Emmys 2019: 10 Most Outrageous Nomination Snubs

Game Of Thrones somehow got 32 nominations, but which big names missed out?

True Detective Season 3 Premiere4
HBO

The Emmy nominations have just been revealed, and as usual there’s already some ups and downs before the gongs have been handed out. BoJack Horseman, Alfie Allen and and Schitt’s Creek have all earned nomination to the delight of fans who’ve frequently pushed for more recognition.

Conversely though, the poorly received Game Of Thrones Season 8 getting a record breaking 32 nominations has baffled some. A few feel earned (Emilia Clarke, Miguel Sapochnik, the aforementioned Alfie Allen), but Outstanding Writing and Outstanding Direction for the 4.2/10 rated finale on IMDb, less so.

There’s lots to discuss amongst those who actually are nominated, such as who’s most likely to win, who deserves it most etc, but there’s arguably more to be said about those who’ve missed out entirely.

The ten actors or shows here have all been overlooked in categories they might have, with a slight reshuffle to the voting panel, actually won. Some have been overlooked for too long, others are former darlings surprisingly left out in the cold, and others again are new shows which just didn’t get traction.

One thing ties them together though; they’ve all been snubbed.

10. Julia Roberts - Outstanding Lead Actress In A Drama Series (Homecoming)

Homecoming Julia Roberts
Amazon

The Emmys just don’t seem to be a fan of 30 minute dramas, and even a massive name like Julia Roberts isn’t enough to change their mind on that.

Homecoming itself missed out too, though aside from Game Of Thrones being nominated off the back of previous seasons, there’s a lot of strong contenders anyway. It would be hard to argue that This Is Us, Pose, Killing Eve, Bodyguard or Bettef Call Saul should miss out. Ozark or Succession maybe, but then you could fairly legitimately claim that they’d been snubbed instead.

So while Homecoming might not be enough to get a nomination on its own, Julia Roberts as Outstanding Lead Actress does feel deserving. Without the 30 minute runtime bias, she might have gotten in too.

Fans have been campaigning heavily for Emilia Clarke to win for Game Of Thrones, but nominations for Mandy Moore in This Is Us and Robin Wright in (this season of) House Of Cards feel much more precarious. With Homecoming being overlooked completely, it might have been fairer to readdress the balance and push Roberts forward here.

She’s not short on accolades across her career, but that doesn’t give the Emmys a pass to ignore her.


9. The Haunting Of Hill House - No Nominations

The Haunting of Hill House
Netflix

The horror genre often gets overlooked when it comes to awards, but with the Emmys being so generous to American Horror Story, that doesn’t seem like it’s as big a factor here.

As will come up a couple of times, the Outstanding Limited Series category is seriously stacked this year. Chernobyl, as the highest rated show in IMDb’s history, is leading the pack, but there’s a few other shows which would have been heavy favourites in any other year.

Even if that category is left aside for now though, The Haunting Of Hill House was a smash hit in a genre which doesn’t usually get much traction. To be passed over entirely seems grossly unfair.

Outstanding Direction for Two Storms maybe? Or Outstanding Writing for The Bent Neck Lady? While The Haunting Of Hill House might not have been strong enough for a whole series nomination, its high points deserve recognition, but they too have missed out.

The male categories are overflowing with talent (more on that later), but with fewer female characters in When They See Us, Chernobyl and A Very English Scandal, both Kate Siegel and Carla Gugino had outside shots.


8. It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia - No Nominations

It's Always Sunny Mac's Dance
FX

Sometimes, people win seasonal awards based on their career. Ryan Giggs was awarded Sports Personality way past his prime (and before we all knew he was cheating on his partner with his brother’s wife), while Gary Oldman’s Oscar for The Darkest Hour was really an apology for not giving it to him for Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy or JFK.

To that end, where on earth are It’s Always Sunny In Philadelphia’s nominations?!

They’ve only ever been recognised for Outstanding Stunt Co-Ordination previously, despite being one of the best comedies of the past decade. Season 13 wasn’t quite vintage, but Time’s Up For The Gang wasn’t worthy of a nod anywhere? Really?!

