Each Lead From The Good Place Ranked Worst To Best
Holy forking shirtballs! Time to position the Good Place crew from worst to best.
The Good Place was an incredibly consistent series, that never failed to be exciting or hilarious. A sitcom based on the afterlife was such a unique concept that the showrunners had almost no limits to the scenarios that they could come up with, and they certainly took full advantage of this.
Despite the outlandish premise, a major factor for its success was relatability. Although the characters are all dead, they still felt incredibly alive and real. This not only assisted the narrative but it made the show worth watching as you needed to know what would happen to them next.
Each lead took a traditional archetypal role in the standard sitcom format and expanded it to become unique. They were helped by the fact that the situations they faced were far more challenging than what comedy characters normally experience.
Amongst these leads is a hierarchy of humour and contribution to the show that is challenging to quantify. However, to explore them and the show in detail it shall be done.
This article will contain spoilers for the entire series. The twists and turns are very important to the narrative and to discuss the characters without exposing the plot would leave a lot to be missed.
6. Jason Mendoza
The reveal that silent Buddhist monk Jiyanu was actually Jason Mendoza from Jacksonville made for one of the shows most dramatic twists, and is an early moment to pique fan interest. Whilst this exposure made a fantastic conflict for the protagonist, Jason became far more than just a task for Elanor to manage.
Developing a real place within the cast, Jason quickly became one of the funniest characters within the group with great dialogue. Paired with a charming performance by Manny Jacinto, he was a welcome presence within the setting.
He sadly ranks at the bottom of this list because his involvement within the plot normally acted more as a diversion than a solution. The character very rarely makes positive contributions to solving problems, and whilst his antics are funny, they often cause issues for the others.
From a non-story focused perspective, Jason lacks a little as well. Although he had great development and character building, he is ultimately playing a role that exists in almost every sitcom. He acts as the dumb wild card character that audiences can laugh at. Whilst this is done well within the show, its setting and overall development of the traditional sitcom make the application of this character stereotype feel uninspired.
The fact that the loveable Jason is last shows how high the standards are for characters in this show.
5. Tahani Al Jamil
Tahani Al Jamil, played effortlessly by the charming Jameela Jamil is a wonderful presence in The Good Place. She went from being Elanor's petty rival to a contributing member of the team with a grand sense of purpose. This progression from a spoilt rich socialite to a humble and hard-working (dead) human being was a highlight for the show.
Similar to Jason, Tahani could sometimes lack agency in problem-solving. However - unlike the Jacksonville Jaguars superfan - she proved herself to be valuable and many scenarios would have failed were it not for her involvement.
Additionally, in contrast to Jason, her character was far more nuanced. The high society presence who loves to name drop all of her celebrity friends had a true identity. There are no other characters in sit-coms that can be compared to her. Although contrasting traditional archetypes she was a perfect fit not only for the format but for the specific setting of the show.
With the afterlife it makes a tonne of sense to employ a character so outlandishly wealthy as this. Normally such a rich character would be avoided as there would be no way to make them feel relatable. But Tahani has a place because nothing in the show is realistic. The audience already needed to find their own way to relate and thus a character like this could only exist in this scenario.
4. Janet
D'Arcy Carden was a perfect fit for this show. Her wholesome portrayal of Janet was a mainstay in the series and part of what gave it such identity. She also acted as an example of how the show could carry out humorous scenarios with upmost creativity.
Janet is a being who serves Good Place residents with no true purpose in her life outside of this. However, this specific model of Janet ends up being rebooted so many times that she develops her own personality and freedom. This was a great way to make the "not a girl" feel relevant despite the seemingly undevelopable concept of her existence.
Ultimately her ability to know everything, obtain anything in the universe and other fantastical abilities gave the writers plenty of scope to establish her importance to the group. Without Janet most of the events of the series wouldn't have occurred, her presence is incredibly valuable.
This speaks not only to the narrative but to the series itself. Without D'Arcy the show would have lacked its most wholesome figure. This positive, upbeat attitude was an integral vibe for the show, and this character was its embodiment.
3. Chidi Anagonye
Chidi Anagonye - like Jason - tends to slide into a stereotypical sit-com archetype, that being the nerdy control freak who has rules and obsessions that they don't like to change. But what makes Chidi extra special is the contribution that he makes to the thematic centre of the show.
Although it is an overwhelmingly silly series, the focus on philosophy and the idea of how one can be a good person grounds it and delivers a purpose outside of the humour. The driving force behind the plot, premise and meaning is the application of Chidi's lessons in how to be a good person through moral philosophy.
Further from this, the character also acts as an incredibly charming and funny presence. His constant worrying and panics make him feel relatable and gives the series a sense that someone is aware of the stakes and realism in the concept.
Finally, his relationship with Elanor is one of the reasons that the show is so beautiful. The awkward flirting and constant confusion makes their courtship unique, but once they finally become a couple they grow into their own. The relationship really helped Chidi to develop as a character.
2. Michael
Ted Danson is a wonderfully charming actor, with a rich history in TV and a unique look that instantly gave him an otherworldly yet relatable presence as Michael. The architect of The Good Place in more than one way, Michael brought everything together and has significant importance to the show.
To discuss him in detail we have to expose his biggest secrets. The final twist at the culmination of season one that Michael is actually a demon and they are all in the Bad Place felt like the end of the journey at first. But the show would only go from strength to strength afterwards, and a lot of that was thanks to the adventure Michael went on.
Redemption arcs are always fun to see, but watching a literal demon become a good person is certainly one of the biggest changes we've ever witnessed. Michael always felt real and natural in whatever stage he was at. Going from a charming (but fake) angelic figure, to a pure evil demon, and finally a caring and thoughtful person.
His importance to the show combined with his fantastic development and hilarious performance easily make him a highlight.
1. Elanor Shellstrop
Finally, the lead character of the series, Elanor Shellstrop. Kristen Bell as a presence in this show brought a lot of validity and investment into the concept that many other actors wouldn't have achieved. Her character work as this beloved mess of a human being was flawless, and her involvement made this series the success it was.
Elanor acted as our eyes into this strange world. We spent the entire journey following her and even when she wasn't the focus her presence was always felt.
The fact that she was clearly flawed as a person but not inherently bad made her instantly relatable and this is a big reason as to why the narrative worked. We felt that she didn't deserve this and like her constantly sensed threat looming.
Her development is easily the shows best. Although technically Michael changes more, Elanor's direction felt so real and honest. Audiences watched her grow and learn, and did the same vicariously through her.
She has to rank as one of the best sit-com leads in recent memory, for her hilarious one-liners, likeable personality and absolutely integral place within the narrative. This is why she is the best character in the show.
Watch Next
Parks And Recreation Or The Good Place Quiz: Who Said It, April Ludgate Or Eleanor Shellstrop?