Every Arrowverse Season Ranked From Worst To Best

Which of the Arrowverse's seasons stood out, and which ones are best left forgotten?

Arrowverse CW
The CW

There has perhaps never been a shared universe on television quite like the Arrowverse.

Spawned by Greg Berlanti back in 2012, the juggernaut-to-be came to life with Arrow - a dark reimagining of the origins of DC Comic character Green Arrow as a once-shipwrecked Oliver Queen returned to Starling City to right his family's wrongs. In doing so, the character would inadvertently start a trend of costumed vigilantes - many of whom attempted to follow in his footsteps.

Following two successful seasons of Arrow, The CW commissioned The Flash - a show that, in one season, outperformed its parent show in just about every way possible, going on to become a huge hit for the network. And soon, others would follow with DC's Legends of Tomorrow giving some of Arrow and Flash's lesser-appreciated supporting characters some much-needed spotlight, and Supergirl showing audiences just how powerful 'girl power' really was.

Now, here we are seven years later, and there have been 20 collective Arrowverse seasons (seven of Arrow, five of The Flash and four of both Supergirl and Legends). And with Arrow set to conclude following its eighth outing, and Batwoman joining the fray, what better time to look back at every season so far just to see which of them truly saved the day (and which of them "failed this city")?

20. Arrow Season 4

Oliver Arrow Season 4
The CW

There are lows, and then there are Arrow Season 4 lows.

After a disappointing third season, we all hoped the writers could return Arrow to its former glory, but in spite of a highly promising premiere, the show would go on to produce the most bafflingly bad season the Arrowverse has ever (and probably will ever) seen.

Sidelining central characters in a bid to focus on the horrendously melodramatic 'Olicity' angle, the writers rammed Oliver and Felicity's relationship drama to the forefront at the expense of actual story. Neither character behaved like themselves and the whole thing turned into a daytime soap opera.

To make matters worse, Damien Darhk was too powerful a villain for a supposedly grounded show like Arrow and, in spite of Neal McDonagh's charismatic performance, he just came off as corny. Oh yeah, and wanting to destroy the world isn't exactly an original idea Damien!

The biggest of all sins, however, came when the poorly-executed 'Who's in the grave?' narrative resulted in the death of leading lady, Laurel Lance (a.k.a. the Black freakin' Canary), destroying everything the writers had put into the comic book character's arc.

Arrow had lost sight of what it was and, in the process, alienated its core audience. And for what? A ship? A season-long narrative? Whatever the reason, it's safe to say that, four years on, it certainly wasn't worth it.


19. The Flash Season 4

The Flash Season 4
The CW

Though in a completely different league than the previous entry, The Flash's fourth season also brought dull days with it.

The creative choice to finally have a non-speedster villain was admirable, no doubt, but perhaps choosing someone like DeVoe was just a little too ambitious. That's not to take anything away from the development of the character because, quite frankly, he was brilliant (as was Neil Sandilands' performance). The problem, however, was that, like Damien Darhk, he was too powerful for his respective show.

As his brain was able to anticipate everything Team Flash would do, he remained one step ahead of them all season long. Thus, in order to drag the season out for as long as possible, the writers had to write the bus of metahumans into his overall plan. This gave the Scarlet Speedster a chance to get ahead of The Thinker... and resulted in a ton of incredibly dull villain-of-the-week episodes.

Moreover, the emphasis on the well-developed DeVoe made all of Team Flash (including Barry himself) seem less interesting while the exaggerated tone resulted in the show feeling a lot cornier than it needed to be.


18. The Flash Season 5

The Flash Legacy 1
The CW

No doubt a major improvement over the fourth offering, The Flash's fifth season once again placed the focus on the West-Allen extended family - and it certainly benefited from it, as the arrival of Nora West-Allen from the future switched things up, and allowed us to see how the core couple of Barry and Iris functioned as parents. Unfortunately, a number of glaring issues prevented it from emulating the success of previous family-centric seasons.

