Doctor Who: Space Babies Review - 7 Ups & 3 Downs
Talking babies, snot monsters, and politics – Doctor Who is BACK, (space) baby!
It's been almost five months since Ruby Sunday took her first steps inside the TARDIS, and now, finally, we get to see what happens next.
It's very clear that we were supposed to get Space Babies in January, given the strong thematic links with The Church on Ruby Road and an ending that takes us back to Christmas Eve. Russell T Davies said as much in his DWM column, stating that the intricacies of the VFX work delayed his desired January launch of Doctor Who Season 40/Series 14/Season 1 (delete as applicable).
For good or ill, Space Babies feels like a throwback to the series openers of the RTD1 era – a paper thin premise that allows plenty of time for the Doctor and their new companion to find their feet.
And yet, Space Babies is bolder and madder than a New Earth or a Partners in Crime. A Doctor Who story that references both Ray Bradbury's butterfly effect and Raymond Briggs' Fungus the Bogeyman, while also sneaking in some astute political commentary.
While it won't be to everyone's tastes, Space Babies is a strong indicator that while RTD may be back in the showrunner's chair, his Doctor Who feels different this time.
10. DOWN - The Info Dump
The 1996 Paul McGann movie was heavily criticised for being bogged down in exposition, but it's got nothing on Ncuti Gatwa's sprawling monologue about being the last of the Time Lords.
As the Doctor rattles off exposition about the Rani, the Timeless Child, the Master's Time Lord genocide, and Gallifrey, it feels like the uninitiated viewers at home should have a notepad and pen.
It's even stranger when you take into account that the Doctor will be repeating much of the same information to Poppy in a scene that makes far more sense in the context of the episode.
As a result of the Doctor reading out his Wikipedia page, we lose Ruby's introduction to the TARDIS under a deluge of clunky callbacks. She can't ask daft questions about how the TARDIS works because she's too busy reeling from the Doctor sharing every painful detail about his lives so far.
The show's called Doctor Who, not Doctor Too Much Information!
9. UP - The Butterfly Effect
The butterfly effect scene feels like an itch RTD has wanted to scratch since it was referenced in The Shakespeare Code. Now, with his influx of Mickey Mouse money, RTD can go wild, depicting Ruby Sunday turning into a... reptile dressed as a fish?
Let's not get into the ins and outs of how a trampled butterfly translates into, presumably, the dinosaurs and the Silurians surviving a crashing Adric. It's a fun image, that quickly gets across how fragile the web of time is.
To turn Ruby back into a human and save the make-up budget for the rest of the season, the Doctor gives the butterfly mouth to mouth, resurrecting the insect and preserving the timeline.
It's a gleefully stupid scene that, combined with the mavity gag, suggests new Doctor Who is more willing to show the fluid nature of time.
8. DOWN - The End Of The World (Reprise)
As bold and brassy as the RTD2 era is shaping up to be, there's a nagging feeling that Russell T Davies only has a finite number of fresh ideas.
Case in point: the scene where the Doctor and Ruby look out into space and discuss mankind making it out among the stars, and the loss of Gallifrey.
It's as if Russell just copied and pasted the same scene from The End of the World, deleted "ROSE" and replaced it with "RUBY". In fact, he wouldn't even need to delete the R.
It's the exact same scene, and the only thing that's changed is the mobile phone technology, as the Doctor sonics Ruby's smartphone so she can phone her Mum back in 2024.
It's not even directed in a visually dynamic way, meaning that as well as sounding like the same, it also looks like a shot-for-shot remake of the earlier scene.
7. UP - Eric
Of all the Space Babies, Eric is the best one. His permanent look of consternation is utterly adorable, as is his frequent affirmations of love for Ruby.
The Doctor's speech to Captain Poppy is very sweet, but the connection between Ruby and Eric is the closest that Space Babies gets to having an emotional core. Which is why the scene where he seemingly gets offed by the Bogeyman works far better than it had any right to.
If there's an image that communicates the sheer madness of Doctor Who, it's surely Eric, in his motorised buggy, wooden sword in hand, trundling off to fight a monster. It shouldn't have worked, but somehow it did, and little Mason McCumskey's slightly frightened face really sold the horror of the moment.
And let's be real, how many of us briefly thought that Russell had just killed a Space Baby on primetime BBC1? While it was an obvious fakeout, the harshness of the cut between the Bogeyman and the Doctor and Ruby was seriously disconcerting.
6. UP - The Doctor Scaring The Space Babies
It's insane to say this about a Doctor Who story that's all about farts and bogies, but there's some deeper themes at play here. We'll get to Space Babies' political statement in a moment, but this is also a story about the importance of being scared.
Throughout the classic era, Doctor Who was criticised for being too horrific for a young audience by the puritanical Mary Whitehouse and others of her ilk. Space Babies rejects this, by delighting in terrifying its intergalactic infants.
The scene where the Doctor joyously shows the Space Babies footage of the Bogeyman and delights in their screaming is a pretty obvious reflection of Doctor Who itself.
