How I Met Your Mother: 10 Greatest Fantasy Sequences

The times that How I Met Your Mother got weird.

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

Being a television show centred around a group of people living in New York City, you would think that How I Met Your Mother would stay pretty rooted in realism. You would be dead wrong on this assumption.

This popular television show is a great blend of both realism and exaggeration, making these characters seem relatable while also putting them in ridiculous situations. This show does not take itself too seriously, and nothing shows that better than some of the strange skits that pop up throughout the show.

This show has some of the most bizarre fantasy sequences that could possibly be on television, mostly due to Barney Stinson, played by Neil Patrick Harris. The womanizing character tells plenty of ridiculous stories, most of which are not true, leading to these wild fantasy scenes that have almost nothing to do with the plot.

From lavish and-in-your-face musical numbers, to scenes involving sexualized manatee costumes, this show really has it all, even if you didn't ask for it.

10. The Front Porch

How I Met Your Mother Ted Marshall Lily
CBS

The front porch is something that Lily imagines when she is trying to decide if she likes a woman Ted is dating. She pictures the four of them, Lily, Marshall, Ted, and the girlfriend, old and sitting together on a front porch.

If the image provided is not to Lily’s satisfaction, she decides to break them up, being almost like an angel of death for Ted’s relationships.

Seeing three of our main characters in old age makeup sitting on a front porch is a funny image as is, not to mention the fact that the picturesque moment is normally comedically ruined by someone that Ted is dating. The prospect of them all growing old together is very adorable, and adds to the strong bond between the characters.

Although a very odd test to see if you like someone, it is extremely endearing on the part of Lily. The fact that the show went through so much effort to show us all the characters in their old age on a traditional porch is very odd, but very enjoyable to watch.


9. Mystery Vs. History

How I Met Your Mother Janet
CBS

The Mystery vs. History episode features some very poignant imagery about how technology is used in today’s day and age to cloud your view of people.

The episode is about Ted going on a date with a beautiful woman, and they have both agreed to not Google each other beforehand. However, after receiving a link to her Google page from every single one of his friends, he caves and looks her up.

He finds out that she is better than he could’ve ever imagined, saving dying children and having a genius level IQ on top of being a stunning woman to look at. We then see the digital wall go up, showing her face surrounded by all of the things he has seen about her online.

Although this isn’t one of the most exciting or visually stunning moments in the show, the way that it perfectly encapsulates how you can see someone when dating in the digital age is executed so well. By showing the wall in front of someone, it shows what the average person will see when they first meet someone, especially when they know things about them through social media.


8. The Sexless Innkeeper

How i met your mother
CBS

The sexless innkeeper is a poem that Barney had written to describe the idea of using someone for a place to sleep.

We are returned to a year to Barney telling the tale, though the image we are given is of an old tavern with powdered wigs and horse-drawn carriages. As Ted tries to point out that if this was a year ago, then carriages don’t really make sense, he is simply trampled by Barney continuing.

He tells a tale all in rhyme about how he was stranded in Queens and used a woman so he could sleep on her couch. Unattractive, he did not want to sleep with her, so he simply pretended that he fell asleep, getting a safe night indoors, while leaving her with a stranger asleep in her apartment.

This scene so perfectly gives us the image of what a Barney Stinson story is like, as most of them tend to return to this era in history, featuring most of the cast in revolutionary garb. It is such a strange image to go from their small apartment in New York City, to a tavern during revolutionary times, all for Barney to tell his ridiculous story.


7. Every Single Play In The Playbook

Playbook Barney Stinson
CBS

The Playbook is the prized possession of Barney Stinson. It shows us all the different “plays” that he uses to seduce women.

Although a bit problematic for today's standards, every single time the playbook is mentioned and/or something from the playbook is put into action, it conjurs just a bizarre image.

Some of the plays in the book involve him dressing up as a genie, putting up his phone number on national television, and even rescuing a cat and “returning it” to a woman who lost her pet. These plays are absolutely ridiculous, and they often show Barney in very hilarious scenarios.

It’s a strange blend of everyone else being completely normal, and Barney in a complicated web of lies that he has created, complete with matching costumes and various accents. Some of these moments are ones that fans of the show recall frequently, showing that they really stick in the minds of those that view them.

Though not the craziest scenes in the world, the absurdity of Barney throughout all of them is what makes them so great, and choosing just one of them would be impossible.


6. The Ye Olde Creation Of The Bro Code

Bro Code How I Met Your Mother
CBS

The Bro Code is an integral part of How I Met Your Mother, being spoken of many different times, and actually being published into a real book that you can purchase. The supposed origins of the Bro Code are really what makes it special and also what makes it even more absurd.

We are taken back to revolutionary times again to see Benjamin Franklin and George Washington having a drink at a tavern in Philadelphia. Franklin accuses Washington of “codpiece block[ing]” him to which Washington states that there is no rule against it.

After they agree that someone should compile these rules, Barnabus Stinson, Barney’s ancestor, steps up to the plate and decides to write the Bro Code. This scene is so ridiculous, featuring our founding fathers in an argument about who went home with which woman.

