Game Of Thrones Vs. Lord of The Rings: 12 Epic Deathmatches We Want To See
Dragons vs. The Nazgul, Lady of Light vs. Lord of Light, Sean Bean vs. Sean Bean.
While Game of Thrones and Lord of the Rings will always draw comparisons to each other, it's simply impossible to definitively say which is better. Lord of the Rings is arguably the greatest film trilogy of all-time, and with an approximate 11 hours (extended editions) running time, they can go into depths that haven't been seen in other films.
Thrones has the distinct advantage, with 50 hours and counting to delve into the rich history and deep politics of the world George R.R. Martin created. For that reason, it's incredibly difficult to line them up against each other and both productions should be equally celebrated. However, when it comes to characters, there are plenty who stack up against each other from both sides.
Tolkien created some remarkable characters, with The Fellowship made up of a fantastic blend of icons, while Martin has also proved a master in the art of sculpting incredible figures to root for and against in his own world, but how would things pan out if warriors of all shapes and sizes from both sides clashed with each other?
Of course, this article is just a bit of fun, there'll obviously never be any form of crossover, but which series has the more badass set of warriors?
12. Lurtz Vs. The Mountain
The first scenario is Saruman's champion vs. Cersei's, the original fighting Uruk-Hai vs. The Mountain That Rides. It wouldn't be a cunning, clever fight, but it would certainly be a mammoth clash between the two giants.
Both were felled in their respective series, though The Mountain wasn't completely finished by Prince Oberyn. He swung some immense blows, but was brought down to earth by a spear, with the wound festering and resulting in his 'death' though he appears to have been re-animated.
On the other side, Lurtz took an immense amount of pain, having a knife plunged through his thigh, arm lopped off by Aragorn, and even dragging a sword through his own belly before finally having his head separated from his shoulders.
If the pair were to meet, The Mountain's sheer strength could be enough to blaze through the Uruk. He was taken out by the mazy, acrobatic Oberyn, whereas Lurtz doesn't seem to have that in his locker.
Result: The Mountain Wins
11. Galadriel Vs. Melisandre
Now skipping from one end of the scale to the other, with Galadriel and Melisandre far more interested in the power of the mind over sheer brawn. Both are exceptionally creepy in both series' and a clash between the pair would see the ultimate 'cryptic quote off' of all time.
Galadriel was all about the mind in her LOTR appearances, not harming anybody greatly, but she had the immense power to break weak men down with only her thoughts. You get the feeling that she's capable of so much more than what was demonstrated, after all, she has a ring in her possession.
Melisandre is a far more inconsistent prospect. Her shadow-birth assassin was immense, and worthy of winning any fight, but it seems like she has to invest a lot into each of her schemes to kill an individual. Royal blood isn't exactly flowing throughout the land, you know?
For this reason, Galadriel takes the victory. She's in total control, whereas Melisandre clearly made a fatal error of judgement in the Stannis saga. She's powerful, but the Red Priestess ain't no Lady of Light.
Result: Galadriel Wins
10. Riders Of Rohan Vs. Dothraki Khalasar
Everybody loves a good bit of horseback combat, and both Thrones and Lord of the Rings play host to two vastly contrasting sets of horse masters. The Riders of Rohan vs. the infamous Dothraki.
The Riders of Rohan are the ultimate 'here comes the cavalry' force, arriving late in both major battles from The Two Towers and Return of the King, but slaughtering the orcs in the their thousands upon arrival. This bunch of farmers, traders and commoners should never be underestimated, they're a boisterous, feisty army with a long-standing reputation.
However, the Dothraki are savages. They rape, pillage, burn, and annihilate villages very similar to those found around the plains of Rohan. There's no mercy, and treat their horses better than they treat one another.
Let's face it, the Dothraki would eat Rohan for breakfast. Not to mention the fact that the Rohirrim only mustered 6,000 men compared to the 100,000 potential Dothraki screamers in just a single Khalasar. This isn't even a fight, this is a bloodbath.
Result: Dothraki Win
9. Gollum Vs. Reek
It seems that every good fantasy series needs a man (or hobbit) tortured beyond recognition, twisted and distorted from reality, and ultimately transformed into a sub-human mess.
Gollum is one of the all-time classic film characters, and Andy Serkis does a stunning job of bringing him to life. Aside from the fact that he literally is CGI, Gollum is far more animated than Reek, but which would triumph in a scrap?