While Jessica Parker Kennedy portrayed Nora to perfection, the character was written in such a way that it often felt hard to root for her. Sure, she was a rookie speedster, but there are only so many times you can make the same mistakes before it gets repetitive. And repetitive it was, as Nora continued to defy her seasoned parents and did her own thing - to the detriment of the mission (and the show).

That, however, sums up the season in a nutshell because it spent too long going around in circles and nothing exemplified that more than Cicada - who was nothing more than a one-note villain who showed up, grunted and flew off when things went south.

The season felt a lot longer than it needed to be and only thrived when it wasn't focusing on its main narrative, with episodes like 'King Shark vs. Gorilla Grodd' and the season finale 'Legacy' stealing the show - the latter of which, in all fairness, is one of the best episodes The Flash has ever produced.


17. Arrow Season 3

Arrow Header
The CW

Arrow's third season initially looked like it was set to continue the show's string of success. Unfortunately, it ended up marking the beginning of the end for its reign at the top of superhero television, as the show veered away from important characters and began centering on an uninteresting villain (and, more annoyingly, an uninteresting relationship) instead.

Ra's Al Ghul had all the makings of a great Big Bad and, in spite of a solid performance from Matt Nable, the writers just weren't able to capitalize on his potential. Thus, the season ended up becoming a watered-down Batman story about how Ra's wanted Oliver to take his place as his successor and, upon the latter's refusal, threw a tantrum and destroyed his happiness.

To make matters worse, the writers began paying attention to the blossoming relationship between Oliver and Felicity but unfortunately, even with their great chemistry, that relationship did anything but blossom - as it resulted in both characters acting out of character and made for some incredibly cringe-worthy moments (Felicity in the A.T.O.M. suit, really?).

Like most of Arrow's misfires, this one started off with a lot of potential but, aside from the brilliant Starling-central trio of episodes led by Katie Cassidy and Vinnie Jones, it ultimately squandered it. And it was all capped off by an incredibly underwhelming finale.


16. Legends of Tomorrow Season 1

Legends of Tomorrow Pilot Part 2
The CW

Legends of Tomorrow is renowned for throwing everything at the wall just to see what sticks, and it certainly wasn't immune to doing that in its somewhat lesser-talked about first season.

While the idea of a time-traveling 'time master' teaming up with a rag tag group of misfits - including a trained (and resurrected) assassin, the fiery duo of a renowned scientist and a former high school student, an arsonist and thief, a billionaire who could shrink himself and two ancient Hawk beings - sounds absolutely ludicrous, the premiere season never fully embraced that and, as a result, some of it came off as too heavy and dramatic.

In all fairness, it's not as bad as many like to make out, and did give a platform to some of the Arrowverse's most beloved supporting characters while also proving to be a solid contribution to the fantasy genre, but the cardboard villain in Vandal Savage prevented it from truly stunning in its debut offering.

Thankfully, things just got crazier from here on out.


15. The Flash Season 3

The Flash Season 3 Savitar
The CW

The Flash's third season was very much like Arrow's third season in that it felt like that transitional sequel in a film franchise that completely lost sight of what it once was - the one that, in all honesty, isn't that bad but, upon reflection, is clearly when things started going wrong for the show.

Returning to the well for a third time, the writers once again employed a speedster villain through the use of Savitar - who wasn't just any speedster but the God of Speed. Thus, Barry Allen was predictably bested time and again by yet another speedster - one that ended up turning out to be a twisted version of himself from the future.

Aside from that, characters like Wally West and Tom Felton's Julian Albert felt lost, Iris was portrayed like a damsel in distress, Cisco's understandable resentment towards Barry weighed the show down and the complete failure to do anything with the iconic Flashpoint storyline resulted in a season full of despair and disappointment.

That said, there were some silver linings, such as Tom Cavanagh's infectious performance as H.R. Wells, the joyous musical crossover with Supergirl and the brilliant finale - which ultimately brought the underwhelming season to a strong, if predictable, close.


