Every HBO Comedy Ranked From Worst To Best

22. Looking

Looking HBO
HBO

A show that already feels much missed even though it’s only been off the air for five years, Looking was often the best show nobody was watching. A touching, incredibly well observed story of three gay best friends living in San Francisco, this was an important and moving series that ended far before its times.

Its three protagonists were given some of the best LGBT+ characters ever seen on TV - Patrick, Agustin, and Dom, all of whom had struggled with their sexuality or the treatment they’d received to some extent, but were now free to live how they wished and seek connections and love in their lives.

Sexuality on TV is still often handled hamfistedly; this is decidedly not the case on Looking, which is frank in discussing the negative experiences the characters have had, but never defines them by this. It’s a show about searching for happiness and acceptance at large.

The second series was its last, but Looking got the opportunity to tie things up in a feature length finale. It’s the least this show deserved.


21. Sally4Ever

Julia Davis Sally4ever
HBO

Julia Davis’ latest undertaking is perhaps her most bonkers yet, with Davis writing herself into another utterly unredeemable lead role. She plays Emma, a confident and freewheeling woman who meets and becomes infatuated with Sally (Catherine Shepherd), a shy and unsatisfied office drone in a tedious relationship.

Emma seduces Sally, and from there inserts herself wholeheartedly into her quarry’s life. She moves into her house, turns her existence upside down, and insists that the pair are deeply in love; Sally, too reserved to argue, goes along with it.

Davis plays Emma perfectly, maintaining a degree of ambiguity to the character: does she genuinely believe she’s found love, or is she simply a monstrous opportunist? Setpieces include an episode on a film set and a corporate getaway, both of which are painfully funny and often downright disgusting.

Even more than Camping, this comedy of cruelty isn’t for the faint of heart, but it’s often downright hilarious.


20. Divorce

Divorce Sarah Jessica Parker
HBO

Sharon Horgan is the hardest working woman in comedy. In between writing and starring in breakthrough hits, she created and wrote on Divorce, the underrated, acidic sitcom featuring career best work from co-stars Sarah Jessica Parker and Thomas Haden Church as the embittered former couple at the heart of this anti-love story.

The leads play Frances and Robert, a well-to-do couple whose union falls apart when he discovers her affair. From there, the first season descends into black hearted chaos as the battling former spouses attempt to gain leverage on one another.

The serious tone of the main plot is supplemented by some hilarious side characters, most notably Molly Shannon as Frances’ nutty best pal. At times she can feel like she’s strayed in from another sitcom, but she adds much needed levity.

Warmth creeps in as the show progresses and the divorcees attempt to rebuild their lives - Horgan has a great way with characters, and creates some doozies here, who you can certainly understand if not empathise with.


19. Da Ali G Show

ali g show
Channel 4

The characters have become so ubiquitous now that it’s hard to recall a time when Sasha Baron Cohen’s creations were genuinely shocking and capable of tricking people. In its heyday, though, Da Ali G Show was the best purveyor of pranks and gotchas since the early work of Chris Morris.

In wannabe rapper Ali G, outrageous Kazakh reporter Borat, and to a lesser extent Austrian fashionista Bruno, Cohen had three golden personas with which to entrap celebrities, politicians, and experts. Interviewees, from Donald Trump to Buzz Aldrin, wanted to appear hip before Ali or tolerant and inclusive with Borat and Bruno.

Being a list of HBO shows, we’re obliged to exclude the first season with which the network wasn’t involved, but even so, the second two seasons provided some incredible and cringeworthy moments, with Cohen winding up DEA officers, Hollywood bigwigs, and the deep south en masse.

For the most part, Cohen is keen to position himself as the butt of the joke (unless he has a truly deserving target); it’s mischievous, rather than truly meanspirited TV.


18. Extras

Extras Ricky Gervais Chris Martin
BBC

For Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant, following up The Office was no mean feat. After a slow burn start, the show became one of the most beloved comedies of modern times, not to mention the most influential.

They made the smart choice to do something totally different with Extras. The first season was more self contained and accessible, with each episode seeing Gervais’ Andy Millman and Ashley Jensen’s Maggie as background performers on another film set, desperately trying to catch a break.

Andy was a totally different character to David Brent, and for the most part the comedy was less indebted to uncomfortable moments (though there’s still plenty of that), with a warm camaraderie established between the characters. The celebrity cameos were mostly used to great effect too, particularly Les Dennis, unbelievably funny as a sad sack version of himself.

The second season kept up the big laughs, though distorted the Millman character to something far more familiar to Gervais’ usual efforts. The execution of its storytelling was somewhat messy compared to the payoff The Office earned, but for laughs, it comes close.


17. Silicon Valley

Silicon Valley Kumail Starr
HBO

The world of tech geeks seems like low hanging fruit for comedy, and indeed The Big Bang Theory proved that mining gags from socially inept nerds can be an easy and lucrative business indeed. The vastly superior Silicon Valley takes a relatively similar world and proves that, with a little more effort and focus on character, there’s still fun to be had in that setting.

