Every Star Trek Series Ranked Worst To Best

Where does Picard rank?

Every Star Trek Series
CBS

Star Trek is a bastion of science fiction, offering hundreds of hours of examples of truly superior storytelling. It has largely aimed for the philosophical side of the future, occasionally forced to do out of budgetary issues. This was not Star Wars and there weren't millions of dollars lying around to pump into action scenes. While the budget has clearly grown in the half century that Star Trek has been on the air, the central tenet of the show has been the exploration of strange new worlds.

Some of the entries in the franchise have displayed this more successfully than others. With so many years of storytelling behind us, it is inevitable that some of the entries will struggle to match with the best while conversely some of the so-called worst often have nuggets of gold hidden, if one only has the patience to look.

From Captain Kirk's first days aboard the Enterprise to Jean Luc Picard's most recent flight aboard the La Sirena, this list ranks the current Star Trek series in order from those struggling the rise above to those which are as close to perfect and Science Fiction television has yet offered.

With more new series on the way, this list is likely to change over time but for now, here are the rankings as stands.

8. The Animated Series

Star Trek Animated
CBS

The Animated Series is an oddity in the Star Trek franchise. It is considered both canon and not, containing elements that would crop up later in the show. It is the Animated Series after all that finally gave the audience Kirk's full name - James Tiberius Kirk. Elements of Spock's childhood were developed here and then later included in the main series. The Search for Spock and Unification both employ some of these story elements.

The series was also the first Star Trek series to win an Emmy. That the show features at the bottom of this list is not so much a comment on its own strengths but rather a sign that the shows that followed and preceded were superior in terms of both quality and quantity. Unfortunately, the Animated Series only ran for one season. It was characterised by writer D.C. Fontana as the Original Series' fourth season.

As there was such a long hiatus between the Original Series and what eventually became the Motion Picture, the Animated Series served as a way to keep interest in the show alive, providing both the actors and some of the crew with paid work in the intervening years. It also was also served by another example of Leonard Nimoy's good nature - he refused to work on the show unless both Nichelle Nichols and George Takei were rehired as well.

Only Walter Koenig's voice did not return, as Chekov was cut. He did however manage to write a script that was included, so all returned in their own way.


7. Discovery

Star Trek Discovery Opening
CBS

Discovery is a show that is improving rapidly. The very shaky first season was succeeded by the wonderful second season. It is by no means the only Star Trek entry to have a rough first year, which seems to have become almost a tradition in the franchise (with one notable exception). The effects are stunning in the show and it benefits from the shorter seasons, allowing for a punchier story delivery and suiting the action well.

However, while this issue has largely been rectified by the end of the second season, Discovery was rather hollow at times. Characters that should have been given more time to breathe were instead fired at the screen with the confidence that the audience would love them regardless. With Saru, this worked in the first season. With Burnham, it did not. In fact, it was very late in the day before Burnham truly became a sympathetic character.

That being said, the show's bold choice to rocket the crew into the far future may end up being one of the best decisions that has been made in the franchise to date. This is not simply to quell the fears of the purists who worry slavishly about canon. This opens up the arena for a level of storytelling not seen since Kirk's first five year mission.

Discovery has truly sailed into the unknown and should the gamble pay off, a future version of this list may well see it shoot ahead in the rankings.


6. The Original Series

Star Trek The Original Series Plato
NBC

Groundbreaking. Pioneering. Era and genre defining. Star Trek beamed onto screens in 1966, offering two pilots, two captains. three seasons and one iconic Vulcan first officer. It is the only entry not to have a terrible first season, as Balance of Terror, The City on the Edge of Forever and Space Seed all fall in that first batch of episodes. It is another entry that lies lower in the ranking because it was the catalyst to some truly fantastic television to follow.

While there simply isn't enough time to properly discuss the impact that this series has had on science fiction in general, suffice it to say that many of the developments in technology can attribute their genesis to this show. While many of the cast have sadly passed away in the intervening years, their legacy can be felt to this day. James Doohan will be remembered forever whenever someone cries 'Beam me up, Scotty!'.

Deforest Kelley is the quintessential doctor, who is a doctor and nothing else, dammit. Spock is logic incarnate, played to perfection by Leonard Nimoy - the only actor to reprise his role in the Kelvin universe films. Perhaps even more widely remembered than Spock is Captain Kirk, played by the still very much alive William Shatner. Generations of fans have grown to love his dramatic delivery, his quiet command and his gung-ho attitude.

This was television at its best when the world was still learning what that meant.


5. Enterprise

E2 Star Trek Enterprise
NBC

The oft-unfairly maligned Enterprise comes in at roughly midway in the rankings. It was a show that was a product of its time, in spite of its time. Appearing on air in the aftermath of the devastating September 11th attacks, this was a show that was determined to present a positive and upbeat view of the future. While the idea of a prequel had been developed long before the show's inception, it became a seemingly great way to show the world a brighter future, right when it was deemed necessary.

Most unfortunately, the world began to move in other directions. While Enterprise was polished and stuck to the Starfleet M.O., shows like Battlestar Galactica were rising in the Sci-Fi ranks, showing a future that was a grim retelling of the current War on Terror.

While neither show did particularly well in the ratings, it was clear that the world was opening up to far darker ideas. Even the most light Stargate SG-1 felt these darkening effects. Enterprise attempted to adapt and the show's heavy third season - taking place in the aftermath of a devastating shock attack on America/Earth - became one of its best. The Xindi Arc though still managed to reflect something of Roddenberry's hopes.

While Enterprise zoomed off into the expanse to hunt down those responsible for millions of deaths, in the end they manage to secure peace with the aggressor. It may not be Star Trek of the '60s, but Enterprise has everything that a great Trek entry needs.


