Game Of Thrones: What If… Ned Stark Was Still Alive?

It would just be better. OKAY?

'Ooh have you seen that new HBO show with Sean Bean', 'Ooh it's quite good isn't it?', 'Ooh they won't kill him though, he's the only one I've heard of'. Oh, if we could travel back to 2011 and warn people of the misery that was about to grip their lives. Ned Stark's death remains the turning point for the entire Game Of Thrones series, transforming a deep, intriguing fantasy world, into a horribly shocking land where nobody is safe. In TV and film, there's always a well-placed escape route for the lead star, but Thrones obliterated the comfort zone by killing their biggest name inside nine episodes. Since then, the show has soared and drove us to the very edge countless times, but there was something about the brutal injustice of Ned's death that will always be raw when we unfortunately remember it happened. But what if Ned wasn't executed? What if Joffrey's mercy was greater than just lopping off Lord Stark's head? Here's a glimpse of what an alternate world would look like if Ned Stark walked free from King's Landing, and it's a very different place indeed...

10. Lord Commander Ned Stark

First thing's first, what would Ned have done instead? Well, it's stated in the show that Ned should've been given the opportunity to take the black and join the Night's Watch. It would've still been an unjust end for him, but it's better than a traitor's death at the Sept of Baelor. Ned would've very quickly risen in the Night's Watch, mainly populated by Northmen, and if Jon Snow could rise to the Lord Commander position so quickly, then Ned would've certainly stood a chance. Jon and Ned's adventures at the Wall could've been amazing to watch, though Jon may never have been allowed to venture beyond the Wall and subsequently become part of the wildling forces, befriend Ygritte, and return with warnings of their intentions.

9. Robb Wouldn't March South

With Ned at the Wall, there'd be no immediate reason for Robb to declare open rebellion and march towards King's Landing. He would rule at Winterfell, grow his forces, tighten his grip on the North, and eventually make plans to divide the realm, though it would've been a much more considered move as opposed to a dash south. Then think of all the trouble that Robb would've been spared. He wouldn't have died, for starters, because the Red Wedding wouldn't have taken place. He wouldn't have been betrothed to a Frey daughter, and would never have met Talisa, and would never have got her pregnant. Robb would've have a fresh slate, and Catelyn would still be alive.

8. Bran Wouldn't Trek North

With Robb and Catelyn largely ruling over Winterfell, Bran wouldn't have been allowed anywhere near the Wall, let alone beyond it. He wouldn't have journeyed north with Hodor, he wouldn't have discovered the Children of the Forest, and he wouldn't have discovered the Three-Eyed Raven, at least in that form. We don't quite know where Bran's storyline is going to progress, but you can imagine it's going to be significant. Everything he achieves now simply wouldn't have happened if Ned had kept his head. He would've continued to adapt to his situation and become a strong ruler.

7. Arya Wouldn't Have Become No One

Remember Arya clinging to the statue in Season 1 as Ned was executed? Remember that moment, now think of every single thing Arya has done since then. She's been at Harrenhal, she's been partnered with The Hound, she's trekked to the Eerie, she's almost been taken to the Wall, she's poured Tywin Lannister's wine, she's sailed to Braavos and joined the Faceless Men. Like Bran, Arya's entire journey would've been wiped out and she would've stayed on at Winterfell alongside her mother and brothers. She may not have turned into a 'proper' lady, but she certainly wouldn't have turned into 'no one'. What would've become of her sister though?

6. Sansa Would Have Stayed In King's Landing

Ned's survival could've worked out a whole lot better or a whole lot worse for Sansa Stark. Ned's 'traitor' status broke her betrothal to Joffrey, and that may have still remained the case, but there's also a chance that Cersei would've followed through with the marriage. The two routes would've been: A) Sansa married Joff, Cersei wouldn't get the military might of the Tyrells, but she would get a tighter grip on the North, despite a probable attempt to steal Sansa back. B) Sansa's betrothal was ended, but she would remain in King's Landing to keep ties with the North without making her Queen.

5. Theon And The Ironborn Wouldn't Have Rebelled

Theon may have still been disenchanted by his 'outsider' status at Winterfell, but seeing that he could've risen to a high position under Robb at Winterfell, the Greyjoy son could've tied himself closer to the Starks as opposed to declaring war on them with the Ironborn. The demise of House Stark led to the Ironborn storming the mainland and reducing Winterfell to a chaos-filled ghost town. They couldn't hold it, but they've seized positions in the North and gained a foothold in Westeros aside from their Iron Islands. Ned Stark kept the Ironborn at bay, but his death gave them an opportunity that they've seized.

4. The Boltons Wouldn't Have Revolted

The Boltons are easily the most opportunistic house in the realm. They've piggybacked their way to the top, and it could be argued that they're the strongest house at the moment. They have a decent number of soldiers, they've got a strong grip on Winterfell, and they polished off Stannis' men without resistance. They leapt onto the Lannister/Frey Red Wedding plot and seized the chance to finish off their contenders. They didn't even have to stretch themselves to capture Winterfell either, Theon had done the hard work, they simply occupied the shell. They wouldn't have stepped out of the Stark shadow if they were still alive.

3. Jaime Would Still Have Both Hands

Joffrey called the shots on Ned's execution, but the Lannisters were hardly devastated afterwards. Their fierce noble competitor from the North was toppled. Unfortunately for Jaime Lannister, he was the one lion who ended up losing a literal piece of himself in the aftermath. After Robb's stunning victory in the Whispering Wood, Jaime was taken prisoner, and things progressively got worse from then on. He fell from frying pan to the fire and back again, losing his hand in the process. That seems like a dire situation, but let's face it, losing the hand saved Jaime's humanity. He pulled off a U-turn, redeeming himself in many areas to the point where people could argue him to be a hero.

2. Daenerys Would've Been Closely Monitored

Daenerys had Robert Baratheon on edge to say the least. He wildly hated the Targaryens, and would've killed the girl himself if he'd been able to get across the Narrow Sea. But after he died, and had Ned survived, the situation wouldn't have been as gung-ho. Dany was a threat to the Starks, and the frosty relationship was mutual, but I still think had Ned survived there would've been a far more diplomatic discussion about her future as opposed to all-out war. Of course, Daenerys could've rejected any chance of peace between the houses, but there was still a glimmer of hope that a discovery in the form of another Targaryen could've reconciled differences between the Starks and Dany...

1. Jon Would Know His Parentage

"The next time we see each other, we'll talk about your mother. I promise." Oh, Ned, you should have just spilled those beans before they spilled your guts. If he was still alive, Ned would be sent to the Wall and he would've had the conversation that would shape the course of the world. WHO. ARE. JON'S. PARENTS? It's the question fans have been asking since the very beginning, and while the famous R+L=J looks like a certainty to come true in Season 6, it still hasn't been 100% rubber-stamped. That conversation would've cleared everything up. And who knows where the story could have developed from there. The sad fact remains though, Ned is dead, history has been written, and now it's down to a select few to restore House Stark back to its glory days. Check back every Friday for a brand new 'What If...?' question, and keep up to date with all of the latest features by following our Twitter account: @WhatCultureGoT

Contributor
Contributor

What Culture contributor. NCTJ accredited Sports Journalist. Regret-filled Sunderland AFC season ticket holder. Optimism-filled NFL fan. Lover of all things Game Of Thrones, Breaking Bad, Walking Dead & more.