Co-created by comedy genius Mike Judge, Silicon Valley assembles one of the best comedy casts in recent memory: Thomas Middleditch as founder of tech firm Pied Piper, and his crew of collaborators played by Zach Woods, Martin Starr, Kumail Nanjiani, and TJ Miller (who was swiftly yanked from the show after appalling details of his personal life came to light).

Perfectly balancing an engaging plot with a high gag rate and maintaining a comedy style that hits hard without ever dipping into outright nastiness, Silicon Valley kept up its pace admirably for six seasons before bowing out on its own terms after sustained critical and commercial success. A class act of modern comedy.


16. Girls

Lena Dunham Girls
HBO

Lena Dunham’s coming of age series did a bang up job of irritating older viewers who seethed because they couldn’t relate to a story of four young women making mistakes in New York City. That’s fine - Girls really wasn’t for them. For other viewers, this was an incisive, often uncomfortably recognisable show that mixed the mundane with the deeply serious and troubling.

Dunham’s aspiring writer Hannah and her cohorts told stories preoccupied with youthful concerns - stagnant careers, unfulfilling love and sex lives - but did so in a more honest and hard hitting way than most NYC hangout sitcoms that deal with similar themes. The acting was naturalistic and often great, with a star making turn from Adam Driver.

When the show got serious, it could tackle sexual assault, consent, and mental health in stark and mature fashion. Girls strayed away from conventional story structure, and often failed to offer neat conclusions or lessons, allowing the viewer to make their own conclusions.

Its flak for focussing almost exclusively on privileged white folks is reasonable, but even if the casting wasn’t exactly inclusive, the stories told were recognisable by viewers of all stripes.


15. Flight Of The Conchords

Flight of the Conchords
HBO

Taking the ball from Tenacious D and running with it, this beloved comedy from New Zealand duo Jemaine Clement and Bret McKenzie (along with British co-creator James Bobin) excels in terms of its sitcom credentials as well as its unforgettable songs, many of which are among the finest comedy numbers ever written.

Jermaine and Bret play versions of themselves, uprooted Kiwis trying to catch a break in New York, but the pair are so delightfully otherworldly that they may as well have come from space. They’re backed by, and give generous screentime to, a fantastic supporting cast, most notably Rhys Darby as their painfully incompetent manager Murray and Kristen Schaal as Mel, the band’s singular fan/stalker.

The Concords’ USP is the music - Jermaine and Bret can turn their hand with hilarious effect (but impressive technical chops) to any genre imaginable, and do so with gusto several times an episode. They serve as their own Greek chorus, two socially stunted weirdos who can only express their feelings through song.

Everyone involved has gone on to great things, and the perfectly short lived series has cemented itself in the pantheon of comedy music for time immemorial.


14. Bored To Death

bored to death
HBO

A terribly underrated but loveable shaggy dog of a show, this comedy-noir starring Jason Schwartzman ran for three glorious seasons between 2009 and 2011. Created by novelist Jonathan Ames, Bored To Death sees Schwartzman play a fictionalised version of the creator, a frustrated writer who becomes an unlicensed private detective, primarily in order to amuse himself.

Schwartzman’s version of Ames is a good natured, romantically minded slacker, keen on the idea of working a dramatic case but too easily tempted by cold white wine and herbal remedies. He’s joined by best friend Ray, a comic book artist played by Zach Galifianakis, and George, a wealthy publisher. Ted Danson as George is the show’s ace in the hole, a charming and free spirited turn by one of the most likeable actors going.

Most episodes are based around noir-lite cases which are genuinely well plotted and intriguing, but the show is built around the loose chemistry of its leads. It’s a sitcom world you’d want to live in.


13. The Righteous Gemstones

The Righteous Gemstones
HBO

Danny McBride’s ongoing HBO project is his most ambitious to date. It’s the story of a multigenerational family of televangelists, the titular Gemstones, who rake in the cash in their megachurch, preaching the word of God while engaging in all manner of unseemly, avaristic, and downright amoral acts behind closed doors.

The family is run by John Goodman in one of his trademark blusterous performances. As Eli Gemstone he’s a man of power and greed, but, in flashbacks especially, Goodman illustrates a softer side to his widower character.

The rest of the cast is made up of McBride regulars - he plays the oldest son in an impressively layered turn; Edi Patterson is hilarious as sister Judy, unpredictable and bonkers, and Adam DeVine takes the sadsack role as youngster Kelvin. Then there’s Walton Goggins having a whale of a time as Eli’s brother-in-law "Baby" Billy Freeman.

If you’ve seen much of McBride’s work you can imagine the kind of humour on show here, but The Righteous Gemstones’ ambition and purview goes beyond that of his earlier work, and manages to work character development and real pathos into a supremely confident debut season.


In this post: 
HBO Veep
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)