Green Arrow And The Canaries: 7 Things That Must Happen
How can the Arrow spin-off succeed?
Arrow may be about to depart our screens forever but it won't be going to the great TV beyond without leaving another little piece of its ever-growing legacy behind. Yes, the show that has already spawned four live-action spin-off shows in The Flash, DC's Legends of Tomorrow, Supergirl and Batwoman is hoping to create one more before its conclusion - one that is more closely linked to it than any of the others. That show is none other than Green Arrow and The Canaries.
Starring Arrow's own leading lady Katie Cassidy, Juliana Harkavy and Katherine McNamara, the potential series will see all three of them reprise their roles as Laurel Lance/Black Canary, Dinah Drake/Black Canary and Mia Smoak respectively. Moreover, it will debut as a backdoor pilot on the penultimate episode of Arrow's final season, with The CW then hopefully ordering it to series soon afterwards.
With all of that mind, Green Arrow and The Canaries has the potential to be the best Arrowverse show on the air, but in order to achieve those great heights and carry on the success of its parent show, there are certain things that must happen... and perhaps more importantly, certain pitfalls it must avoid.
7. The Series Is Set In The Present Day
When it was announced that Mia Smoak would be joining Laurel Lance and Dinah Drake in their spin-off series, we all found ourselves wondering what time period the show would be set in. After all, the Canaries were kicking ass in the present day while Mia was doing it all the way in 2040.
Of the two options, 2040 seemed the most likely because the badass child of Oliver Queen and Felicity Smoak has crossed paths with both Black Canaries during her time. However, given the year, both of them were naturally much older.
According to the official synopsis for the backdoor pilot (also titled 'Green Arrow and The Canaries'), the team's first outing will indeed take place in the future, but it appears that things will be different as the character - now named Mia Queen - will be living the life she always wanted when Laurel and Dinah turn up.
It's likely that the pair have time-traveled to the future in order to meet her and that they aren't, in fact, the aged iterations. That being said, it's imperative that they return to the present for the remainder of the series because if 2040 really has changed as the result of the Crisis, it's lost its appeal altogether.
Why set a show with all the promise to be gritty and compelling in a perfect world that is the complete opposite of the dark and gritty future Star City we already knew? Moreover, doing so also robs the show of chances to cross over with any of the others - bar Legends - and puts them under pressure to ensure that their continuity lines up with the other present-day shows.
With that in mind, it would make more sense to simply set it in the present-day after the Crisis.
6. William Joins The Line-Up
In spite of Arrow's best efforts to make it seem otherwise, William Clayton is much more important to the show's overall continuity than his sister ever was. That's not to take away anything from the badass that Mia Smoak is, but it seems like the writers have forgotten that Oliver was a parent long before the adult version of his broody daughter came into his life as it's only now that characters are cracking jokes about 'parent Oliver' being a thing. That being said, they have a chance to remind us just how important William is by also having him play a part in the spin-off.
Every team of superheroes needs a guy or girl in the chair to guide them and while you might not necessarily agree with that statement, it goes without saying that every team of superheroes on The CW needs one. As far as Green Arrow and The Canaries goes, William is perfect for the role.
One of the most underappreciated characters on the show, William shines in short bursts and he adds some much-needed colour to his sister's black-and-white world. And more to the point, Ben Lewis has been a revelation in the role - so with that in mind, it really would be nice to see him continue making us smile here.
5. NO Felicity
Years ago, when fans envisioned the perfect Arrowverse Birds of Prey series, they imagined the likes of Laurel's Black Canary, Speedy, Sara's White Canary, Huntress and Nyssa Al Ghul leading the pack, while many of them also imagined Felicity playing the Oracle role - and why wouldn't they, as she had adopted so many of the comic book legend's traits? However, times have changed.
Following the disaster that was Season 4, the character just hasn't been the same lovable and empowering person she was in those initial two seasons and, quite frankly, it's hard to look at her without thinking of the selfish caricature she became in those dark days. And that in itself highlights one of Arrow's major recurring issues - it can't help itself when Felicity's on-screen. Whenever she's featured, the writers run away with her and stretch her beyond the limits of which she was designed, ramming her down fans' throats in the process.
With Arrow ending, the Arrowverse has a chance to move on from the divisive character once and for all. It's a chance for the writers to finally leave the mistakes of that character in the past and give the focus back to the show's strongest and best-developed characters - characters who were designed with less limitations.
We'll never forget all the brilliance that Felicity Smoak has given us (especially in her first two wonderful years), but it really is time to let her go.