It seems as though Gollum is used to the way he is, he knows how to survive in the wildest of wild places, living on nought but raw, wriggling fish and 'filthy orcses' whereas Reek is clinging onto at least a slither of civilisation despite living in the dog kennels at Winterfell.
This glimmer of humanity in Reek would be the reason he could topple Gollum, after all, Theon has skill with a sword and bow. If he could harness an ounce of his former self, Gollum would be no match considering he could've been put to the sword by a hobbit, and is solely distracted by his 'precious'.
Result: Reek Wins
8. Sam Gamgee Vs. Sam Tarly
Every fantasy series needs a tortured soul, and every series apparently needs a loveable, surprisingly resilient, always-developing Sam character who's frequently teased about his weight, and can't quite believe some of the things he's done across his journey.
Let's get one thing clear, Sam Gamgee is the most criminally under-thanked character in the entirety of Middle Earth. Without Sam, Sauron and his minions crush Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli, Gandalf, thousands of soldiers from Rohan and Gondor, then Minas Tirith, followed swiftly by the whole world which would fall into ruin, fire and darkness. What does he receive for preventing the obliteration of basically everything? He gets pushed to one side so the gang can hug Frodo in his sick bed...
Meanwhile in Westeros, Sam Tarly is cast out by his family to the Wall, where he surprises himself and everyone else with his usefulness and takes out a White Walker. He's grown incredibly throughout the seasons and looks set for big things as a maester.
Tarly can take a pummelling, but let's not forget that Gamgee climbed to the top of Mt. Doom carrying Frodo on his back. Now THAT is endurance. The most likely result of a 'fight' between the pair would be a warm fire and a good book with Gilly and Rosie Cotton happily by their sides, but if things got ugly, Gamgee could make Tarly yield.
Result: Sam Gamgee Wins
7. Frodo Baggins Vs. Arya Stark
It's controversial, but the film adaptation of Frodo was a whining brat for most of it. Sam was portrayed as the liability throughout, despite being the fuel that kept the ring's journey on track.
But let's give Frodo at least some credit. He proved his resilience through some tricky spots and all with the one ring draped around his neck. He also fled away from the main group to carve his own path, much like the ass-kicking Arya in Westeros.
Arya's storyline has incredible potential. If she completes her training and develops into a face-changing assassin, the coolness levels will skyrocket. She's done everything for herself, and escaped some grim situations, improvising every step of the way.
There's no contest here. While Frodo has the ability to bounce back, in a duel, Arya could quite easily 'stick him with the pointy end' and finish him for good if she wanted to... Then steal his face...
Result: Arya Wins
6. Boromir Vs. Ned Stark
The Boromir of old and Ned Stark are cut from the same cloth. They're both rugged, hardened warriors, they're both staunch leaders of men, they're both honourable and selfless, and they're both Sean Bean.
Boromir is a fearless leader, and while his lust for the ring could've been his downfall, it was the three arrows pierced through his chest that possibly did the most damage.
Travel to Westeros and you'd find Ned Stark, a noble Lord with a noble heart, which is also the reason his head was mounted on a spike. He's arguably more grizzled, and hardened to war, with a stronger mind, wouldn't have stalked Frodo for the ring.
In a straight up fight, it's incredibly close to call seen as they're the same flesh and blood... Ned might hold a slight edge (and a double-handed, Valyrian steel greatsword) but this is Sean Bean we're talking about. Ned would probably have Boromir in his sights before showing mercy. Boromir would cut him down, mortally wounding Ned, who would summon his last ounce of strength to slash Boromir. The result is inevitable.
Result: Sean Bean dies twice. Obviously. Nobody wins.
5. Gimli Vs. Tyrion
Gimli and Tyrion are vastly opposing dwarves between the series' with one based on brain, and the other on brawn.
The Lord of the Rings dwarves are spoken of like a more cynical race, sticking to their gloomy mines and industrial lives, bitter towards the dwarves and keeping themselves to themselves. Gimli breaks the mould, forging an alliance with Legolas that quickly turns into a beautiful friendship, with the kill count forever rising between them.
On the other side, Tyrion is a far more cunning individual. He could single-handedly plot a city's downfall or it's security, as demonstrated against Stannis' fleet, and while he's been caught up in several battles, he's not an out-and-out soldier.
