episode. Also, the audience had no real connection to Grant - or his superhero alter ego The Ghost - so his struggles with unrequited love and the ability to “have it all” didn’t resonate.
The plot in general, involving brain-swapping aliens, was Whovian enough to be passable, but the addition of a superhero seemed a little too out of place. Superheroes are currently everywhere, and until December 2016 Doctor Who had been one of the few safe havens from the worldwide superhero takeover. Well, it was nice while it lasted.
6. The Justification Of Nardole
For the majority of series 10, The Doctor was followed around by a cue-balled cyborg known as Nardole. He first appeared in the 2015 Christmas episode with a purpose and then proceeded to just sort of hang out afterward with no discerning purpose. Then midway through series 10 in the episode Extremis, his purpose was explained. It didn’t help matters.
The tacked-on reason Nardole gave was that River Song sent him to make sure The Doctor didn’t take any extreme actions following her death. This was a cheap use of a beloved character to justify another character that is likely around because he amuses the showrunners. So why not use that? If they explained Nardole was still around because he amused The Doctor it would’ve made more sense than the heavy-handed reason they came up with.
On top of that, almost every moment with Nardole is a less than desirable moment. The actor Matt Lucas may have been the second funniest performer on Little Britain, but on Doctor Who, he’s a whole lot of nothing. With larger than life characters such as Missy and Bill, Nardole adds nothing and at times even detracts.
5. The Master's Very Familiar Face
The series 10 trailer spoiled that John Simm would return as The Master at some point. However, since he didn’t appear in the first ten episodes, it became a given that’s he’d appear sometime during the two-part series finale. And while they might have been saving him for part two, it was likely they’d want to utilize him for the entire story arc.
So with all that in mind, a character that looked a lot like John Simm in heavy makeup appeared about 15 minutes into the penultimate episode, The World Enough and Time. Some viewers may have been as shocked as The Doctor and Missy were by the reveal, but it could’ve been handled better.
Simm did his part by disguising his voice and mannerisms. Yet it feels like a lost opportunity with an easy enough fix, if anybody had cared. The whole thing could’ve been avoided by either not including The Master in the trailer, or by disguising Simm in even more makeup and prosthetics.
4. Lobus Caecilius's Youthful Face
The series nine episode, The Girl Who Died revealed that the 12th Doctor subconsciously chose his face as a reminder to always try to save people whenever possible. This was a callback to The Fires of Pompeii, a 10th Doctor episode in which he saved a man named Lobus Caeclius and his family from Pompeii’s eruption.
In that episode, Caeclius was played by Peter Capaldi, making the explanation a sort of inside joke about casting. However, this explanation brings about a series of more confusing questions. Questions like: Why did he choose to make Caeclius’s face look eight years older than what he remembered? Or why did the soothsayer in that very episode look exactly like Amy Pond? Or why does Caeclius also look exactly like Secretary John Frobisher from Torchwood’s Children of Earth storyline?
A metric ton of British actors have played multiple roles on Doctor Who, and numerous members of the principle cast started out in smaller roles. So in overexplaining the 12th Doctor’s appearance, the writers inadvertently wrecked a ton of continuity all to fix an inconsistency that no reasonable viewer cared about in the first place.
3. Cameo In Class
Class is a Doctor Who spin-off that has most likely been cancelled due to lack of interest. Capaldi’s 12th Doctor appeared in the pilot episode of the show in hopes of increasing their viewership. Unfortunately, Capaldi wasn’t given much to do aside from acting as a Deus ex Machina that prevented any other character in Class from being the hero. Not the strongest message for a premiere episode.
Class’s main problem is being a spin-off of Doctor Who devoid of any major characters from the Whovian mythos. In the past, spin-offs like The Sarah Jane Adventures and Torchwood were successful because they took characters fans loved from the original show and put them in new exciting situations.
Class was a blank slate that didn’t really understand the scope of its world. It even failed at making The Doctor appear interesting. Doctor Who has standalone adventures all the time, which either work or don’t depending on how fleshed out each world is and how The Doctor behaves within them. In the end, having the impact of a lesser Doctor Who standalone is why Class failed.
2. Forest On The Streets Of London
Nobody ever watches Doctor Who wishing to see more of Clara teaching. Nor does anyone want to see Clara and her series eight romantic interest Danny Pink guiding a group of kids through a forest-covered London. And if somebody does, they probably should call for help immediately.
But that’s exactly what everyone got in the series eight episode In the Forest of the Night. Everything about this episode screamed boring. And just when you thought it was leading to something, the ending was even more of a letdown.
'It was Earth all along' may have been an epic ending for The Planet of the Apes, but here the planet exhibiting human characteristics to protect itself was not only underwhelming it was also condescending of the real life problems facing the Earth.
Then again, maybe we should all just let the planet take care of itself.
1. That CGI T-Rex
After his two cameos in The Day of the Doctor and The Time of the Doctor, Capaldi made his first full appearance in Deep Breath. It was a fun, inventive episode that was enhanced with the appearance of familiar favorites, The Paternoster Gang and the 11th Doctor.
Sadly, the episode wasn’t as shining a premiere as it should’ve been for one Jurassic reason - Cretaceosus to be exact. Somehow a Tyrannosaurus-Rex materialized in Victorian London and The Doctor had to deal with that alongside a half-faced man and the ill-effects of his recent regeneration.
The latter two elements worked well enough, but nobody could take the T-rex seriously as it was some of the worst CGI of all time.
The 12th Doctor’s first episode didn’t work out as planned because there’s simply no getting around a poorly done job. If better CGI wasn’t available the show would’ve been better off not having a dinosaur at all. Instead die hard fans were forced to ogle that abomination for an extended episode. Thankfully, it died about halfway through.
Agree with this list? What do you think are teh Twelfth Doctor's worst moments? Let us know down in the comments.