Doctor Who: The Cartmel Masterplan - What Could Have Been

Survival Doctor Who
BBC

You get the depressing sense that come Survival's conclusion the work is half done, leaving so much of Andrew Cartmel's hard work left unfinished. It's unclear how long it would've taken to finally seed in his changes, and how much longer Sylvester McCoy would've stuck around.

There's indication that he may have regenerated at the end of Season 27, or perhaps stayed on for a further season. Either way, there were plenty of vague ideas as to where the show would be taken next, alongside a list of writers that Andrew Cartmel wanted to use to expand his creative new version of Doctor Who.

Whether or not this whole 'masterplan' would've paid out is uncertain. Although for those who have read the New Virgin novels during the Wilderness Years will have delved deep into Andrew Cartmel's plans, with him and his team building upon their ideas and formulating the foundation of the more gritty, adult-like narratives. This ultimately concluded with a novelised version of Lungbarrow, thus finally completing the journey that would've taken place on screen.

Sadly, those books are now extremely hard to come by, making it difficult for modern fans to delve into the wonderous world of Doctor Who that could've been. However, it makes you wonder whether Chris Chibnall took inspiration from 'the Cartmel Masterplan' and wished to finally tap into those uncharted territories. Although, only time will tell whether or not this daring approach to storytelling will pay off, as history prepares to repeat itself.

Advertisement

Watch Next


Doctor Who: How Well Do You Know The Time Lords?

Doctor Who Gallifrey Hell Bent
BBC

1. Who Has Not Been Lord President Of Gallifrey?

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Loving husband and full-time nerd. My pastime is analysing and sharing my thoughts on things. I dabble with video games, enjoy a good horror movie, and love my superhero content. And Doctor Who is my favourite show of all times.