His Dark Materials: 10 Things The TV Series Must Get Right

Please don't be anything like the movie.

It turns out that Philip Pullman's Northern Lights was wrong: there IS something to be gained from wishing. After years of wishing and hoping for the author's His Dark Materials trilogy to receive the adaptation it's so deserving of, but never really thinking it would come true, the BBC has once more shown just how important it really is by announcing that it's going to be making a TV series based on the books. YES! Pullman's books are an epic work of fantasy, rich in world building and an ever fantastical set of characters and creatures, from armoured bears (the panserbjørn) to witches, but it's so much more than that. It's a story of real people, of human life, and of being a child and having to grow-up. Over the past two decades children and adults alike have found themselves entrenched in this world, which is just like ours and yet oh so different. However, while in this time we've witnessed the likes of Harry Potter, Lord of the Rings, and A Song of Ice and Fire become global pop culture phenomenons with big adaptations, His Dark Materials still feels like something of a hidden gem, which wasn't helped by the disastrous 2007 movie The Golden Compass. Thankfully it is now getting the second chance it deserves, but if the TV series is to succeed like those other well-known literary adaptations, there's a few things it's going to have to get right. Ignoring the film is only the start.

10. Stay Faithful To The Books

Just incase it wasn't clear from that intro, I love the books. If you're reading this, you probably love the books too. And why wouldn't you? They're an utter joy to read at any age, and the first two in particular are rather stunning works of fiction. So, why would you need to change anything? Yes, there's always going to be some things you can do in a book that you can't on TV, and vice versa, but on the whole the new series needs to stay very much true to the books. It's been so carefully plotted, the world so precisely built, that it's all there for them. Don't needlessly change the chronology, don't have the exposition-filled intro, and don't remove the f***ing ending.

9. Make It For A Grown-Up Audience

His Dark Materials is aimed at a variety of audiences. The beauty is that you could read it at pretty much any age, revisiting it at various stages, and find different kinds of enjoyment and meanings from it. As a child it's a wonder-filled fantasy, a magical realm to escape into. As a teenager, a story about growing-up. As an adult, an expertly-written critique of organised-religion. Presumably this will be a flagship show for the BBC, something to put on a Saturday night when Doctor Who is off the air. As such, it'll need to have a broader appeal than something like, say, Game of Thrones. But that doesn't mean it has to be too light, and they should trust the audience with some more grown-up material. Indeed, Doctor Who has been airing increasingly later over the last couple of years, dealing with dark themes or scary monsters (or both). An adaptation of His Dark Materials needs to deal with the strong themes and dramatic elements, while maintaining the fantasy setting.

8. Take Their Time

The Golden Compass wasn't even two hours long. That seems pretty remarkable for any blockbuster these days, and especially one adapted from such rich source material (by contrast, the shortest Harry Potter film is 2 hours 10 minutes, and that was from a book split into two movies!). You just can't do justice to these books in that space of time. There's an array of characters, a world filled with magical creatures, and various machinations pulling the plot strings together. Basically, it seems perfectly suited for a TV adaptation, if they take their time with it. The plan is for 8 episodes (with a report of five seasons being the goal), and you'd imagine these will be somewhere between 45-60 minutes in length. If the entirety of Season 1 follows the first book, Northern Lights, then that's 6-8 hours of screentime in which to do it. There's no need to rush things, or make unnecessary changes to expedite the plot.

7. World Building

Northern Lights may take place in Oxford, England, but it's not as we know it. From armoured bears to witches, through to everyone having a dæmon, the Magisterium, and of course Dust, the world of His Dark Materials is rich with characters, locations, stories, and history. From Jordan College to Svalbard, Cittagazze to the Land of the Dead, there are some incredible locations in the books, ones readers would love to visit and experience if given the chance. This is a way of doing that. One of the great things about Game of Thrones is the way they've created each location. They're all distinct, and fantastically detailed. With the opportunities the lands and locations of His Dark Materials offer, that's the sort of quality they should be aiming for here.

6. Give It The Budget It Deserves

As mentioned throughout this article, there's a whole lot in this world that needs to be translated properly to the screen. Those locations, the fantastical creatures, they need to be brought to life in the best way possible, and that means spending a fair bit of money. That's perhaps the biggest question mark over this at the minute. Will the BBC be able to deliver on the big budget this show needs, especially when it comes to the special effects? They haven't always been successful on Doctor Who, but then they're probably not as important there. The 'Beeb' can do fantastic drama, but with His Dark Materials they'll have to show that they can dig deep into the coffers and deliver on spectacle as well. Bad Wolf, who are working with New Line Cinema on the series, have just partnered with HBO, so hopefully that may help things in terms of delivering the scale it needs.

