Doctor Who: Every NuWho Companion Ranked

We've had many friends come through the NuWho TARDIS, and this list ranks them from worst to best.

Donna Noble Doctor Who
BBC Studios

Doctor Who has been running for over 50 years and in all that time, the Doctor has almost always had someone by their side. The companion, or the friend, the partner, the team, or the Fam, is an important role in Doctor Who. For the show itself, the companion acts as the audience surrogate, and in the context of the show's universe, the companion allows the Doctor to see the universe from a different angle and see what it is like to experience the stars for the first time.

With the recent 'Revolution of the Daleks' sending off Ryan and Graham, and John Bishop's 'Dan' set to join, now would be as good a time as any to look back on all of the Doctor's companions in recent years. This list will only be showcasing companions from the 'NuWho' era (from 2005 to the present) and will only be featuring passengers of the TARDIS who have been around for at least one series - so unfortunately no Captain Jack or River Song, although they would rank high.

10. Ryan Sinclair

Doctor Who Ryan
BBC

There are two major issues with Ryan. The first is that he's just boring. I can't think of a single moment where he seemed to show any real form of emotion throughout his time on the TARDIS, but worst of all, and this is a problem with the entire 'Fam', he feels like a witness to the story, but never a driving force. He just seems to react to what's happening.

The second major issue is his portrayal, and more to blame, the writing's portrayal of his disability. Ryan suffers from dyspraxia, but only when the plot needs him to. You see the show doesn't do a very good job of showing just how bad dyspraxia can be, all we see about it from Ryan is that he can't ride a bike and he has trouble with ladders. This isn't a terrible issue but it's just kind of annoying that, for the most part, it seems like they forget about it unless it's relevant to the plot. Thankfully, they do show that Ryan is still suffering from it even after these adventures, showing you that there isn't an easy fix. But it just always felt convenient from a writing point of view.


9. Clara Oswald

Doctor Who Clara Christmas
BBC

This one might be a bit controversial, but Clara is not a good companion. During her first season with Matt Smith she was fine, she was fun (if a bit bland), and she had an interesting mystery. But then they solved said mystery, and she stuck around. The biggest problem with Clara was that they kept making her more and more special, she also had no defining character traits other than she's basically just the Doctor, until it all accumulated into her effectively becoming immortal and getting her own TARDIS with Me.

Some of the things that make Clara so special include, being there for the Doctor's entire life (including telling him to take the TARDIS that they still have today), undoing the Doctor's most important day, becoming the Doctor's imaginary friend, instilling them with some of the Doctor's defining traits, and and causing the Doctor to shoot someone point blank just to try and save her life!

One major issue I have with Clara comes down to one moment, and that moment is when she told the Doctor to let a bunch of children burn and die so that they wouldn't become orphans. She said this to the Doctor, an orphan, in front of her boyfriend, another orphan. Good.


8. Yasmin Khan

Doctor Who Yaz
BBC

The biggest issue with Yaz as companion is the wasted potential of having a police officer in the TARDIS. It is frustrating how little of that aspect of her character shows up. The worst offender of which is in 'Arachnids in the UK' when someone pointed a gun at her. The only times that we get reminded that Yaz is a police officer is when it's not very important like in 'Kerblam'.

But as said, the biggest problem with Yaz is her unused potential. Out of the 3 companions we've had for the last 2 series, she's very clearly the one who has had the least amount of development. And that's not really her fault, Ryan and Graham had that family connection which lent itself to allow for the 2 of them to develop each other, and they also had a direct connection to the reason they all joined the Doctor in the first place through Grace. But Yaz didn't really have that. Here's hoping that now Ryan and Graham have left, Yaz will have more screen time and more opportunities to develop. lt will be nice to have an all female Team TARDIS- oh, they're introducing another middle-aged white man to the team. Oh well.


7. Bill Potts

Doctor Who Bill
BBC

Sadly, Bill didn't need to be this low on the list. There isn't really anything majorly wrong with Bill as a companion, she had all of the appreciated traits. The problem is that, at best, she was just fine, and at worst, she was forgettable. I genuinely can't name anything significant about Bill other than the fact that she was gay, and that's only because they couldn't help but bring it up in each episode, even when it felt out of place.

Bill's ending as a companion also felt vague and ill defined as to what actually happened to her. It was almost backseated to the return of John Simm's Master in the Series 10 finale. I enjoyed her return for 'Twice Upon a Time', but it just raised further questions about what happened to her.


6. Graham O'Brien

Doctor Who Graham
BBC

The worst thing about Graham as a companion is the same problem with the rest of the most recent companions, and that is that there were too many of them, which meant that none got the development or the screen time that they deserved or needed. Graham was the kindest member of the 'Fam', and while he could be hesitant to the ongoing adventure, he wasn't a coward. While you may not have liked his jokes, he was arguably the best part of Team TARDIS these past few series, and that includes The Doctor.

While Graham, like with the other companions of the 'Fam', didn't get a lot of character development, he didn't need that much to begin with. Right from the start, Graham was a kind person, going out of his way to try and make an effort to connect with Ryan, and be supportive for him and the rest of the group. The one major flaw with him as a character, from a growth point of view, was that he wasn't brave, but that was quickly remedied in subsequent episodes.