This is obviously not true, but it does give the audience a chance to see just how off the rails Barney can get when left with his imagination. The creation of the Bro Code is a moment in the show where the absurdity of Barney’s stories really took shape, giving us the hilarious image of Franklin and Washington partaking in a devil’s three-way with one another.


5. The Bracket

HIMYM The Bracket
CBS

Although not a fantasy scene per say, the number of ridiculous things that are both done and said during this scene are too crazy not to talk about.

The bracket refers to a list of 64 women that Barney has screwed over throughout the years in terrible ways. He gets the entire gang to sit around with beer to vote through a series of head to heads, deciding which of these girls has been hurt the most.

This scene is outrageous, with the things that Barney has convinced women of being so extremely outlandish. Examples featured in the bracket include saying he only had 12 hours to live, a fake proposal, and even that a woman had his dead wife’s kidney, and therefore they were meant to be together.

The scenarios and images that this scene provides are hilarious because there is no way that anyone would believe them. They do not even have to show us how he did them, and it will still make you laugh out of your seat off of the descriptions alone.


4. Slap Of A Million Exploding Suns

How I Met Your Mother Yellow Face
CBS

I think this goes without saying, but the episode involving the Slap of a Million Exploding Suns has not aged well, and is definitely problematic. It features most of the cast in Asian garb and makeup for a good portion of the episode, which is not something that should be done ever.

This being said, the entire sequence is absolutely ridiculous otherwise. Marshall tells a story of how he set out on a mission to learn the ultimate technique for slapping, so that Barney’s last slap from the slap bet will be one that he will never forget.

This shows Marshall traveling to different parts of the globe to learn the three most important aspects of the perfect slap, including speed, strength, and accuracy. The masters of each of these slap aspects are the three other members of the group, with Ted teaching accuracy, Robin teaching speed, and Lily teaching strength.

This also shows Marshall gaining strength by getting slapped by women that Barney has wronged in the past. This way, the slap will pack the ultimate punch to Barney, and hurt him far worse than any slap before.

The description of this episode alone shows you how strange and odd this episode is, being one of the most problematic, and yet memorable episodes in the series.


3. Robin Sparkles

Robin Sparkles
cbs

We find out in the show that Robin, the gun-toting, whiskey-drinking badass, used to be a pop star in Canada known as Robin Sparkles. Every single time she is mentioned, and we get a glimpse into her life as a pop star, we get an extremely hilarious scene.

Not only do we get three iconic songs, Let’s Go to the Mall, Sandcastles in the Sand, and The Beaver Song, but we also get ridiculous imagery of Robin in outdated clothing. These scenes are absurd, not only because we know Robin’s character well, but because it such a perfect parody of pop stars in real life.

Every sequence with Sparkles features moments that we have all seen pop stars go through in their lives, including the initial hit that launches her career, the dramatic sequel to said hit, and the eventual mental breakdown that nobody can turn away from.

Sparkles is also a large part of the jokes made surrounding Canadian culture, with her proudly displaying many of the stereotypes. It is a very hilarious character, with some great fantasy scenes to boot, making Robin Sparkles an extremely memorable part of the show.


2. The Mermaid Theory

How I Met Your Mother
CBS

The Mermaid Theory is one of the many Barney Stinson tangents that leads to bizarre imagery for the rest of the episode.

The theory simply states that a man will always become attracted to a woman, no matter how initially unattracted to her he is initially. This is all because sailors used to see manatees in the water, and due to being gone from women for so long, would see them as beautiful mermaids in the ocean.

This leads to a scene in which not only is Barney in a sailor outfit with mermaid accoutrements, but also a scene in which Robin is in a manatee suit. This pops up a couple times throughout the episode due to Marshall hanging out with Robin for the first time alone, but it gets even weirder if you can believe it.

Not only is Robin in a manatee suit at one point, but the manatee suit now has a seashell bra and a long blonde curly wig. This image is something that I don’t think any fans of the show, or anyone in general, would have ever expected to appear on television at all, let alone on this series.


1. Nothing Suits Me Like A Suit

Barney how I Met Your Mother Suits
CBS

This is by far the most well-constructed musical sequence in the show, utilizing the amazing vocal talents of Neil Patrick Harris. The energetic dancing, the costuming, and even the way that it is shot show us just how to properly create a pseudo-Broadway number.

It all starts with Barney trying to seduce a woman that only goes out with men who don’t wear suits because she sees men in suits as being rude, misogynistic people. He decides that in order to sleep with her, he must suit down for the first time in years.

This leads us into a dream sequence where every single character is wearing a suit, including the rest of the gang, the background dancers, and even some babies he passes on the street. The song itself is extremely catchy, with a tune that gets stuck in your head almost instantly.

On top of this, Harris has a fantastic voice, as most of us know from his Tony award and his Grammy nominations. This makes for an amazing performance, along with strong dancers in the background, and very energetic choreography for everyone in the cast to participate in.

For the show to take so much time and effort to relay the emotions that he feels towards suits in a musical format is something that is unmatched in any other television series.


Watch Next


The Ultimate How I Met Your Mother Quiz

Ted Mosby How I Met Your Mother
CBS

1. What Object Was Ted's Best Friend While Growing Up In Ohio?

Contributor

I am a musical theater performer that trained in ballet for 12 years. I love horror movies, anime, video games, and makeup.