When it's later revealed that the Bogeyman was created to scare the Space Babies it makes perfect sense. For all of human history, parents have created scary monsters to keep their children in line, so it stands to reason that an intergalactic baby farm would do the same thing for its tiny crew.
It's a fun idea that helps to lift Space Babies above its baser instincts.
5. UP - Politics!
Thanks to the Disney+ deal, Doctor Who can now reach more American viewers than ever before. Which is why it's a ballsy move for Russell T Davies to use the season opener to comment on the US Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade in 2022.
This landmark decision led to a swathe of abortion bans and restrictions introduced in states across America, a regressive move that set back women's rights by decades.
In Space Babies, the Doctor and Ruby are given some backstory on the baby farms, courtesy of Jocelyn, the only adult who stayed on the space station. After first mandating the use of baby farms, the government on Pacifico Del Rio pulled the funding and refused to provide support for the babies after they were born.
It's a classic sci-fi allegory for how those states that ban abortion will also refuse to provide any sort of social care for the babies after they're born.
It's hardly subtle, but it needed saying, and makes you wonder what else RTD will be taking aim at during his new era.
4. UP - The Bogeyman
If I had a pound for every Doctor Who monster that was made out of bogies, I'd have two pounds, but it's weird that it happened twice. The biological origins of the Bogeyman may draw unfavourable comparisons with the Sandmen from Sleep No More, but it looks great.
The scene where it's about to be ejected from an airlock is stomach churning to look at, as fragments of dried up snot get broken off and flung out into space. The horror of the Bogeyman is aided by the fact it's largely shot in low light, to emphasize the scariness, and cover up its snotty secret.
The design of the Bogeyman is one of the highlights of Space Babies, providing the slight script with a proper scary monster. It looks utterly disgusting, dripping with glistening slime and bearing a set of terrifying teeth.
Whether it's chasing the Doctor and Ruby down a hallway or menacing little Eric, the Bogeyman is a horrific-looking thing that lives long in the memory after the credits roll.
3. DOWN - The Big Space Arse
It's been 19 years since Aliens of London/World War Three, and Russell T Davies still finds farts as funny as ever. You can imagine him hooting with laughter as he writes the directions of a giant space arse guffing its way through the stars.
However, in an episode that also features a monster made of bogies and a companion covered in snot, the giant guffing space arse just comes across as embarrassing.
Without wanting to get all serious and scientific about a space arse, methane can be used as a rocket propellant. So yes, a space ship powered by farts, or in this case rotten nappies is a funny idea.
The problem is that RTD flogs the joke to death by showing the space station's globes parting to eject a big cloud of methane. Sure, it's probably really funny to a generation of kids that watch Captain Underpants and Thunderpants.
However, shouldn't Doctor Who's big bold Disney+ era be skewing more toward a young adult audience? Particularly with Sex Education's Ncuti Gatwa as the lead?
Still, at least they showed some restraint by not playing a huge comedy fart sound when the giant space arse ejected its nappy gas.
2. UP - The Snow Was A Warning
The ending of Space Babies is a corker, and proves that Russell T Davies has been copying Steven Moffat's homework.
But let's go back a bit first, to the flashback to The Church on Ruby Road, where the Doctor's memory of Ruby's mother changes to show her pointing a warning finger at him. What this means for Ruby's arc is not yet clear, but it does inspire the Doctor to set some ground rules.
Ground rules that he'll probably disregard later in the series.
While he's banned Ruby from travelling back in time to meet her mother, the Doctor's curiosity gets the better of him, as he runs a TARDIS scan on his new companion. It felt like a worrying callback to when the Eleventh Doctor began investigating whether Amy had been replaced by her flesh avatar in Series 6.
Ruby's memories and the TARDIS scan had the odd effect of causing it to snow in both the baby farm and the console room. The snow, surmises the Doctor, is a warning not to track down Ruby's mother.
The image of snow falling inside the TARDIS console room was a haunting image to end the episode on, and a portentous tease of things to come.
1. UP - Ncuti Gatwa
Sure, he's had an episode and a half to get comfortable, but Ncuti Gatwa hits the ground running as the Doctor and proves why he was such inspired casting.
His easy chemistry with Millie Gibson makes the Doctor and Ruby an instantly likable TARDIS team. It's a joy to spend time with these two friends as they laugh and joke through time and space.
Ncuti Gatwa's Doctor sparkles onscreen, reeling off sci-fi nonsense with supreme confidence one minute, then roaring with laughter in the very next.
In fact, it's mostly down to Ncuti Gatwa that Space Babies works at all.
Let's face facts, Space Babies is ludicrous. It's a story about talking babies, farting space arses, and a giant snot monster. And yet, Ncuti Gatwa sells the hell out of it, never sending up the most outrageous excesses of RTD's script, but instead imbuing it with wit and wonder.
The Doctor risking his life to save a giant snot monster should be the stupidest, most absurd thing in the world, and yet in the hands of Gatwa, you find yourself caring about the emotional nuance of bogies.
It's going to be utterly thrilling to see where Ncuti Gatwa takes his Doctor over the next seven weeks.