Doctor Who 12th Wishlist - 13 Probable, Plausible And Impossible Replacements For Matt Smith

matt-smith_doctor_who11 Heartbroken. I remember, as a young boy, watching Tom Baker's Fourth Doctor fall from the top of a radio tower in Logopolis and start to change. I was heartbroken. He may have been the Fourth Doctor, but he was my first. At that point, my only. He was The Doctor. How could anyone replace him? I feel now like I felt then. I was ecstatic in 2005 when Doctor Who was resurrected, and when I finally got my hands on the DVD's in the U.S., Christopher Eccleston's Ninth Doctor instantly became an all-time favorite. Of course, by then, the news had already made it across the pond that he had quit and the Ninth Doctor was no more. I hadn't even started watching and he was already gone. For some reason, that softened the blow. But I was not prepared for this. David Tennant was brilliant, but when he left, it felt like the right time. In fact, Journey's End has been such a note perfect finale, the specials that followed kind of made it feel like he was overstaying his welcome. And then came Matt Smith... I admit I was skeptical, at first. But, in the last four years, Smith has won me over completely. The Moffat/Smith era of Doctor Who has been my absolute favorite of any era in the entire series history, from 1963 to the present, and believe me when I say I have seen them all. As far as I'm concerned, during these last few seasons, Doctor Who has been the best it has ever been. And Matt Smith has become The Doctor. Not A Doctor. But THE Doctor. The genuine article, you might say... And then, a few days ago, he announced his departure... And I am heartbroken. How could anyone replace him? And more to the point, WHO...? So, to console myself, I have made my Wishlist of worthy successors. Not anyone can play the Doctor, of course. But each of the candidates listed below possess a certain quality or qualities in their screen presence and performances that are essential to the Doctor's character. You will recognize some as fan favorites. Some I have never heard mentioned before. Some are popular choices. Some will raise outraged objections. And some are just outright ridiculous and impossible. Regardless, I am well aware that, in all likelihood, none of the candidates below will be named as the Twelfth Doctor come July. It will be probably be some actor I barely know, or don't know at all. That's how it usually is. And eventually they'll win me over. In Moffat we trust, after all... But if it were up to me to find someone to pick up the pieces after the Fall of the Eleventh and carry on, these would be my 13 nominees... One for each potential incarnation of the Doctor (though they've probably thrown out that bit of Doctor Who mythos)... And it's 2013, after all, so 13 seems appropriate... And, the truth is, I just happened to run out of ideas at 13, so it seemed as good a number as any, really... Anyway...

13. Chiwetel Ejiofor -->

-->

Chiwetel Ejiofor

You probably know Chiwetel Ejiofor as the actor who singlehandedly upstaged the entire Firefly cast with his charismatic turn as the remorseless, yet congenial Operative in Joss Whedon€™s Serenity. He was first mentioned as a potential Doctor after David Tennant announced his departure in 2009, and his name has come up repeatedly since (rumor has it his odds are currently 7 to 1). A sublimely gifted character actor who has received accolades for playing seductive villains and quirky supporting characters on stage, in film, and in television, Ejiofor brings a distinctive, yet recognizable emotional depth and intellectual complexity to every character he plays, standing out even in otherwise mundane roles.

WHY HIM: His deep, soulful eyes give him the perfect face to carry the weight of the Doctor€™s ever-more-burdensome past, and his ability to run hot and cold - to be stern and authoritative one moment and compassionate and vulnerable the next €“ make him an ideal choice to capture the Doctor€™s inner €“ and sometimes outer - conflicts and contradictions. Possessing a cosmopolitan confidence, you€™d never doubt that he knew his way around time and space. And, finally, though I see no need for a token black Doctor, casting him might silence some of those pesky, hypersensitive academics and their ludicrous accusations.

