Gotham: 10 Future Villains We Want To See

It's time we saw Black Mask transformed to a live-action environment.

Black Mask Gotham Perhaps one of the biggest selling points for Fox's freshman Gotham series is its promise to explore the corrupt city and the people within it at a time before Bruce Wayne appeared as the Caped Crusader. Villains who have challenged him time and time again all had to start somewhere, crafted and warped by their upbringings, uncontrollable circumstances or otherwise, and Gotham offers viewers the opportunity to see many of them long before they become the easily recognizable figures they are. So far, the show has introduced a number of characters big and small from Batman's rogues gallery, from crime lords like Sal Maroni and Carmine Falcone, future supervillians like Oswald Cobblepot and Edward Nigma and, of course, a young Selina Kyle, with confirmed future appearances by other characters like Harvet Dent, Victor Zsasz and Thomas Elliot along with the long-term tease of the Joker. Suffice it to say, Gotham shows no signs of shying away from bringing many more into the fold as it chugs along. Without the presence of Batman in the show, there are certain characters we can understand the show skirting around this early in its run; for instance, having Ra's al Ghul come in to threaten Gotham seems "too big" of an issue to be dealt with without the Dark Knight around. On the other hand, it's just a matter of time that logical, pre-supervillain appearances occur by popular characters in some way, like Victor Fries as a researcher at Wayne Industries or Harleen Quinzell as an Arkham intern. With this list, we'll take a look at 10 of Batman's future enemies who could fit into the show's world as active players long before the arrival of the Dark Knight and offer up possibilities as to how they can be weaved in.

10. Rupert Thorne

Beyond the classic Batman: The Animated Series, the influential crime boss hasn't frequently appeared in media outside the comics. With Gotham's interest in exploring the politics of the city, Thorne would be a solid addition in fleshing out the constant power struggle that so often threatens to tear the city apart. As a city councilman and leader of one of Gotham's major gangs, Thorne could take the show's exploration of corruption in a more public avenue, perhaps gunning - literally and figuratively - to get someone deep in his pocket into the mayoral position, with Gordon doing his best to bring him down before he can get a solid hold on the city. With characters like Falcone and Maroni on the scene, it seems only fair that Thorne gets a shot at some live action glory after decades of waiting in the wings, and Gotham is as good a platform as any to give it to him.

9. First Electrocutioner

The brother of the third Electrocutioner, Lester Buchinsky (above), started off as a vigilante fighting in the name of justice. Though he would die, leading Lester to take up the mantle - and eventually turn to a life of crime instead - the original Electrocutioner would slot perfectly into the world that Gotham has set up. Armed with far less complex technology than his future brother would utilize, the arrival of a crime-fighting Electrocutioner in Gotham City would follow through on the promise the Balloonman delivered to Gordon that more vigilantes would turn up in his wake, sick of the corruption and true villainy coursing through the city's veins. As an upstart vigilante, the Electrocutioner could easily pop up throughout several episodes before ultimately being apprehended or killed, with a cameo by his brother Lester leaving the door open for the villainous alternative to show up down the road, perhaps fueled by the desire to avenge the brother who died unjustly for justice.

8. Basil Karlo

Long before he would become the shape-shifter most Bat-fans identify him as, Basil Karlo was an actor who went on a murder spree against the cast of a remake of one of his own horror films. Aside from the fact the issue of remaking classic films is a rather topical one in our own world, Karlo's decision to take up his old character's moniker of Clayface and begin murdering the actors in the order they die in the film would give Gordon an entertaining ticking clock mystery to solve. While we wouldn't expect Karlo to turn into the supervillain in the show proper, his inclusion and incarceration in the show would serve as a great nod to the fans, putting the murderous actor in the same place he would be visited years later by Sondra Fuller, the fourth person to take on the Clayface name. An episode devoted to Gordon's investigation of the Clayface killings could be an enjoyably creative and welcome diversion from the larger criminal machinations at play in Gotham.

7. Jervis Tetch

An up-and-coming Mad Hatter could provide Gotham with one crazy trip down the rabbit hole for Gordon and Bullock. Through his obsession with Alice in Wonderland and with a host of potential kidnapping victims in Gotham, from children to the future Mrs. Gordon, Tetch would give the show an opportunity to play with some truly twisted imagery involving tea parties, lots and lots of hats and a complete package of Wonderland-themed weirdness. Should Tetch be locked up after his first appearance, the fact that the character was finally granted his first live-action appearance would be cool enough. Unfortunately for Gordon's arrest record, we'd be rooting for Tetch to get away and make recurring appearances throughout the seasons at random, allowing the audience to check in with the character now and again as he develops and hones his propensity for mind control while continuing to spiral deeper into madness.

6. Julian Day

Calendar Man is a character whose presence on the show could be a long-term game. Across the course of a season or seasons, the GCPD could continually be faced with holiday-centric or seasonally-themed crimes with no leads on a suspect until the creative team decides it's finally time to introduce Julian Day in the flesh, either left to continue committing his crimes uncaught until Batman arrives or apprehended to give Gordon a win. If the latter were the case, the show could even take a page from how the general public may know him from the popular story The Long Halloween or through the Arkham games, with Gordon being forced to visit him for the sake of garnering clues about a criminal at large that Day cryptically may or may not know something about. While the character's criminal methodology may seem relatively tame, the right actor could completely turn Day into an uncomfortably scary but wholly pleasing addition to the show.

