Doctor Who: 8 Potential Masters For Peter Capaldi's 12th Doctor

james-nesbitt Now that we know who the next Doctor will be, it's time to place our bets on who will play his greatest adversary: the Master. While there's no word yet on whether or not the Master will be featured during Capaldi's reign, it's likely that after four years off the classic villain may be staging a comeback. Each Doctor-Master relationship is unique, but they frequently have a yin and yang, almost codependent thing going on. The suave Roger Delgado matched perfectly with Pertwee's Bondesque Doctor, just as the manic John Simm worked well with Tennant's emotionally fragile Doctor. It would have been impossible to try to cast a Master without knowing who his Doctor would be. But now that we've got Peter Capaldi, we can determine what actor would be perfect to take him on.

8. Cillian Murphy

cillian murphy When it comes to the Master, the post-2005 Doctor Who has given us a new explanation for why he is the way he is. The new canon interpretation of the Master is that he's an emotionally damaged man, driven mad in his youth by the Untempered Schism. And if we're going to stick with that, rather than reverting to the more traditional version of the Master, I can't think of anyone better than Cillian Murphy. He can play emotionally unstable characters with the best of them, and is 100% capable of turning in a vulnerable and sympathetic performance while still being perceived as the villain. The Master does such terrible things, but you can almost feel bad for him, regardless. If he had the right scripts, Murphy could create a really nuanced interpretation of the character with a level of depth that goes way beyond what we've seen so far.

7. Jason Isaacs

jason isaacs Look me in the face and tell me that Jason Isaacs isn't on everyone's wish list for the Master. He was put on this Earth to play the role. While he has a long and illustrious history of playing the villain, I think that his unique brand of dark humor and upper class entitlement is a perfect fit for the Master. And because the character only makes occasional appearances, he wouldn't have to worry about a major time commitment or scheduling conflicts. If the past few years have taught us anything, it's that Doctor Who is capable of getting big name actors for supporting roles (see John Hurt, Derek Jacobi, Michael Gambon, Bill Nighy,etc). He could just show up when he felt like it, be awesome for a little while, then go back to his life. How is this a bad plan?

6. Dan Stevens

Alright, before you start chucking tomatoes at my head, give me a chance to explain. If you had suggested this idea to me a year ago, I would have given you a look of extreme disgust, because who could imagine Matthew Crawley playing the Master? But while he famously played Mr Nice Guy on Downton Abbey, Dan Stevens has a much greater acting range than that. His critically lauded performance in The Heiress on Broadway last year revealed the ability to play a cold, calculating manipulator, something that for me has always defined the Master. I think the contrast between an older, wilier Doctor and a younger, more genteel Master would be an avenue worth exploring.

5. James Nesbitt

james-nesbitt Let's face it, the Master is and always has been a ridiculously over the top role. I almost don't know if I would want an actor who was going to play the character with a touch of restraint. Maybe I want someone who's going to gleefully chew the scenery to bits. To that end, James Nesbitt seems like a perfect choice. He's done the Jekyll/Hyde thing already, so we know that he's more than capable. Is it perhaps too similar to his critically acclaimed performance on Jekyll? I don't think so. At the end of the day, I feel that he has the perfect energy for Moffat's brash, exuberant spectacle. He would bring such a malevolent intensity to the role, without going too far off the reservation.

4. Idris Elba

idris_elba_38068 Idris Elba is one of the names that always seems to come up whenever they're casting a new Doctor. And really, why not? He's well-known, well thought of, and immensely talented. But I've always thought that he would be much better suited to the role of the Master. He doesn't seem to have the natural eccentricity that I like to see in the Doctor, and his intensity would make for an incredibly compelling villain. The Master has sadly become something of a laughing stock over the years...I mean, he's sort of like Wile E. Coyote, with all his ridiculously convoluted schemes that never work out. Idris Elba could go a long way in making him a credible threat again.

3. Dominic West

dominicwest Dominic West would be a great choice to take the role of the Master in a direction that we've never gone before. We've had debonair with Delgado, campy with Ainley, and manic with Simm. West could give us a Master that was cold, aloof, and even cruel. A different approach, but somehow still the same man. It might even seem like a logical progression from the madness and intense emotions from Simm, to have a Master that buries any feelings he has down deep. The only way for him not to feel everything is to feel nothing at all. While not usually typecast as a villain, I've seen enough of his nastier characters to think that Dominic West could give us an iconic interpretation of the Master.

2. Iain Glen

Jorah Looking for something a little different? Maybe the next Master could be a bit more rough-and-tumble, while still maintaining the sneering persona that's made him famous. I suggest Iain Glen. He's capable of a malicious streak that gels really well with the role, but he's not the typical aristocratic Master. Plus, I'm not going to lie, I really enjoy the concept of the Master's regenerations piggy-backing the Doctor's. Oh, hi 10. You're in your mid-30s? I'll be in my mid-30s! Hi, 12. You're Scottish? I'll be Scottish! And I'd love to hear more nutters whinging about the Scottish Agenda. So I say full steam ahead!

1. Peter Capaldi (With A Goatee)

Doctor-Who-Peter-Capaldi-Cover Back in the days before Peter Capaldi was announced as the next Doctor, a lot of people were saying that he would make a perfect Master. After all, the role he's most known for is a frankly malevolent politician, which isn't too far off the mark. Isn't it exactly the sort of thing the Master would do, regenerating into a doppelganger of the Doctor, just to mess with him? And we've already established that the Master seems to have a greater level of control over his regenerations, as he's able to take the form of others (as we see in The Keeper of Traken) and decides to pick a body similar in age to Tennant's Doctor in the new series. All he needs is the delightfully evil goatee Capaldi's been seen sporting of late, and we're good to go.

Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.