Grey's Anatomy: Every Season Ranked Worst To Best

The highs and lows of Shonda Rhimes' long-running medical drama.

Greys Anatomy
ABC

After 20 years, as many seasons, countless cast changes, numerous deaths, an endless supply of romantic entanglement and abundant tragedy, Grey's Anatomy shows no signs of slowing down.

Created by TV powerhouse Shonda Rhimes, who would go on to produce such megahits as Scandal and How To Get Away With Murder, Grey's Anatomy premiered at a time of seismic change, when numerous prestige dramas such as The Sopranos, Mad Men, and Deadwood were shaking up the way TV was watched and perceived.

Unlike these shows, though, Grey's Anatomy proved that TV dramas didn't have to be too self-serious or, crucially, male-dominated. With its diverse cast and comedic touch, the show was an instant hit, intensely watchable, and maddeningly popular.

Two decades into its run, it's not able to rake in the rating highs of its early seasons, which could rope in as many as 20 million viewers an episode, but it remains one of the most popular series on-air, and through the years its mark on pop culture has been felt even by those who've never visited Seattle Grace Hospital or the lives of its surgeons.

Grey's Anatomy has endured despite its many reinventions, controversies, and missteps, and for all its inescapable flaws it remains, even at its weakest, a show endlessly fascinating, deeply entertaining, and truly empowering in its depiction of the professional and personal lives of Meredith Grey and her family and friends.

With that in mind, here are all 20 seasons of Grey's Anatomy ranked worst to best, with major spoilers throughout.

20. Season 17

Grey's Anatomy Season 17
ABC

Going into the 2020 TV season, Grey's Anatomy was facing a mountain because of the COVID pandemic, which hindered season 17's production at every turn. But Grey's, never one to shy from a challenge or a real-world cataclysm, took the global tragedy and decided to use it, telling a vital story about the heroics of frontline workers.

And to that end, the much-maligned season actually does quite well, especially when it settles on the real, such as ventilator shortages and the difficulties of performing life-saving surgeries when the simple act of getting close to another human being could bring disaster. 

Following Meredith as she falls into a coma also has its virtues, with cameos from deceased fan favourites George, Mark, Lexie and Derek offering some affecting closure. Unfortunately, Mer being lost in a beached purgatory quickly runs out of steam, and for all its tragedy much of the season ends up feeling repetitive and emotionally dulled. 

All of this is compounded by some questionable twists, from the death of DeLuca to the departure of Jackson, two characters whose stories should have ended with much more care, and a jumbled narrative that can't quite settle on all it wants to say. 


19. Season 16

Grey's Anatomy Season 16
ABC

When a show has been running for as long as Grey's Anatomy, there's almost always a moment where it jumps the shark, taking its drama and the twisty lives of its characters in a direction that proves fatal. 

Such is the case with show's 16th season, which is most famous for the departure of original mainstay Alex Karev. Seeking to leave the show and pursue new things, actor Justin Chambers left Grey Sloan Memorial unceremoniously at best, disappearing without warning before it's revealed he abandoned his wife and friends to live with his estranged ex, Izzie Stevens. 

It's a shocking and terribly executed farewell for a character there since day one, and it doesn't help to make him all that likable despite the nice little letters he writes for everyone he's leaving. Worse still, it distracts from the season's more profound developments, such as Webber's cobalt poisoning and DeLuca's bipolar diagnosis. 

Grey's has always taken big, melodramatic swings (it's had plane crashes, mass shootings, drownings, dreamscapes, you name it), but season 16 may be where it took things too far, executing its biggest storylines with little focus. Potential, wasted. 


18. Season 20

Grey's Anatomy Season 20
ABC

The shortest season since its debut, Grey's Anatomy's landmark 20th chapter brought about some major behind-the-scenes changes, from the heavily reduced role of Meredith's Ellen Pompeo to the loss of Krista Vernoff as showrunner after six years (and many more as a prominent writer). 

Meg Marinis, a writer on the show since its third season, took over from Vernoff with an eye on returning the series to its more emotionally grounded basics, shifting focus from Meredith and back onto the new interns of the hospital. The drama here is simpler than in previous years, more character-focussed, less explosive. 

Meredith still plays a role, and her Alzheimer's research project certainly has some powerful beats, especially when it slows down to remind audiences how far she's come... and how much she's lost. Likewise, prolific mainstays Miranda Bailey and Richard Webber are also on great form as they teach the new interns to thrive. 

