Doctor Who: Dot And Bubble Review - 5 Ups & 5 Downs

Well, I think we all know who our new least-favourite character is...

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Lindy Pepper-Bean
BBC Studios

Like many episodes this season, we didn't know much about Dot and Bubble heading into it, other than it seemed to be Doctor Who doing its best impression of Black Mirror – something it achieves with mixed success.

It's an episode of extremely high highs, but also some very low lows. I would like it on record, however, that I liked it a lot more than the evenly balanced Ups and Downs might suggest. Still, Dot and Bubble has its flaws, and I have to acknowledge them.

Intriguingly, we know that this was RTD's pitch for an episode way back in 2010, and would've served as an Eleven and Amy Pond story – had this been the case, the commentary on social media might have felt less 'old hat'. It ultimately didn't end up coming to fruition 14 years ago due to being too expensive a concept (those were the days before Disney money), but in any event, it might've felt a little fresher back then, though it would have robbed us of those juicy last ten minutes.

Anyway, let's see what stuck the landing, and what didn't!

10. UP - A Supremely Hateable Performance

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Callie Cook as Lindy Pepper-Bean
BBC Studios

Dot and Bubble features up-and-comer Callie Cooke as a guest lead, and she does a remarkable job.

Unlike other Doctor-lite episodes (which have given us extremely likeable one-off leads like Sally Sparrow and Elton Pope), Dot and Bubble takes an altogether different route by making the central character an absolutely abhorrent person. Blissfully unaware of how the world works, socially performative, manipulative, and self-serving, Lindy Pepper-Bean may be one of the most unlikeable characters in the show's history, and that's without factoring in that she's a massive racist.

I'm not giving Callie Cooke an Up because I loved her character – quite the opposite. It's an achievement to embody a character so well, that they can make your blood boil constantly. Cooke plays the vapid influencer side of this character to frustrating perfection, and absolutely nails it when the story calls for a more sinister turn towards the end. It's honestly depressing that people like this exist in the real world, too.

Overall, I commend this approach. I'm sure that following such an irredeemable character for the entire runtime won't be to everyone's taste, but it makes for a very different type of story. More big swings from Russell, and another hit. We're picking up some momentum now.


9. UP - Another Glorious Day In Finetime

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

Dot and Bubble takes place entirely within the city of Finetime, a wonderfully realised and distinct setting with its pastel colour palette and horrendously saccharine inhabitants. The vibe is spot on, with the whole aesthetic coming together with some great worldbuilding that tells you everything you need to know about this moral gutter of a city before the opening credits even roll.

I loved the design and effects work with the bubble, which absolutely feels like a believable 'final form' of social media. It's a literal echo chamber (though honestly, to me, this claustrophobic, over-stimulating rainbow prison feels more like a torture chamber).

The wardrobe department also had a field day with the costuming this week, absolutely nailing that quirky influencer look. Another detail I absolutely loved was how much fun RTD had with the sickly-sweet and often terrible character names, poking fun at rich people and their chronic inability to name their children something normal.

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

The production team nailed it on this one, and once again I have to give credit to director and Doctor Who newcomer Dylan Holmes Williams, who also directed 73 Yards, for giving us the two standout episodes of the series from a production perspective. He can come back next year.

Lastly, I'd like to submit a formal complaint to Russell T Davies, who absolutely ruined my night's sleep because I had 'Itsy Bitsy Teenie Weenie Yellow Polka-Dot Bikini' on a loop in my head. Like I said, the bubble is a torture chamber.


8. DOWN - Another Doctor-Lite Episode

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Ncuti Gatwa Fifteenth Doctor
BBC Studios

Doctor-lite episodes are great, and they've been absent for too long. They give us different types of stories to tell, and as of yet, I firmly believe there hasn't been a bad one (Love & Monsters is overhated and I will die on that hill).

But two in a row?

I know that the Doctor and Ruby did have an ongoing presence in the story, but there's a big difference between sitting in front of a colour screen for most of the episode versus actually being on set, even if Gatwa does make up for it by absolutely stealing the scene at the end.

I'm rather concerned that, in an eight episode series, having a quarter of those episodes not feature the Doctor in a starring role is harmful to Fifteen's development. Fifteen and Ruby have a great dynamic, but we're approaching the finale now and honestly, they still feel like they've just met. We need another episode like Boom that puts their dynamic front and centre, and sharpish.

Unfortunately I'm not sure that next week's Rogue, with its two high-profile guest stars, is going to satisfy that quota either.

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Fifteenth Doctor Ruby Sunday

I understand that Gatwa was filming the final season of Sex Education and wasn't available for the first filming block of this season, but this feels like something the production should've been postponed for – there's a lot riding on this series, after all.

The episode order continues to baffle me too, from opening with Space Babies and The Devil's Chord (both of which were weak), to putting this one back-to-back with 73 Yards. Surely there had to be a better way of arranging them.


7. DOWN - 'Technology Bad'

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

I touched on this briefly in the introduction, but the commentary on technology in this episode gets a big old down. Not because it's necessarily an inaccurate reflection of society, but because 'social media is a corrosive influence' is just about the least original sci-fi theme going these days. 

