Gotham TV Series: 10 Actors Who Should Play The Riddler

Riddle me this, Riddle me that...

Riddler It's no surprise with the success of the hit show Arrow on the CW that FOX isn't hesitating to jump on board the emerging DC juggernaut that's starting to churn its way into our lives. While other studios and franchises have had success stories of their own, Marvel has undoubtedly dominated cinemas around the world. Although Warner Brothers is looking to catch up by using two of DC's most noticeable characters, Batman and Superman, it appears that right now the war will be fought on the small screen. Much like the CW focusing on a smaller character from the DC world, FOX will attempt to do the same with its upcoming Gotham TV series. The pitch for the show is to follow Jim Gordon of the GPD and his rise through the ranks of the force. While creating an amazing backdrop for a minor character in the Batman Universe, it allows the studio to tease the audience with the famous rogues gallery that makes up this world. Although this show is designed to be a Batman-less adventure, it will use the villains that the Dark Knight has combated over the years. Speculation is already running rampant over who we might see. Although some villains are obviously more popular than others, it has to be assumed that we'll see a number of classic villains along with a multitude of smaller ones. Right now, we're going to speculate on who could fill the shoes of the puzzle obsessed Riddler.

10. Ian Somerhalder

For better or worse, the best iteration of the Riddler that has been seen on screen was from the polarizing film done by Joel Shumacher, Batman Forever. The Riddler, played by highly energetic Jim Carrey, was undoubtedly at the pinnacle of his career when this film was released. With the Gotham TV show, it has to be assumed that audiences will see a younger, new Riddler. Gotham will be an origin story of Jim Gordon and along with his origin, it has to be believed that audiences will also witness a number of origin stories about its villains. Taking the form of a more serious Riddler, actor Ian Somerhalder could fill that role nicely. Although not known for any sort of psychopathic or maniacal roles to date, Somerhalder would be able to pull off a more mysterious and youthful Riddler more in line with something we might see from the Nolanverse. Better known now for the playing the role of Damon Salvatore on the CW's Vampire Diaries, Somerhalder burst onto the scene from the hit show LOST as Boone Carlyle. If Somerhalder played an origin storied Riddler, it would be interesting to see him as more of a curious, coming of age villain than the established Riddler we all know.

9. Jim Parsons

While Somerhalder would offer a more balanced and calculated version of the Riddler, if one were to step that up a notch with a "deeper" vocabulary, perhaps they could look no further than Jim Parsons. Any fan of the Big Bang Theory already feels that Parsons character Sheldon lives a life of riddles. He's borderline ADD as it is and could easily harness some of that character into a Gotham TV series Riddler. Although personally I'm not the biggest fan of the Big Bang Theory, or Sheldon Cooper for that matter, there's no denying that he plays a brilliant role on the show. Take the characters idiosyncrasies, obsessive compulsive behavior and mash that into a riddle infused bad guy and it could work. Although a no shot more than a long shot, it would be interesting to see Parsons in such a role.

8. Michael C Hall

Even though Hall is more of a main stream actor, who can deny his performance as Dexter Morgan from the hit Showtime series Dexter? Hall has already displayed to audiences his ability to play a sociopathic serial killer so why not give him a green suit and a couple of riddles? The two characters aren't really all that far apart from one another either as Dexter enjoyed hunting his victims prior to killing them where the Riddler is in the game of riddles and puzzles with his victims prior to killing them. Hall has the ability to pull off a more intense Riddler which would be different than anything fans have seen on screen. Hall could also represent an opportunity to possibly break from the more flashy and outgoing Riddler of past screen appearances and comic adaptations.

7. Michael Emerson

Fans fell in love with Michael Emerson and his portrayal as the sometimes villainous, sometimes hero of Ben Linus from the show LOST. Emerson is now known for the character of Harold Finch on the show Person of Interest. Emerson would be a good fit as the Riddler because of his ability to present a natural creepiness with "questionable" motives. Emerson has amazing skill at carrying scenes with just his eyes and persona alone. Again, depending on the tone of the upcoming Gotham show, Emerson would once again fall into the category of a more grounded and realistic Riddler like someone from the Nolanverse. In many of the roles that he's played, Emerson has always done a superb job with dialect. He could pull of some of the Riddler's more smooth talking and intellectual abilities with his character portrayal.