SEE HIM IN: The aforementioned Serenity. Though the Operative is the film€™s primary antagonist, Ejiofor never plays him as fearsome or threatening, instead imbuing the character with a remarkable balance of smooth charm, quiet authority and tragic self-awareness. Though not at all a Doctor-y character, his moments of detached, almost alien, amusement at human behavior, his near-tenderness with his victims as he carries out assassinations, and his wistful description of saving a world in which he has no place give some indication of what characteristics he might bring to the Twelfth Doctor given the chance.


--> -->

12. Eddie Izzard

izzard timelord

The notion of Eddie Izzard as the Doctor first came up back in 2003, when Tom Baker - the Fourth Doctor, himself - suggested that he€™d be an excellent choice to take on the role in the new series. In retrospect, I wouldn€™t part with Christopher Eccleston€™s Ninth Doctor for all the whiskey in Ireland, but at the time, he seemed such a perfect choice, I was surprised and disappointed that he didn€™t get the role. In 2008, Izzard vocally suggested himself as a replacement for David Tennant, and again €“ though I have no regrets €“ he was passed over. In the intervening years, Izzard has proven time and again that, not only is he a superlative comedian and stage performer, he€™s also a gifted, versatile actor who€™s more than capable of carrying a TV series.

WHY HIM: Izzard€™s stand-up is a tour-de-force of hyper-literacy, fierce intelligence, off-the-cuff silliness and manic energy. His dizzying tangents and digressions display a byzantine mind working at lightning speed. (Stop me when this sounds familiar€) And yet, in his dramatic work, he evinces a quiet intensity - even a dark and sinister quality that suggests he€™s got more going on behind his eyes than you€™d really care to know. Brilliant, charming, eccentric, witty, fun, mysterious and maybe a little dangerous€ Sound like anyone we know€?

SEE HIM IN: The criminally underwatched and underrated television series The Riches, in which he runs the gamut from wry comedy to gritty drama and back again as Wayne Malloy, the scheming father to a family of gypsy grifters. Or, if you don€™t feel like sitting through two seasons of television, do a double feature of Dress to Kill, one of his funniest stand-up specials, and The Cat€™s Meow, in which he plays a decidedly unfunny Charlie Chaplin.


-->

11. Helen Mirren

helen_mirren_bw

Another name that has come up repeatedly, Dame Helen Mirren needs no introduction. She would not only be the first woman, but the first full-blown, internationally recognized, Oscar-winning movie star to take on the role of The Doctor. But, hell, if you€™re going to cast a celebrity, why not go for the gold€?

WHY HER: Let€™s put aside, for the moment, that she€™s one of the greatest living actresses, that her knowing smile, no-nonsense attitude and noble bearing make her perfect for the role, and that she€™s been the favorite choice of fans for a first female Doctor for years, and just cut to the chase: SHE WANTS TO DO IT. She has said in interviews that she€™d like to be the first female Doctor and would jump at the chance. Are we really going to say, €œNo,€ to Helen Mirren€?

SEE HER IN: Jesus, people, it€™s Helen f**king Mirren€ Take your pick€ But just for all you ageist naysayers who are about to jump in and tell me that Doctor Who has changed since the 1960€™s and older actors just wouldn€™t be able to keep up with the action-star demands of playing the Doctor in the current series, check out Mirren laying down machine gun fire with grace and aplomb (wearing an evening gown and combat boots, no less!) in RED.


--> -->

10. David Thewlis

david thelwis

Though, for no reason I can apprehend, Thewlis has not been mentioned as often as some of the other actors on this list, I think he has the makings of a wonderful Doctor. Perhaps people associate him too closely with the world of Harry Potter, thanks to his stand-out performance as Remus Lupin in the Potter films. But if Ian McKellan can be Gandalf AND Magneto AND the voice of the Great Intelligence, there€™s no good reason Professor Moony can€™t be the Doctor€

WHY HIM: An excellent, if peculiar, actor, Thewlis brings a healthy dose of natural eccentricity to the screen. His eyes can glow with boyish mischief one moment and burn with the tortures of the damned the next. All at once manic and weary, he€™d ably convey the Doctor€™s age and experience, while wearing his inner child€™s heart on his sleeve. His brief cameo in The Big Lebowski as the erratically giggly Knox Harrington shows off his comic timing and proves he€™s not averse to just being silly. And then there€™s the voice€ Ever since Eccleston broke the €œreceived pronunciation€ barrier, it€™s been a puzzle to me why more people haven€™t pushed for Thewlis as the Doctor just to hear him playfully banter with his companions or righteously berate Daleks in his distinctive Lancashire accent.

