Every Simpson, Griffin & Belcher Family Member Ranked
Who’s the best of these three funny families?
Animation Domination has hosted a lot of shows in its time, but there’s only been three or four which have really landed.
Golan The Insatiable, The Cleveland Show, Axe Cop, High School USA, King Of The Hill, Lucas Bros. Moving Co., Allen Gregory, Napoleon Dynamite and Sit Down Shut Up have all been in the line up over the years. Of those though, only King Of The Hill, Napoleon Dynamite and The Cleveland Show are particularly memorable, with the latter two only because of a previous connection to something much better.
This leaves The Simpsons, Family Guy, Bob’s Burgers and American Dad. However, with American Dad moving to TBS, Fox rebranded Animation Domination as Sunday Funday, though the original title will never die.
Here, each member of the Belchers from Bob’s Burgers, the Griffins from Family Guy and the Simpsons from, well, you know, have been ranked. Sorry, American Dad fans, but they’re not in Animation Domination anymore, so have been disqualified.
Brian counts as an honorary Griffin, but don’t expect to see Santa’s Little Helper or Snowball II clogging up the list. Abe neither, as he’s not a fixed family member living at 742 Evergreen Terrace.
16. Maggie Simpson
She’s a baby...
Granted, there’s another baby from a different family who features much higher up the list, but he’s involved heavily in the plot and is an iconic part of his series... plus he actually has lines every episode.
Maggie is more often than not just there. Some episodes, particularly Treehouse Of Horror episodes, cast her into the spotlight, the most notable time being when she was voiced by James Earl Jones.
Away from those though, she’s also shot Mr. Burns, saved Homer from a flying beer bottle and, on another occasion saved him from the mob. Still though, in 30 years she hasn’t contributed all that much to the general fabric of the show.
Judging her on her best moments, she’s a contender to the rest of the characters on this list; judging her on her whole run and impact, though, she’s easily bottom.
With Maggie Simpson: The Longest Daycare, she does have an Oscar nomination to her name, something which makes her unique on this list. Still, it's not enough to bump her up.
15. Lois Griffin
Only finishing above Maggie practically puts Lois last.
She's a decent part of the Griffin family, but the writers rarely do team-up episodes, with the cast mostly splitting off doing their own thing. As the show has rolled on, this has only gotten worse for Lois.
Family Guy is great at punching down; it’s not for everybody, but by now you should know what you’re getting into. Considering they don’t really try to write rounded women (the fact Jillian is one of the most developed females speaks volumes), Lois consequently bears the brunt of most gags.
The worst thing is she's not even that good at even being that; Meg makes a much better and more creative punching bag. Lois’ rare solo efforts seem to rely on ‘Ha! Wives!’ comedy. By now, it’s stale.
She used to get in on the Meg dogpile, and her one-sided rivalry with Stewie used to get a decent plot every now and then. These days though, she’s either not involved at all or a supporting character in a Peter story.
Her only interaction with her kids tends to be telling them off to set up jokes for a bigger hitter to land. She’s easily the least funny or important Griffin.
14. Marge Simpson
Marge typically gets more involved than Lois (and obviously Maggie), but she still doesn’t have all that much going on in the grand scheme of things.
She’s occasionally good for a chuckle, but like Lois, is more often than not involved as a disappointed mother or angry wife. At least with Marge this comes off as realistic though, and without the mean spirited ‘aren’t moms and wives the worst?!’ shtick from Family Guy, which often falls flat in the Griffin household.
Because of this much sweeter tone of Marge’s motherly love, she’s able to be part of much deeper, more touching stories. The Simpsons Movie revolves around Marge leaving Homer for his selfishness; it’s hard to imagine this having as much impact with Lois & Peter.
Marge Be Not Proud is one of the best examples of this, as well mining the relationship between Marge and her special little guy for genuine drama.
All too often though, especially these days, her more focussed outings rely on her yet again having marital difficulties with Homer. This plot is used at least 4 times (with 3 other maybes) in Season 30, with I Want You (She’s So Heavy) being a quiet contender for their worst ever attempt.
13. Lisa Simpson
How the mighty fall...