14. Supergirl Season 3

Supergirl Kara
The CW

It's almost common practice for the Arrowverse shows to go dark in their third seasons, so it should come as no surprise to hear that Supergirl followed suit.

A season that focused on the rise of the deadly Reign, the show adopted an apocalyptic tone throughout the first half of Season 3 that ultimately built towards a Gothic showdown between the Girl of Steel and the unearthly warrior in the midseason finale. Sadly, it was never able to fully capitalize on that in the second half, as the season needed to be dragged out for another 14 episodes which only ended up diluting all of the stakes.

That said, the emotional inner conflict as Sam struggled to contain the demon within was excellent - thanks to Odette Annable's convincing performances.

In a similarly divisive note, Mon-El's character development was a work of genius, but after the writers finally allowed him to achieve the redemption he had been working towards (he refused to betray his wife, who understood his feelings for Kara and ultimately ended their marriage), he was quietly written off without a powerful moment with the Girl of Steel. This understandably left fans feeling rather short-changed, and made us all wonder why it had built towards their reconciliation only to pull out at the last minute?

That aside, narrative issues, lack of overall stakes and rushed editing ended up undercutting what should have been the show's most powerful season, and resulted in quite a lot of predictability.


13. Arrow Season 6

Arrow Season 6 Finale
The CW

Arrow Season 6 is something of an enigma as it somehow managed to incite reactions of applause and outrage on a recurring loop.

While it started off rather strong, fans were disappointed at the complete lack of risks taken with the fallout of Season 5 when it was revealed that no major regular character died in the Lian Yu explosion in the previous finale. Continuing the mixed response, the full-time addition of Black Siren reinvigorated the show while main villain Cayden James significantly held it back.

However, the season reached peak divisiveness midway through its run as the forced conflict between the new and old members of Team Arrow was nothing short of infuriating to watch and dragged episode after episode down, while revealing Ricardo Diaz to be the main Big Bad resulted in a major dynamic shift that ultimately benefited the show.

That dynamic shift led the season towards its conclusion and, in the process, produced what is perhaps the greatest string of consecutively strong episodes in the series' history. From Diaz's strategic takedown of Green Arrow to Black Siren's emotional turmoil over her newfound affection for father figure Quentin, there was so much juicy material in the second half - and it all led towards an equally strong finale. In the end, that was enough to make up for the infuriating Team Arrow drama.


12. Legends of Tomorrow Season 4

Legends Of Tomorrow Finale
The CW

Legends of Tomorrow's fourth season was, believe it or not, even more ludicrous than everything that came before, as the introduction of magical and mythical creatures led to a ton of colourful adventures (or 'mythteries' as they were once affectionately named) for the Legends.

Unlike the two previous seasons, this one struggled to get the balance between satire and serious right at times as it often leaned too heavily on the wacky and bizarre, resulting in a few unnecessarily over-the-top episodes (yes, even for Legends), but that doesn't mean that there weren't any emotionally strong arcs (Nate's relationship with his father was particularly endearing) or standout moments - who could forget those truly magical musical numbers?

Moreover, the full-time introduction of Matt Ryan's John Constantine was well worth the wait and the exploration of Sara and Ava's relationship was, for the most part, a compelling core narrative (though they could have done without the predictably forced break-up). Nora Darhk also came into her own and proved to be a valuable addition to the show, serving as a believable foil to the demonic Neron.


11. Arrow Season 7

Arrow S7 Oliver Queen
The CW

The seventh season of Arrow brought with it a major change of pace for the show as, for the first time, the status quo had been completely shattered.

Oliver's imprisonment at Slabside changed things up for the better and paved the way for a number of new and unique prison-centric storylines which allowed the show to return to its darker roots. That also worked well on the outside, as Laurel, Felicity, the SCPD and A.R.G.U.S. all had their own reasons for desperately attempting to track down Ricardo Diaz.

This all led to a number of new and unique dynamics - particularly the unexpectedly endearing friendship between Laurel and Felicity - which made for a strong first half.