6. Jeremy Davies

The Riddler's main focus is not to simply kill but to put his victims through a gauntlet of traps and puzzles to see if they can escape. He is the Jigsaw of the Batman Universe minus the self mutilation to escape. Well, maybe not always... One thing about the Riddler is that he's not necessarily known for any kind of brute force and fighting abilities but comes across as more of a calculated villain that doesn't get his hands dirty in a fight. Jeremy Davies has the acting ability to be a more wormy or cowardly Riddler. Davies could also come across as a more traditional Riddler in being maniacal and flamboyant as seen in past inceptions of the character. As an actor, Davies has a wide range in being able to play a lot of different roles. His cowardly Corporal Upham from Saving Private Ryan to his more recent hillbilly portrayal as Dickie Bennett on Justified are proof of this.

5. Rainn Wilson

Getting more in line with the traditional version of the Riddler, Rainn Wilson could fill that spot. Much like the Carrey Riddler from Batman Forever, it would be entertaining to see another funnyman try to pull off the role as well as if not better. Once again depending on the tone of the show, the writers could take full advantage of Wilson's ability with humor and twist that into the riddle throwing villain everyone loves. Although Wilson could work in the role, it might be difficult for the audience to differentiate him from Dwight on the Office. However, Wilson is known for his comedy and it's possible that the show could take advantage of that given the direction of making the Riddler a more off the wall type of villain.

4. Will Arnett

Along the same lines with Rainn Wilson, Will Arnett could fill a similar role with a more evil or sinister side. Arnett would also add a better physical look to the character with his size and build. His appearance and expressions could correlate well with the classic adaptations of the Riddler. A Riddler played by Arnett could easily switch between a more level character to a frenzied and crazed Riddler. He could pull the role off with quiet and frighting dialogue and then switch to a deranged lunatic when presenting one of his riddles to an unlucky person or party. Arnett would be a good casting in the fact that the man has been in a lot of roles already that could represent something similar to what fans could see with the show.

3. John Slattery

Although kind of a left field choice, John Slattery is one of the actors that makes the show Mad Men so great with his performance as Roger Sterling. With the show basically being an origin story about Jim Gordon and ideally other Batman villains, Slattery might be a bit old for the role. That being said, his ability to blurt out smooth and cool dialogue matches up with the slick talking Riddler. Perhaps the writers could do a re-imaging of Slattery being an original Riddler and passing the torch to someone else. Again, a left field idea and something that is not true to form in regards to the characters origins but these guys have to come from somewhere too, right? Much like a lot of other characters on this list, a Slattery portrayal would have to be more serious rather than the Carrey Riddler. However, it's not impossible to see him as a Riddler similar to what gamers have seen recently in the Arkham video games.

2. Alan Tudyk

Tudyk Alan Tudyk is known for his roles as a slick talking, witty goof ball . He cracked that mold a little bit with his portrayal as the extremely racist baseball coach Ben Chapman in the movie 42 with dialogue that left audiences feeling uneasy. Tudyk is probably best known as Wash from the cult classic show Firefly that saw its fire go out on FOX back in 2003. Tudyk is another actor with incredible range that could easily switch in and out between the riddle obsessed madman to a cool and calculated genius. It could be a real treat to see Tudyk play the Riddler's alter ego Edward Nigma when not out causing havoc on the streets of Gotham. As an audeience, it should be important to see the villains as their "human" selves and this is especially true for the Riddler.

1. Neil Patrick Harris

Is there any man on television right now that is more suited for this role other than Neil Patrick Harris? His wit and aloof personality on the soon ending How I Met Your Mother has been the life blood of that show from the beginning. With the show ending, it has to be assumed that Harris will be looking for some new work or series to jump on board with. Although the Riddler may not appear on every episode of Gotham, seeing Harris in a Riddler green suit would be worth it. Harris could easily take up the mantle left behind by Frank Gorshin from the 1960s TV show and Jim Carrey's interpretation from Batman Forever. Even if Harris played the role somewhere in the middle, it would be a great representation for audiences to witness. What do you think? Will the role of the Riddler go to a big name actor or a smaller unknown? Keep checking back to find out! Follow @BrentDiNunzio on Twitter.

Contributor
Contributor

“We don’t stop playing because we grow old; we grow old because we stop playing.” - George Bernard Shaw