Taking just the Golden Era of The Simpsons into the equation, Lisa would’ve been a shoo-in for the top five; she might even have been a dark horse to finish above her brother. These days though, her character has been utterly butchered into a parody of what she once was.
Recent Lisa episodes only show her to be preachy, arrogant and unpleasantly selfish; worse, she’s often the antagonist in Bart and Homer stories. In Season 30, up to eight episodes have Lisa as the bad guy in some way or another, usually with minimal justification.
The worst ever example of this though was when she gave her patronising defence of Apu to the camera, which seemed to misunderstand the criticism anyway. Is Apu a racist depiction? Maybe, but Lisa Simpson would be the last character on the show to talk down to those fighting a perceived injustice.
Everything that made her special has been chewed up and spat out. Lisa The Vegetarian, Lisa’s Date With Density, I Love Lisa and Lisa Vs Malibu Stacy remain classics, but the last fifteen or so years have seen her stock drop massively.
12. Chris Griffin
It’s very much a statement about Lisa and not about Chris that he finishes above the Simpson girl here. Chris too has declined a little bit since Family Guy’s start, but that’s only because recent seasons seem to have stopped writing for him.
He still gets dedicated Chris episodes or cutaways where his buffoonery pays off, but he’s less and less a part of the general background. Where Stewie, Brian or Peter can pop up every now and then with a gag, even if it’s not their plot, Chris is usually vacuum sealed in his own storylines.
Going off their respective highlight reels, he’s a much, much worse character than Lisa. Since his show hasn’t chopped him up into tiny pieces, extracted his soul then stitched him back together though, he claims the spot just above her.
His carefree spirit can be endearing, but Chris is often best when he’s played off as a weirdo. Recently, Brian and Stewie tried to cure him of his internet porn addiction, taking him to a boutique to look at the girls there.
Instead, he’s more interested in the disassembled mannequins who look ‘kinda afraid’. It’s this strange Chris we need to see more of, moving forward.
11. Meg Griffin
Meg Griffin is typically just the butt of jokes in Family Guy, and you won’t find many people who’d have her as their favourite character. But here’s the thing; Family Guy writers are experts at making people the butt of jokes.
Meg might not be anyone’s favourite, but the same can be said for everyone below her too. Once we enter the top ten, that starts to ring less and less true. Of the bottom half, though, Meg comes out on top.
Meg episodes on their own aren’t great - Peter even makes a joke about this, inviting you to change the channel - but they’re a bit better than they’re given credit for.
Yes, Brian, Peter or Stewie episodes are usually the best, but examining the most recent Family Guy season sees Meg do surprisingly well. Griffin Winter Games and Girl, Internetted were both decent offerings from her which fly in the face of her reputation.
She’s still best when she’s taking the hits though. She tried to fight back a few years ago in Seahorse Seashell Party, but it didn’t land. When she just absorbs zingers, she gets a lot of laughs.
Basically, shut up Meg.
10. Gene Belcher
Gene’s ranking makes him the worst Belcher, but that’s an incredibly harsh way of looking at it.
Without giving too much away, you can expect the Belchers to all congregate around the middle of the list, and unfortunately for Gene, he’s the one left propping them up.
Unlike the Simpsons and the Griffins, the Belchers are definitely greater than the sum of their parts. Therefore, when it comes to splitting them they mostly bunch ahead of the Animation Domination weaker offerings, but below the more iconic characters.
While Gene’s trailing for them here, he actually has a fantastic dynamic with pretty much everyone in his family. He’s sweetly inappropriate, carefree and is never anything less than himself.
In the early years, he was shuffled around a little as Bob’s Burgers struggled to find its niche. The other characters didn’t really go through this, so again he’s knocked back in the ranking slightly.
Because they rely so much on family dynamics, Bob’s Burgers doesn’t go in for solo episodes all that often. When it does though, Gene episodes are pretty much the worst.
9. Linda Belcher
Linda is the best mom character of the group, and honestly it isn’t even close. The lack of Bob’s Burgers penetration into the zeitgeist means she’s the least recognisable of the trio of moms, but most Animation Domination fans would have her as their favourite.
This is probably because she’s most obviously a mother. The gags and storylines she gets play into that, and they have a warm, recognisable humour to them. Compared to Marge and especially Lois, Linda Belcher does a wonderful job of melding her motherly duties with her comedy.