Society may not have done much in the way of course-correction, but modern audiences as a whole are far more aware of the pitfalls of social media and its effects on mental health than we were ten years ago.

Dot and Bubble elbows its way into a debate that was settled some time ago and adds very little to the discussion – it's been eight years since the Black Mirror episode Nosedive dropped, with a pretty much identical message but infinitely better execution.

Black Mirror Season 3 Nosedive Bryce Dallas Howard 2
Netflix

RTD feels a bit out of touch with this one, and altogether too proud of his literal 'living in a bubble metaphor' in his behind-the-scenes interview. The attempts to use the lingo of the TikTok generation also fall flat on their face, and are about a decade out of date (no cap).

I get what he was going for, but some of the more exaggerated aspects of this concept – like the arrows for walking, and Doctor Who's new arch-nemesis, Doctor Pee – just feel excessive, bordering on patronising. A little nuance would have been nice.


6. DOWN - Lindy's Mobility

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

Following on from my last point, I'd like to come back to Lindy's little walking problem, because frankly, it's so bad it deserves its own Down.

The idea that Lindy is completely incapable of walking in a direction without instructions from her Dot is insanely dumb, and not in a good way. Despite her limbs functioning properly with the bubble up, she loses motor function without it, unable to walk in a straight line.

The depth perception issue with the table is perhaps understandable, but not being able to step backwards from a literal monster, or walking straight into a lamp post twice in a row? It's just a bit silly, really. I sympathised with the Doctor's immense frustration here – though he's one to talk considering the last two episodes have been caused by him not looking where he's going and stepping on something extremely dangerous. Even Ruby managed to step on a butterfly – seriously, this is the weirdest running theme ever.

What really makes this fall flat as a concept though is RTD realising that the episode is going to get really old really quick if we have to watch Lindy stagger into walls for the rest of it, so he just decides to abandon the idea halfway through. Lindy is cured the moment she meets Ricky, gleefully jogging around the city, taking a flight of stairs at speed, and even managing to climb flawlessly down a ladder at the end. It's a Christmas miracle.


5. UP - Ricky September

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Ricky September
BBC Studios

After spending 25 minutes following Lindy, it's a massive relief when we're finally introduced to the infinitely more pleasant Ricky September, played by the charming Tom Rhys Harries.

I was fully expecting Ricky, the apex influencer at the top of the social chain, to be the worst of them all, but the episode turns this assumption on its head by depicting the only character in this city that has a healthy relationship with social media.

Ricky is instantly shown to be more grounded and capable due to switching off his Dot and taking the time to educate himself. No points for subtlety there, but RTD has a point. He's also the only character not out for himself, attempting to save Lindy (wouldn't bother mate), and also showing remorse over the fact that people have died (which really shouldn't be something that makes him an outlier). I was a little slow to trust the character at first, but that reaction to losing his planet sold me.

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Ricky September
BBC Studios

Ricky takes on a very Doctor-esque role in this story, and those scenes where he grabs Lindy's hand and the two run through the streets gave me Nine and Rose vibes, which I suspect was intentional. Sure, he's a little one-dimensional and underdeveloped, but his presence is sorely needed to stop the audience losing faith in humanity.

Ultimately, he has one purpose, and that's to be likeable enough so that what happens later is impactful. And in those ten minutes, he nails it.


4. DOWN - Space Slugs

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble slugs
BBC Studios

The central antagonists (well, sort of) of Dot and Bubble are the 'Man Traps' – creatures so underdeveloped that I only found out that's what they're called when watching the behind-the-scenes interviews.

These sluggish chaps are definitely the most traditional Doctor Who monsters of this era so far (for better or worse), and I appreciate the continued commitment to leaning into practical effects. On the whole though, they're uninteresting, and not particularly threatening. And once again, despite expectations, they weren't out-and-out aliens, simply constructs. That means Fifteen still hasn't come face-to-face with an actual confirmed alien in any of his seven episodes – this has to be a new record.

It turns out that the Man Traps were created by the Dots. I'm not sure how, but more importantly, I'm not sure why. We see the Dots in action towards the end of the episode, and they're far more effective at pest control than their constructs, essentially turning themselves into malicious, sentient bullets. They could wipe out the city in an instant, so why do they resort to creating literal slugs, which aren't famed for their speed or agility, to do the job for them?

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

One possible explanation could be that the inhabitants would clock on to the fact that people were being murdered by their Dots and deactivate them, but this is never suggested in the episode, so RTD doesn't get a pass. While I kind of agree with the motivations of the Dots to initiate this purge, it's not really explained how they gained sentience, or why the homeworld needed to be eliminated too.

We've had better villains. Much better. These come in just above the Bogeyman, and that is not a compliment.


3. DOWN - The Alphabet Twist

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

Around the same time we discover the origins of the Man Traps, we discover the secret to why the citizens of Finetime seem to be dying in a specific order, and oh my, is it an anticlimax.