Season 20 may feel miles away from where Grey's Anatomy started - and there's a sense, yes, that these newcomers can't carry the show as the old guard did - but it still makes for engaging television. Far from what it was, but it's ticking along just fine. 


17. Season 18

Grey's Anatomy Season 18
ABC

In many ways, Grey's 18th season had an even bigger task than its 17th, because after contending with COVID, it now had to tackle its aftermath, including how the pandemic slowed the progress of the hospital's newest recruits to Meredith's brief flirtation with death. 

And, in classic Grey's Anatomy fashion, the season proves a mixed bag, full of brilliant highs but plenty of undesirable lows. The highs come courtesy of Meredith, who kicks her Alzheimer's research into high gear, whilst Owen illegally supplies drugs to dying veterans and Webber's teaching methods are thrown into question. 

These developments are frequently thrilling and well-executed - Owen, always a conflicted soul, has rarely been so compelling, elevating the season at every turn - but they are hindered at times by the repetitive nature of Amelia's love life and some intern melodrama we've seen a million times over.

With romance and returning faces (Derek's ex Addison, Meredith's new beau Nick), season 18 is full of emotional call-backs to past heartbreak, with just enough filler and meandering subplots to hold it back from greatness. 


16. Season 5

Grey's Anatomy Denny and Izzie
ABC

Where to begin? Season five has some of Grey's Anatomy's most controversial and downright awful storylines, the most prominent of which being Izzie's cancer diagnosis, which causes her to have visions of her late lover Denny, and the absence and eventual death of the beloved George O'Malley. 

These developments are, frankly, pretty poor, especially George's. Though his death offers one of the show's most emotional plot twists, it also appears as if from nowhere, with minimal build-up or care considering his importance to the show's success and fanbase. His is a difficult loss to forgive, even after all these years. 

The Izzie stuff is better, if only because the performances of Katherine Heigl and Justin Chambers are so raw. It tackles grief in a fresh way, though it does drag for an embarrassingly long time before her official cancer diagnosis. 

These much-mocked developments are countered by the season's highs, mind you, including the blossoming relationships of Mark and Lexie, and Callie and Arizona, and the introduction of haunted military doctor Owen Hunt. It's a messy season, to be sure, but this is Grey's Anatomy we're talking about - every cloud has a silver lining. 


15. Season 4

Grey's Anatomy Season 4
ABC

If you were to put a label on Grey's Anatomy's golden years (all long-running shows have them), you'd probably be inclined pick the first three, when Meredith, Cristina, Alex, George, and Izzie were interns and the melodrama of the hospital was at its most new and exciting. 

The series itself clearly agrees with this, because going into its fourth season the writers seemed to suffer something of a creative lull, throwing its characters into positions they'd already been in many times before without offering too much in the way of originality. 

Now, it's not all bad; there are particularly poignant moments with Lexie, Mer's half-sister who reminds her of her fractured childhood, and some funny ones with the scene-stealing Mark Sloan. Season four also gives us Callie's first same-sex relationship after her marriage to George, a wonderful little twist for the show. 

That being said, the season also has Meredith and Derek play another round of break-up-make-up, and new surgical chief Erica Hahn fails to bring the necessary complexities to the OR in the absence of her predecessor, Preston Burke. It's all so very "been-there-done-that," though the seeds it plants are certainly promising. 


14. Season 7

Grey's Anatomy Season 7
ABC

The final season to feature Shonda Rhimes as showrunner, Grey's seventh batch of episodes offered some of the series' most prominent storylines, though for all its emotional highs remains a chapter of jarring stuffiness. 

Overflowing with melodrama and far too many characters, the season's big focus is Callie Torres, whose relationships with Mark Sloan and Arizona Robbins give it its emotional centre. Unfortunately, as entertainingly tragic and empowering as Callie's journey into motherhood and marriage is, it's not always seamless. 

There are moments when the love triangle becomes tiresome and certain episodes drag out their friction, sometimes in such a way that jolts you out of the reality of their situation. The same is true of Meredith and Derek's relationship, which takes a big step but suffers a major setback when Mer tampers with their Alzheimer's research.

A season of frequent brilliance - other highlights being Sara Ramirez's stunning singing voice, Mark and Lexie's fraught will-they-won't-they, and Cristina's PTSD following season six's mass shooting - but tedious repetition, Rhimes's swan song is whole lotta drama, not enough cohesion. 


13. Season 19

Grey's Anatomy Season 19
ABC

Over the years, Grey's Anatomy has had to reinvent itself time and time again. Not just to keep things fresh - though that's a big part of it - but also to compensate for the loss of prominent cast members and to stay attuned to the times.