4. Mia Becomes A More Engaging Character
It's common knowledge that a good character doesn't have to be all that likable, so that would be the wrong term to use here. In Mia's case, the priority needs to be making her less unlikable.
A character that is perpetually moody, it's clear that she's Oliver Queen's daughter (as so many characters have humorously pointed out) - there's no doubt about that. That being said, Mia has developed all of her father's broodiness and none of his charm, as she snarls and grunts her way through every mission while finding new ways to be unnecessarily confrontational. And while that shtick might have worked in the future, it doesn't when she's around more experienced vigilantes as she comes across like a petulant delinquent.
However, she's improved a great deal in Season 8, as the writers have finally begun to address the root of her problems and through emotional scenes with the likes of Oliver, William and Laurel, she's becoming that much more engaging. And with the Arrowverse hoping to make her one of three protagonists on a show, it's imperative that this character journey continues going forward.
There's so much potential in Mia, and this show is the writers' chance to make it all a reality.
3. More Female DC Heroes Are Featured
Green Arrow and The Canaries isn't the Arrowverse's first female-led superhero series, but it may just be its most exciting. The closest that The CW's shared universe of vigilantes and villains has ever come to producing the Birds of Prey series that fans had long been calling for, it's a chance for them to delve deep into the DC Comics (and Arrow) archives in order to bring in other female heroes.
The Arrowverse is full of great recurring heroines that fans would undoubtedly be happy to see return to their screens. It goes without saying that they'd like to catch up with Thea (and her and Talia's League of Heroes) at some point, or even cross paths with Jessica De Gouw's Helena Berintelli/Huntress - who we've all been craving to see return since her last appearance back in Arrow's second season. And let's not forget Nyssa and Katana too.
Furthermore, considering the title of the show, we'd all love to see Legends of Tomorrow's White Canary Caity Lotz show up at some point to team up with her sister's doppelganger once again - especially after Arrow's brilliant Lost Canary episode last season.
In terms of returns, there are so many great possibilities here, but this would also be their chance to introduce some new characters too...
2. The Laurel/Dinah Friendship Is Strengthened
The budding friendship between Dinah Laurel Lance and Dinah Drake on Arrow was something of an unexpected one. While the former took issue with the fact that Dinah had become her Earth-1 doppelganger's successor as Team Arrow's Black Canary, the latter soon developed a blood feud against Laurel when she had been coerced into killing the newcomer's love Vigilante. However, when the former Black Siren found redemption, she also ended up finding forgiveness.
Following that, the pair developed a love/hate relationship whereby they ended up working incredibly well together without ever admitting it to each other. Eventually, this developed into friendship and, upon learning of their future from Mia (as the two lieutenants of The Canaries), they attempted to make that future a reality much earlier.
Former enemies that somehow found their way to friendship, these Canaries have a great relationship here and, thanks to the brilliant on-screen chemistry between Katie Cassidy and Juliana Harkavy, it's one that could end up becoming the foundation upon which Green Arrow and The Canaries is built.
With that in mind, it would be nice to see the writers continue to build upon that in the spin-off, strengthening their partnership and ultimately allowing it to flourish - something that would, no doubt, allow the show to do the same.
1. The Canaries Are The Primary Focus
That brings us to the most important of all things that Green Arrow and The Canaries must do, and that is ensuring that the primary focus remains solely on the Black Canary.
Now, obviously in this particular scenario, we have two Canaries - as both Laurel and Dinah currently utilise the mantle - and that's okay. In fact, it's great, as it gives the show two chances to succeed. But it's imperative that it uses it wisely because they are undoubtedly the key of marketing this show.
Black Canary is DC royalty and, as this is the closest the Arrowverse has ever gotten to a Birds of Prey series, it would make perfect sense to maintain the focus on both iterations of her - especially in a year that the character will also make her debut in the Birds of Prey film. More to the point, Katie Cassidy is a household name and, as she was the first leading lady of the Arrowverse, it would also make sense to heavily focus on her character - especially since Earth-2 Laurel has been cited by many as the MVP of Arrow's final season.
At the end of the day, The CW is attempting to appeal to a whole new audience with this show - and as a major part of that audience will naturally be comic book fans - they're going to want to focus on the biggest draws. And in this case, we have two of them.
A legendary DC Comics character who only occasionally received the spotlight she deserved on Arrow, this is the creative team's chance to finally get it right. It's time for these Canaries to Cry.
-
What would you like to see from Green Arrow and The Canaries? Tell us in the comment section below.
The Flash Season 6 Quiz: How Well Do You Remember The First Half?