Doctor Who: The 10 Weirdest Moments

Masterdance It should be noted going into this question- pretty much the entirety of Doctor Who is at the deep end of the weird pool, if you compare it to just about anything else on television. And there's a simple reason for that: That's what it was specifically designed to do. As different as the Verity Lambert era is from the Innes Lloyd, John Nathan Turner, or Russell T. Davies eras, the one thing that they all have in common is that they fundamentally exist to show you unusual places, things, and people (who are also sometimes things.) So you could randomly select 10 30 second clips from any point in Doctor Who's history and have a reasonable assumption that they are going to be fairly bat-s**t crazy compared to, let's say, Hot in Cleveland. (although sometimes Betty White surprises you...) What I'm getting at here is that for a moment to be considered a high water mark of strange in contrast to other Doctor Who... well, we've pretty comprehensively left Kansas by that point. The rules remain the same - We're considering only Nu-Who here (which sadly means we're unable to mention the Zarbi... except that I just did.) And while 'Weird' is less subjective than 'Funny' (and arguably more-so than 'Romantic') these are still my personal choices for most WTF-ness. You may be more well adjusted to these sorts of things than I am. In any case, your choices may vary and please feel free to add them in the comment section. Are you sitting comfortably? Then we'll begin.

10. That's Not Sanitary, Moxx Of Balhoun

moxx-of-balhoon Time has dulled the surprise factor of "The End of the World", since we've revisited the time period a few times and become BFFs with The Face of Boe. However, try to think back to 2005 (2007 if you're in America and were strictly ethical about international piracy statutes) and remember what it felt like at the time. This was, if you recall, only the second episode to be made since the TV movie 9 years earlier (which plainly didn't count), so we were in new territory. It's arguably the first proper story of the new series, as "Rose" really exists more as an extended sizzle reel for the new series comfortably masquerading as a remake of "Spearhead from Space" (Look at all the things you'll see this season! Billie Piper! Aliens! Wacky CGI Dustbins!) "Rose" existed to help viewers settle in to the new series, it couldn't risk being too alienating (no pun intended). Which makes Russell T. Davies decision to go for broke with the weird on "The End of the World" curiously brave and commendable. To sum it up - Rose gets taken to the future, told that the Earth is about to explode forever, meets a butt-load of aliens, and watches the Doctor seem to seriously consider having sex with a tree. Then the last human comes in and turns out to be a bitchy trampoline with a catchphrase and some serious self image issues. Then, to cap it off, the formal greetings involve a tiny blue terrier/lawyer on a floating throw pillow who spits in your face by way of saying hello and everyone just sort of rolls with it. Now that's a party.

9. The Daleks Need Pig Slaves Why Now?

DalekPigMeninElevator

First, can we all agree to call the episode "Daleks Take Manhattan" instead of "Daleks in Manhattan". It puts them more pleasingly in the line of not just the Angels, but also Jason and the Muppets. So. Mr. Diagoras has a mysterious set of new 'Masters' that are controlling the building of the Empire State Building. You know, the way that mysterious Masters do. He summons these mysterious 'Masters' from the basement to deal with an employee relations problem, and we're treated to an extended, tension-raising shot of the elevator indicator sign slowly moving our way. At least is would be a tension-raising shot, were the episode not entitled "Daleks in Manhattan" which gives the game away just a little bit. However, this is certainly not our first rodeo for this exact thing. There's a fifty year old tradition of spending the first episode building up a mysterious adversary, only to reveal in the last shot of the first episode that it's - gasp - a Dalek! Just as had been advertised for months and clearly mentioned in the title. (See also: Daleks, Planet of the; Death to the; Power of the; Evil of the; and Genesis of;) So you might forgive the viewership for being less than blown over with shock when the elevator doors opened and - gasp - there were Daleks! And... um... I'm sorry, are those anthropomorphic pigs... behind the Daleks there...? Which is probably why the pigs were there to be fair. They knew we were expecting Daleks, but no one expects Dalek Pig men! And obviously the pig men weren't just there for a surprise. They were vital to the Daleks' plan for... um... The Daleks needed them to... uh... Later, they were crucial for... Hmm. Well, sod all, actually. They do a little dramatic menacing, a bit of fetch and carry and there's a brief mention of them being trained to tear people apart with their fangs, not that we ever see it. Personally I think they're just there entirely for that interior elevator shot of the group of them staring up at the progress indicator, which just proves that pig men hate pointless small talk as much as anybody. They may also have been a deliberate attempt to recreate the joy of...