Season 19 features the show's biggest facelift, as Meredith steps up as Chief of Surgery and attempts to revamp Grey Sloan Memorial with a modern touch. There's a host of new interns who take centre stage, including the pragmatic Jules Millin and charming Lucas Adams, and a sense of great change that shakes up the hospital's veterans. 

Not all of the season works, especially in regards to Pompeo's heavily reduced screen time (she appears in barely half of its 20 episodes) and increased, now-monotonous friction between Owen and Teddy, but when it does, it offers some startling innovation.

The best of the season comes from Bailey and Addison, whose work in abortion care causes them to clash with political extremists. It's harrowing and timely stuff, and a striking reminder that even after all these years, Grey's Anatomy still has plenty left to say about the state of the world. 


12. Season 15

Grey's Anatomy Season 15
ABC

Although Meredith Grey is the centrepiece of Grey's Anatomy, many of the show's seasons actually pick another character and focus most of the upcoming drama around them. Season one had Meredith herself, season two had Izzie, season seven Callie. In season 15, it's Alex Karev who takes centre stage. 

Arguably the medical drama's most complex character, Karev is stuck in love with Jo Wilson and haunted by memories of his mother, all the while trying to prove his worth as the hospital's new Chief of Surgery. Each storyline is powerfully executed, making perfect use of Karev's fractious childhood and compelling contradictions.

Elsewhere, the season also tackles domestic abuse with one of Grey's most powerful hours, when Jo learns the secret of her birth and forms an emotional bond with a survivor of sexual assault. Jo's collapse into depression offers some of the show's most meaningful scenes. 

Aside from Karev and Jo, it's not all smooth sailing, with Meredith's insurance fraud storyline and Owen and Teddy's dreary relationship woes proving particularly unconvincing. But even so, season 15 is urgent and affecting enough to survive its flaws. Like Jackson, it finds enlightenment within the heartbreak and horror. 


11. Season 12

Grey's Anatomy Season 12
ABC

As it stands, Meredith Grey may just be the most tragic character on TV. Since the first season of Grey's Anatomy, she's survived a bomb explosion, drowned, lost both parents, seen a dozen of her closest friends die, landed in a coma, and, by season 12, she's also recently been made a widow. 

The death of Derek Shepherd weighs heavily this season, and the show's customary depictions of grief are heavier than ever. Meredith throws herself into work, and, in the absence of Cristina, forms a surprising but loving friendship with Karev. Elsewhere, Callie and Arizona have a heartwrenching custody battle over their daughter. 

These developments, all mashed together amongst the usual surgical cases and grieving families, make season 12 one of the show's most gruelling. The Callie/Arizona clash in particular is difficult to stomach, though not quite as harrowing as watching Mer brutally attacked by a violent patient, her jaw, leg, and arm broken. 

Season 12 won't win any prizes for its joy - it also has Amelia breaking years of sobriety, just for good measure - but wins everything for the power of its stories, and the way it allows its key characters to heal by the final episode.


10. Season 13

Grey's Anatomy Season 13
ABC

Grey's Anatomy's 13th season offers another big change, only this one is more meta than previous or future efforts. The arrival of consultant Eliza Minnick forces the hospital to clean old wounds and adapt to new practices, little of which sit well with the staff.

This development is the season's great strength and biggest weakness. Because whilst Minnick throws a wrench into the lives of the residents, pitting them against their interns and shaking up previously strong dynamics, Minnick herself dominates the screen without much depth of character (the same issue also true of Mer's new love interest, Nathan Riggs). 

This glaring issue aside, though, season 13 also takes some bold and exciting leaps, especially in regards to Karev facing jail time for beating DeLuca, and April and Jackson's attempts to adapt to life as parents. It also has a couple of almost-bottle episodes in place to separate its warring surgeons and give them room to breathe. 

Tackling post-partem depression, prison healthcare, and a literally explosive finale that puts a heroic Stephanie Edwards front-and-centre, season 14 is not without its flaws, but its emotional depth and challenging character arcs are enough for it to offer some of the show's most compelling late-era episodes. 


9. Season 10

Grey's Anatomy Season 10
ABC

Season ten starts with a raging storm following the chaos of the season nine premiere. Webber is badly injured, Bailey is suffering from OCD, Meredith and Cristina's friendship is disintegrating, and April leaves her would-be husband at the altar after Jackson confesses his love for her. 

And this is just the tip of the iceberg, because season ten is surely one of Grey's Anatomy's most densely packed chapters. To its credit, though, almost all of it works, from Derek's invitation to work with the White House, to Callie and Arizona's separation. It sometimes ties itself up because so much is happening, but what happens is deeply rewarding.

