Hannibal: 10 Things That Would've Happened Next

If you are feeling hungry for more of NBC's Hannibal, let's see where could the show have gone next!

hannibal cast
NBC

A show that quite literally ended on a cliffhanger, NBC's Hannibal was the show that had us hungry for more. Sadly, Hannibal was cut down after just three seasons, thanks to tumbling ratings and constant schedule movements. The cast were released from their contracts, and the bidding war between networks died down.

Creator Bryan Fuller had reportedly planned a seven-season arc, pulling out Thomas Harris' trilogy of books centering around the cannibalistic psychiatrist. Stars like Mads Mikkelsen, Hugh Dancy, and Gillian Anderson have gone on to bigger things, but all have expressed an interest for a second course of Hannibal.

While everything has been quieter than an awkward dinner party, fans will be relieved to know that talks are rumoured to be starting up again in early 2017. With Bryan Fuller recently departing Star Trek Discovery, now would be as good a time as any for Dr. Lecter to sharpen his kitchen knives. Could next year be the year that we see "Hannibal Rising" again, or will it all fall flatter than a souffle?

While we salivate over the thought, let's look at where the show could have gone in Season 4 and beyond - my mouth is already watering at the prospect.

10. Hannibal (2001)

Hannibal Kiss
Universal Pictures

The TV show stole not only the namesake, but the majority of the plot devices from 2001's horror-thriller. Gary Oldman's Mason Verger took up the mantra as the film's big bad, and we had the infamous pig scenes. Unfortunately all this was used across Season 3 of the show, but there are still some elements we could have seen.

Presumably developed over a multi-season arc (and assuming they got the rights to Clarice) you would see a final showdown between Lecter and his new FBI plaything. We already saw his psychotropic drug use on Bedelia and the two fleeing to Italy, which is exactly how Robert Harris' book series ended.

However, fans of the films will know that there was a very different ending in the Hopkins era of films, where Clarice handcuffed herself to Hannibal, and he chopped off his own hand to escape. Asking how many lives can one man have, having Hannibal once again "on the lamb" offers either an ending or a continuation for the series.


9. Back Behind Bars

The Silence Of The Lambs Anthony Hopkins Hannibal Lecter
Orion Pictures

Serving as a cat and mouse affair, the capture and escape of Hannibal Lecter has always played a large part in both the books and the films. Arguably the masked menace is never more terrifying than when he is behind bars and teasing you with his escape.

The show flipped that formula around in the first season, having Hugh Dancy's Will Graham putting on a perspex version of the infamous Hannibal mask, but flash forward to the show's end and we had a daring car escape by an incarcerated Lecter. However, we need Lecter back behind bars again, if only to escape for one particular scene.

Jonathan Demme's 1991 thriller/horror Silence of the Lambs sees Lecter attack his guards, and the glorious image of his blood-soaked face conducting classical music. Lecter's method of escape was to disguise himself using the face of a recently downed officer, and it would be perfect for the Fullerverse. Having the face switch-a-roo is one of the most chilling moments in an already horrifying film, and one that the show just had to do somehow. Imagine Hannibal and Will swapping faces? It would be an incredible way to send the character off!


8. The 'Lass' Resort

Hannibal Scene
NBC

One of the incredibly annoying loose ends of the series was "Whatever happened to Miriam Lass?" Due to legal troubles with MGM, Fuller's Hannibal couldn't acquire the rights to any of 1991 Silence of the Lambs material - this meant that plot points and characters belonged to the studio, while MGM ended up selling the Clarice Starling story to Lifetime.

Lass therefore served as a replacement Clarice Starling, a rising FBI Agent, who after her brief brush with death, returned for an even briefer stint on the show. Under the influence of Lecter's hypnosis, Lass incorrectly accused Dr. Chilton of being the Chesapeake Ripper, and when put in an interrogation room, shot Chilton (who survived) through the cheek. Lass was never seen from again, and we will never know why she wasn't used further.

Presuming that NBC couldn't get the rights to Clarice, Lass could easily have served as the 'Clarice' character on a more permanent basis - the tough new female presence to go up against Lecter. The whole Will and Hannibal story was winding down to some sort of romantic entanglement, but the show definitely needed a Clarice-esque voice. From what little we saw of Anna Chlumsky's performance, she was more than a great match for Lecter, and it was a shame we didn't see her more.


7. A Verger Merger

Hannibal Clarice
NBC

While her vile brother Mason is bobbing around the bottom of a fish tank, Margot Verger is very much still part of the Hannibalverse. However, what could force Margot to return? Oh I don't know...say the death of Alana Bloom? When we last left the couple they were running into hiding for fear that Lecter would come for them.

Pretty much all of the Verger storyline from the novel Hannibal may have been used up, and perhaps one of the most disappointing aspects was the portrayal of Margot. The character of the books was a tough bodybuilder, and I couldn't wait to see that played out screen. Katharine Isabelle was great at her own take, but there was something missing from Margot.

The family estate, and the wealth is still out there, plus a desire to get revenge on Lecter. Alana Bloom seemed pretty happy in her lesbian tryst, but Hannibal never really did happy endings did it? Bloom's story had run her course, but a roid-rage Margot could be just what the doctor ordered.


6. Barney Rubble

Hannibal Barney
NBC

Fan-favourite Barney Matthews was one of Thomas Harris' few characters who escaped the wrath of Dr. Lecter unharmed. Showing that manners get you everywhere, Lecter preferred to eat the rude, which he called "free range rude."