Gimli would take the round on fighting ability, even if his brain doesn't match that of the Lannister's, and despite the fact that Tyrion is the master of burrowing his way out of extremely tricky situations.
Result: Gimli Wins
4. Legolas Vs. Oberyn
Ladies, roll up. The two pretty boys of Middle Earth and Westeros have arrived to the party. Orlando Bloom and Pedro Pascal stole the hearts of many an admirer, but who would take the victory?
Legolas is the cult hero of Lord of the Rings, with at least one ridiculously 'Hollywood' moment per film. First it was the slo-mo arrow shot across practically from one side of Moria to the other, then it was him surfing on an Uruk shield down a flight of Helm's Deep stairs firing as he went, then perhaps his greatest feat, systematically unravelling an entire Mumakil, complete with fully armed crew. These were ludicrious moments, but screw it, they were epic.
Oberyn is a different proposition. He's an exotic, deadly assassin figure, and could've developed into a far greater warrior than he was shown to be on-screen, so the judgement has to be made from what he demonstrated.
The Dornish Prince was nimble and ferocious against The Mountain but he had an enormous motivation. The only way Oberyn could summon the same fire to finish off Legolas would be if the elf stole his beard trimmer for Gimli.
Result: Legolas Wins
3. Aragorn Vs. Jon
Rugged, dark-haired, strong. Girls go for Legolas and Oberyn, ladies opt for Aragorn and Jon Snow. They're both outcasts, they're both highly-skilled swordsman, they're both heroes.
Aragorn is the perfect leader, commanding respect, authority, and power, while he also has the power to sway an elf away from eternal bliss for a few years with him on earth before a lifetime of gloom and misery. He's the main man of the Fellowship and eventually becomes the main man of the world controlled by men.
Jon followed a similar path in the fact that he was cast out, and shares the same compassionate yet decisive nature. He basically does what is right. Jon's road has been more of a rollercoaster, slaying a demonic White Walker before being stabbed to death by his own men and a child.
It would be an incredibly tough test, but if any man from Middle Earth was going to take down a Walker, it was going to be Aragorn. The fight would be tough, and brilliant, but the reigning King of Gondor takes it by a whisker.
Result: Aragorn Wins
2. The Witch King Vs. Daenerys
Now we're getting into the realms of sheer insanity. Picture in your head, the Witch King flying into an aerial battle with the Nazgul against Daenerys atop a war-armoured Drogon, with her two other dragons either side.
The Witch King is a fearsome character worthy of killing anything in his path, armed with a morgul blade, crunching mace, and riding a fell-beast, he could take on entire armies and probably do a good job of it.
Daenerys is a novice to the art of dragon-riding, but given time, she could develop into a true Targaryen warrior, with the distinct advantage of dragonfire on her side.
The Nazgul are notoriously difficult to kill, but any sort of Valyrian steel should be good enough, and the fire has already been known to repel them at Weathertop. But forgetting everything else, while no man can finish off the Witch King, Daenerys is 'no man'.
Result: Daenerys Wins
1. Night's King Vs. Sauron
Okay, so if the idea of dragons flying into battle against the fell-beasts of Mordor wasn't enough to get you excited, imagine a final showdown between the Night's King, the White Walkers and his wights, and Sauron, armed with the One Ring and a legion of orcs.
There's nothing that really needs to be said about Sauron that hasn't already been said. The guy had so much "cruelty...malice, and...will to dominate all life" that he had to forge a magic ring to store the excess in. If only he'd worn a thicker pair of gloves during the battle with Isildur he wouldn't have needed to confine himself to being a fiery eye in the sky.
Flipping into Westeros, the White Walkers are still an unknown force. While fans got a great tease for them during 'Hardhome' it's still tough to work out how vast their power is, though all evidence suggests 'colossal'.
This would be the ultimate war between ice and fire, and on this occasion, a fit and firing Sauron complete with a ring on his finger (and those previously mentioned padded gloves) is unstoppable. The ultimate showdown winner simply has to be Sauron.
Result: Sauron Wins
That takes the scores to 6-5 in favour of Lord of the Rings, and obviously that's without including Gandalf, for whom there is no Game of Thrones equivalent worthy of even stepping into the same ring with him.
Which other Middle Earth-Westeros showdowns would you like to see?