Is Doctor Who A God?
Over the course of Doctor Who, the Doctor has had many names, been called by many titles. The Oncoming Storm, the Predator, great warrior, Sweetie, the Raggedy Man, clever boy, lonely angel, the lonely god, the Time Lord Victorious. The Doctor is someone people have died for, without hesitation or regret. People have prayed to him for salvation, have wondered why he doesnt come. Hes even appeared in church iconography. There was an article on Cracked.com a while back, called How Doctor Who Became My Religion. The author said of the Doctor that I mean the Doctor is a god. But one we can see and understand. And he loves us more than all the other creatures in the universe. He would die for us, but what he really wants to do is live with us. And this, to him, was good because it meantThere is the possibility of a god who roots for us, loves us, and grieves for us just like the Doctor. Does all this make him a god? What Do We Call A God?
According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, the lowercase definition of a god is a being or object believed to have more than natural attributes and powers and to require human worship. So the question becomes: does the Doctor fit this definition? He certainly has more than natural attributes and powers. His mind moves so quickly we cant even follow it. He can travel through time, can stop armies, can save people and shake societies to their core. Does he require worship? Thats a trickier question. In The God Complex, the Doctor told Amy that he took her with him because he was vain, because I wanted to be adored. One interpretation of the Companion-Doctor relationship is indeed that he requires a sort of hero-worship. And the Tenth Doctor once told a cat-nun that there was no higher authority, that if he declared what she was doing was wrong, it was wrong. Could that be requiring worship?
Even if the Doctor doesnt require worship, he certainly receives it. In The Last of the Time Lords, the Doctor was able to defeat the Master through the power of prayer (and some science mumbo-jumbo). In Journeys End, the Doctor was brought to Earth by the combined prayers of his friends. And both Amelia Pond and the boy in Night Terrors met the Doctor when he answered their prayers for help.
The darkest facet of worship is sacrifice, and the Doctor is certainly the recipient of sacrifice. Any companion who travels with the Doctor sacrifices their chance at a normal life completely. He will always own a portion of their souls. Many of them literally lose the life they had before, as did Rose, Martha, and Amy. Donna sacrificed her mind, Clara sacrificed her life, River sacrificed her everything. Plenty of one-shot characters have sacrificed their lives to the Doctor too. So the Doctor has the powers of a god, and he is (functionally at least) worshiped as a god. So he is, basically, a god. What does that mean, then?
9 and 10, The Davies Era: A God Who Must Not Know It
It was always essential during the Davies era that the Doctor not behave like a god, that he not know he was a god. In some ways, this was easy. The Doctor is a god who loves humans, who emphasizes with them, who looks at them in awe. From the Doctors perspective, we humans look like giants because we have the ability to live in and love this universe. And when the Doctor had a companion, he could maintain that perspective. Rose was important to the Doctor because she was someone he could believe in. As he said in The Satan Pit, in the great game of gods and devils, out of all the gods the Doctor has seen, he believes in Rose. He believed in her goodness, her humanity, and that she would be there when he came to get her. And Rose loved him for the man he was, not the god or the angel.
Madame du Pompador loved him for the angel. And later, River loved him for the god. But thats another story, one Ill get to later. Donna once told the Doctor that he needed someone to travel with him, because sometimes you need someone to stop you. Thats why he picked Martha up and invited her along: because he knew he needed someone. But after Martha and Donna, he stopped. He couldnt take the connections being broken anymore. He loved and believed in people, but they broke his hearts. All through this era, the limits of the Doctors power were important. He couldnt save Rose from an alternate dimension. He couldnt convince Nurse Redfern to travel with him. He couldnt help Jack, or save Donna. There were fixed points in time that he could do nothing about, and even if he tried he may make them happen. In Voyage of the Dead, when the Doctor ruled over angels, he was told that if you could choose who lives and who dies, that would make you a monster. And who hasnt wondered that, if gods were all powerful, how they could let terrible things happen. The arc of the Tenth Doctors story took him to Mars, to a fixed point in time. And he decided to change all that. He would decide who lived and who died. He would be the Time Lord Victorious. The Master once said that being a Time Lord Victorious must have been like being a god, and the Doctor shied away from the thought. Not anymore.
If the Doctor reached for more power, if he reached for godhood, it would make him a monster. That was the story of the Davies era. And it took a human sacrifice, the act of a human woman, to bring him back to himself. Because the fact that the Doctor is a god was, during the Davies era, his greatest secret from himself.
Eleven And The Moffat Era: A God Who Must Not Be Worshiped
The Doctor was certainly a god to the girl who waited. She spent her life sitting, looking up at the stars, waiting for the Doctor to come back for her. It almost destroyed her life completely. Eventually, her time with the Doctor cost her her daughter, her family (she lost her parents when she went back in time), the possibility of children, and her life.
The Doctor cost River everything. He cost her her family, her childhood, and her adulthood. Her entire life was built around her relationship with the Doctor, her holy journal, the sacrifices she made to him. She was raised to the religion of the Doctor, she didnt get a choice. Im pretty sure she was the only companion who ever called him a god. The idea that the Doctor should apologize for fighting evil seems repellent, even based on the idea that he got too big. But if you re-frame it in the context of a god being worshiped, the story looks very different. If you see fear of the Doctor as worship.
From that perspective, the problem with the Doctors life was that he was demanding worship from his foes. When he challenged them before the Pandorica, when he rubbed in his victory at Demons Run, when he told the Atraxi to run, he was acting as a god, using the threat of his power. The form of worship he received was supposed to be fear, but he didnt count on what that fear would produce. As River told him in A Good Man Goes to War, This was exactly you, all of this. You make them so afraid. Doctor, the man who healsbut if you carry on the way youve been going, what might that word become?