-->

SEE HIM IN: If you want to keep to lighter fare, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. By far the best of the Potter films, and the one in which Thewlis features most prominently. If you€™re looking for something darker, check out his career-making turn in Mike Leigh€™s psychologically brutal Naked, wherein Thewlis€™ Johnny - an aggressive, intellectual bully and self-made nihilist prophet €“ takes us on a dark odyssey through after-hours London.


9. Tim Roth

tim roth

Am I alone on this? I have never once heard Tim Roth named as a potential Doctor, but to me, he seems such an obvious choice. I always felt that, if anyone ever had the audacity to attempt a Doctor Who origin story, Roth would be ideal to play a younger, pre-exile First Doctor, putting his own unique stamp on William Hartnell€™s piercing, avian stare and mercurial shifts from gruff impatience to childish glee. So why not let him have a crack at Twelve€?

WHY HIM: An accomplished actor with proven abilities in almost every genre, Roth conveys an intense braininess and an edgy idiosyncrasy in every role. He can be cold and distant, observing the world from deep behind his heavy-lidded eyes, or warm and gentle, allowing a strange compassion and awkward innocence to radiate on his face. Added to which, he is a professed fan of the show, and considers himself a bit of a sci-fi junkie, so I can€™t imagine him turning it down.

SEE HIM IN: If you can stomach the overall poor quality of the film, Roth has all pistons firing in Michael Caton-Jones€™ Rob Roy, as a duplicitous, villainous courtier named (somewhat obviously) Cunningham. But really, you€™ll have more fun sitting back and watching him play out existential Laurel and Hardy routines with Gary Oldman in Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead.


-->

8. James Callis

james-callis

It was James Callis that kept me watching Battlestar Galactica when the show spiraled into convoluted, telenovela-worthy nonsense in its final season. I€™m not speaking hyperbolically when I say that his turn as Gaius Baltar in Ron Moore€™s cult revival is one of the finest television performances I have ever seen. Moore deserves credit for writing Baltar as something deeper and more interesting than the moustache-twirling, George Sanders wannabe of the original Battlestar, but it was Callis€™s performance that made him simultaneously repugnant, heart-breaking, hilarious and even, at times, a little bit frightening. Ostensibly, the closest thing the series had to a villain, Callis made Baltar so human and sympathetic, even in his myriad flaws, that you couldn€™t help but find yourself rooting for him.

WHY HIM: Well, let€™s see€ We know he can compellingly play an eccentric, tortured scientist with a unique fashion sense who travels the galaxy and is, by turns, brilliant, funny, vulnerable, unpredictable and enigmatic. The only question is whether he can switch out Baltar€™s reptilian moral flexibility for the Doctor€™s hardened sense of righteousness and noble heroism. I think it€™s worth giving him the chance€

SEE HIM IN: I don€™t really need to repeat myself, do I€?


-->

-->

7. Eamonn Walker

eamon walker

Put Chicago Fire out of your mind. Wipe away Tears of the Sun. Ignore The Whole Truth. Yes, Walker might want to consider firing his agent, but his arguably poor career choices do not reflect his majestic talent and nimble versatility. It€™s not every actor that can ham it up as a gay, Jamaican housekeeper in the BBC sitcom In Sickness and in Health, and then turn around and play the powerful, magnetic Muslim leader, Kareem Said, in HBO€™s Oz. And then there€™s his strutting, threatening and yet somehow warm and sympathetic portrayal of Howlin€™ Wolf in Cadillac Records€