Though everyone has their favourite characters, the cast have frequently spoken about how Rob McElhenney, as the show’s overall creator, is the man who holds everything together. After his performance in Mac Finds His Pride, it’s ridiculous he’s been overlooked for Black-ish’s Anthony Anderson or The Kominsky Method’s Michael Douglas.

IASIP is no stranger to this, of course. In The Gang Tries Desperately To Win An Award, they even highlight the many reasons they feel they’ve been overlooked. Disappointing as it is, that was unlikely to change this year.


7. True Detective - Outstanding Limited Drama Series

True Detective Season 3
HBO

True Detective Season One was a phenomenal season of television, securing nominations for writing, directing and both Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey. However, it missed out on the big enchilada of Outstanding Limited Series, and Season Three has followed suit.

Season Two didn’t deserve to be in the conversation, but the third offering, while flawed, was a real phoenix moment. The fact it’s not only missed out on the big category but writing and directing too feels a bitter pill to swallow.

There’s some big guns in the Limited Series category, but Fosse/Verdon and Sharp Objects were both seemed slightly short of True Detective’s level. Fosse/Verdon especially feels unnecessarily showered in nominations after a lukewarm critical and commercial response to it.

Perhaps True Detective still couldn’t quite crawl out from Rust & Marty’s shadow.

Mahershala Ali has at least been nominated as Outstanding Lead for True Detective, but he’s destined to be an also ran.

It seems grossly unfair that only one of Jharrel Jerome or Jared Harris can win the category after their stunning turns in When They See Us and Chernobyl; both are easily the two best performances on television this year; maybe this decade. Whoever misses out will be desperately unlucky.


6. The Jelly Lakes - Outstanding Animated Program (Tuca & Bertie)

Tuca And Bertie
Netflix

There’s a few categories that you can pretty much write off from the start. If you’re playing Emmy bingo, you can’t afford not to have BoJack Horseman’s Free Churro as the winner here.

BoJack’s Time’s Arrow was overlooked completely last year as Rick & Morty’s Pickle Rick romped to a largely unchallenged victory. Looking at the competition, BoJack looks set to follow in its footprints.

Tuca & Bertie though, as probably the best new animated show since BoJack itself, deserved some recognition. With its similar animation style, it’s like BoJack’s little cousin, though its humour is more of the Broad City variety.

The show would’ve gotten a huge signal boost from a nomination in its first year, but more than that, looking at the competition, it simply deserved it. The Simpsons is growing stale, and Mad About The Toy wasn’t even as good as E My Sports or Woo Hoo Dunnit.

Likewise, while Bob’s Burgers is one of the best cartoons around, Just One Of The Boyz 4 Now For Now was a pretty tepid premiere. Against The Helen Hunt or The Taking Of Funtime OneTwoThree, Tuca & Bertie might have struggled, but against this lot, it should have been in there comfortably.


5. Native Son - Outstanding TV Movie

Native Son
HBO

Similar to BoJack Horseman feeling like its already got one hand on Outstanding Animated Program, Outstanding TV Movie feels like it already belongs to another Netflix smash hit. The gong is Black Mirror Bandersnatch’s to lose, but Native Son still should be in the chasing pack.

Led by Ashton Sanders, who previously played the intensely fascinating teenage years of Chiron in Moonlight, Native Son tells the story of a poor African-American boy brought into a world of wealth once he gets hired as a chauffeur in Chicago.

However, it does much more with the concept than surface level white/black driving narratives like Green Book or Driving Miss Daisy. Native Son strikes deep at the heart of race relations in America, and takes several dark and sordid turns.

Again though, the nominations here are slightly irrelevant. Whatever you think about the overall quality of Bandersnatch, the concept and ambition has to be lauded. With several different endings, various twists along the way and a near seamless integration of multiple choice scenarios, Bandersnatch was the television event of the year.

How lasting its impact will be remains to be seen, but it’s a massive front runner in a category which is often a bit weak.


4. Kristen Bell - Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series (The Good Place)

The Good Place Season 2 Finale Eleanor
NBC

This one is a little strange, all things considered.

Just a quick scroll through of the nominations will tell you that the Emmys love The Good Place. It’s up for Outstanding Writing In A Comedy, Outstanding Comedy on its own and its two acting nominees from last year, Ted Danson as Outstanding Comedy Actor and Maya Rudolph as Outstanding Comedy Guest, have both been honoured again.