5. Floyd Lawton

Deadshot has already made live-action appearances in Smallville and Arrow, but that doesn't stop us from wanting to see Gotham's take on the character. With Penguin's insistence that a war is coming to Gotham and the various criminal families all at odds with one another, it wouldn't surprise us in the least if a young version of the bragging assassin were to show up with a list of names needing to be crossed off. That said, bringing an established Deadshot into the series before Batman's arrival would be at odds with the character's original history, wherein Lawton became Deadshot in order to take Batman's place (not that such adherence to the source seems to be of concern to those behind the show). As such, Gotham could easily move away from his previous live-action incarnations in exploring his origins as a son who accidentally takes his brother's life with a rifle shot instead of their abusive father. Lawton's entire character is thus built from this moment, as the guilt over his brother's death causes him to be indifferent to his own life and instills in him the desire to never miss another shot. Though Lawton's story wouldn't really require Gordon's involvement, it could easily be a fascinating trip down a narrative alley that would help color Gotham City as a place where good people can be forever changed even without the absence of crime while giving audiences a live-action look at Deadshot that stands out from the pack.

4. Roman Sionis

Long before he would become known as Black Mask, a young Roman Sionis grew up caught in the same social circles as Bruce Wayne. Unlike Bruce, however, Sionis hated the superficiality of his parents, both of whom would frequently put their desires to move up the social ladder over their own son despite the fact they themselves loathed everyone else, the Waynes included. Sionis' parents would go on to die in a fire, leaving behind a cosmetics company that he would eventually crash and burn in his adult life before going crazy and donning his infamous mask after Wayne Industries bought it out. Though we don't expect the show to go that far, particularly due to his putting on of the mask and the permanent manner in which it ends up on him taking place when Batman is in Gotham, the inclusion of a young Sionis and his parents during glimpses of the city's socialite affairs would be a great touch that wouldn't have to feel shoehorned in. Even further, the show would earn bonus points if, at some point during its run, Sionis' parents are killed in a fire just like their comic counterparts and the table is set for his fall and rebirth as Black Mask.

3. Hugo Strange

Hugo Strange is one of Batman's most intriguing villains, most well-known for having deduced the hero's identity and for his persistent attempts to "be" Batman. Strange has yet to make a live-action appearance in any Batman media and bringing him onto Gotham could be a great introduction to him for general audiences who may have also missed out on his fantastic turn in Batman: Arkham City. Strange could easily be brought onto the show in a number of ways, either as a psychiatrist at Arkham, a professor at Gotham State University or even as a psychological consultant on a GCPD case. The seeds that something's not entirely right with him could effectively be planted in his appearances, perhaps even leading to a Hannibal/Will Graham dynamic between him and Gordon should Strange decide to offer Gordon therapy. Regardless of how they tackle him, the possibilities for Strange are endless and we'd love to see his dangerous mind at work in the years before Batman comes home.

2. Waylon Jones

Considering Gotham's relatively grounded tone so far, Viper/Venom aside, introducing the monstrous Killer Croc without feeling too fantastical would be a tricky business. Unlike, say, Basil Karlo, whose story could easily be told without needing to end with him truly becoming the shape-shifting Clayface, Croc's condition is an intrinsic piece of his character's origins and development. An easy way to bring in the character would be if a carnival came to town and, with it, a series of grisly murders and robberies. As Gordon and the GCPD investigate who's behind it all, a young Waylon Jones could make an appearance on the series as an angry, vengeful victim of the earlier stages of his condition, with the series suggesting that it is only bound to get worse and more in line with the hulking creature he is in the comics. Leaving Jones with an ambiguous fate, either through apparent death or an escape into Gotham's sewers, could afford the show with the opportunity to bring him back in later seasons with his condition worsened or simply leave Jones as a one-off character whose existence could continue on throughout the show's run as a running urban legend to tease his future as one of Batman's most dangerous foes.

1. Jonathan Crane

As much as Cillian Murphy did a great job with Scarecrow in Christopher Nolan's trilogy, the fear-loving doctor ultimately got the short end of the stick when it came to truly exploring what he can do. With so much untapped live-action potential and a host of sources to draw inspiration from in what can be done with him, whether it be from the comics, the various animated shows or Batman: Arkham Asylum, the inclusion of a young, experimental Dr. Crane could make for some truly nightmarish television. Crane's a character who could be introduced when Arkham reopens as an unassuming member of its staff and slowly fleshed out over the course of the series as his experiments grow increasingly more dangerous, the doctor more deranged and his efforts pushed beyond the walls of Arkham. And considering his Scarecrow persona is part of who he is long before Batman arrives on the scene, the show wouldn't have to completely tease towards his future, allowing him to embrace who he is and give viewers a healthy dose of fear. As with most shows, Gotham's finding its footing and going through its freshman growing pains as it carves out its own identity. With so many paths for it to take and characters to explore, many fans surely have their own villainous origins they're hoping to see. This list is just the tip of the iceberg, so feel free to share below how you think these or any of Batman's other rogues could be brought into series!

In this post: 
Batman Gotham
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Writer, film enthusiast, part-time gamer and watcher of (mostly) good television located on the fringe of Los Angeles, who now has his own website at www.highdefgeoff.com!