Game Of Thrones: 10 Smartest Changes HBO Made From The Books

It really wasn't all bad you know.

A Song Of Ice And Fire

Let's face facts, seasons 5 through 8 of GOT were not as good as 1 through 4.

The decline in quality is largely due to the show being forced to work without any original source material.

It's not entirely the show's fault, the book kept getting delayed and Martin tried to keep as much of it as secret as possible to prevent spoilers forcing more improvisation. Also adapting A Feast for Crows (often thought of as being the weakest book in the series) and A Dance with Dragons would haven been an unenviable task for anyone.

Unlike the first three books the story takes place across multiple locations that don't interconnect with one another and the timelines jump around a lot. There was also a huge amount of focus given to characters whose stories went nowhere (looking at you Sam!) whilst some key characters seemed largely forgotten like Sansa. That's before you meet all the new characters that keep being added throughout like Aegon Targaryen.

There was too much ground to cover and a lot of altering was required in order to fit in with the narrative the show had been telling.

Having said that, there was still fun to be had in the later episodes: some of the best action in the entire series, twists and revelations as well as key moments with devastating emotional impact.

Let's focus on the good times, and of course spoilers ahead, duh!

10. The Finale

A Song Of Ice And Fire

No, it wasn't to everyone's taste but the endings to long-running series very rarely please everyone.

You can pull at those loose threads all you want, but season 8's final episode stood out as its best. It was full of the emotionally driven performances and bittersweet moments that the rest of the series had been lacking.

It also felt more in tune with Martin's style of storytelling, obviously we don't know how the books end yet, but the show's creators were informed of the important mile stones. How they get there was up to them.

Inevitably it will be fun to see what changes are made in the books and how much so. Characters achieved what they wanted, just not necessarily in the manner they expected and helped to bookend the entire series marvellously.

Sansa did get to become a queen, Jon went back to serve at The Wall and Arya went on her gap year.

You may have rolled your eyes at Bronn and his brothel fixation and maybe you expected Bran, with his god-like powers, to do something more remarkable than become king, but the good far outweighed the bad.

The important thing is we got a largely satisfactory ending.


Alex Harvey hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.