8. The Exciting Adventures Of Space Pig!

SpacePig

I personally am a huge fan of the Adherents of the Repeated Meme, should anyone ask, but if you were to ask the bulk of fandom who the best monster of season one (series one for you Euro-types) was, there's a pretty good chance that they're going to say 'Space Pig' (I know. Not the Slitheen. Shocking.) The year was 2005, and the story was "Aliens of London". (Someone please begin playing Warren Zevon at this time.) As part of the Slitheen's sinister plan*, they had to convince the world that we were under threat of alien attack. So they fake up an alien, chuck it at Big Ben and bingo - the World is on red alert. In order to fake up the 'Alien', they take a regular pig, rewire his brain a bit to be all alien-y, teach him to walk on his hind legs and put him in a space suit. The result was undeniable adorable. I'm not sure if it was a deliberate homage to the Muppets' old Pigs in Space bit, but when he starts squealing while he briskly jogs down the hallway in his little outfit, I defy you to not think 'awwwwwww' to yourself. Which makes it a particularly effective sequence when Space Pig is brutally gunned down by the military a moment later. One heartbreaking speech from The Doctor about how scared he must have been and you have a truly touching, charming and heartbreaking scene about something fundamental in humanity. Centered around a pig in a spacesuit. I'd like to see Law and Order pull that one off. *I'd like to take this moment to point out that for all the flack the Slitheen get, their sinister plan actually holds together pretty well and makes significantly more sense than anything the Master or the Cybermen have ever attempted. Say what you will about the childish farting, they'd at least bothered to put some time in on the forward planning.

7. Dinosaurs! On A Spaceship!

Doctor-who-dinosaurs-on-a-spaceship-preview

OK, I acknowledge that this one is kind of a gimme. But dammit, it scores pretty high on the weird meter. And let's be honest, who amongst us didn't have the ten year old boy inside start doing summersaults of joy when we first heard the title? "Dinosaurs on a spaceship." It's like you distilled awesome down to an awesome liquor and poured it over awesome flavored ice cream. Which wouldn't be enough to justify its existence if we didn't already have a really, really good reason to explain how the titular dinosaurs got on their spaceship in the first place. I may or may not be alone on this, but on first viewing I could not have been more pleasantly surprised to discover that it was a Silurian spaceship. Of course it was. We knew that there had been a technologically advanced species coexisting with the dinosaurs. How on Earth did we not piece together that they would have brought some dinosaurs into space - After all, we sent plenty enough chimps and dogs* The whole riding the stegosausus and the engine rooms being a beachside cliff (a revelation that was so pleasingly nuts that it was repeated to far lesser effect in "Journey to the Center of the TARDIS") were just icing on the cake at that point. The only thing more enjoyable than bats**t crazy is justifiable bats**t crazy. *Did you know that there was never any intention of bringing Laika, the first dog in space back. I bet they didn't mention that while prepping her with soviet era milkbones and belly rubs. I like to imagine that she got picked up by the Sycorax or someone and spent the rest of her life going for delightful alien walkies.

6. So How Long Was Hitler In The Cupboard Anyway?

doctor-who-lets-kill-hitler

We've all been there, right? You happen to meet up with an old friend, then kidnapped by an even older friend who goes and gets shot by Hitler, only to magically turn into your daughter, but evil. So while she's out of the room thinking about putting on some jodhpurs, you take a moment to have a little sit down and see if you can't come to terms with the day. If only Hitler would stop making so much noise in the cupboard in which you locked him. And that's not even getting to the tiny time-traveling vigilante people in the shape-shifting robot. The really notable thing about this one however is that it almost didn't make the list, because as you watch it all play out in context it all seems to make some sort of sense at the time. One thing sort of leads to another, which leads to another, until suddenly it's you and Hitler and the jodhpurs* and how in the name of crap did we get here? *Side note - Hitler and the Jodhpurs might arguably be the worst band name in all human history.

5. It's A Fair Question - What Is Pre-revolutionary France Doing On A Spaceship?

2x04-The-Girl-in-the-Fireplace-doctor-who-17797067-1600-900

"The Girl in the Fireplace." You know, besides girls being in fireplaces* there are quite a few examples of things being in unlikely places here. The horse gets a lot of mention, and admittedly- randomly encountering a horse on a spaceship is pretty high up there on the 'huh?' meter. But when Mickey questions the weirdness of that The Doctor counters with the observation that the horse is not the strangest thing on the ship. I'm not sure why this doesn't get commented on more often because it's a hell of a good point. It is far more reasonable to expect a horse to be in space than it is to have an entirely unrelated historical going on there as well. Other notable examples of 'hey, that shouldn't be there' - classical clockwork inside high tech robots, and human organs grafted into the ship's wiring. A rare example on this list of weird being used for a chilling effect *First off - if it needs to be said - you should absolutely not put girls into fireplaces. That's just bad parenting. But the point I really want to make here is - If the fireplace connection back to the spaceship is only undamaged because it was offline since it was moved to Versailles- what exactly was Madame Du P. shouting into not ten minutes earlier to call out for The Doctor's help?