5. Rory Williams

Doctor Who Rory Cyber-ships explosion A Good Man Goes To War
BBC

Rory started off as Amy's companion of sorts, but he very quickly rose above his station. Rory was humble, loyal, and had a sarcastic wit that lent itself to brilliant comedic moments. The fact that Rory had a way of being amazed at what's going on, but not to be infatuated with the idea of the Doctor was enjoyable and unique. He wasn't afraid to call the Doctor out, and while he trusted them with his life, he often didn't rely on the Doctor, such as in 'God Complex'.

While he could often fall into the jealous boyfriend archetype, he brought a different perspective to the TARDIS team, and he very quickly became a strong hero willing to risk his life to save people. Another nice aspect is that, unlike with Yaz, Rory's nursing background does come into play throughout the episodes. If in no other way than his motivation to help people everyone, even sometimes the villain of the episode.


4. Amy Pond

Doctor Who Amy Pond Karen Gillan
BBC

Amy was a great companion. She was adventurous and reckless to a fun degree, bringing a sort of 'spunk' and/or 'attitude' to the series. Being the first companion for a new Doctor and a new head writer, she held an important position in the fandom. While she might not have been great in her early episodes, she became one of the better companions as the series went on. Once her boyfriend-turned-husband, Rory, was introduced as a companion, Amy developed a new aspect of her character that greatly enhanced her adventures.

Unfortunately, the reason why Amy is not one of the better companions is because without Rory she suffers the same problem that Bill does, which is she's somewhat not very unique, at least after her first series. Initially she had an interesting mystery surrounding her that played into the overall plot, but after Rory boards the TARDIS, we don't get a whole lot of her alone. I think the main take away is that Amy and Rory together are great, almost perfect, but alone, they both seem lacking in any sort of spark.


3. Donna Noble

Doctor Who Donna Noble Partners In Crime
BBC Studios

While Donna wasn't all that likable in her debut episode, 'The Runaway Bride', you quickly grow to really enjoy her and her interactions with the Doctor in her subsequent series. She's definitely a companion that you learn to appreciate once you go back to her episodes. And because they came off as really good friends as opposed to having a romantic relationship like with other companions, she truly felt unique and enjoyable. Her quick wit bounced off well with Tennant's Doctor.

Unfortunately, she was the companion during a middling season. While Series 4 has some amazing episodes, 'Silence in the Library' and 'The Unicorn and The Wasp', to name a few, it also has some of terrible episodes such as 'Turn Left' and 'The Planet of the Ood'. Another unfortunate aspect of her character is her ending, which does show more why she was a good companion, in that she doesn't remember what happened, and that really is one of the most unfortunate endings for a companion of the Doctor.

However, regarding her ending, it would be remiss if I didn't mention the "Doctor-Donna", which suffers from the problem that Clara does, in that she becomes incredibly special without any real reasoning behind it.


2. Rose Tyler

Doctor Who Rose Tyler
BBC

Rose had a very important job in being the first companion of this new era, and she was thankfully excellent. Rose had everything you need in a companion. She was kind, intuitive, and brave. As the first companion for a lot of fans today, Rose had a lot to accomplish, both being a the audience's perspective of the world and everything she was seeing, while also being an interesting character in her own right, unlike some other surrogate characters. And, you could argue that she was a perfect companion- for the first series.

Possibly one of the only problems with Rose was the love plot that the show seemed to want to push between her and the 10th Doctor. And a lot of the times it fell flat, while Rose and 10 had great chemistry as Doctor and companion, the Doctor shouldn't have a love interest with a companion. It works with River because she knows all of the Doctors and she can be them throughout their life, but with Rose it was only with 10 and also, like the Doctor says, she can spend the rest of her life with them, but they can't spend the rest of their life with her. This romance plot also hinders future stories such as most of the relationship between the Doctor and Martha, and also ruins Rose's ending.

The separation of the Doctor and Rose was heart-breaking, but the fact that Rose settles for a pseudo-clone of the Doctor makes it worse, she doesn't move on and instead spends her life with someone who ultimately isn't the person she loves but is just close enough.


1. Martha Jones

Doctor Who Martha Jones 42
BBC Studios

Smart, brave, and kind, all traits you would want in a companion. But more importantly, she felt independent. Martha is effectively the opposite of Clara. While Clara will help save the day because she's special or because of convenience sake, Martha saves the day because of what she actively did in the story. She was also part of one of the best seasons of Doctor Who, and she stuck by the Doctor through all of the rigmarole that they put her through. She endured The Doctor becoming John Smith in 1913, even though that would not have been a great time for her to be stuck in, but also walking across the face of the Earth just to inspire people and help them. She's also one of the few companions to leave voluntarily, which is big bonus to her character.

Martha's biggest issue is Rose. Martha was effectively a rebound companion, she fancied the Doctor but they were still hung up on Rose. And while this pining after someone who wouldn't reciprocate the same feelings does hinder her character, it never felt like it was taking away from the story. They did amend it by having her move on with her life and becoming a doctor, which is also a great aspect of her character, in that she is usually one of the first to respond and jump into action when someone needs help. She also became an important player in U.N.I.T., and then doing her own independent work keeping the planet safe.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

John Hinch hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.