The key storyline of the season comes from Cristina, who decides to leave the hospital to work wonders over in Switzerland. It's the end of an era, but the way she manages to leave Seattle so amicably and on her own terms makes for one of the show's few peaceful farewells.

Before the end, Cristina was the glue holding much of the show together, her loving but no-bullsh*t attitude making her an entertaining force to be reckoned with. Things would never be the same again, but who doesn't love a happy ending?


8. Season 14

Grey's Anatomy Season 14
ABC

The first season to feature long-time writer Krista Vernoff as showrunner, Grey's 14th outing takes a refreshingly upbeat approach to its drama, making it a welcome breath of fresh air following years of all-out relentless tragedy.

With some added comedy courtesy of the arrival of DeLuca's OB/GYN sister Carina, the season's most prominent developments give many long-suffering surgeons a much-needed break. Jackson inherits his late grandfather's fortune, Karev and Jo finally get married, and Meredith wins the coveted Harper Avery Award. 

There are some hardships amongst these splashes of happiness, of course (this is still Grey's Anatomy, after all), from the reveal that Harper Avery was a sexual predator who used his wealth to escape accountability, to Amelia's battle to survive a brain tumour, but not enough to leave you reeling too badly. 

Season 14 tackles the usual with a comforting display of togetherness, giving touching moments to Karev and Jo after years of struggle, following Meredith as she reaches a new career high, and allowing April to find solace after a wrenching crisis of faith. It's still heartbreaking, but the joy is there in wonderful abundance. 


7. Season 8

Grey's Anatomy Season 8
ABC

Season eight offered fans Grey's Anatomy's biggest twist yet when, in the finale, Meredith, Derek, Cristina, Mark, Lexie, and Arizona are involved in a calamitous plane crash. The build-up to this moment is expertly crafted, making the tragedy of it all the more devastating. 

The main focus this season shifts between character and place, as Meredith and Derek's marriage suffers from her recent tampering of their Alzheimer's trial, and various couples - from Mark and Lexie to Jackson and April - struggle with conflicted feelings and heartbreak.

This is, all told, Grey's at its most romantic, following the surgeons as they finally put themselves out there to seek the relationships they've always wanted but never had. Mark goes from arrogant playboy to loving father and boyfriend, Mer and Derek show marriage for all its colours, and Webber bids farewell to his wife. 

It's all rather thrilling at times, watching all these characters battle their instincts and fears whilst the usual patients come flooding in. But with the season's ability to sell the drama so poignantly comes that final twist, to date one of Grey's most horrible bolts from the blue. Can't these guys have anything nice?!


6. Season 11

Derek Shepherd Grey's Anatomy
ABC

To date, season 11 remains Grey's Anatomy at its most inventive. It features the usual trials and tribulations - Derek moving to Washington and straining his marriage to Meredith; another of Mer's secret sisters arrives in town - but explores the backstory and trauma of Meredith's life with startling creativity.

Utilising stirring flashbacks to give added insight into Meredith's childhood and her fraught relationship with her late mother, the season is a deeply moving exploration of family, following Meredith as she connects with her sister Maggie, and Webber as he grapples with the news he's Maggie's father. 

Amongst this, Derek meets a nasty fate, left braindead in a car accident before dying in hospital. But it's worth noting that, difficult as it is to let McDreamy go, his final episode actually sends him off brilliantly, with a level of tension and emotional weight to make it feel real rather than forced (like, say, what happened with George).

Emotionally resonant, rarely manipulative, and full of unforgettable performances courtesy of Pompeo, Patrick Dempsey, and James Pickens Jr, Grey's 11th chapter is the show at its most bold and insightful. 


5. Season 6

Greys Anatomy Season 6
ABC

Some Grey's Anatomy seasons work in spite of their flaws, their best developments overshadowing them (see seasons four or 15), but the best seasons are the ones that build to the big moments with real purpose, the major twists revealed in such a way that they feel both inevitable yet shocking.

Such is the case with season six, which in its final episodes throws the hospital into turmoil when a grieving widower commits a mass shooting. The shooting is the most horrible thing Grey's has ever done, but it's never manipulative.

Before this, the drama is already of the highest order. From Derek becoming Chief of Surgery, to the departure of Izzie Stevens and the aftermath of George's death, the season allows each of its characters time to thrive as their careers take drastic turns, all the while dropping painful hints of the horrors to come. 