WHY HIM: I know what you€™re thinking: Why choose Eamonn Walker over the arguably similar fan favorite, Idris Elba? Simple. I love Stringer Bell, but the fact is, Walker is the better actor and has a broader range. No question, Elba is intense, imposing and quietly tragic. But Walker is also all those things, plus he can blaze with the kind of fiery conviction that has been the hallmark of so many great Doctors, he has a spry comic agility that he rarely gets to express, and he exudes a commanding dignity the likes of which we haven€™t seen since Tom Baker. (You know that €œAppreciate it!?!€ speech Baker gives in the Douglas Adams penned episode, ThePirate Planet? Imagine Idris Elba delivering that speech. Now, imagine Eamonn Walker. You see what I mean€?)

SEE HIM IN: Check out some YouTube clips of Walker as Winston in In Sickness and in Health and then watch the first season of Oz. Yeah, that€™s the same guy€


-->

6. Richard Armitage

richard armitage

€œPowerfully built€ and €œruggedly handsome€ are not the sort of descriptive terms that usually leap to mind when one talks of The Doctor, but unlike a lot of contemporary leading men, Armitage also possesses the sort of brooding intensity that leaves one hankering for the halcyon days of Brando, De Niro and Pacino. A skilled and subtle actor, he can do a lot with very little, conveying the full force of a character€™s raging inner conflicts with the arch of an eyebrow or twitch of the lip.

WHY HIM: A harder, more contained Doctor, to be sure, but considering that, according to Doctor Who mythos, the Twelfth Doctor is poised to give rise in some, way, shape or form, to the Valeyard (an embodiment of all the long-repressed darkness in the Doctor€™s nature), Armitage might be just the actor to throw some light on the shadowy corners of the Time Lord€™s psyche. His icy, blue gaze conveys a penetrating intelligence, but his lopsided grin and roguish charm prevent him from ever being unapproachable. He can break your heart as the agonized villain as easily as the tragic hero €“ an essential ability for anyone playing a Doctor who may have to be both at once. The image of a haunted Armitage stalking about the TARDIS in a long black coat, trying to keep his darker passions at bay is a pretty compelling one, if you ask me€

SEE HIM IN: The BBC series, Spooks (aka MI-5 in America), as the affable, but mysterious Lucas North €“ a man attempting to atone for his dark past by pursuing a life of heroism. If that doesn€™t scream The Doctor, I don€™t know what does€


-->

5. Ian McShane

ianmcshane600

You can€™t really see him as anyone other than Deadwood€™s Al Swearengen, can you€? Added to which, the man is 70 years old, which, yes, would make him the oldest actor ever to play the Doctor (anniversary specials, notwithstanding). In light of those facts, I fully expect McShane to be the least popular nomination on this list. But remember when you first saw photos of Matt Smith, after he€™d been cast, and you thought to yourself, €œToo young. Too hip. And who the hell is he, anyway€?€ And now, here we all are, four years later, crying into our keyboards because he€™s leaving us too soon€ So, hear me out€

WHY HIM: McShane is quite vigorous for his age, as anyone who€™s seen him wield a knife on Deadwood can attest. And remember that, before he cemented himself in our heads and hearts as Swearengen, he charmed us as the almost preternaturally gifted and charismatically roguish antiques dealer, Lovejoy. Watch a couple of scenes of McShane€™s Lovejoy explaining how he knows this or that particular antique is authentic or a forgery, and it€™s difficult not be reminded of the Doctor explaining transdimensional engineering to one of his companions. Like Armitage, he can bring a dark aura to the Doctor if they choose to pursue the Valeyard mythos. And most importantly, remember that Al Swearengen earned not just our awe but our sympathy. Because, for all his ruthless Machiavellian calculations, McShane gave Swearengen the soul of a lost child who learned too many hard lessons at too tender an age. How many times did we see his icy glare momentarily melt into wells of fear and pain as he internally revisited some past wound that never quite healed€? And how many times have we seen that same look on the Doctor€™s face? Yes, McShane would be a risky choice, I agree. But as the Doctor gets on in years, should Moffat choose to bring him back to his roots and force him to confront some of his most closely-guarded secrets, he could also be a very rewarding one.

