How I Met Your Mother: Ranking All Ted’s Love Interests From Worst To Best

20. Carly

The youngest of Ted’s many love interests, Carly Whittaker was the half-sister of Barney, who initially encouraged his best bro to give the 21-year-old a shot, unaware of her true identity.

Ted and Carly bonded over a love of Star Wars, but the age gap was too much for anything lasting, even though Barney insisted that they marry upon learning what had happened.

19. Natalie

This poor girl was dumped on her birthday...twice. There were times during the show’s run that Ted’s conduct with women was questionable, and Natalie was certainly a victim of that.

Having said that, what did Ted see in the martial arts specialist to give her a second chance? She was plain and had a fixation with sock monkeys. Plus, she had a little bit of a temper...