Unfortunately, a lack of interest in figuring out who its main villain truly was, and a lack of interest in Emiko altogether, resulted in a problematic second half that ultimately fell apart in a rushed season finale that was more worried about setting up the final season (and giving Felicity an unnecessarily long farewell) than wrapping up Season 7 in a fulfilling way.

That said, the season produced some outstanding episodes, including the equally brilliant 'The Slabside Redemption', 'Lost Canary' and 'Confessions'.


10. The Flash Season 2

The Flash Zoom Hunter Laurel Black Siren
The CW

The Flash had the tall task of following its incredibly strong first season with something that was capable of proving that the show that was applauded for being 'The CW's biggest hit ever' wasn't just a one-hit wonder. Thankfully, it succeeded in doing so, for the most part.

Much of the formula is the same as its predecessor, as a violent speedster from the great unknown shows up to terrorize Central City, allowing the Scarlet Speedster to learn more about the capabilities of the world around him. This time, the speedster was Zoom, the 'great unknown' was Earth-2 and the vital new information was the existence of the multiverse.

While it couldn't ultimately live up to the standard set by Season 1, it did prove to be a solid, if somewhat repetitive, offering that was vital to the show's overarching narrative. It wasn't afraid to take risks and thrived on the use of Earth-2 doppelgängers of some of our favourite characters. But its greatest strength lay in its Big Bad, as Zoom was nothing short of diabolical, proving to be a worthy successor to the first season's Reverse-Flash.


9. Legends of Tomorrow Season 3

Legends of Tomorrow Mallus
The CW

Legends of Tomorrow really turned things around with its second season, and all eyes were watching to see if they could pull it off again for the third. The answer was, of course, yes.

With Rip Hunter now serving a new, recurring purpose, the show split its time between the remainder of the Legends rather well, allowing every character to get some well-earned screen time as the team collided with the Time Bureau. Moreover, Kid Flash/Wally West was a welcome addition to the line-up and received more spotlight in the ensemble piece than he ever did on The Flash, creating a unique dynamic that we hadn't seen before.

In addition, the return of Damien Darhk once again worked wonders as he and Gorilla Grodd served the demonic Mallus, providing the show with a new formidable team of villains. And in case you thought you'd seen it all, the season comes to a head in a gargantuan battle between a giant winged-bat demon and a super-sized plush doll. Yeah, you gotta see it to believe it.

But it wasn't all silliness as the death of a major character played a huge role in the season's narrative and was handled with the maturity it needed to be in order to impact the remaining characters.

A great season, the third time was (also) the charm for Legends.


8. Supergirl Season 4

Supergirl The Quest For Peace
The CW

Supergirl decided to get political in its fourth season when long-time alien supporter Ben Lockwood became the villainous Agent Liberty, using fear tactics to turn the public against alien immigrants. Naturally, the Girl of Steel attempted to counter this with her messages of hope, which opened up the stage to a ton of differing views. The irony, however, was that these unrealistic situations were simply metaphors for real world issues.

While the political tone wasn't for everybody, it certainly resulted in some of the strongest writing that the show had ever seen. Though that resulted in it feeling somewhat less triumphant than before, it ensured that it stood out as the best Arrowverse show during the 2018-2019 TV season. And the comic book purists sure got what they came for as the season approached its conclusion.

While the handling of the Red Daughter's arc was problematic, the payoff was worth it, as it led to the long-awaited debut of Lex Luthor - who was revealed to be the master manipulator behind everything that had gone wrong that year. And even though he was only in three episodes, Jon Cryer used his little time wisely, turning in an outstanding performance that solidified this Lex as the real Big Bad of the season and earned himself a place among the greatest Mr. Luthors of all time.


7. Arrow Season 5

Arrow Team Arrow
The CW

Following the travesty that was Season 4, Arrow bounced back with an admirably strong fifth season that turned its back on magic and Olicity (at least temporarily) in its attempt to return the show to its darker, grounded roots. This attempt was a highly successful one, as the show found itself once more in a small, contained narrative that didn't revolve around the end of the world or an ancient leader but instead focused solely on Oliver and how his mistakes birthed one of his greatest adversaries.