It has all the hallmarks of classic Grey's Anatomy - the one-night stands, the outlandish surgeries - and for all its pain (Meredith has a miscarriage whilst watching her husband die from a gunshot wound, in one of her greatest tragedies) it still manages to find some laughs and hope amongst the chaos.


4. Season 1

Grey's Anatomy Season 1
ABC

And here we have it, folks: where it all began. Introducing the world to Seattle Grace Hospital and new interns Meredith Grey, Cristina Yang, Alex Karev, George O'Malley, and Izzie Stevens, Grey's Anatomy was a hit from day one, striking a chord with audiences in just nine episodes of drama. 

Full of compelling characters, romantic entanglements, and medical turmoil, the show's debut season blended classic rom-com tropes with procedural thrills, all the while casting actors of colour in positions of power, and allowing its female protagonists to be just as successful and sexually free as their male counterparts. 

Groundbreaking in almost every regard, Grey's debut launched its cast to superstardom, introduced a string of terminology into everyday use - "my person," "McDreamy" - and proved that popular TV dramas didn't just have to be emotionally powerful, they could also be laidback, sexy, and amusing with their character-driven stories.

Watching Grey's humble beginnings again after all these years is to see all of this and more, but also that, 20 years later, the show's rarely been better than when it first threw Meredith and Derek together, or when its baby-faced interns were just getting started.


3. Season 3

Grey's Anatomy Season 3
ABC

Following on from the heartbreak of the previous season, season three decides to double down on the tragedy with a string of major deaths, break-ups, and professional conundrums. 

This time around, the season's centrepiece is Meredith, who drowns attempting to save a man after a ferry accident. The resulting near-death experience throws her into an almost purgatorial state (to be revisited in a big way in season 17), and puts her life - as well as the lives of her loved ones - into crystal clear focus.

Amongst this, there's no pause between each calamity, from the death of Meredith's mother and stepmother, George's father, and Webber and Adele's unborn child. Meanwhile, Cristina starts performing Burke's surgeries so no one will notice he has tremors in his hand from his near-fatal shooting last year. 

Twistingly intense, Grey's third season packs an extra wallop of heartbreak, but it all comes together brilliantly, allowing its interns to become more burdened, more flawed, more lost, and more conflicted than ever before. The results are dynamite, a perfect cocktail of the show's ability to be both wonderfully over-the-top and authentically heartrending. 


2. Season 9

Grey's Anatomy Season 9
ABC

Season nine starts where season eight ends, with Meredith, Derek, Cristina, Mark, Lexie, and Arizona stranded following a plane crash. From there, it creates some of the show's most unforgettably heartbreaking drama from its immediate aftermath. 

The season starts as it means to go on, by killing Lexie just as she and Mark confess their love for each other. Afterward, the disasters keep coming. Mark dies after slipping in and out of a coma. Arizona loses a leg. Derek's career is derailed by a wounded hand. The survivors win a large sum of money, buy the hospital, and rename it Grey Sloan after Lexie and Mark. 

All of this may sound like too much, but the strength of season nine is how surprisingly measured it all is. We're given emotional insight into Derek and Mark's friendship, Jackson's role is expanded when he becomes the director of his grandfather's multi-billion dollar foundation, and in the end, despite everything, there's a real sense of peace. 

Season nine balances the melodrama and the emotional reality of its characters' world perfectly, constantly seeing how far it can push them without ever becoming gratuitously hopeless. Grey's has rarely been so daring or agonising before or since.


1. Season Two

Grey's Anatomy Denny and Izzie
ABC

The longest season, and the best. Fans could argue until the end of time how to rank the rest of the show's seasons, but few will argue against Grey's Anatomy's second year being its greatest. 

This was the year that had it all, where all of Shonda Rhimes' skills and ambitions came into focus. The sexual tension is ramped up to eleven as Meredith deals with the arrival of Derek's estranged wife, Addison, and the emotions run at an all-time high as Cristina suffers a miscarriage, George starts a relationship with Callie, and Izzie falls in love. 

The Izzie subplot is the most compelling, and arguably the most iconic of the series, following her as she falls for Jeffrey Dean Morgan's dying patient Denny. Their relationship is doomed from the start, but beautiful in its brevity and made all the more powerful by the nerve-wracking performance of Katherine Heigl. 

Balancing Meredith's relationship and professional woes with a real, authentic sense of loss, season two is the medical drama at its absolute best. From Denny's final fate to the friendship of George and Bailey, from the introduction of Addison Montgomery to its horribly tense bomb episode, this is far and away Grey's Anatomy's finest chapter. 


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/