Doctor Who Retrospective Review - "The Unquiet Dead"
Welcome to Episode 3 of my Retrospective Review series. This is one of my favorites of the first season and so it will be a little lighter on the hard-hitting psychological analysis and a little heavier on the "awwwwwwwwws." Also be prepared for my pet theory on a certain type of apocalypse. Just to be fun, we're going to be going a little out of order from the last two editions. Where We Are
Now that Rose has seen the end of the world and pretty close to the end of time itself, the Doctor takes her to a slightly more familiar stomping ground. 1860, he claims. 1869, as it turns out, but when you've just come from the year 5 Billion, what are nine years? I have a three-episode rule for watching TV shows and, as I probably explained in an article you read before, my first three Doctor Who episodes were not "Rose," "The End of the World" and "The Unquiet Dead." They were "Blink," "The Empty Child" and "The Doctor Dances." Either way, the reason that I mention my three-episode rule is my reason for imposing that rule. When I was a child, my mother made all sorts of wonderful foods. She knew how to make a killer meatloaf, grill salmon, flip some Swedish pancakes for my birthday, etc. On the other hand, she insisted on making side dishes that I loathed. I still can't stand asparagus or broccoli and I hate beets. Her rule was that I could get out of eating the side dish as long as I gave it an honest try. That 'try' consisted of three heaping spoonfuls or forkfuls of whatever I didn't want to eat. If I put up with those three bites and didn't like it, there were no hard feelings. I apply that rule to TV shows. It's why I've never gotten into Battlestar Galactica or Commander in Chief. I decided after watching three episodes that I just really didn't need to see where the rest of the series went. Next up is My Little Pony. Since we are on the third episode of the new series, this would have been the make-it-or-break-it episode. Let's see how it measures up.What The Dickens
I absolutely love the Doctor Who episodes that involve historical fiction. Technically, if you consider time travel to be valid, you can consider all of it to be historical fiction, but that's not the point. I'm a history nut and I love episodes like "The Unicorn and the Wasp" and "The Fires of Pompeii" as a result. This is our first brush with greatness in the New Who. The actor chosen for Charles Dickens is delightful for a few reasons, but my reason for liking him is that he never seems to break character. I remember going to a production of A Comedy of Errors when I was fourteen and the actors completely flubbed a fight scene, but stayed in-character until they had their bearings back. Every time this actor opens his mouth, I can hear the man who narrates Dickens' books. The writing is wonderful and he carries it off very well. What is best about this portrayal is that Dickens has a little bit of Scrooge in him. He does respond fairly graciously to everyone from the theater workers to the Doctor himself, but he seems a little world-weary. At the end of his Christmas adventure, he vows to make amends with his estranged family and work out the ending to The Mystery of Edwin Drood. You can almost hear him promising to "keep Christmas in heart" and we are not surprised when he pops up with a "God bless us, every one!" We don't see Charles again until Series Six when he's interviewed on telly about his sequel, but this is a great vignette about one of literature's greatest authors.
The Zombies
So here come my opinions on the Zombie Apocalypse. I've read World War Z and Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, but the only zombie books I love are the ones in Mira Grant's Newsflesh series. I'm not into zombies very much and according to a co-worker who greets me with "How are you this zombie-free morning" every day, I'm in the minority. I first realized where I stood on the effectiveness of the zombie mythos when I was 20. I was in BYU's University Chorale and we sang an unusual Easter song. It was in Creole and one part of the lyrics went like this: "Christ is risen, hallelujah, He's not a zombie, hallelujah." Um...what? Yeah, my first reaction to a man miraculously rising from the dead is to make sure he's not a zombie and I'm sure that the Jews of Nazareth felt the same way. Since this is a Christmas-based episode, I think I can get away with a little religious commentary here. It says in the Bible that "the trumpet shall sound and the dead shall be raised incorruptible." I think that the modern world is not so much afraid of going to hell as they are afraid that when we die, there is no heaven or hell. There is resurrection, but it is not "incorruptible" as the faithful believe. It's a violation of everything that life after death is supposed to entail. There's also the matter of us being able to choose between good and evil ourselves. We all have the power of choice...until the Zombie Apocalypse. So not only does God ditch us when we're promised that eternal life is all that, but he makes sure we can't do anything about it. I'm going to leave this conversation now before I start quoting more of the Bible. So yeah, that's why I figure people fear the zombie mythology. Or at least why the Christians of the world have reason to fear it. And since this is a Christmas episode, we'll go with that being a solid rationale. Plus the white walkers in this episode are kind of creepy.
