Frasier: How It Should Be Re-Cast In 2021

Seattle's finest: the new breed.

Frasier Recast
Paramount

The much-mooted reboot of Frasier continues to toil in TV development purgatory. Kelsey Grammer, in particular, frequently teases his impending return as everyone’s favorite stuffy small screen psychiatrist, but at this stage, it’s starting to feel like this may never happen. Depending on your perspective though, this may be a good or bad thing.

So instead of seeing an ageing Grammer slide back into the tweed, let’s consider how we might recast Frasier in 2022. The original show boasted a tight, brilliant cast with disparate characters who complemented one another perfectly, pulling in sitcom stalwarts and dramatic actors for a melting pot that worked like gangbusters for 11 remarkably consistent seasons.

It’s tough to imagine anyone else playing Niles, Roz, or - particularly - the titular Crane himself, but the world of TV is crammed full of talented performers who could, given the time, make the roles their own.

Perhaps one day we’ll see Grammer return to Seattle to once again sneer and quip at the mores of crass modernity, but he’s done it for 22 years. Maybe it’s time to let someone else have a go.

5. Frasier Crane - Paul F. Tompkins

Community Tv Show
Sony Pictures Television

TV fans may recognise Paul F. Tompkins from most of the past decade’s best sitcoms: Community, Curb, Brooklyn Nine-Nine. He’s previously featured more heavily on Mr Show, and even appeared on an episode of Frasier back in the day. He’s a visible presence, even if you don’t know his name.

To lovers of comedy at large, though, Tompkins has long been a superstar. He’s pretty much the king of comedy podcasts, appearing frequently on every major funny show you can think of, particularly Comedy Bang! Bang!, and his stand up ranks among the best in the world.

Tompkins could have a whale of a time getting stuck into the verbose dialogue of Frasier, and has somewhat of an old soul quality to him that could be tweaked to fit the tenor of the show, whether the good doctor is rhapsodising about opera or bemoaning the latest depths pop culture has sunk to.

He also has a delightful, mellifluous voice (which he lends to Bojack Horseman) that any self respecting radio DJ needs. He’s long deserved a major role like this, and would absolutely nail it.


4. Roz Doyle - Sharon Horgan

Catastrophe Sharon Horgan
Channel 4

After 10 years of quality work, Sharon Horgan finally cracked the US in earnest with Catastrophe, the delightful romcom she created and starred in with Rob Delaney. From there, she has been in high demand on the big and small screen, with her previous work like Pulling getting a well deserved rediscovery.

With her relatability, humour, and ability to skirt the line between confidence and vulnerability, there could be no better choice to play Frasier’s radio producer and foil Roz Doyle. Alongside Martin, Roz’s role was to act as an earthy counterpoint to Frasier’s pomposity, a worldly woman who was always on hand to puncture Frasier’s booksmart buffoonery.

Over time, though, Roz was given weightier stories of her own, and Morgan has repeatedly proved her chops as a dramatic actress. Most recently in This Way Up she put in a heartbreaking turn as Aisling Bea’s sister, a woman who seemed to have her life in place but couldn’t resist putting a spanner in the works.

Tompkins and Morgan would make for a fantastic comedic double act, and Morgan could likely bring even more to this meaty role.


3. Niles Crane - Jim Parsons

Jim Parsons
Chris Pizzello/AP

All-consuming sitcom The Big Bang Theory wasn’t for everyone, but it’s hard to have anything but praise for the performance of Jim Parsons. As neurodivergent physicist Sheldon Cooper, Parsons was tasked with making a difficult and often unpleasant figure the hero of the story.

He achieved this by delving into the minutiae of Cooper, turning what could have been a tedious and robotic (and even problematic) character into a living, breathing character. While Niles Crane was a fundamentally more pleasant figure, David Hyde Pierce similarly built his performance out of micro-moments, making the deeply silly character the heart of the whole show. Witness his balletic slapstick or the way he’s entranced by Daphne - it’s studied but human.

Parsons can do prissy in his sleep, and is adept at portraying a character who you simultaneously love but want to see knocked down a few pegs. He’s proved that he has many more strings to his bow than his most famous role, and could bring to the part the requisite combination of dignity and foolishness.


2. Daphne Moon - Mandip Gill

Doctor Who Series 13 Mandip Gill as Yaz
BBC

Much of Frasier’s comedy came from its many culture clashes, often earthiness vs academia. In the case of Daphne, not only was she from another nation to the rest of the characters, but often another planet, a would-be psychic who believed deeply in the whims of fate in spite of scorn from skeptic Frasier et al.

To take the role of the spacey therapist, how about an actress with genuine (sort of) outer space experience? Mandip Gill is best known for her role as Yasmin Khan, a companion to the 13th iteration of Doctor Who. In the beloved BBC sci-fi drama she was asked to do a bit of everything, with the show’s brand of charming silliness sometimes making way for a more serious character with mental health issues.

To this end she would be perfect for Daphne, a character who starts out as the show’s most nakedly sitcommy presence but slowly becomes part of the series’ most detailed and emotional arc, her slow simmering love connection with Niles.

Gill has been steadily making her name in the UK and is poised for a true breakthrough in a starring role. She could be a revelation in this; unlike Jane Leeves, she even has an authentic Northern accent.


1. Martin Crane - John Lithgow

dexter john lithgow trinity killer
Showtime

Since his last sitcom run on Third Rock From The Sun, John Lithgow has reestablished himself as a brilliant and versatile dramatic actor. On the small screen particularly he has done astonishing work as a terrifying killer on Dexter and as Winston Churchill on The Crown, along with continued success in the movies.

But perhaps his greatest skill comes when he paints with a lighter touch, and there can be few actors better equipped to take on the deep role of Martin Crane than Lithgow. Like the late John Mahoney he could bring his years of thespian experience across a multitude of formats to the table and build a character who’s so much more than a grumpy sitcom dad.

The heart of early Frasier was the thawing of the somewhat icy relationship between father and son, two opinionated men who’d been apart for many years. Lithgow would be ideal capturing the sense of a man of action finally accepting that his virile days were behind him.

Key to the sitcom format: he’s also a very funny guy with proven chops on episodic telly. There’s every chance Lithgow doesn’t want to get tied to another long running sitcom, but for Martin Crane, he’s the guy.


In this post: 
Frasier
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)