4. Picard

Star Trek Picard
CBS

When news broke that Patrick Stewart was returning to the role of Picard, Trek fans lost their minds globally. This was the news that they had been waiting for since 2002 - finally, a post Star Trek Nemesis show was coming. Finally, a chance to see what had been happening with all of our favourite characters. What the fans received was something very different from what came before. The show attempts to walk a line between optimism and the dark pessimism that crept in around the time of Enterprise and the result is debatable.

There is much to love in Picard's freshman year. There is a compelling mystery and the effects are stunning. The opening shot of the Enterprise D delivered chills and the return of Stewart to the role was a true joy. However, the season fell into some of the same issues as Discovery. While this was very much not the Next Generation - perfectly acceptable - it didn't seem to know what it wanted to be. Should it be quiet and contemplative?

If so, it raced forward at breakneck pace, featuring action for action sake. Should then it be a Sci-Fi opera, the likes of Discovery? If so, it spent too much time mired in lore. The fallout was that the show, while certainly delivering many excellent moments and new characters, stumbled through its first season. The acting though is stellar and the final scene between Jean Luc and Data pushed the series up a couple of ranks.

With some luck, season two will continue a positive trend.


3. Voyager

Star Trek Voyager Resolutions
CBS Media Ventures

Much can and has been said about the wonderful Jeri Ryan's introduction as Seven of Nine and her return in Star Trek Picard. But it was in Voyager that she cut her teeth on the role, firmly planting herself as part of a fantastic ensemble of characters. Kate Mulgrew's portrayal as Captain Janeway led this show through the prerequisite dodgy first couple of years and into the fans' hearts as one of the most beloved Trek entries.

One of the criticisms most often fired at Voyager was that it was very similar to the Next Generation in its style and tone. There is a degree of truth to that but that is also one of the show's strengths. This was Starfleet, lost in the Delta Quadrant and exploring strange new worlds. It was an adventure show but without any help from the rest of the Federation. It was a gamble that paid off dividends.

The show ran for seven seasons, developing a strong fandom and inspiring an upcoming documentary. It matched the Next Generation in one respect certainly. This crew was a family, as diverse as any but as close as any other. Maquis and Starfleet put aside their differences.

Klingon, Vulcan, Hologram and Borg all learn to be as one. With many stand out episodes along the way, Voyager was perhaps the best example of the search for strange new worlds out of the entire franchise, bearing the torch of Roddenberry for years after his sun finally set.


2. Deep Space Nine

Deep Space Nine The Visitor
NBC

Controversial from the beginning, Deep Space Nine broke the mould, ditching the episodic star ship formula and setting the action firmly in the one place, on a space station over a distant planet. From the beginning, the show was dark. The Federation moved in to help a world recently freed from occupation to rebuild. Religion plays a key theme throughout the series and there is an open dialogue on the merits of terrorism in the struggle for freedom.

If Roddenberry wanted to teach humanity to rise above their failings, then Deep Space Nine was often the mirror that showed those failings, warts and all. This was not a bright and Utopian view of the future. This was darkness. This was strife. This was failing to understand and love thy neighbour. This was sectarianism and xenophobia, hidden under the veneer of Starfleet.

It was also the most character driven entry to the franchise. The very setting of most of the action in one place allowed the show to explore the consequences of those actions. Something that may happen in the first or second season could reappear in the fifth or sixth, linking perfectly in with the character growth as shown on screen.

The Dominion War was created to show what Starfleet was capable of in the future, not unlike the decision to embrace the Navy in the Wrath of Khan. Time has brought more fans to the station than initially visited and the recent losses of Rene Auberjonois and Aron Eisenberg are sorely, sorely felt.


1. The Next Generation

Star Trek The Next Generation Darmok
CBS

The Next Generation redefined what Star Trek was. With only the Original Series to content with, it was in largely uncharted territory, taking place roughly eighty years later. The straight laced Captain Picard seemed a far cry from the fun Captain Kirk. Commander Riker was no Spock. The doctor was a woman this time? Surely not! Then they put a Klingon on the bridge and a blind guy flies the ship? What's next, robots in uniform?

The show has become the most beloved entry in the franchise. The cast's bond is so pure and heartwarming that it continues to bring joy to fans to this day. The show explored themes of exploration like never before, becoming the example for what first contact should be with alien races. Picard's diplomacy was legendary and his capture by the Borg was terrifying.

Yet, in that same moment, who didn't root for Riker to rise to the occasion and become the captain we all knew he could be? This series, more so than any of the rest, embodied Roddenberry's brave new world, his Utopia. There was largely no conflict on board ship, something which frustrated the writers but allowed beautiful on screen relationships to rise.

The ship was stunning, the music emotive and the alien cultures both explored and developed. Here, the Klingon strive for honour was truly defined. Romulan duplicity and Cardassian militarism were introduced and the all-knowing Q saw everything. The show may be no more but if Picard keeps even some of that spirit alive, then the future of the franchise is moving in a very good direction.


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Seán is the host and head writer/presenter for TrekCulture, as well as a writer/presenter on WhoCulture and WhatCulture Horror. He has authored two novels, dozens of short stories, and hundreds of articles for WhatCulture. He holds a Master of Arts in Creative Writing from University College Dublin. As part of his work with TrekCulture, Seán has been invited to participate in collaborations with Roddenberry Entertainment, as well as contributing to several Star Trek community projects. An avid fan of Star Trek, Doctor Who, and the horror genre at large, Seán's expertise has helped develop these channels to the successes they are today. As host of the Ups & Downs series on TrekCulture, Seán has become internationally recognised for his positive yet critically informed approach to reviewing every episode of modern Star Trek, ensuring he is one of the go-to voices in the Trek community. Favourite Quote to describe himself: "I'm serious about what I do, just not always about the way that I do it"