Most known for the portrayal by Frankie Faison in all three of the Hopkins Hannibals, Barney was the head orderly at the Baltimore State Mental Hospital for the Criminally Insane. Unlike Dr. Chilton, Barney was kind to Lecter, and it is undoubtedly what saved his life. Having a much larger part in the books than the films, the book even starts up a romantic liaison between Barney and Margot Verger. With Chilton left *erm* incapacitated at the end of Fuller's show, if Lecter were to return to the hospital, there would have to be someone else in charge. Given her ties with the Verger storyline, perhaps Alana Bloom again, which could tie him back into his relationship with Margot.

After Lecter's escape, it is revealed that Barney is posing online, selling off valuable Lecter merchandise as a way to get rich after the hospital's closure. As the final chapter of the Hannibal book actually takes place from the viewpoint of Barney himself, the character is a must-have addition to the cast.


5. I'll Have The Bill Please

Hannibal Buffalo Bill
MGM

Making up 90% of The Silence of the Lambs story, aside from Clarice, the other biggest missing piece of the puzzle was Buffalo Bill. The story of the man who put moth pupae down his victims throats even inspired the classic poster for the film, so if Hannibal was going to make it to seven seasons, some iteration of Bill would have turned up.

Buffalo Bill (real name Jame Gumb) was the story's biggest villain alongside Lecter and Frances Dollarhyde. Played by Ted Levine in Silence of the Lambs, Buffalo Bill became synonymous with horror villains, and even managed to out-horror Hannibal. Fuller must have had an idea to either include Gumb, or find a way to create the character again like he did with Lass.

Possibly sensing the show's end, Fuller moved the formula for his seasons up. Season 3 of the show packed in a hell of a lot into it, combining both the Hannibal and Red Dragon novels, which presumably meant that Silence of the Lambs (aimed for Season 5 and 6) would have become the sixth the final seasons. With the show cancelled we will never know, but presumably Fuller had a vision.


4. Brain Food

ray Liotta Hannibal.jpg
Universal Pictures

Alongside pig feasts, Buffallo Bill's dancing, and Miggs throwing his seed at Clarice, the other most infamous scene of the films is the one where Ray Liotta eats his own grey matter. Hannibal's 'dinner party' scene where FBI Agent Paul Krendler dines on himelf is cemented as one of the film's most graphic scenes.

Krendler himself was never introduced, although back in Season 2, the introduction of Cynthia Nixon's Kade Prurnell instantly seemed to fit the role - K.P = P.K. As an investigator for the Office of the Inspector General, Prurnell had the balls to take on Jack Crawford and Will Graham, but she became another loose send.

Prurnell's departure was never really explained, and it would be fantastic to see her return to ruffle some feathers. She would be just in time to be Lecter's main course, all that falling to your death and surviving must be hungry work. Plus it gives Cynthia Nixon the chance to get her chops back into the show, joining the other female powerhouses like Gillian Anderson and Caroline Dhavernas.


3. Dinner For Two

hannibal gillian anderson
NBC

It is a given that after Will and Hannibal's cliff tumble, Dr. Lecter would be out of action for a while. The show would need someone to take his place as killer in waiting, before his triumphant and bloody, return. Who better than his psychiatrist-cum-wife Bedelia? If anything, it would just be great to get some more Gillian Anderson screentime. All the more fitting, because the very last shot of the series was a lonely Anderson waiting for dinner with Hannibal, and her freshly cooked leg plonked in front of her.

So, what would be next for the blonde bombshell? Well, Season 3 revealed that Bedelia wasn't as pure as she claimed to be, and had actually murdered her patient Neal Frank (Zachary Quinto). We also saw her get a reluctant taste for bloodlust in Italy, so her take over from Hannibal would be a relatively easy transition. You can bet that Bedelia would look great in the see-through kill mac, and that even with only one leg she could outrun the authorities.


2. The Silence Of The Lambs

Clarice Silence Of The Lambs
Orion Pictures

Sticking with the theme of Silence of the Lambs, the Clarice Starling origin has Bryan Fuller's artistic licence written all over it. Can you imagine slow motion animal slaughter and more blood than a Nightmare on Elm Street film?

The story of a backwater girl with her cop daddy, meant that Clarice always aspired to be in law enforcement. Her father was shot on duty and died a month later, which was a point that Lecter was all too quick to pick up on. After her father's death, Clarice was sent to her aunt and uncle's horse farm, where she witnessed the slaughter of lambs, citing the "silence" of the lambs.

However, her tragedy didn't end there. Clarice ran away and was taken in by a Lutheran orphanage, which all pieced together to make the tough and cold individual that Lecter meets. We do love a good sob story, and if Fuller ever did get his hands on Clarice, it would have been just perfect.


1. Where There's A Will, There's A Way

Hugh Dancy Gun Hannibal Tv Will Graham Nbc
NBC

Could a complete turn of events have had Will Graham killed off after his cliff fall? No matter what happened, there would need to be a time when Hugh Dancy stepped aside so Clarice (or someone similar) could be in the limelight. It is hard to imagine having two such large characters in the Hannibal literature sharing the same space, but it is also hard to imagine the show without Will.

There could have been a season that was relatively light on Will, allowing the Silence of the Lambs storyline play out, returning for a team of FBI characters to team up against Hannibal once more. The only other option is that Will gives in to the bond that he and Lecter share, and the pair become more than just patient/doctor - a'la Clarice and Hannibal in the books or Hannibal and Bedelia in the show.

Dancy told collider that Fuller's idea for Season 4 was:

"Really fantastic. … It took us back to the first season in a very unexpected way, and made total sense of that cliffhanger ending; it seemed justified. It was born out of a part of one of the books so it was still coming out of that universe, but it wasn't the Clarice/Silence Of The Lambs storyline."

We can only guess what Fuller had in mind, but presumably something to do with Lecter's old patient and a reimagining of the Silence of the Lambs material.


In this post: 
Hannibal
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Warden of the north - bearded and tattooed. Lover of all things Horror Storied, Throned and Walking whilst Dead. Twitter: tomtomchap