Still no love for leading lady Kristen Bell though.

Obviously, sometimes a show is greater than the sum of its parts and can be recognised overall without singling out its stars. The Good Place though doesn’t feel like one such show though. For one, Danson and Rudolph have been recognised twice now, but watching it always feels like the tone is being maintained by Bell’s infectious enthusiasm.

The laughs come from here, there and everywhere. It’s a very funny show, and you could easily make the argument that Danson and Rudolph are funnier than Bell. The Good Place just wouldn’t work without her performance as Eleanor though.

Outstanding Comedy Actress is unusually stacked this year, with Phoebe Waller-Bridge, Julia Louise-Dreyfus, Christina Applegate, Natasha Lyonne and Catherine O’Hara all wonderful nominees, but Bell has been desperately unlucky.


3. Richard Madden - Outstanding Lead Actor In A Drama Series (Bodyguard)

Bodyguard David Budd
BBC

Utterly baffling.

Richard Madden is one of the few younger Game Of Thrones actors to have secured himself a career post Westeros, and in Bodyguard has fully established himself as a major TV star for years to come. Expect rumours of Madden as a Bond candidate to circulate for the next decade.

He’s already been won the Golden Globe in this very category for his performance as David in Bodyguard, which makes the snub even stranger.

Obviously, different award ceremonies have different voters and it would be boring to have the same person win everywhere, but it’s rare that a winner in one gets ignored completely in another.

It’s a strong category, but there is one name that feels like it’s trading on its past. Kit Harington was an amazing Jon Snow, but Season 8 just saw him repeating ‘ah dunt want ett, ah nevah have’ over and over. Hardly the stuff Emmy wins are made of.

The one silver lining is that no Madden makes it easier for Billy Porter to win for his searingly delightful performance in Pose, although Sterling K. Brown is surely the front runner now.


2. Catch-22 - No Nominations

Catch-22 Kyle Chandler
Hulu

George Clooney, for all he’s famous as a gentlemen and a heartthrob, always does his best work as an oddball.

Either through directing Confessions Of A Dangerous Mind, which supposed game show host Chuck Barris was actually a CIA deep operative spy, or through roles in Burn After Reading, O Brother, Where Art Thou and The Men Who Stare At Goats, Clooney’s at his best when he’s weird.

It was no surprise then when he adapted and starred in the cult satirical novel Catch-22. It was also no great surprise that the adaptation turned out to be pretty good, including Clooney’s often bizarre humour and brilliant facial acting.

However, seeing as it was a Hulu exclusive (in the US, at least), it’s also no surprise that it missed out on any nominations anywhere. Hulu’s big limited series last year, The Looming Tower, suffered a similar fate.

Though Netflix scored 117 nominations across the board Amazon’s The Marvellous Mrs Maisel dominates the categories it’s eligible for, Hulu doesn’t seem to have the clout of its streaming competitors, and so Clooney, Kyle Chandand Catch-22 miss out here.


1. Stephen Dorff - Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Limited Series (True Detective)

True Detective Season 3
HBO

In a way, it was to be expected that Stephen Dorff get overlooked here, despite his career reviving performance in True Detective.

Mahershala Ali got all of the press coverage at the time, and with True Detective missing out for Writing, Directing and Limited Series, it would have been strange for both actors to still get the nod.

Gun to the head, Ali probably does deserve it more than Dorff. We saw him struggle with Alzheimer’s and PTSD, as well as getting the lion’s share of the plot and some of the best dialogue the show has ever had. However, that’s not really how it works.

Dorff was supporting Ali this season, hence would be in Outstanding Support. True Detective fans have been reluctantly grateful that at least Ali is up for an award, but they aren’t even in the same category.

When They See Us was phenomenal, but John Leguizamo being nominated feels hollow when fellow nominees Michael Kenneth Williams and Asante Blackk overshadowed him anyway.

He’s not the only one to miss out here either; while Stellan Skarsgård has rightly been recognised for Chernobyl, Paul Ritter has been overlooked, despite him and Dorff both bringing a much needed extra angle to their shows.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)