Every Sword Art Online Season Ranked Worst To Best
Aincrad? Gun Gale Online? The Underworld? Which virtual realities did it best?!
When it comes to Sword Art Online, a very common adage arises, and that's "you either love it, or you hate it". The divisive anime exploded in popularity after its release, much to the delight of many, and the irritation of others.
The world of virtual reality gaming, MMORPG's, and epic sword fights is full of action, romance and quirky characters, but it's also incredibly inconsistent. When watching the series through the first time, you'll be mesmerised by some incredible sequences and the great dynamic between the lead characters, but will also find yourself scratching your head wondering why certain decisions were made.
SAO's narrative directions, visual style and alternate worlds have felt different during each arc, and that has helped to make the series feel anthology-like. If you don't enjoy one season, you only need to wait for the next one to try something else entirely.
Ultimately, it's a very up and down series, with soaring highs and crushing lows, but by taking the good with the bad, it can be easy to discuss what makes this anime so special.
(This list will only include the mainline anime, and thus Ordinal Scale and Gun Gale Online Alternative won't be included, but both deserve an honourable mention.)
7. Alfheim Online - Season 1, Part 2
It really could be nothing else. The second half of season one, otherwise known as the Fairy Dance Arc, is such a poor example of an anime reinventing itself that it's easy to see why many viewers thought they'd be done with the series.
The land of Alfheim did have some plus points, but the overwhelming majority of the season was made up of awkward choices and character destroying moments.
In this arc, Kirito - freshly escaped from SAO - ventures to a new VR game called Alfheim online to save Asuna who's still trapped in the Nerve Gear. Alongside this is a narrative with his cousin Sughua as she plays the game with Kasuto and battles her feelings for him.
The pseudo-incestuous angle between Kirito and Sughua is uncomfortable and continues the trend of female characters falling in love with Kirito. It does have some great emotional moments but felt like a baffling romantic choice.
However, the worst aspect of the arc has to be the treatment of Asuna. She went from being a badass second in command and dual protagonist to a damsel in distress who's quite literally trapped in a birdcage. It was disappointing character assassination, and the new VR world didn't distract from it.
6. Calibur - Season 2, Part 2
Sword Art Online II's second half goes in a strange direction, as it inserts an additional arc that only lasts a few episodes. Now, this could work well as a nice break from the norm and a quick side adventure, but only if the arc was good, and in this case, it wasn't.
The Calibur arc follows Kirito, Asuna and friends as they go on a quest for the legendary sword Excalibur and find themselves responsible for saving all of Alfheim. While that sounds somewhat exciting on paper, the arc is a rather mundane experience, as the stakes just aren't high enough.
Each arc thus far has brought real-life threats into the game, but here, it simply feels like they are partaking in a quest, which makes it feel unimportant. Towards the end, nothing has changed as no one believed Alfheim would get destroyed, and Kirito barely even makes use of the sword he receives.
Plus, the fact that one of the central characters was a jellyfish elephant named Tonky goes to show just how silly this arc was. It felt entirely out of character with the rest of the show, as there was no real danger, and it was simply filler.
5. Gun Gale Online - Season 2, Part 1
Sword Art Online II had to work hard to cleanse the viewers' palettes after the disastrous Alfheim online arc, so they came in with an entirely new direction, and it worked pretty well - for the most part.
The dramatic changes seemed too much at first, but the introduction of an alternative world and new weapons promoted a positive shift for the show.
In the Gun Gale Online arc, Kirito finds himself contracted to investigate the titular game, as a rogue player called Death Gun's in-game kills have resulted in real life deaths. So, he grabs a Photon Sword (or lightsaber, if you want Disney's lawyers to get involved), and jumps in.
There are plenty of positives to this arc, such as the introduction of Asada Shino and her tragic backstory, the world of GGO itself and the thrilling connection to SAO's Laughing Coffin guild. However, there are a few drawbacks that keep it just shy of being great.
This mainly comes down to the slow pacing towards the end. The arc starts rather explosively but soon slows down as the Bullet of Bullets tournament begins, and you watch as Sinon and Kirito talk and wait for Death Gun to appear.