Marge too is a loving mother, but a lot of her humour comes away from this stock role. Lois, meanwhile, is a terrible mother, but Family Guy tends to ignore this rather than mine what could be a rich vein of laughter.
Linda’s over enthusiasm is incredibly endearing, and she provides so many great gags, even if she doesn’t always get them herself. Her willingness to dive headfirst into new ideas is ideal for the show’s wacky plots as well.
She’s arguably the most malleable Belcher too, excelling as a lead character and supporting member, plus having success when teamed up with any of the other four in her family.
8. Tina Belcher
The third Belcher in a row, Tina is often put forward in promotional material as the face of the show, but she’s not actually their biggest hitter.
Her deadpan delivery makes for good, quick adverts to highlight the wit of the series, but across the whole series, she’s probably not the funniest. Tina episodes tend to throw a lot of focus into the supporting cast, with Jimmy Jnr, Zeke, Andy, Ollie and Tammy getting more of the spotlight.
In terms of the episodes themselves, this actually works out great, seeing as Bob’s Burgers has a huge range of wonderful characters. For Tina’s personal ranking though, it has to hurt her.
She’s one of the best characters here, across all of the Animation Domination shows, at carrying a story. More often than not though, this involves her sharing the spotlight, either with her siblings or the supporting cast.
She can be gross, with her erotic friend fiction and obsession for Jimmy Jnr’s butt and Duncan’s legs. This is never played too straight or too disturbed though, and comes off as endearingly weird.
7. Brian Griffin
Brian breaks up the typical pattern the Animation Domination families all follow of mom, dad and three kids, and also breaks the three-in-a-row streak of Belchers bunched around the middle.
Even though he’s not really part of the Griffins technically, he’s done way more than enough to be an official member of the family. It was nice to see The Simpsons Guy wink at this in the Simpsons Family Guy crossover, pairing Brian up with Santa’s Little Helper, but ultimately that did waste his potential a little.
Brian is dry, witty and typically gets some of the most creative storylines, including the fantastic Road To adventures with Stewie.
The problem with Brian is that he can be quite polarising; some would have him much higher, others much lower. He started off as a voice of reason within the madness, but evolved into more of a mouthpiece.
This works well when they lampshade it, or when Brian tries to be woke but only exposes himself as a fraud. It can definitely come off as preachy when played too straight, though.
Oh, and remember that time they pretended he was dead for a couple of episodes? Not cool.
6. Louise Belcher
Louise Belcher just misses out on the top five, but considering how legendary Family Guy and The Simpsons are compared with Bob’s Burgers (which is just, at the end of the day, a good cartoon show), it’s still a fantastic effort from her.
Pretty much all of what was said for Gene as a stand-alone star can be flipped for Louise. Sure, she still has a great dynamic with the rest of the cast, but it’s a much more dominant one.
Where Gene bounces off and roles with the punches, Louise tends to be a steamroller.
She gets the lion’s share of the cutting remarks, she drives a lot of episodes and her solo outings are usually the some of the strongest each series had to offer. Flu-oise and The Hurt Soccer particularly show how her tales can be touching as well as hilarious.
She’s had her edges sanded down a little since the earliest couple of seasons as Bob’s Burgers found its niche, but in general she’s been steady and consistent throughout. Only two of the most iconic and beloved TV youngsters keep her from being the best kid in Animation Domination‘s roster.
5. Bart Simpson
Bart is arguably the most iconic character in the Animation Domination lineup, likely generating the most TV shirt sales in his long run as America’s Bad Boy, but he has to settle for fifth here.
Just as there’s a clear difference between Meg and Gene, the gap between Louise and Bart is a pretty sizeable one too; any of the top five could have finished first, although the eventual winner did run away with it once everything was taken into account.
Bart is hilarious, makes up a key part of the show and, importantly for a show as long as The Simpsons, is far and away their best B-story star.
Recently though, partially because they’ve failed to replace Mrs. Krabappel and also due to Bart’s old-fashioned pranks not fitting a ten year old in 2019, he’s been tweaked.
He’s not always consistent episode to episode, but a good recent Bart episode is E-My Sports. Some (for once not dated) tech humour sees Bart become a professional e-sports star, bonding with Homer and finding purpose.