--> -->

SEE HIM IN: You can never see too much Deadwood, can you€?


-->

-->

4. Robson Green

-->

-->

extremeFishing_0

Not as recognizable outside the UK, Robson Green is well-known in Britain for his starring roles in Touching Evil (co-written by Russell T. Davies, incidentally) and Wire in the Blood. A compact, intense actor, given to playing cerebral eccentrics with a special connection to the dark side of human nature, Green has received much acclaim for his performances, and is, by all accounts, a committed artist who takes his acting very seriously. Perhaps a little too seriously€

WHY HIM: Supposedly, Green turned down the role of The Master in the current Doctor Who€™s third season, snarling, €œI don€™t do panto.€ So it€™s highly unlikely he€™d ever take the role, even if it were offered. But if Green would just get over himself for a moment €“ and if Who fans can get over their fury at him for the comment €“ as the Doctor, he could bring a lot to the console. In addition to his introspective intensity, Green can also be effortlessly funny, allowing an understated humor to emerge organically from his characters€™ quirks. Projecting a bookish authority, despite his relatively small stature, he can deliver reams of forensic data and psychobabble (and, therefore, presumably technobabble, as well) with professorial confidence and a contagious enthusiasm. The only complication I foresee is that, at times, he is so strongly reminiscent of Sylvester McCoy€™s Seventh Doctor, his performance could come dangerously close to seeming imitative€ But that€™s really a problem for him and the production team€

SEE HIM IN: His best €“ and most Doctor-reminiscent work €“ is in Wire in the Blood.


3. Kate Winslet

-->

-->

kate-winslet

Like Helen Mirren, Kate Winslet needs no introduction and, like Helen Mirren, she is one of the finest living actresses. Which is pretty damn impressive considering that she€™s a full 30 years younger. According to Russell Davies, she was the first choice to play River Song before the role went to Alex Kingston. That ship has sailed, obviously (Melody Pond€™s penchant for regenerating, notwithstanding), but I find the idea of her playing the Doctor even more intriguing. Naysayers will always nay, but from Heavenly Creatures to Titanic to The Reader, Winslet has been both a box office and a critical darling, so if the BBC is worried about losing viewers with a female Doctor, she€™s the answer. She might even make the show MORE popular...

WHY HER: Talent and acclaim aside (because, you know€ what do those things matter€?), Winslet possesses one of those rare traits present in every actor ever to play the Doctor: she can carry herself with a noble, near-aristocratic bearing and also be unapologetically, unashamedly goofy. Smart, sexy, witty, quirky, commanding, and - above all - FUN, Winslet€™s Doctor could take you on the joyride of a lifetime, while never losing sight of the burdens she would quietly, stoically bear. (Wow, that DOES sound good, doesn€™t it€? Come on, admit it, naysayers: Not only would you watch it, you€™d LOVE it. And eventually you€™d have to admit that she belonged in the role...) Unfortunately, while there€™s probably nothing this woman can€™t do, there are probably a few things she won€™t; and, even though she got her start in Russell Davies€™ short-lived Dark Season way back when, I have a feeling that, these days, committing to play the lead in a sci-fi TV series is one of them.

SEE HER IN: Anything. From Revolutionary Road to those American Express commercials€ She€™s brilliant in everything. That said, Michael Gondry€™s Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind allows her to be unrepentantly loopy€ Or check out her cameo in Ricky Gervais€™ Extras to see her really indulge her mischievously playful (if slightly vulgar) side€


-->

2. Gene Wilder

-->

-->

There€™s been a lot of talk lately about the possibility, or even the likelihood, of a stateside Doctor Who reboot. As I sit here, campaigning at my keyboard, for a black Doctor, or a female Doctor, I must confess that there is one kind of Doctor that I never want to see: An American Doctor. I have heard all the names tossed around: Johnny Depp€ Robert Downey Jr. € Even (yipes!) Nicholas Cage€

I remain unconvinced.

