Gotham: 10 Most Disturbing Episodes
Gotham putting the 'dark' in the Dark Knight's origin story.
Gotham was created as a means of putting a slightly different spin on Batman's origins - converting the now-familiar tale into TV format and shifting the focus to young, up-and-coming Jim Gordon.
It was a masterful move, really; covering the less-trodden path of Batman stories, focusing on Bruce's formative years following his parents death - something which is often left untouched by other adaptations.
While some fans of the Caped Crusader were less than pleased with the many creative liberties Gotham took with its source material, it's hard to deny that the prospect of such an extensive dive into Gotham's past is more than a little exciting.
Those expecting the show to keep pace with the grittiness of Batman's source material certainly weren't disappointed: while Gotham is occasionally a little cartoonish, it featured more than a few incredibly horrifying moments, despite its apparent 'crime drama' label.
Anyone who thought Gotham might take the CW's patented approach to superhero storytelling was likely more than a little unsettled by the many aspects of horror on display, but it certainly made for fresh, entertaining viewing.
It might carry Batman's well-established dark tone throughout, but let's take a look at some of Gotham's most disturbing moments.
10. 'Look Into My Eyes' (S3 E3)
Season 3's 'Look Into My Eyes' introduces one of Batman's creepiest and lesser known villains, Jervis Tetch, AKA The Mad Hatter.
Deviating from the comic book character's established back story, Gotham's Tetch is looking for his sister, Alice, who we later learn that he raised himself after the death of their parents. It's also heavily implied that Jervis abused Alice.
Shortly after establishing that Tetch has a remarkable knack for hypnotism, he employs Jim Gordon to help him find Alice, who disappeared after Tetch sought help for a condition that made her blood toxic.
Tetch is one of Gotham's most unpleasant villains, and here we see him hypnotise a man, forcing him to kill his wife and then himself simply so Tetch can steal their home.
The implied relationship with - not to mention the control he has over - Alice makes for uncomfortable viewing throughout, and as each detail comes to light, you'll find Tetch more and more repulsive.
There's also a B-story in which Bruce and Alfred take care of 5, Bruce's secretly psychotic doppelganger, and this, combined with Tetch's unsettling nature makes for a disturbing watch.
9. 'A Bitter Pill To Swallow' (S2 E9)
With the sinister Theo Galavan behind bars, you'd be forgiven for assuming that Gotham City might just feel a little less creepy for a while.
It doesn't. The episode opens with Galavan's sister Tabitha putting a hit on Jim Gordon. Shortly after, we see that Penguin has found his way into Nygma's clutches, and the latter is keeping him sedated.
This begins a theme that runs through the episode; the beginning of a strange, unpleasant and uncomfortable relationship between the two villains starts here, and they're both so unnerving in different ways that the two of them together is cause for unease.
With all that ramping up, we learn that the hitman hired to kill Gordon is none other than Eduardo Flamingo, one of the Dark Knight's most unapologetically bizarre adversaries, and it's established immediately that Flamingo is renowned for eating his victims.
The episode's climax sees Flamingo making good on this reputation, killing GCPD Officer Parks by gnawing at her neck until she dies, as a roomful of cops frantically beat him in hopes of separating the pair.
This episode is a slow build to the most horrifying sort of crescendo, but it's certainly a memorable watch.
8. 'Red Hood' (S1 E17)
Possibly the least disturbing entry on this list, season 1 episode 'Red Hood' has made its way onto this list by merit of one particularly unforgettable moment.
While the scenes depicting the ill-fated exploits of the Red Hood gang are much lighter than your standard Gotham fare, the Wayne Manor scenes are quietly unsettling.
After receiving a visit from old army colleague Reggie, Alfred begins to suspect that his former comrade might have a sinister motive. The scenes between Reggie and Bruce are noticeably uncomfortable, with the former soldier's attempts to teach Bruce crossing the line between well-intentioned and plain creepy.
But the true heart of this episode's disturbing nature lies in the Dollmaker's prison. When Fish Mooney finally gets to see the upper levels of the facility, she comes to understand that the people imprisoned below are there as unwilling organ donors.
During a conversation with the Dollmaker, Fish learns that he intends to harvest her eyes, so she grabs a nearby spoon and scoops one out herself. It's one of Gotham's most outrageous moments, and it makes for particularly uncomfortable viewing, but it does serve to highlight just how far Fish is willing to go to survive.
7. 'Knock Knock' (S2 E2)
Season 2 marked the introduction of numerous villains, but one of the best had already (briefly) been featured in season 1.
After escaping Arkham, a group of inmates - including Barbara Kean and Jerome Valeska - are brought to Theo Galavan, who recruits them to do his bidding. He sends them out into the world as the Maniax, we're helpless to watch as they throw several captives from a rooftop, introducing themselves to Gotham City.
But their fun doesn't stop there. They go on to hijack a bus filled with teenage cheerleaders, which they promptly soak in gasoline and attempt (and fail) to set alight.
Despite the GCPD's intervention, the Maniax escape, and the episode culminates with an all-out assault on the GCPD, during which they kill everyone in sight, and tie Commissioner Essen to a chair. With her tied up, they point a camera in her face, proceeding to taunt and threaten her.
We learn afterwards that they shot and left Essen for dead, rounding out the episode with Jerome's message to the camera, in which he delivers a deranged monologue, channeling his inner Joker and hinting at more death and destruction to come.
6. 'The Scarecrow' (S1 E15)
The second episode to follow Gerald Crane as he continues his killing spree, this episode marks the birth of one of Batman's greatest enemies, putting a new and slightly different spin on his established backstory.
Forced by his father to join in with the torture of their victims by using adrenal glands to trigger extreme fear, young Jonathan Crane is shown to be a quiet, nervous boy.