Prometheus is, without a doubt, one of the greatest villains to ever make his presence felt in the Arrowverse. A terrifying panic-inducing zombie-like archer, his burlap mask solidified him as a visual threat, while his intricate plot to slowly pick Oliver apart (which he partially accomplished with a smile through his everyday activities as his best friend D.A. Adrian Chase) was nothing short of villainous brilliance.

There were issues, such as one-dimensional characters like Evelyn and the unnecessary introduction of another Black Canary in Dinah Drake when we already Black Siren, but overall, Season 5 is among the best that the Arrowverse has to offer and proved to be a thoroughly compelling narrative, packed full of intense storytelling and outstanding fight choreography.


6. Supergirl Season 1

Supergirl Kara El
CBS

Supergirl's debut season is perhaps the least Arrowverse an Arrowverse show has ever felt, and that's because crossovers and multiverses were never really on the cards until halfway through its run - due to the fact that it aired on CBS instead of The CW. It had its own unique, standalone tone that set it apart from the rest, and it rocked it.

Focusing on the Girl of Steel's early days as a superhero, the show detailed how Kara's desire to help people outweighed her feelings of self-doubt and how that ultimately propelled her to become the hero that National City desperately needed her to be. The CatCo environment ended up encouraging her a lot more than she ever thought it would, and it provided the show with a larger-than-life aesthetic that it simply doesn't have anymore.

On that note, Calista Flockhart's show-stealing turn as Cat Grant is one of the main reasons why later seasons will probably never reach these heights ever again, as it was the scenes between her and Melissa Benoist's Kara that truly grounded this ambitious series with some realistic character development.

It wasn't all perfect, as some of the villains were pretty dull and the forced romance between Kara and James really weighed a portion of it down, but it was triumphant, powerful and even a little bit cheesy - a heroic combination that never failed to bring a smile to the faces of countless viewers.


5. Supergirl Season 2

Supergirl Superman
The CW

It's hard to believe that there was a time when a second season of Supergirl wasn't a guarantee but, in spite of great ratings, the show's fate was up at in the air at one point... that is, until it moved to The CW to join its fellow Arrowverse shows. And that move allowed it produce one heck of a second offering.

The show adopted a slightly less cheesy and more mature approach which, in all honesty, came with positives and negatives. That said, it did allow for some incredibly touching storylines, such as Alex's journey towards acceptance of her sexuality - a storyline that was undoubtedly one of the season's standout aspects.

The departure of Cat Grant certainly hurt the show, but the debuts of Mon-El, Lena Luthor, Maggie Sawyer, Lillian Luthor, Lynda Carter's President Olivia Marsdin and, most importantly, Superman made up for all of that as they enhanced the season and created a new dynamic going forward. And even though the villainous Rhea was a little one-dimensional, Teri Hatcher's performance elevated the material as it all paved the way for an epic two-part finale.


4. Legends of Tomorrow Season 2

Legends of Tomorrow CW
The CW

The first season of Legends of Tomorrow may have been decent, but it didn't have all that much to say. Season 2, however, was a different story altogether.

Adopting a more tongue-in-cheek tone than its predecessor, the show embraced every inch of the wacky and wondrous world around them. As a result, everything was so much more exaggerated - and that ultimately made it all the more enjoyable.

That's not as to say that there wasn't any seriousness because, seriously, there was. From Sara's desire to undo Laurel's death to Rip's sinister turn, the writers weren't afraid to weave emotionally heavy narratives in there too and, to their credit, they handled them with all the necessary maturity.

Speaking of maturity, the villains were also a significant improvement over the one-dimensional Vandal Savage - and not only because the Legion of Doom consisted of fan-favourite Big Bads Reverse-Flash, Dark Archer and Damien Darhk - as each of them were tired of losing and thus, in a clever way of using the far-fetched concept of the show to create a surprisingly believable goal, they wished to change reality so that they could win instead.