4. Most Series Resist The Urge To Kill Of The Titular Character In The First 10 Minutes Of The Season Opener...

doctor-who_the-impossible-astronaut

In the promotional material for The Impossible Astronaut, they made quite a big deal out of the fact that one of our four beloved lead characters* was going to die in the season opener. And we all assumed that it would probably just be Rory again, since we were sort of used to that by that stage. It was therefore with more than a little mild surprise that we saw The Doctor gunned down by a spaceman who appeared to live in a middle-sized lake in Utah (as one does) and then verified dead by two independent sources. Of course we all knew that something would happen to reverse it before the end of the episode, since there was the slight detail of them having to make 12 more episodes that year with him in them. Which is why I personally enjoyed the twist of then having the 200-odd year younger Doctor turn up and realizing that the rest of the season was going to be building up to where we saw the Doctor at the very beginning. Obviously nobody thought that they were actually going to kill him off, but it provided a nice shape for the season. * Or 'Three Beloved lead characters and River", if you're of that school of thought. Personally I like her.

3. All Of "Love and Monsters"

love-and-monsters

Let me be perfectly clear on one point. I adore "Love and Monsters." I love it into tiny little pieces. This story gets a fair share of flack from a lot of fandom, and while I kind of understand some of it, a lot of it is just simply boneheaded. Yes, the Absorbalof is on the cheesy side. Yes, I agree, they probably would have done better to lose the sex with a paving slab joke at the end. However neither of those things are remotely the point of the episode. Or rather, the fact that they jar tonally with what we expect Doctor Who to feel like is the point of the episode. Take for example the blatantly Scooby-Doo chase scene. What people who complain about this scene tend to miss is that it's presented that way because that's how Elton saw it. That's his frame of reference, and in that he's the one telling us the entire episode, of course it feels different. And if you're one of the people who dismissed this episode as 'not being Doctor Who', as if Doctor Who was in any way about having to be one specific thing with everything else being 'wrong', then you have spectacularly missed the point of the last 50 years of stories. All of the tonal strangeness here exists for one reason. To get to this moment- "When you're a kid, they tell you it's all... grow up. Get a job. Get married. Get a house. Have a kid, and that's it. But the truth is, the world is so much stranger than that. It's so much darker. And so much madder. And so much better."

2. The Master Takes A Moment Away From World Conquest To Do A Dance Number

Masterdance

I realized after "Last of the Time Lords" aired that in all these years we have never seen The Master actually succeed. At anything. At all. So it makes a certain sense that after finally managing to pull one of his crazy schemes off he felt a bit like celebrating. I wouldn't have pegged him for a Scissor Sisters fan (and if he was I probably would have gone with 'Return to Oz', seriously, have you heard it? Great song) but hey - it sort of worked for him. But it also made me think... .was he always planning to cap things off with a dance number? Is it just that we've never seen him get far enough along in a plan for it to have come up? Did Roger Delgado have Abba's 'Super Trooper' all cued up and ready to jam the moment the Sea Devils took over the world? Was Anthony Ainley poised with his cassette tape of The Hooters just waiting for King John to not sign Magna Carta?* Any moment that causes that succession of images while advancing the plotline of the story at hand has really achieved something. *Eric Roberts would of course probably have gone with that Chumba Whumba song which would just have given us one more thing to be disappointed with.

1. Cats, And Lesbians, And Gospel. Oh My.

doctor-who-gridlock

There's a lot to enjoy in "Gridlock". For one it has Martha Jones in it, who is rapidly becoming in my mind the most under-appreciated companion of the modern era. Additionally, it gives us a third view of the post-Earth era, and manages to show us not just a completely different view of the world than we saw in either "New Earth" or "The End of the World" but also a third view that seems to co-exist with the first two, making the era a richer and deeper place than it initially seemed, back at number 10 on this list. If you really look at it, there's a lot of the world around us right now that doesn't seem to logically fit with other parts of the world around us. In scripting terms it's called 'consistent inconsistency', and it's more or less at the heart of what Matt Smith was talking about when he said that the universe is large and complicated. By which I mean that when you reach the moment where a cat and his human wife are jokingly claiming to be offended at the thought of the married lesbian couple who live in the car two lanes over, just before we pause to complain about how there's never a cop around when you need one and then everyone stops to sing a quite lovely hymn together out of nowhere*... well, it just sort of feels right. Simultaneously insane and right. The world IS so much stranger. And darker. And madder AND better. More like this please. *Oh, and the entire planet has crabs. I'm sorry, I tried to resist saying that.

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Mikey is, in no particular order, a freelance writer, improvisational comedian, volunteer firefighter, playwright, Bon Vivant, and Jane Espenson enthusiast. Born in the small mining town of Eden Prairie, MN, he has some 40 years later successfully moved about 20 miles north of there to the City of Brooklyn Center, MN where he lives with an unreasonable number of dogs. If you'd like to hear him discuss something other than Doctor Who while pretending to be a dog, check out www.the42ndvizsla.blogspot.com or follow him on twitter at @the42ndVizlsa