The episode mostly revolves around Gordon and Bullock following the Cranes' trail, and we learn that Gerald has been dosing his son with the serum, causing the boy's fragile mental state.
As the detectives finally catch up to the pair, the Cranes attempt to escape, stopping by an old scarecrow, when Gerald decides to administer the last of the serum. He gives Jonathan a massive dose, then leaves him beneath the scarecrow as he steps out to face the detectives.
A brief cutaway gives us our first glimpse of the horrors of the Dollmaker's prison, and then it cuts back to Jonathan Crane, lying in a hospital bed, convulsing and screaming in terror. Gordon is told that he's constantly hallucinating, and that the serum has permanently altered his brain chemistry.
5. 'Rogues' Gallery' (S1 E11)
Rogue's Gallery takes the action into familiar and terrifying territory, taking place inside Arkham Asylum as Jim Gordon is assigned to work guard duty for the newly reopened, still-derelict hospital.
A host of crazies feature, and there's brief elements of comedy, but the setting of the episode alone is enough to earn it a spot on the list.
It's not all about atmosphere, though - there's plenty of disturbing story in this one, too.
After Gordon discovers a patient in a vegetative state, it soon becomes clear that they've been subjected to brutal (and illegal) electroshock treatments, effectually frying their brain. With more victims turning up and the Asylum director ordering Gordon to drop the investigation, it's an exercise in creepy tension as the former detective continues to hunt the perpetrator.
It's got everything you could want to be disturbed by: hordes of the criminally insane all locked up in an ancient, rusting facility that's hardly equipped to deal with anyone, a murderer operating in plain sight, and a production of Shakespeare's The Tempest.
It's a great episode, and it's one that's impossible to watch without being on the edge of your seat.
4. 'Selina Kyle' (S1 E2)
Gotham started its dark trend pretty early with the obligatory death of the Waynes in the first episode, but the second featured a far more disturbing story.
Street kids are being lured into a van by a couple from the "Homeless Outreach Project", never to be seen again. Gordon and Bullock stumble onto the case while investigating a murder, and it soon escalates when they discover that dozens of homeless teens have been abducted.
It turns out that Patti and Doug have been procuring wayward souls for the Dollmaker, but before the detectives can catch up to them, they've managed to hijack a bus headed for a juvenile detention centre, with none other than a young Selina Kyle on board.
After arriving at a warehouse instead of their intended destination, Selina realises something is wrong and hides. She then proceeds to attack one of the warehouse workers off-screen, who screams, alerting Patty. Clutching his eyes, Patty tells him it's just a scratch, and it's revealed that young Selina Kyle has gouged his eyes out - likely with her bare hands - before escaping. Dark.
3. 'Hog Day Afternoon' (S4 E6)
Possibly one of the creepiest villains in Batman's rogues' gallery, Professor Pyg makes his first Gotham appearance in season 4, caught up in Sofia Falcone's scheme to reclaim her father's criminal empire.
We first glimpse him as he butchers an on-duty police officer, and the episode only gets more disturbing from there.
When Gordon is called in, he sees that the killer has placed a pig's head over that of the deceased officer. The investigation soon turns up more dead cops, all left perfectly presented with pigs' heads over their own.
Gordon and Bullock tail the Professor, who has kidnapped yet another police officer, and find their colleague just in time to discover that he's had a grenade placed inside his stomach, the blast of which renders both detectives unconscious.
Waking up, Gordon finds himself tied to chair, face to face with Professor Pyg. After a brief monologue from the creepiest man in Gotham, the killer leaves Gordon in order to slit Bullock's throat.
Bullock may have recovered from the events of this episode fairly quickly, but it took the audience a little longer to get over their first taste of Pyg.
2. 'Into The Woods' (S2 E17)
Penguin is one of Gotham's most interesting characters.
He's capable of awful things, but he's got a lot of endearing qualities, too, and occasionally, it's easy to forget that Robin Lord Taylor's iteration of the character is an out-and-out villain.
Season 2's 'Into the Woods' removes any of these misconceptions, painting the character in the darkest light possible.
After undergoing Hugo Strange's treatments, Penguin's conditioning seems to have subdued him to the merest shadow of his former self, but meeting his estranged father Elijah changes all that. When Elijah dies, Penguin suspects his stepmother, Grace, and starts to investigate. All the while, Grace and her children (Penguin's step-siblings) abuse and humiliate him, although his conditioning prevents him from retaliating.
Into the Woods sees Penguin find that proof, and the taunting from his siblings causes his conditioning to fail. What follows is one of Gotham's creepiest scenes, where Penguin reveals to Grace what he's discovered over dinner, with his siblings notably absent.
When Grace calls for them (due to Penguin being overly creepy), he laughs at her, revealing that he killed them both, cooked them, and served them to her for dinner.
1. 'The Anvil Or The Hammer' (S1 E21)
By merit of not one, but two of the show's most disturbing moments, season 1's The Anvil or the Hammer' tops the list.
The lesser of the two unsettling aspects of this episode comes from Nygma as he casually disposes of Officer Tom Dougherty's corpse. Carrying it into the GCPD's forensics lab in two suitcases, he begins dissolving the remains in a sink before forging a goodbye note from his victim.
As if that wasn't dark enough, we also see the culmination of the Ogre storyline. After a night together, Barbara tries to leave the Ogre's apartment, only to stumble into his torture chamber. We revisit the scene to see Barbara tied up, being told that she'll be there until she learns to love the killer. He insists she gives him a name for his next victim, threatening to slit her through if she doesn't co-operate.
It's an episode that makes for difficult viewing in the best way, but it also shaped Barbara for the seasons to come, changing her from a slightly irritating innocent into a fully deranged psychopathic murderer all in one masterful stroke of storytelling.