The worship the Doctors foes gave him made them stronger. It meant they took River and bent her to their will, made her a weapon that almost cost the Doctor everything. It made the Daleks stronger, costing one of Claras incarnations her life. The worship the Doctor received almost tore the fabric of reality asunder in The Wedding of River Song. Thats why the Doctor arranged his own death. He demanded one more sacrifice from River Song, and he tried to stop Amy and Rory from knowing he was alive. Notice that it didnt mean he stopped fighting evil: it just meant he stopped demanding worship. The Doctor sacrificed Amys faith in him, told her he wasnt a god. He made her stop waiting, stop worshipping, by telling her that he was nowhere near as powerful as she thought. Thus, Amy made him a man by seeing him as a man. The Doctor was made to understand that he had demanded worship. and it was terrible, by River. River was created to be a devil to his god, to bring him down. The plan backfired because the planners didnt count on Rivers feelings, or on the Doctors brilliance. But the essential tragedy of Rivers story was that she and the Doctor could never have an equal relationship, because she could never stop worshiping him.
River was in love with him before she met him. She fell in love with the idea of the Doctor, not with the Doctor himself. She was the epitome of the terrible things that would happen if the Doctor allowed himself to be a god. That was the essential problem with the Doctors and Rivers relationship, for better or for worse: to her, he would always be a god. And having someone around who believed he was a god was really, really bad for him. It put her in the unique position of being able to tell him when he was acting like a god, of being able to scold or hit him, because that basic fact that she worshiped him was a constant. River once said one psychopath per Tardis, and she was right. If she had stayed with the Doctor permanently, it would have been a disaster. And that fact, that she would always be waiting for him to see her, was truly awful.
Post-Pond Era: The Doctor Becomes A Man
In The Snowmen, the Doctor is behaving like a god. He lives in the sky, looking over humanity and refusing to intervene. Hes decided that since the universe doesnt care what happens, neither does he: put another way, if God doesnt care what happens, then why should a god? Madame Vastra said of the Doctor he stands above this world and does not interfere in the affairs of his inhabitants. He is not your salvation, nor your protector. If one end of the god spectrum was 10s intervention, his embrace of power, the 11th Doctor had shifted over to the other end of the god spectrum. He refused to help, only observing. It is the prerogative of a god to not interfere, and that was what he decided to do. He no longer demanded worship, he no longer demanded sacrifice. He was just there. Until Clara came along.
When told the above about the Doctors godliness, she refused to buy it. She said they were just words. When told why the Doctor had retreated from the world, she thought and said man. She didnt wait for the Doctor to help her, she went to find him. She told him to come upstairs when she saw him outside. And the story she told her kids about the Doctor was that he was a man who lived on a cloud, keeping children from having bad dreams. Hardly godlike. Clara didnt worship him. Not a jot, ever. Instead, Clara demanded some worship from him, some sort of faith. He had to take her with him on trust, not knowing what she was or what she was capable of. She didnt wait for him, she told him when to come and pick her up. He had to follow her instructions, or she wouldnt travel with him. And he needed her with him.
If the Doctor is a god, Clara was his protector god. In her mortal form, she connected him to the world, gave him someone to believe in (which he hadnt had since Rose left). In her time vortex form, she spread herself through time and space, doing the impossible, to save him. She sacrificed her life for the Doctor, but it was not an act of faith in him. She had no expectation that he would find a way to save him. It was an act of faith in herself. The Doctor of the latest series was a Doctor who had lost all three of his Ponds, but that was for the best, really. Theres no one who worships him now. He has come face-to-face with the limits of his own powers and his reliance on another living being to save him. Left without this, without the protection of his secrets, without the prerogatives of a god, the Doctor who walked away from us at the end of The Name of the Doctor is perhaps more human than the Doctor has ever been. And thats good, because nothing good comes of the Doctor being all-powerful, or worshiped.
Conclusion
I: The Doctor is a god, but he is a god who needs to not be a god. To behave as a god is to lose himself, to stop being the Doctor. Thats what happened to the Time Lords. They behaved as gods, behaved as if the universe were there for them to play with. The Master behaved as a god. What he did to earth was godlike: the psychic mesmerizing he created could be conceived as worship. And the Master was evil, and he died. The Doctor must never become like that. Sometimes, the Doctor needs his companions with him. They keep him close to Earth, remind him that to be a god is a terrible and lonely thing, remind him that his powers have and need limitations. Sometimes, the Doctor really ought not to have companions with him. Thats why the Ponds stopped being full time, why River and he never traveled together permanently: because for them to worship him was wrong, and did far more harm than good. When the Doctor acts too much like a god, when he starts to believe in his godliness, he needs someone who believes that he can be a man. Or else the universe will suffer. II:
Doctor Who asks a very simple and very complicated question: how could a god be good? How could there be a god who allowed terrible things to happen? What would the prerogatives of a god produce? The Doctor said once that good men don't need rules, and that's why he has to have so many. He is not a pure soul. And he knows it. Clara once asked what people could possibly be to the Doctor, from his godlike perspective. And his answer was that people were the only mystery worth solving. The only thing in the universe worth living for.
People are what can save us. Our potential, our ability to deal with the universe.
At our best, we can rise above the carelessness of the universe, can weather the battles of gods and devils.
Thats what the Doctors companions do. Thats what we all do, every day. We have the potential to be good. And when the Doctor follows our example, so does he.