For my money, there is one, and only one, American who could ever have played the Doctor and, all things considered, they€™d need to find themselves a real TARDIS to make it happen. Gene Wilder is 80 years old and retired from acting, but in his prime, I would have welcomed him as the American incarnation of the Time Lord.

WHY HIM: Two words: Willy Wonka. While Wilder€™s wizard of chocolate wasn€™t exactly the Willy Wonka Roald Dahl had envisioned, place him at the TARDIS console - velvet frock coat, top hat and all €“ and it€™s a perfect fit. Wilder€™s inherently gentle screen presence enabled him to dig into the mystery and menace of the character without ever losing his audience. Like a candy-coated Pied Piper leading a group of children, one by one, to their just desserts (Ha€ Sorry€), Wilder€™s Wonka would beam with wide-eyed wonder at the candy land he created, and then treat the children in his care with condescension, impatience, detached amusement, disappointed rage and, occasionally, warm affection. He would excitedly invite them to try his latest concoction and then scare the hell out of them with an increasingly frenzied chant during a nightmarish boat ride. And through it all, he somehow maintained an air of innocence and joy€ Alien, enigmatic, childlike, ancient, literate, playful and a little bit scary€ If America was going to try their hand at Doctor Who, they€™re about 30 to 40 years too late€

SEE HIM IN: Funny About Love.


1. Neil DeGrasse Tyson

-->

Neil-deGrasse-Tyson-600x300

Did I say Gene Wilder was the ONLY American who could play the Doctor€? What I meant was that he€™s the only American ACTOR. Dr. Neil DeGrasse Tyson is a world-renowned astrophysicist, but he€™s not your stereotypical, solitary, socially awkward scientist. Large in stature and larger in personality, Dr. Tyson is brilliantly intelligent, charismatic, charming and, as his numerous television appearances display, as comfortable in front of a camera as he is behind a telescope. He was instrumental in the demotion of Pluto to dwarf planet status and offers this sage advice to those who bristle at having their concept of the solar system redefined: €œGet over it.€ Additionally, he€™s a trained dancer, a former college wrestler, a pop culture enthusiast, a patron of the arts, and a wine connoisseur, all of which makes me think he must be a time-traveler because I don€™t know how else he would have the time for all those things€

WHY HIM: Read the above description. He€™s as close as we have to the real thing. I don€™t know if he can act, but he can certainly captivate an audience and, unlike a lot of past actors who have played the Doctor, he€™d have the advantage that all those lines of technobabble would pose no challenge for him. Hell, he might even be able to make a few corrections, ensuring €“ at least on a theoretical level €“ their scientific accuracy! And finally, check out the vest. The man€™s practically in costume already!

SEE HIM IN: The Storytelling of Science panel discussion (it€™s on YouTube) wherein he poetically considers the importance of Van Gogh€™s Starry Night to the field of astrophysics, and thus the importance of art€™s relationship to science in general, and later, righteously blasts Brian Greene with impassioned fury on the subject of scientific funding. And then there€™s The Poetry of Science, where, in an altogether friendlier discussion with Professor Richard Dawkins, Tyson explains why the universe has no center, imaginatively riffs with Dawkins on the subject of extra-terrestrial life and relative intelligence, and manages, throughout, to throw in references to X-Men, Daredevil and A Bug€™s Life. Or you can just tune into any of his hundreds of appearances on The Daily Show and The Colbert Report.


Contributor
Contributor

Matt J. Popham is an erratic, unreliable writer, an unapologetic intellectual snob, an opinionated political loudmouth, a passionate cinephile, and a near obsessive fan of Doctor Who and punk rock. I also tend to overuse commas and ellipses... If you're on Facebook and a fan of Doctor Who, go here: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Doctor-Who-50th-Anniversary-Page/387058671391930 This is my blog that I almost never keep up with: http://killingthemedium.wordpress.com