Rose
I love Rose in this episode. The result of her first two documented adventures with the Doctor is that she has hit her stride with audacity. She takes more initiative, participates more in the adventure and finally has the kind of snarky working relationship with the Doctor that is practically a mandatory part of the companion experience. In this episode, we start to see what I consider to be an integral part of Rose's character. We had a hint of it in the previous episode, when she was talking to our blue plumber. I believe that Rose, if she ever got out of her shopgirl persona, would have a wide range of careers open to her. She is, by her own confession, not the sharpest of people, but she is intuitive and empathetic. If Rose were famous, she might make a good UN Goodwill Ambassador. She's someone who does not have many medical skills or economic policies, but she would work very well as an advocate. She looks at an event and sees the people instead of the situation. I love that she is the one to stand up for Gwyneth and takes a stand for the rights of the dead. While I find it unlikely that Rose would be an ambassador, I could very easily picture her as a social worker or a school counselor. This is one of the reasons that I'm so looking forward to hearing what she's been up to in her parallel universe. Last time we checked, she'd spent a lot of time trying to break down the barrier to the universe where the Doctor can visit, but once that's resolved, I want to know what she's gotten up to.
The Doctor
Some of my favorite things involve how we recognize the Doctor as different incarnations of himself. In "The Eleventh Hour," the first episode of Series 5, the Doctor rants, "20 minutes to save the world and I've got a POST OFFICE. And it's SHUT!" That is done essentially in the same tone as one of my favorite lines from this episode: "I saw the Fall of Troy! World War Five! I pushed boxes at the Boston Tea Party! Now I'm gonna die in a dungeon...in Cardiff!" Yes, Doctor, you do bravery marvelously. You do grandstanding marvelously. We can't blame you for wanting to go out in a blaze of glory. Or at least not in Cardiff. The Doctor in this episode makes a hilarious fanboy, but an awful sympathizer. When Rose balks at his willingness to provide hosts for the Gelth, he tells her to "get used to it or go home." He can't compliment his lovely companion because it's "considering...that you're a human." The man even compels poor Chuck Dickens to exclaim, "Now you tell me that the real world is a realm of spectres and jack-o'-lanterns. In which case, have I wasted my brief span here, Doctor? Has it all been for nothing?" I had to wonder at this point if we'd ever run into a LIKABLE version of the 9th Doctor. Certainly, he's a hilarious man and sage in unexpected ways, but I feel like quoting the future companion Donna Noble and asking him, "This friend of yours, just before she left, did she punch you in the face?" I do like that he tries to help the Gelth out of compassion and pity, but Nine scrapes out my respect by giving Dickens a reason to live in the end.
Shadows Of The Future In the previous episode, we heard of the Bad Wolf Corporation. Gwyneth, the seer, realizes that Rose has seen the "big Bad Wolf." I'm assuming that most people reading this article will have known what "Bad Wolf" is, but if there is someone who doesn't, let's just point at it and say "KEEP TRACK OF THAT!" I will say that it's such an important thing to note this early that as an April Fool's Day prank two years ago, my friends and I wrote "Bad Wolf" on index cards in dozens of languages and put them on bulletin boards across our city. We put it in plastic cups on the chain-link fence over University Parkway. I was forewarned by my Whovian friends that I would hear things in these episodes that would only make sense at the end of the season. I look forward to looking at the context of these things.
Best Bits: Rose: Aren't you going to change? The Doctor: I changed my jumper. Come on! Charles Dickens: This is precisely the sort of cheap mummery I strive to unmask. Séances? Nothing but luminous tambourines and a squeeze box concealed between the knees. This girl knows nothing! The Doctor: Now, don't antagonize her. I love a happy medium! Rose: I can't believe you just said that. The Doctor: I saw the Fall of Troy! World War Five! I pushed boxes at the Boston Tea Party! Now I'm gonna die in a dungeon... in Cardiff! Until next time, good night and God bless us, every one!