Doctor Who: Looking Back At The Multi-Doctor Stories

doctor-who-time-crash-0 The recent Royal Visit to the Doctor Who studios seems to have confirmed that John Hurt is indeed one of the Doctors and that the 50th Anniversary will be The Three Doctors Mark Two with the Hurt Doctor meeting the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors. So with that confirmation (Or it may be subtle misdirection. You never know with Steven Moffat at the helm), we continue the monthly countdown to Doctor Who€™s 50th Anniversary by looking back at that time-honoured Doctor Who tradition: the Multi-Doctor story...

1. The Three Doctors (1973)

three doctors We€™ll start with where it all began: 1973 and Doctor Who€™s tenth anniversary. The decision was made to unite the First, Second, and Third Doctors in a four-part story that saw them team up to take on Omega, a renegade Time Lord inhabiting a universe made of anti-matter. However, William Hartnell€™s failing health led to a substantial rewrite that reduced the First Doctor€™s role to a point where it was manageable for Hartnell, throwing more focus on the Second and Third Doctors. The relationship between the Second and Third Doctors turned out to be the focal point of the story with their clashing personalities leading to some great dialogue and situations, including the Second Doctor€™s now famous line about not liking the way the Third Doctor redecorated the Tardis, as well as the general timey-wimey nature of the Doctors meeting each other being an excellent story element in itself. Despite the dodgy special effects (even for 70s Doctor Who), The Three Doctors is a story that has stood the test of time and is still a great watch forty years later. It€™s also the story that gave birth to celebrating Doctor Who€™s milestones in this way. A tradition that is still being carried on four decades later.

2. The Five Doctors (1983)

Doctor Who€™s twentieth anniversary really set the standard for celebrating the programme€™s history with exhibitions, every story of Season 20 featuring a returning enemy, and The Five Doctors: a 90 minute special that saw the Doctors being taken out of time and deposited in the Death Zone (an abandoned gladiatorial arena on Gallifrey) to play the Game Of Rassilon and discover his secret of immortality. A more accurate title for this special would be €œThe Three And A Half Doctors€ since Tom Baker refused to take part (a decision he now regrets) and, because William Hartnell had passed away in 1975, the role of the First Doctor was played by Richard Hurndall, who was cast for his resemblance to Hartnell. But despite that, it€™s still a cracking story. The Five Doctors does exactly what it€™s supposed to. It gathers together a large number of elements from Doctor Who€™s past and present, and uses them to tell a large scale story. As well as four Doctors; we get the Master, Daleks (Well, a Dalek), Cybermen, a Yeti, and a companion for each of the past Doctors with three more appearing as illusions. The Doctors are mainly operating solo with their respective companions as they attempt to reach the Tomb Of Rassilon at the centre of the Death Zone but once they join together for the climax, it really hits the mark since, once again, we see them working together and overcoming evil. On top of that, the final moment where the Doctor goes on the run from the Time Lords and observes €œThat€™s how it all began€ is the perfect way to not only end the story, but also to start the next step of Doctor Who€™s life.

3. The Two Doctors (1985)

twodoctorsomega The last full fledged Multi-Doctor story so far, The Two Doctors sadly doesn€™t live up to the height of its predecessors. In a continuity breaking plot, the Second Doctor and Jamie are dispatched by the Time Lords to a space station in order to stop the time travel experiments taking place there. The Second Doctor is then put to death, disrupting his timeline and causing the Sixth Doctor and Peri to investigate after feeling the disruption. Add Sontarans and a brutal alien chef named Shockeye who wants to eat Jamie and Peri to that and you€™ve got just a bit too much going on for three 45 minute episodes. The whole thing feels too packed with story elements, a bit disjointed, and we don€™t really get a lot of Multi-Doctor action. Especially since the Second Doctor spends a lot of time captured by the story€™s villains. It also doesn€™t have the celebratory spirit of the other Multi-Doctor adventures. It€™s a solid enough story but it just lacks the warmth and spark of Multi-Doctor story, which is probably because it wasn€™t written as a celebration like the other Multi-Doctor stories and was always going to be just another Doctor Who story. Enjoyable enough, but not on the same level as its predecessors.

4. Dimensions In Time (1993)

Doctor Who Dimensions In Time This one€™s just... weird. And not Doctor Who weird, more €œWhat were they thinking€ weird. A short Children In Need special produced in 3D, Dimensions In Time reunited all of the surviving Doctors along with a huge number of companions and monsters. In an Eastenders crossover. No, stop giggling. It€™s real. The story saw the Third, Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh Doctors (with the Fourth Doctor having a more minor role similar to the First Doctor's in The Three Doctors) being trapped in Walford (the setting of Eastenders) in a twenty year time loop by renegade Time Lady the Rani. The Doctors meet up with various companions and Eastenders characters, and work together to break the Rani€™s time loop and escape Walford. Something I'm surprised the Eastenders characters weren't attempting as well It€™s a bizarre and frenetic mess of a story but it€™s campy fun in a €œSo bad it€™s good" sort of way and managed to be biggest ever gathering of Doctors so at least that€™s something. It€™s just a shame that it crossed over with Eastenders (which is pretty much Doctor Who's antithesis) and that the Doctors are never seen properly working together like in the other Multi-Doctor stories.

5. Time Crash (2007)

time crash doctor who It may have only been eight minutes long but Time Crash was the episode that came closest to capturing the spirit of the Multi-Doctor story since The Three Doctors in that its primary focus is putting different Doctors together and having them interact with each other. Shortly after the end of Last Of The Time Lords, the Tenth Doctor has just rebuilt his Tardis and has the shields down, causing it to crash into the Fifth Doctor€™s Tardis. And from there on in, it€™s just the Fifth and Tenth Doctors playing off each other and taking a moment to stop the destruction of a portion of time and space exactly the size of Belgium. Time Crash is full of brilliant little nods to past including mentions of the Fifth Doctor's companions Nyssa and Tegan, and the Doctor once again taking exception to how his future self has redecorated the Tardis. And another interesting dimension is that Peter Davison was the Doctor that David Tennant grew up with and was inspired by. So the Tenth Doctor€™s €œYou were my Doctor€ speech towards the end is not only the Tenth Doctor admiring the Fifth Doctor but Tennant admiring Davison as well. It€™s small scale but the sentiment of it is spot on. It€™s a love letter to days gone by that links both Classic Who and Nu Who in an incredibly strong way. Which is perfectly embodied through a simple exchange between the Doctors:
Fifth Doctor: To days to come. Tenth Doctor: All my love to long ago.
Those two lines sum up the whole spirit of the Multi-Doctor story. And since both Time Crash and the 50th Anniversary were written by Steven Moffat, it's a relatively safe bet that the 50th Anniversary will continue that spirit. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4I76p1cZbq4 What's your favourite Multi-Doctor story? Leave a comment...

Contributor
Contributor

JG Moore is a writer and filmmaker from the south of England. He also works as an editor and VFX artist, and has a BA in Media Production from the University Of Winchester.