Game Of Thrones: 5 Great Characters Ruined By Poor Writing
David Benioff and D.B. Weiss completely lost their way in the final season...
George R.R. Martin is one of the best fantasy writers alive today. Though his work is heavily influenced by the godfather of modern fantasy – J.R.R. Tolkien – Martin stands out from the crowd due to his knack for writing nuanced characters who undertake fascinating evolutions.
In the earlier seasons of Game of Thrones, Martin’s characters were expertly brought to life. The casting for the show was spot on, and due to David Benioff and D.B. Weiss’s ability to adapt the source material, the scripts were impressive as well.
Unfortunately, the showrunners lost their way without the guidance of Martin’s books. This became increasingly apparent after Season 4, which is regarded by many as the peak of the show. And the longer Game of Thrones went on, the more the dialogue and the storylines started to lose their shine.
The receding quality of the show was particularly obvious in the final season. Many of the major characters were wrecked by poor decisions from the showrunners who seemed to prioritise subverting expectations over anything else. Even the outstanding performances from the cast weren’t enough to salvage the poor writing from Benioff and Weiss…
5. Daenerys Targaryen
Daenerys underwent a huge transformation over the course of eight seasons. During her time in Essos, she changed from the tame daughter of a Targaryen prince to an admirable yet fearsome queen. With an ever-increasing army to support her, she made her way through Slaver’s Bay and freed the inhabitants of Astapor, Yunkai, and Meereen.
Whilst the majority of her evolution was authentic, her decision to burn King’s Landing in the final season was ridiculous. Such a move would have been more understandable had Daenerys been on the verge of defeat. But this wasn’t the case – her victory was sealed the moment the Lannister army rang the bells of the city as a sign of surrender.
This crucial moment in the show’s final season wasn’t flat-out terrible owing to the brilliant performances and the mesmerising score from Ramin Djawadi. It’s just a shame Daenerys’ descent into madness was far too abrupt to be taken seriously.
4. Jon Snow
Jon Snow wasn’t one of the most distinctive characters when Game of Thrones first aired. Yet he gradually won the affection of fans through his goodwill and determination. And as the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark, he was also one of the key contenders for the Iron Throne.
But the problems with this character arose in the final season. His relationship with Daenerys was never very authentic. Aside from the fact the Mother of Dragons also happened to be his aunt, their romantic interactions never felt sincere, especially when compared with Jon’s relationship with Ygritte.
Whilst Jon certainly played his part in The Battle of Winterfell, he was marginalised in ‘The Last of the Starks’ and ‘The Bells’. What's more, his decision to betray Daenerys lacked any dramatic tension due to the nonsensical events that occurred beforehand.
The only saving grace was the reunion with Ghost – his dire wolf. But this still wasn’t enough to redeem Jon’s lack of involvement in the rest of the season.
3. Tyrion Lannister
Tyrion Lannister is George R.R. Martin’s favourite character, and it’s easy to see why. He’s witty, smart, and easily the most likeable member of House Lannister.
Peter Dinklage captured the brilliance of this character remarkably well and earned multiple awards for his performance. Indeed, Tyrion’s storyline in Season 4 (which involved him being falsely accused of Joffrey’s death and then having to flee King’s Landing) is a strong contender for the best part of the whole show.
Unsurprisingly, issues started to arise once the show ran out of source material. Specifically, Tyrion’s time as Hand of the Queen was not well-written. For one thing, it was strange just how quickly Daenerys was willing to give him such a prestigious position, and Tyrion wasn’t particularly successful with his new role. Thanks to his strategies, Yara’s fleet was destroyed and the Unsullied were trapped inside Casterly Rock.
In fairness, Tyrion did have some good scenes in the final season – such as his conversation with Sansa in the first episode. But just like Jon, he was also marginalised. Most frustratingly of all, he did next to nothing during the Battle of Winterfell despite having fought previously throughout the show.
2. Arya Stark
Arya Stark had one of the best storylines in the earlier seasons of Game of Thrones. Her adventures in Harrenhal and her time with Sandor Clegane were particularly good.
But Arya’s story started to go awry in Season 5 when she arrived in Braavos. The inhabitants of the House of Black and White were rather dull compared with the Hound, and Arya seemed to spend most of her time sweeping floors. In fairness, her rivalry with the Waif was interesting, but this wasn’t enough to salvage Arya’s storyline in the fifth and sixth seasons.
Sadly, Arya became an even worse character in the final two seasons. The main issue was how powerful she became in such a short space of time, which by extent made her less relatable. Her battle with Brienne whilst at Winterfell was a clear sign that the writers had lost the plot. Given Brienne’s experience and strength, there’s no way Arya would be able to match her.
To top it all off, Benioff and Weiss even gave Arya the privilege of defeating the Night King. Given Jon’s history with this iconic antagonist, he should have been the one to deliver the final blow, not Arya.
1. Jamie Lannister
Jamie Lannister’s redemption arc was brilliantly written for the first seven seasons. He went from being one of the most hated characters in the entire show to being one of the most adored. But like many things in Game of Thrones, it all went downhill in Season 8.
One of the central components of Jamie’s journey was how he compared with his sister. As the show went on, he gradually became more honourable, whereas Cersei became more villainous. Benioff and Weiss somehow missed this crucial aspect of Jamie’s character and decided to reunite him with his sister during the closing stages of Season 8.
Many fans had even speculated that Jamie would be the one to kill Cersei. As well as tying in with the prophecy Cersei heard as a child, it would have been a satisfactory conclusion to Jamie’s character arc.
Whilst Nikolaj Coster-Waldau was still terrific in Season 8 (especially in his scenes with Peter Dinklage), his character deserved a much better send-off. Fans can only hope George R.R. Martin will deliver a stronger ending for Jamie than Benioff and Weiss did.
Which great characters do you think were ruined by poor writing? Leave your thoughts below in the comments thread.
Game Of Thrones Quiz: Who Said It – Jamie Or Cersei?