The Doctor treats this like it's a crazy reveal, really hyping it up with his patented "No... it can't be...", only for the big twist to be that the citizens are being killed in alphabetical order. There's no particular reason behind this system and the overreaction makes the moment almost comical. Had there been more logic to this twist – perhaps if they were a hivemind of sorts that could only focus on one objective at a time – I'd give it a pass, but it seems like more of a throwaway gimmick than anything.

There's also some inconsistency to this logic. If the murders started at the beginning of the alphabet, and the Man Traps ignored those later in the alphabet until the earlier ones were dead, how on earth did a bloke called Brewster Cavendish manage to escape, and why didn't this break the system? Even the Doctor doesn't seem to question it, despite the fact that it makes Cavendish extremely suspicious – especially since he also seems to benefit the most from the purge by proclaiming himself the leader of the survivors, and is the one spearheading this 'new life' for the colonists.

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

I also have questions about why the entire homeworld was murdered first and didn't seem to follow the alphabetical order. Why was Lindy's mother (played by our old friend Susan Twist), already dead by this point, while the Man Traps were somewhere around the 'Paul' mark?

I was so sure the murder order was going to be something to do with follower numbers, and I'm not entirely convinced that more couldn't have been done with that idea instead.


2. UP - Lindy's Betrayal

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Ricky September
BBC Studios

That's all the moaning out of the way, because I'm pleased to say that the final ten minutes of this episode were top notch.

Dot and Bubble pulls a Kill the Moon here, slapping you with some breathtakingly intense character work at the eleventh hour. The final act is a one-two punch of shocking turns, the second of which I'll cover in a moment. For now, let's talk about the moment where Lindy fed Ricky to the metaphorical lions.

By this point, we're all too aware that Lindy is by no means a good person, but it isn't until right at the end that we truly understand how vile she is. Despite idolising Ricky, she is willing to sacrifice him in a heartbeat when she thinks her life might be at risk, despite the fact she isn't even necessarily in a 'my life or his' situation – they've managed to survive the Dot thus far, but she seizes the moment regardless.

Ricky's death is so blunt, and despite the lack of blood, quite graphic for this show through implication alone. But what's more disturbing is how Lindy does this with almost no remorse. She doesn't say sorry, she just climbs down the ladder and waltzes off with a forced, disconcerting smile.

Another instance where the wrong person survives. At this point, Lindy is practically the antagonist, and it only gets worse.


1. UP - A Powerful Ending

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble Ncuti Gatwa Fifteenth Doctor
BBC Studios

While we're still reeling from Lindy's heartless betrayal, Dot and Bubble doubles-down in an absolutely devastating way, leaving us with one of the bleakest endings to an episode we've ever had.

Lindy and her friends have a chance of escape by going with the Doctor, versus essentially becoming colonisers (which, unsurprisingly, they seem to relish the idea of). But, after intentionally avoiding the Doctor at first, she refuses, and the jigsaw pieces start to come together to create a very ugly picture.

I'm not afraid to admit that I, a white man, hadn't clocked what had been going on throughout this episode. I'd been too wrapped up in the story to realise how blatantly different the treatment of the Doctor had been throughout. I was in my ignorant little bubble, after rolling my eyes for 45 minutes about the characters being in one – if this was intentional, chef's kiss and message received.

On a rewatch, the racism aimed at the Doctor is so, so present throughout: the way the Doctor is instantly blocked while Ruby isn't; Lindy's disgust at the two of them being in the same room; her repeatedly alluding that Fifteen is beneath her; and even assuming he's a different person the second time he crops up. Of course, the biggest clue of all was that every single cast member, except Gatwa, was white.

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble
BBC Studios

The line of subtlety was expertly toed. If you weren't looking for it, or aren't used to recognising microaggressions, it could fly right over your head, all while being painfully obvious when you watch it back. I think a lot of fans will be kicking themselves for not spotting this, and it's rare that an episode of this show can prompt a moment of actual self-reflection (in fact, I'd argue that the last time this happened to me was almost 15 years ago with Vincent and the Doctor). Turns out RTD does have some subtlety in him after all.

Lastly, I'd be remiss not to mention Ncuti Gatwa's phenomenal performance in these closing moments. It's his standout moment to date in my opinion, and all the more impressive when you learn it was the first scene of the season he filmed.

Doctor Who Dot and Bubble

The desperation to save these people, despite them being objectively terrible, was pure Doctor. That incredulous laughter that morphed into a scream of pure frustration was deeply upsetting – I felt that in the pit of my stomach. Between Fifteen's outburst, and Ruby trying to keep it together only to quietly break into tears the second the Doctor snaps, the ending here said so much without the need for words. Couple that with Murray Gold's bleak twist on Fifteen's theme, and perhaps I'm too invested, but my lip was quivering. We're seriously lucky to have Gatwa and Gibson in this show.

I think we'll be looking back on this moment for a long time. This was an era-defining scene.


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Alex is a sci-fi and fantasy swot, and is a writer for WhoCulture. He is incapable of watching TV without reciting trivia, and sometimes, when his heart is in the right place, and the stars are too, he’s worth listening to.