It was a solid way to start the second season but wasn't quite perfect.
4. Aincrad - The Beginning - Season 1, Part 1
If there's one thing you can give credit to Sword Art Online for, it's that the anime makes it clear from the offset whether it's for you or not.
The humble (town of) beginnings for this series introduces the world and characters wonderfully and gives you a clear taste of what to expect. It's awkward and a little rough around the edges, but the Aincrad arc showed why this anime became such a juggernaut.
SAO opens with the most simple narrative, as the online MMORPG releases and all the players who enter find that they cannot log out and are told they must clear the game to escape. To make matters even scarier, if they die in the game, it will result in their permanent death IRL.
The arc is full of quirky characters, epic fight sequences and some genuinely emotional moments, but it's the connection between Asuna and Kirito that it lives by. The dynamic between them and their budding romance is intense and quick, but you can invest in it quickly, thanks to how much the show commits to it.
Plus, seeing Kirito rise through the ranks, becoming more powerful in each episode keeps the arc moving forward, and it all concludes with an epic twist and an emotional climax.
3. Mother's Rosario - Season 2, Part 3
It's safe to say that the Mother's Rosario arc is easily the hardest-hitting segment of the show, and it worked hard to try and rectify some of the mistakes of the past.
Unlike other arcs, this one places Asuna Yuuki in the role of the protagonist, and while it doesn't make up for the show's poor treatment of one of their best characters, it still gives her a fantastic chance to shine.
Mother's Rosario focuses on Asuna's involvement with the Sleeping Knights guild as she befriends their leader Yuuki and forms a bond with them. However, a dark and tragic secret causes a rift between them, leading to one of the show's most emotional character arcs.
You get so much this season as the straightforward narrative allows for a quieter and more intimate story. Learning about Asuna's home life and her connection to her mother was a smart way to make her feel more three-dimensional. Plus, the character of Yuuki also manages to charm you before breaking your heart entirely.
This arc did something genuinely sentimental and dignified, which is what helps it to rank so high.
2. Alicization - Season 3
It seemed that SAO was always going to be a guilty pleasure anime, but the Alicization arc came along and showed fans that there was something better behind it. The shift to a more serious tone and the focus on AI was the right move for the series, as it went in a far more mature direction.
Alicization shows as Kirito is put into a land known as The Underworld through a machine known as a Soul Translator. Here, he works with his friend Eugeo and a girl named Alice to reach The Administrator.
Gone were the days of overly-sexualised characters - for the most part - and replacing it was a surprisingly gritty and honest narrative. It marks some of the show's darkest moments, and the slick animation combined with the new aesthetics helps give it a completely different vibe from the rest of SAO.
Plus, taking an entire 24 episodes to explore the arc meant that it could really take its time. Instead of going a mile a minute and shoving a lot at you, Alicization walks you through this new world at a leisurely pace before attacking you with thrilling action sequences and swordplay.
It was a genius direction for the series, but it would only get better...
1. Alicization - War Of The Underworld
The last entry on this list discussed how the Alicization arc managed to take its time and span a whole season, but that's ignoring the fact that it continued for a whole further 24 episodes.
Taking this entire narrative and spanning it across two epic seasons was a great move, and this second half brought the spectacle to new heights.
Carrying on directly from the last arc, this one shows as Alice vows to protect the human territory from the invading dark territory, leading to a slew of epic encounters and a war for the ages. Unlike the previous season, this one introduces Asuna into the mix, which adds something a little more familiar to the show.
War of the Underworld doesn't work too hard to do anything different narratively, but it delivers on the visuals well. It even ends up rivalling the spectacle that was presented in the SAO Movie: Ordinal Scale, which pulled out all the stops to be as big as possible.
Overall, it's a fantastic conclusion to the Alicization arc and ditched a lot of the awkwardness of the previous seasons, which grants it the highest position here.
Watch Next
You'll Never Be Able To Name 100% Of These Anime Villains