5. Have Fun With The Dæmons

Who doesn't want a dæmon? They're a loyal companion that, up until a certain age, can take the shape of animal in the world, and then settle into something that reflects your personality, and stay with you for the rest of your life. You'll picture it being some fantastic mythical or bad-ass creature, but in truth it's probably just a cat or a dog. But that's still fine, because it's a cat or dog capable of human thought and speech, and they won't die, and you don't have to clean up any mess. While they'd still make a great companion once you've grown-up, let's be honest: the most fun is when they're changing forms. Thankfully, this period does last a while, and it's something the show can really have fun with. They can introduce a wide-array of dæmons, and really play around with the visuals of them changing into all manner of animals, big and small, real and fictional.

4. Get The Right Cast

While the film got a lot of things wrong, one of the few aspects you cannot criticise too much is the casting. Nicole Kidman was pretty much pitch-perfect as the manipulative Mrs Coulter, and Dakota Blue Richards delivered an assured performance for a child actor as the feisty Lyra. While it's unlikely that they could attract Kidman back to the role, and Richards is too old to convincingly play Lyra, it's important that they get these two characters right in particular, given just how important they are to the story (there's a wide-array of characters who serve their purpose, but these (along with Will) would be considered the main ones). Get them right, and the rest of the cast should hopefully fall into place. Thankfully, there's a lot of great British acting talent out there in TV. Just look at the cast lists for shows such as Game of Thrones, Doctor Who, Downton Abbey and Broadchurch. Wrangling stars from those or similar series, or perhaps discovering an unknown talent for Lyra, and getting the best possible people to play the part is an absolute must if this show is to succeed.

3. Iorek Byrnison

This falls somewhat into the category of having the necessary budget, but it's a very specific part of that, and much more besides. Iorek Byrnison is an armoured bear, a loyal and fierce companion to Lyra, and one of the biggest and best characters in the entire trilogy (as well as the small spin-off book, Once Upon a Time in the North). He's thus got to play a major part in any adaptation, and the BBC need to find a way of successfully pulling off a talking polar bear on a week-in, week-out basis, all the while making him feel like a real character with intelligence and emotion. It's one of the big obstacles they'll face, and one they absolutely need to overcome in the right way. That means that the CGI or whatever else they use to create him has to be spot-on, he can't just be used sparingly, and they need the right voice actor for him as well. No pressure, Beeb.

2. Improve On The Finale

If there was a misstep in His Dark Materials, I'd say it was The Amber Spyglass. Not that it was bad - far from it - but it didn't have that same sense of majesty, the story wasn't as gripping and as flowing, as in Northern Lights and The Subtle Knife. It's generally a bit more scattered, while creatures like the Mulefa will be difficult to adapt convincingly (four-legged wheeled animals, with one leg at the front, one at the beg, and then one on each side). Hopefully they can do that, and also pull it all together into a slightly more focused piece of work. The end battle is something that can hopefully play out well on screen too, and they can make it into a truly epic war (provided they, y'know, have the budget).

1. Don't Play Down The Religious Themes

There has been a lot made of what the film got wrong, and how it changed from the book, and one of the biggest is the notion that there was significant pressure to tone down the anti-religious themes that play out throughout both Northern Lights and the subsequent instalments. It still came in for some criticism for its portrayal of the Catholic Church and organised religion in general, but nowhere near on the scale the book did. If you've read the book, you'll know that it is very critical of organised religion, with author Philip Pullman being a noted atheist. It's a big part of the series, and an important one, because it plays into how the characters act and react to situations, and is tied up in the entire plot of the trilogy. You can't make an effective adaptation of this story while ignoring this aspect, it simply doesn't work. Hopefully the BBC will realise this. Yes, unfortunately, there's always going to be those people who get upset by it. The MailOnline will no doubt write a highly negative piece about how the BBC HATES CATHOLICS and their readers will take to the comments in their droves to complain about their money being wasted on 'leftist propaganda bulls**t'. But generally most people who are going to watch the show, and have read the books, can accept its message, regardless of their beliefs. Getting angry or upset about it would be like an atheist getting upset about the Chronicles of Narnia. There's also so much more to this book than just the religious (or anti-religious) aspect, with an incredible fantasy world, an exciting plot, and deep characters, so there's plenty to enjoy (indeed, it'll no doubt go over the heads of the younger portion of the audience anyway), and there's no need to ignore it in fear of some criticism or controversy. Do that, and you'll end up p*ssing off the people who really matter to the books and the show: the fans. Are you excited for the TV series of His Dark Materials? What do they need to do to get it right? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.