Legends of Tomorrow is now arguably the best (and, without a doubt, the most consistent) Arrowverse show of them all, but it wouldn't be so without its incomparable second season.


3. Arrow Season 1

Arrow Oliver Season 1
The CW

The idea of a world without Smallville left fans wondering if superhero TV would disappear into obscurity once more. Thankfully, we didn't have to wait long to find out as Arrow debuted on The CW a little over a year later.

A dark and twisted reimagining of DC Comics' Green Arrow, the debut season told the story of how a shipwrecked Oliver Queen returned to the city he left behind five years prior and sought to reign down vengeance on those poisoning it - all while hoping to prove himself to the love of his life, Laurel Lance.

With a strong central narrative that set the show apart from your average villain-of-the-week series, an exceptional use of flashbacks to showcase Oliver's "five years in hell", and a positively brilliant threat responsible for all of it in the Dark Archer, Arrow reinvented the Green Arrow for a new generation and, in taking inspiration from Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy, produced one of the strongest seasons of the 2012-2013 TV season - something that wouldn't have been possible without its stellar cast.

By the time that the credits rolled on the season finale, it was clearer than ever that, yes, superheroes still had a place on TV. Arrow hadn't failed its source material... at least not yet.


2. Arrow Season 2

arrow slade wilson deathstroke felicity smoak
The CW

If Arrow Season 1 was The CW's answer to Batman Begins, Season 2 was undoubtedly its Dark Knight.

With all the groundwork having been successfully laid throughout the flashback narrative of Season 1, the writers pulled the trigger on, well, everything they had been building towards. As a result, Oliver's life was turned upside down as two old figures returned from his past (and the dead), and although one was there to help him - Sara Lance's Canary - one was there to destroy him. The latter was, of course, Slade Wilson a.k.a. Deathstroke.

Slade's intricately-plotted downfall was so effective that the only thing better than it was the writers' ability to intricately plan such a storyline, and all of this foreshadowing raised the stakes, as Slade was more than just your average villain - he knew Oliver before he was The Arrow, and he knew exactly how to destroy him.

From Deathstroke's desire for revenge to Laurel Lance and Roy Harper's personal struggles, the show tackled a ton of mature narratives throughout the season, and somehow it managed to handle them all really well - while also ensuring that there was enough time to conclude the season with the city in flames as Arrow and Deathstroke fought for supremacy one more time.

A grim, deep and thoroughly compelling offering, Arrow's second season was the cream of the crop for superhero television. The show has never ever been better.


1. The Flash Season 1

the flash barry allen
The CW

Perfect is a word that gets thrown around a little too often when describing entertainment simply because even the best of it can be improved upon. In spite of that, The Flash's first season was nothing short of perfection.

A heartwarming tale about a young hero who still had an idealistic view of the world even after suffering tragedy, The Flash was just about as far removed from its parent show (Arrow) as possible. But it was equally as effective in setting up its respective hero's story, as Barry Allen's lab accident and the subsequent abilities that he received only enhanced what was already there, setting the stage for the debut of the Arrowverse's greatest hero.

Attempting to free his wrongfully imprisoned father while also being a guardian angel for the people of Central City, the Scarlet Speedster was driven by the thought of using his speed to track down the "Man in the Yellow Suit" that killed his mother. It was this motivation that allowed the series to thrive, as it paved the way for a compelling mystery that ran the whole way throughout. And it didn't rush to its conclusion either; it was a marathon that expertly kept us guessing as it slowly built towards its explosive finale and dropped some major revelations along the way to increase the stakes.

With strong writing, a brilliant cast, admirable homages to the comics and an endearing performance from Grant Gustin at its heart, The Flash reinvigorated the superhero TV genre, setting a new standard that has yet to be surpassed.

-

Which Arrowverse season is your favourite? Tell us in the comment section below.


Arrow Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Season 1?

The Hood
The CW

1. Who Was The First Person The Hood Targeted?

In this post: 
Arrowverse
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.