This episode though is ruined by (drumroll) Lisa, who forces her way into Bart’s trip, convinces Homer competing at anything is bad, and has the whole tournament shut down.
4. Bob Belcher
Finishing just a bit higher than his daughter Louise, Bob manages to break the top five and ends Bob’s Burgers’ run just shy of the medal places.
He’s the only character to have more solo episodes than Louise, and tends to work well with a lot of the supporting cast like Mr. Fishoder and Teddy as well. Typically the season openings, finales and holiday specials are thrown Bob’s way, though this isn’t a given.
The most recent season finale, Yes Without My Zeke, has him in a fun (but minor) bit part back at the restaurant while the kids have the A-plot. This, however, proved to be a lacklustre season finale compared to the previous Something Old, Something New, Something Bob Caters For You, which has Bob leading and is possibly the show’s best.
H. Jon Benjamin does some great voice work as the character, just as he does with Archer and Family Guy’s Carl. Bob’s weary and irritable nature which occasionally spills over is a massive part of what makes the show a hit too.
Though he’s finishing as the lowest ranked dad, he’s clearly the best actual father in the bunch too.
3. Peter Griffin
Despite talk in Bart’s entry of any of the five being worthy winners, Bart’s frequent recharacterisation and Bob’s Burgers lack of a real animation legacy chopped it down to three favourites. Unfortunately for him, Peter finishes third in a very, very tight three horse race.
More than Bob’s Burgers or The Simpsons, Family Guy throws the focus onto Peter almost entirely. It’s very rare that he’s not either in the A-plot or a bloated B-plot, extended to give him some room. Stewie and Brian adventures are the only true exception to this, and even then they usually have cutaways with something ‘the fat man’ did.
He’s the worst husband and father by a distance, but this sets up so many gags that it makes Peter much more likeable; at least in the dark comedy stylings of Family Guy.
The show does seem to just think up Peter Does Something plots these days though. Trans Fat sees him mistaken as transgender, but the show does nothing with it.
The jokes are just lazy, about how all women order salad, drink wine and fart when waiters aren’t nearby. Strange. Very strange.
Still, across all the seasons, he’s a great character.
2. Stewie Griffin
Victory shall be his! Well, not quite...
Stewie pips his dad Peter as the best Griffin around and claims his spot in second place. It was a close run thing, but Stewie’s slightly more subtle humour means he can get more jabs in and steal the spotlight. His bonus answers on Family Fight, such as 9/11 being his favourite holiday, are possibly the best example of this.
He also gets great action sequences; Stewie Kills Lois/Lois Kills Stewie being classic examples, Pal Stewie bringing it this year. This dynamic with Brian is easily the best out of any Animation Domination pairing, even if plots involving those two can sometimes get too weird.
Their decision to throw him the 300th episode (which ended up airing as the 301st, go figure), didn’t work out though.
Send In Stewie Please might have been a decent examination of his inner psyche, but it seemed too erratic and too focussed on showing us how clever Stewie is; after 300 episodes we’re more than aware, and most would have preferred a more introspective episode, given the set up of a psychiatric evaluation.
And lets just all forget that time he got pregnant with Brian’s babies, shall we?
1. Homer Simpson
Homer Simpson is, quite possibly, the greatest cartoon character ever. He faces some stiff competition, not least from some others on this list, but with The Simpsons having such a monumentally long run with Homer at the centre, he has to be top.
Yes, the show’s not as good as it used to be. But to still be around in any form after 661 episodes is frankly staggering for a cartoon. For reference, Family Guy is at 329. Bob’s Burgers? ‘Just’ 171, which is still a pretty amazing showing.
Never say never, but it’s highly unlikely either will get to The Simpsons’ record, especially with Homer and the rest renewed through two more seasons, taking them comfortably over 700.
Early on, the show switched from having Bart at the centre to having Homer, and they haven’t really looked back. This change ushered in the Golden Era, pumping out some of the best animated episodes the world has ever produced.
Homer The Smithers, You Only Move Twice, Last Exit To Springfield, Homer’s Phobia, Homer’s Enemy... the list goes on and on (and on and on) of simply outstandingly high quality episodes with Homer at the centre. Nobody else could really come first.